r/classicwow • • 13h ago • Bravo 1

Forever What's the point in extremely trash heavy dungeons with the mob xp so low?

Drowned City and Krol'Dok are on average 2 hour dungeons with insane amounts of trash. Multiple of packs more than any other dungeon in Classic. And in those two hours you probably only clear 30% of trash.

What exactly is the point of this design? It's not fun, the pack variety is minimal and it's bad xp. It feels like they packed these dungeons with trash just to make them longer for no reason other than a lazy attempt to make them feel "epic".

EDIT: to the people posting you are doing the dungeon in 1 hour and anyone taking 2 hours is "trash", cool good job bro, but you are completely missing the point. It's still not fun, the dungeon design is still lazy and boring, and the xp is still trash.

327 Upvotes

366 comments sorted by

14

u/moht81 12h ago

2 hour dungeons… that’s a whole raid cleared in retail. It’s too long for a rebooted dad game to be spending in small group content.

25

u/Vilraz 12h ago

Wait till you see BRD that actually takes +2h to full clear

24

u/reasonablejim2000 12h ago

the difference is BRD is a varied, interesting dungeon, every area feels unique and the trash packs are varied. Drowned City and Krol'dok are mostly one big space with the same trash pack spammed all over the area.

4

u/Vilraz 12h ago

But eventually in brd its just tank and spank

1

u/DuckPuppyOverlord 12h ago

I’m a retail player who was excited to experience BRD in a classic environment for the first time. I did it yesterday and was extremely disappointed. Everything looks the same and it was so slow and boring, our run took us 3 hours (our tank is a newbie) and we didn’t even complete because we called it quits at the torch bearer dudes towards the end. Not sure if it’s intended or not but they were instantly respawning and not allowing us time to recover. Drowned city and Krol’Dok were far more enjoyable.

8

u/reasonablejim2000 11h ago

wow, that's a fucking wild take. BRD is the greatest MMORPG dungeon ever made.

5

u/Odd-Bandicoot-9314 7h ago

Maybe if it's the first time you've done it. I dread doing it now unless it's just for 1 or 2 bosses

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ruger15 10h ago

Just curious, why do you think that?

•

u/C-Icetea 2h ago

Yes it is and the only reason is that it was supposed to be a raid but got turned into a dungeon very late.

Why they don't do that again I don't understand. Brd has so many possibilites for skips and run-types that it is like an organic diremaul.

10

u/H90Q 11h ago

brd full run is fucking awful

in classic you targeted a boss and farmed it that's what was great

3

u/Foamie 12h ago

Torch room is a suppression room, very common mechanic in vanilla designed to push your group/raid to get through the area fast and not waste time.

5

u/New-Independent-1481 9h ago

End game classic dungeons follow a 'megadungeon' concept in which you are not supposed to sit there and clear the entire thing in one go. There are different wings and shortcuts between them to encourage coming back multiple times. Think of them like an entire group-only zone.

Also the fast respawning non-elite mob room is the design, you just failed the mechanic as intended.

2

u/gavriloe 9h ago

BRD and Sunken temple are on my list of dungeons that can feel absolutely terrible if you're with a bad group. They're just so long and maze-like that if your group is having trouble it can turn into a real headache. I distinctly remember running ST with a tank who was extremely drunk (pretty sure he was drinking during the run, when it started he seemed pretty normal). I was healing, and it was actually like painful to be there for that run, bro couldnt hold threat at all. Eventually we did clear the dungeon, and the tank did get guzu'd into the hole in the middle at one point, which briefly boosted the morale of me and the dps, but it has made me wary about doing ST ever since then.

Same with BRD, I think I've only ever been to Emperor once actually, and again it was a 3 hour run where the tank was a bit undergeared and I had this warlock who was aggressively life tapping the whole. With a decent group BRD isn't too bad, or if your just doing jailbreak or whatever, but with it being so long it can make a bad group even more painful than usual.

•

u/Vreas 51m ago

Emphasis on being a nightmare with bad groups.

When I’ve run with quality peeps they’re both some of my favorite wow experiences. ST especially.

1

u/Difficult-Ask9856 8h ago

No they respawn very fast, to get you to go to each platform quickly

•

u/Soapykorean 3h ago

Yes it’s intended, you need to know how to navigate it.

1

u/FrogstonLive 5h ago

What are you smoking? Brd enemies are same same

7

u/therinlahhan 12h ago

More like 4 hours if you actually do everything.

And I love every minute of it.

1

u/LeatherNew6682 12h ago

I already expected a BRD raid at SOD, I'm so mad I will never have it

2

u/mrmarkme 12h ago

Took my group close to 4 hours to complete it. Was epic, got so lost. But we powered thru

•

u/Junior_Point4746 3h ago

Thats why you slice it in several runs mot times : arena, lava emp run, vault run…

5

u/Lyoss 12h ago

I've done a bunch of drowned city and kroldok and I'd say that the first generally is an hour and kroldok is like 45 minutes, a bit more without the key

Either they're 3 manning the dungeons or they have half the group afk if it's hitting 2 hours

1

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

No man it is just that most people do not know the dungeon since most people are one and done , so yeah I can see how it will take a bunch of people that don't know where to go and have no idea the most efficient way I can see how it can take them 2 hrs can't you?

1

u/Xadus 12h ago

Weird, I did both the other day completely blind with other people who also hadn't done them, and they both took less than an hour each. So no, it's not that. If you're pulling EVERY SINGLE MOB, then no shit it takes super long but you don't have to do that in either dungeon! Just skip trash! It's not like they give good XP anymore :p

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OneHitCrit 10h ago

That you only run once while leveling. It is so absurd.

3

u/naarcx 12h ago

It doesn’t actually take 2 hours tho. The original post is bait, hyperbole, or from someone who is likely the underlying factor of a lot of extremely cursed runs

1

u/Aggressive-Stand-585 12h ago

Maybe with multiple wipes and factoring in the wait time from the group being formed to everyone being there and until the dungeon is cleared, I could see it.

1

u/KarlFrednVlad 12h ago

Two hours is insane. I did kroldok under levelled with a full wipe and a few other deaths, it took one hour

1

u/Hehehecx 7h ago

Ya I did it with it being everyone’s first time in less than an hour, and we even had someone hearth out to get the key cuz we thought we had to lol

1

u/Lord-Celsius 5h ago

The target audience is people who never played classic, or ultra big fans of classic.. so the fact that it's rebooted or that people take their time shouldn't matter.

1

u/velianieli 10h ago

how will your 17 kids and 36 minutes of play per week deal with this

0

u/Emsela 12h ago

I’ve done every dungeon so far and the only one that might take two hours is a full BRD.

-1

u/tckr_sys 7h ago

Why play an MMO if u don't have 2 hours

2

u/whutchamacallit 5h ago

I literally can't take the sub seriously anymore. I just have to enjoy it as unintentional satire at this point.

98

u/nyxpuppet 12h ago • Bravo

The dungeon xp nerf pretty much killed the game for me. I unsubbed. I hope they restore the xp to the way it was in classic. I think that with the way it is right now, it's going to stop Forever from being a long term success and the population will decline heavily after a few months. Blizz want Forever to be a altoholic game, but since dungeons are a one and done and questing is the way they want you to play as a 95-5 questing-dungeon split; it just makes the entire thing incredibly monotonous and boring.

My levelling experience has always been something like 70-30 in favour of dungeons-questing. Even if I did choose to come back, I'd get my priest to 60 and never touch the levelling "journey" ever again on another character. The way they've disincentivized player choice this heavy handedly will not bode well for the long term imo.

27

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

This is exactly where I am at also. I do not enjoy this version, I will get my main to 60 but no way do I feel like I want to do this shit again on an alt.

32

u/DinosaurBill 11h ago

Yeah, can't see myself questing again to 60

Dungeons are dynamic experiences, questing is not

→ More replies (11)

•

u/STDS13 40m ago

I paid for three months and already turned off the auto-renew. I've mained healer for over a decade and if they don't want me to spend some of my time actually healing in dungeons as I level...well then I don't have a reason to play.

16

u/Newbie4Hire 12h ago

Don't worry, they will solve this problem with a $60 boost.

•

u/biggest_tub 48m ago

Man I'm in the same spot. In fact, I'm actually more of a quester. I enjoy dungeons but I don't like to spam them. I like to run a few to chase loot that gives be a nice power boost when questing for a few levels. Now if I don't get the drop it's just like, cool I wasted multiple hours of my time just to get a smidge of xp. It's killed the core gameplay loop I enjoyed.

2

u/Lockenheada 6h ago

I count grind the crit helm from SM:Armory because I can't run dungeons multible times

•

u/Educational-Half2437 2h ago

I totally agree with you and here is my tinfoil har theory: After Blizzards data shows that a majority of the playerbase have hit lvl 60 they will up the dungeon xp to close, or the same as Classic era rates.

Then the people who complained about xp nerfs will be happy when they level alts, and the people on the other side of the coin , eg the "we dont dungeon spamming to be the most optimal xp"-crowd wont bother because now they dont have fomo from not spamming Dungeons since they're already max lvl.

0

u/Falcon84 12h ago

There are so many dungeons now it’s not even close to 95-5 split. Even doing all of them only once. It’s much close to 70-30 like you said.

4

u/nyxpuppet 12h ago

That's true that there's more, but the 70-30 is just false. I did each dungeon once because going back in is totally worthless.

3

u/Falcon84 10h ago

Yeah and there are over 30 dungeons now. Even doing all of them once that’s a lot of dungeon content while leveling.

1

u/ReflectionEterna 5h ago

That would account for like 10% of the leveling process even if you do every dungeon and their associated quests once.

•

u/Accurate_Cap5535 4h ago

Am I the only one on earth who ran dungeons multiple times on my journey to 60 with no complaints at all? and now I'm 60 I'm running even more dungeons multiple times.

•

u/Greendayy77 3h ago

You are a minority, Blizzard didn't confirm any numbers but in the last podcast they said that they have data of "people not running dungeons as much as their expectation".

My friendlist and myself included have only done each dungeon exclusively once until level 55.

-16

u/Admiralsheep8 12h ago

Dungeons give plenty of xp. You might as well post that you form all your opinions from reddit instead of playing 

8

u/reasonablejim2000 12h ago

an average run of Krol'Dok with quests gives less than one level.

0

u/Admiralsheep8 12h ago

How much do should a late game dungeon give . If it gave competitive xp to quests there would be zero reason to actually go into the open world .

The reality is if it was old school dungeon xp there would be zero reason to quest . Theres enough new dungeons that a guild group could level exclusively via dungeons and it would be so much faster then questing becauS you wouldn’t have to compete with anyone for mobs or do rediculous drop rate quests or travel . Then you would also be getting much better gear cause dungeon loot is markedly better then any quest loot , To make it worse you would also make say more money off the elite drop table then you would questing. Is that what you think is good and healthy for the game . Dungeons being optimal money time and equipment with only organized mage overworld hyper spawn grinding beating it 

People already farm krol for the bis ass drops why make it the best source of xp too

13

u/Newbie4Hire 12h ago

They give almost no exp outside of the quests.

15

u/JustATextBox 12h ago

A full run of SFK takes over 35 minutes on average, and for that you get ~6500XP. That's 19% of a level at 25. Even if you don't consider the fact that people don't run dungeons multiple times so you have to find a new group every run and wait ~30 minutes for them to get there, that's still ~3 hours per level

If you take into account the extra ~30 mins per run that it takes for your group to get there, you're now looking at ~5 hours per level

If you take into account that not every run will be smooth and you might get a bad group that wipes a few times, it'll be even worse

I would've legitimately leveled faster doing grey quests from westfall than I would've doing SFK runs

-5

u/Admiralsheep8 12h ago

That’s because you’re slow as shit .

If I wanted to level fast I would just grab my mage friend and paladin mage mass pull zones and aoe it down because that has been the fastest way since forever , why even quest .

Everyone bitching about dungeons doesn’t even care about it xp per hour or whatever , they just want to be mad cause Reddit tells them to be .

With front loaded xp from quests you get more xp from 3 runs of sfk then you used to in 3 runs , if you want to be optimal for leveling maybe you shouldn’t run the same dungeon at lvl 23 for 5 hours . Thats pretty lame 

12

u/JustATextBox 12h ago

That’s because you’re slow as shit .

That's the average player bud. I did 7 runs in SFK, and 35 was one of the fastest. Feel free to try it yourself with random players, you're not going to do much better. God forbid you get a run where a warlock pulls an entire room 3 times, that run back is a huge time killer

If I wanted to level fast I would just grab my mage friend and paladin mage mass pull zones and aoe it down because that has been the fastest way since forever , why even quest .

It's not about leveling fast it's about not leveling extremely slow. I'm not saying that dungeons should be the fastest 1-60, but they shouldn't be so slow that people are only doing dungeons for the quests. They shouldn't be so slow that grey quests 10 levels below me give better XP/hr

With front loaded xp from quests you get more xp from 3 runs of sfk then you used to in 3 runs

There's no way that's true, but feel free to do the math and prove it

if you want to be optimal for leveling maybe you shouldn’t run the same dungeon at lvl 23 for 5 hours . Thats pretty lame 

I don't want to be optimal for leveling. I want to be able to run some dungeons without feeling like I'm completely wasting my time and trolling. I don't want to be able to look at my quest log, see an old ass quest from westfall, and realize "if I just left and did that quest I'd get more XP/hr than I would doing this dungeon"

6

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

10

u/ThatLeetGuy 12h ago

Without the quests, full dungeons give like 2 bars of exp.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/TheClassicAndyDev 12h ago

No they don't. Dungeons give horrible exp.

3

u/Admiralsheep8 12h ago

That’s because everyone just sees that mob xp is 60 percent what it used to be and says wow I’m getting 6:10 xp now , and not accounting for dungeon quests giving way more xp . 

3-4 runs gives the same xp as the old 3-4 runs they just front loaded the xp for forever.

4

u/TheClassicAndyDev 12h ago

Stop talking. You are wrong.

1

u/Admiralsheep8 12h ago

The reality is if it was old school dungeon xp there would be zero reason to quest . Theres enough new dungeons that a guild group could level exclusively via dungeons and it would be so much faster then questing becauS you wouldn’t have to compete with anyone for mobs or do rediculous drop rate quests or travel . Then you would also be getting much better gear cause dungeon loot is markedly better then any quest loot , To make it worse you would also make say more money off the elite drop table then you would questing. Is that what you think is good and healthy for the game . Dungeons being optimal money time and equipment with only organized mage overworld hyper spawn grinding beating it 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ambroz168 12h ago

With quests they do. Otherwise they do not. 21 druid, ranked WC for my friend last night. 58 min run and 3 bars.

3

u/nyxpuppet 12h ago

They give plenty of xp once because of the quests. Then I never touched the dungeon again because it was pointless.

The quest xp is too high, the mob xp is too low. It kills my style of play.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/CellIntelligent9951 12h ago

I think you might be

-8

u/Sinkrast 12h ago

If your preferred method of playing the game is just "getting to 60" with a dungeon spam, then Forever simply isn't for you. Dungeon spamming was never popular in the old days, it's just been popularized in modern classic by retail min-maxxers looking for the most efficient and streamlined way of rushing to max level.

You're part of a very loud minority, and the game will be just fine.

9

u/Lyoss 12h ago • Heartwarming

I wish tourists would stop trying to make this narrative a thing

People would level in dungeons back in 2004, why wouldn't they? It's a social experience

5

u/--Snufkin-- 12h ago

People would "level" in dungeons in 2004 because they wanted to run dungeons, not because of experience rates

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Soulspawn 12h ago

We didn't intentionally do it or at least I didn't, back then we had no questie, sure we had website but that was still incomplete and most of that data came out later on. We just ran out of quest and had no choice but to grind mobs or do dungeon.

To me exp gain is just about right. Enough to feel like your progressing not too much that it feels like I should do 10zf to level up

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/LeatherNew6682 12h ago • Bravo

And leveling as never been popular in 20 years of wow, what's your point.

You didn't play back then even at BC I was dungeon spamming.

The people that like questing are the dad gamers that imagine forever will be like vanilla, and those people will leave in one month, and all the sweats will keep the game alive, exactly what happened on classic.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

What a stupid take and honeslly all of you that have this take have never played Vanilla wow and it shows.

Dungeons are and have always been a huge part of lvling in wow.

It was a training ground for tanks healers and dps to learn their class and how to work as a team.

Now you have healers that know nothing not even to dispel or drop the right totem and tanks that can't tank

So stfu with your stupid ass take.

You know zero about vanilla and never will you are prickly lvl 15 looking at sunsets telling everyone what a great game this is when you know fuck all about it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/UntimelyMeditations 12h ago

I hated leveling 20 years ago when I played vanilla. I've hated leveling thorugh all the MMOs I've played since then, and I still hate leveling now. Its a boring, mindnumbing slog.

But.

Its all worth it because the endgame is so much fun.

→ More replies (3)

-14

u/flupiflup 12h ago

I would be upset if I made 1000 new quests and everyone skips them because they want to get 60 lvl as fast as they can. Idk, try to think about something except your ego.

8

u/sennoden 11h ago

This is such a weird take, are we the customers or are blizzard? We PAY TO PLAY the game, yet we should just bend to whatever vision they have?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Agent101g 10h ago

Why stop there? They should remove all loot drops from bosses and limit loot to quest rewards only.

/s

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Rdhilde18 9h ago

I’ve really enjoyed the 200 “fly to ironforge, fly to booty bay, fly back to ironforge” quests I’ve done so far.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Guilty-Nobody998 12h ago

The devs should also think of something except their ego then too lmao

-3

u/flupiflup 12h ago

Why? It's their game, they can do whatever they want. If you don't like it, don't play it. They want people to do quests and explore the world, they stated it several times, they keep saying it on podcasts and still there are people who are genuinely curious why they nerfed dungeon exp. Human's stupidity is unbearable.

6

u/Agent101g 10h ago

Human’s blind loyalty to overlords with no independent thought is also unbearable

•

u/flupiflup 4h ago

I am literally enjoying my free time after work, what redditors see:

I am loyal to overlord and don't have independent thought

That's actually fantastic

12

u/Guilty-Nobody998 12h ago

"Its their game they can do whatever they want" lmao. How does that boot taste?

2

u/flupiflup 12h ago

Idk, I paid for subscription and enjoy my journey, and you paid for something you don't like. Try to guess who looks dumb in this situation.

10

u/Guilty-Nobody998 12h ago

Who said i didn't like it? I would just prefer more than one way to level, especially when i inevitably level an alt. You're the dumb one for assuming shit lmao

4

u/Interesting_You6852 11h ago

☝️☝️☝️☝️

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

My guy some of us have explored the world for 20 yrs ! So stfu with your stupid ass takes.

And no the game should never be about their ego my guy it should be about the player experience since that is what we pay for.

I am not paying for a subscription to suck dev dick, maybe you are but I am not..

The changes in the world are not that exciting to incentivize the players who know the world like the back of their hand to go explore.

I would have much other spent some time exploring the new dungeons but it feels like shit getting one bar of exp per dungeon.

So stfu all of you retail Andy's that will lvl to 40 maybe and then quit the game

→ More replies (28)

1

u/Salamander115 5h ago

They wish it was their game. They’re just the current caretakers of a great game made by a once legendary team.

8

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

Id the quest they made would have been anyting new then maybe just maybe but they are just copy of other quests for example riverland is just a copy of molgor and west fall with the same type of gathering quests.

For us that have played the game for 20 yrs it get boring collecting 20 pig penises after a while.

The dungeons on the other hand were new and they could have made them exciting and had people explore more but there is zero incentive so now it is one and done.

Can't you see what a stupid design this is?

And I am sorry but I am not paying money for a game to stroke the devs egos.

Vannllila wow had many paths to 60, retail wow has pretty much one if you want to do anything in the game you have to follow the main story line. Turning vanilla into retail will kill this fucking game.

0

u/flupiflup 12h ago edited 12h ago

So why are you not playing retail? Retail is made exactly for people who were collecting penises for 20 years and got tired. Now you download the game that was explicitly presented as penis collector+ and you whine that you have to collect penises. Again, human's stupidity is unbearable.

I understand that you want to be a part of the hype, you want to be among first players. But sometimes things are not made for you and you have to deal with it.

3

u/Agent101g 10h ago

Nobody in this sub wants to play retail cut the crap. We’re all allowed to be welcome in this game.

2

u/Rdhilde18 9h ago

You understand questing is the only way to level in retail yeah?

→ More replies (4)

•

u/vradar 2h ago

I would be upset if I made a bunch of new dungeons and everyone skips them because the xp is shit and they take too long.

•

u/LimbonicArt03 50m ago

I would be upset if I made 9 new dungeons and reworked so much of the loot, for people to only do them once in passing along the way, skipping as many mobs as possible, thus not exploring the full dungeons, and not seeing 66% or 75% of the loot that exists

•

u/STDS13 37m ago

You would've skipped all the new quests if they didn't nerf dungeon XP?

1

u/Typical-Tax1584 11h ago

For real, I can't wait for them to ban and roll back everyone who uses questing addons and guides. They're skipping the least efficient quests and hitting 60 as fast as they can. Everyone who uses questie or rested or any questing addon is spitting in the dev's faces.

•

u/LimbonicArt03 30m ago

I can't figure out whether this is sarcastic or not 💀

1

u/-BZ82 5h ago

Devs also made more dungeons everyone will play once and then forget about and never touch again. Isnt.... that the same thing? If people come back for more they probably like it. If I was a dev that worked on a new dungeon its be cool to find out people like it. I gaurentee no ones hyping any of the new quests like this. Except maybe the sleeping bag quest for all the goodies you get.

If they gave incentive to re run dungeons also, they could easily aquire data on which ones are popular and make more content similar to them.

People seem to love the ruins of lordaeron dungeon, people seem to hate krol'dok dungeon. Havnt really read anything about how people feel about the other new ones though

→ More replies (3)

-6

u/This_is_opinion 12h ago

If that killed the game for you, your bloodline is weak

•

u/N4vil 2h ago

Honestly, if the dungeon xp nerf is enough reason for you to kill the game for you - the game might not be for you.

•

u/nyxpuppet 2h ago

You don't say

-7

u/GingerM 10h ago

Good riddance

→ More replies (9)

228

u/Lyoss 12h ago • Bravo

I agree they need to revert the exp nerfs but neither dungeon is 2 hours unless the group is exceptionally slow

54

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

They are that long with people that have never done it . They are pretty long and the fact that most people are one and done there are few that know those dungeons relay well

28

u/--Snufkin-- 12h ago

I cleared both in an hour with no one having done them before

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bodydefinesyou 8h ago

Dunno, my sunken temple times were about an hour and a halfish.

•

u/Wooden_Drummer2455 4h ago

"heh its not 2hrs its 1hr and 30min checkmate"

→ More replies (2)

-12

u/KarlFrednVlad 12h ago

This is such ridiculous hyperbole. I ran kroldok under levelled with a group of people who never did it. We full wiped once and had a few other deaths. It was one hour

-7

u/Interesting_You6852 12h ago

Your narcissism is showing dude! Just because you did it does it mean everyone else did it also?

But wait you are in that group of people that keep saying " its the journey the only way to lvl is through quests" so yeah your narcissism makes sense since to you it is your way or no way.

8

u/GenericRacist 10h ago

"Your anecdote is narcissism while my anecdote is the truth"

Are you ok?

The guy you are calling a narcissist isn't alone in saying that a 6 boss dungeon shouldn't be taking people 2 hours unless they're going super slow or wiping a lot.

My anecdotal experience aligns with his and most of the videos I can find also land around the one hour mark.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/UltiMikee 12h ago

Lol yeah I haven’t done either of these but I assume we’re talking about low skill groups here

35

u/gorillagrip913 9h ago

Because game designers did not know that the 3 clown podcast council would remove all XP from dungeons when they added the trash.

They wanted to make drowned city something that could compete with SM. All the trash before the XP removal would have done that. Now with the clown council making last minute decisions, the entire design of drowned city makes no sense.

10

u/Yadilie 5h ago

All the new dungeons are just run like Retail if your team is smart enough. Skip all you can to get the loot and quests and bounce. Only full clear area is the pirates. Same with RoL, Shapers Terrace and Blackmaw.

36

u/Kbearforlife 12h ago

There needs to be incentive to clear the trash they are putting in the new dungeons apart from the nerfed xp if they want players to engage with them.

20

u/tostatortilla 12h ago

Better add quests to loot items off mobs in dungeons but there’s too few drops to get them in one go for the entire party. There. Your incentive has been already provided by Blizz…. 😂

0

u/bodydefinesyou 8h ago

They technically did with the newer dungeons. They drop the BoE blue sets. Still don't think its enough compensation for all the trash though

40

u/SimpleGuy4141 8h ago

The road to Hell is paved with the best intentions. They had good intentions with the XP nerf. They wanted people questing. They wanted boosting curbed.

What they got was a tank/healer shortage. Dungeon meta of skip everything that is unnecessary. New Dungeon design that falls in line with prior xp philosophy, but makes no sense with curbed xp gains. Splintering of a whole group of players who like to just hang with friends in discord and dungeon spam because they wanted to skip a zone or because they wanted to have fun.

My hope is they cut bait now, revert the changes, tone down the dungeon quest xp, and just let the system work the way it was intended. They tried to reinvent the wheel and it backfired. Move on.

•

u/Markgormley69 38m ago

Perhaps I was just in a bubble but I honestly never heard people crying for a dungeon XP nerf literally ever in the entire 6 years of playing classic. I heard people cry about spell cleave or melee cleave metas or boosting, but never the amount of XP

•

u/Normal_Berry_ 2h ago

Were they good intentions? Wanting to force everyone on to the same linear path reeks more of you have to have fun how I say you have fun mentality. It completely ignores how people actually interact and makes the game less social, its nothing more than an ego trip.

•

u/starplow 1h ago

what i never understand, how is reduced xp responsible for tank and healer shortage?

there have always been fewer tanks and heals than dps, nothing new. are people just blaming something because they read about it online being blamed?

and how is less dungeon xp responsible anyways?
if less healers and tanks run dungeons, less dps run dungeons too, whats the difference?

•

u/stack_corruption 45m ago

that healer/tank-shortage always exists in all mmos, reddit is just dumb and tries to find as many reasons to justify their dungeon xp arguments

•

u/klonkish 31m ago edited 25m ago

Huh? Think about it for a second.

Leveling as a dedicated healer through open-world quests sucks. Why would anyone bother speccing into healing when the main way to level as a healer has been nerfed to a fraction of what it was before Forever?

Okay, just get dual spec, right? That costs a lot of gold, and you can't even get it until around the same time you're saving for your mount. It's not even an option for every class.

Healer shortages have always existed, sure. But how does that mean you can't make them worse? DPS can still quest just fine, while healers have lost their main way of leveling efficiently.

What else changed in Forever that would explain the shortage getting worse?

•

u/jh_2719 5m ago

I wanted to level a healer in Forever, but being treated like a second class player because of wanting to level via dungeons, help people out, socialise etc it's just not viable. And quest leveling? I'll just reroll a DPS class if I want to do that.

•

u/Sarmattius 3h ago

there is no tank/healer shortage. There is a shortage where there isn't good loot for that class. Guess who never wants to come to SM Armory - caster dps, rogues and ferals. Half of LFG for armory are tanks.

Guess what drops in SM Cath - a 2h mace, a healing weapon - Suddenly 90% of LFG for cath are healers and feral druid tanks...

17

u/memekid2007 10h ago

Get Frictioned on xDDDDDD

Blizzard special

•

u/Moddingspreee 3h ago

I did the stronghold with a top tier tank and he knew how to skip almost every pack. It's the new way blizz intends us to play, aka retail speedrun but without the rewards.

4

u/Smelly-Elf 12h ago

I am gonna assume not every dev unanimously decided to nerf dungeon xp. It's possible they made the dungeon before that decision was made.

17

u/Legitimate_Post_8807 12h ago

So that working class folks don't run dungeons

-2

u/Human_Bison579 5h ago

Brain damaged comment

2

u/Legitimate_Post_8807 5h ago

I'd like to do a deep dive into why this, specifically, has triggered you.

6

u/Klutzy-Caramel-9777 12h ago

I run Stronghold today for first time. It was 1:20 with realy averege groupe, we get lost few times, one wipe and i feel like it ok.
Its true that same packs are really repetetive but you can mount up in dungeos soo its nice that you can use mount inside when you get him. And its feel unique and like real ogre stronghold ( its cant be small).
+ you get skip key in the end.
Soo i kinda like it but yes, there can be less mobs or same more unique "minibosses" insted.

3

u/Equanimity_779 11h ago

Drowned city is like 75 min and I thought it was awesome

6

u/xMoneymonster 11h ago

if krol dok takes you two hours get a better group or look inward and improve

4

u/r3turn_null 13h ago

Great question.

6

u/rodrigo8008 12h ago

My drowned city run was long around 55 minutes, but not sure where you’re getting 2 hours from lol. Why do all of these posts make shit up?

5

u/New-Independent-1481 9h ago

People unable to fathom that somehow even in Classic they fucking suck at the game. My first run with a fully blind group of Drowned City was about 50 mins. We did it again with some new pugs and pinged the way, and it was just over half an hour. If it took them 2 hours, they must have been doing abysmal DPS.

4

u/rodrigo8008 8h ago

Long runs are usually a function of the tank and/or healer. Sure good dps speed things up but like marginally

1

u/-BZ82 5h ago

Idk how but ive had a run where the tank was doing tank stuff just fine, I was healing and keeping everyone up just fine. The dps however, didnt have enough dps to down the boss before it would enrage and then wipe us. Happened 3x before I left. Idk wtf the dps were doing.

•

u/JJenJenny 1h ago

Drowned city is actually really small if you think about it

•

u/Wooden_Drummer2455 4h ago

Bro is acting like everyone is the same god gamer and you don't get mages who single target in packs of 5+ mobs

•

u/ThumpaMonsta 1h ago

The game is so incredibly braindead easy as far as dungeons go. If you need two hours to clear Koldrok. The group objectively sucks.

2

u/Zadiuz 12h ago

Everyone in my group just said the same thing about Krol'Dok. But to be fair... it also only took us like just under an hour... and we were all lost and had no idea of where to go for the whole thing.

But we did skip like 80% of the dungeon.

3

u/AltruisticFilm4466 12h ago

Im more worried you take 2hours to clear drowned city and kroldok maybe you shouldn’t be posting here and question game design

2

u/rr770 10h ago

There is no point. Blizzard devs simply don't know what they are doing 

1

u/FroztyBeard 12h ago

After doing Drowned City: It felt like a mini-raid, similar to BRDs and the like. So feels like Drowned City was a early first taste of a mini-raid dungeon

Managed to tank it to full completion, took around 1 hour-ish and I enjoyed the dungeon for what it was

1

u/aglock 12h ago

My first runs on both Drowned City and KrolDok where all bosses in about an hour. They could be 30 minutes runs if you know the path and play quickly. 2 hours is not the normal clear time.

1

u/Coulstwolf 10h ago

Drowned city took my group 47 mins it was all of our first time there, we did all quests

1

u/thexzmeh 10h ago

To waste your time

1

u/BIitzez 9h ago

no incentive. in blackmaw hold, kroldok and drowned city we ran right by 70% of the trash.

i was told getting the collection quest done from the pirates wasnt possible in one run so we just skipped that shit too.

1

u/thrillho145 9h ago

They need to nerf the hp of some of the dungeon mobs. They're really high

1

u/MoreLikeGaewyn 8h ago

Blizzard not knowing what the fuck they're are doing.

1

u/jamesbongsixtynine 8h ago

to spite you lol

1

u/No_Ticket2438 7h ago

80% of those mobs dont have to be pulled unless you want to, without even doing any crazy skips. The drowned -->city<-- and the ogre stronghold are populated with mobs mainly for aesthetic, what point is a city or a stronghold unless it has people in it.

Both dungeons can be done in under 40 minutes with random pugs

1

u/FluffyWuffyVolibear 7h ago

Idk I enjoy it. Doing a dungeon is a real investment and takes real thought and collaboration. There's a lot of downtime that often gets filled by idle chatting and joking. I've had a great time in every dungeon so far.

1

u/GL2U22 7h ago

Yeah you’re doing something wrong if it’s taking you 2 hours to clear those dungeons. The xp probably feels even worse because you’re taking twice as long to clear something 😂

Get good, nerd. Nah, jk but seriously, even with a bunch of wipes the very first time I went through Kroldok, it still only took like an hour and 15/20.

1

u/MinimumFeedback219 7h ago

My fun is not dependant on mob xp lmfao

1

u/smashisbeast 6h ago

you dont have to pull all the mobs

1

u/Deliverme314 6h ago

I havent done drown city; I skipped it

But you call krol'dok lazy design. It is anything but. Its a seriously awesome dungeon. And, by design, yes its huge. But you can skip 2/3 of the trash mobs.

I am not calling you a bad player. Idgaf. But you have judged this dungeon unfairly. 

1

u/guimontag 6h ago

Brother if it takes you 2 hours to do either of those the issue isn't with the devs lol

1

u/Human_Bison579 5h ago

If Drowned City and Krol'Dok are taking you 2 hours, get good.

1

u/polaris112 5h ago

I ran drowned city twice and only took 1 hr each time, that's with clearing all the mobs for the voodoo artifacts and getting lost

•

u/Greedy-Quantity4062 4h ago

Do not do them, lol. Who cares?

•

u/scorcherdarkly 4h ago

Mechanically, yeah, it kinda sucks.

Thematically, both of these areas are supposed to be CITIES. They should be full of the citizens of that city. So I think it's more of a flavor thing.

•

u/Glupscher 4h ago

Drowned City isn't a 2h dungeon on average lol.

•

u/xharxhojin 3h ago

Get better? These dungeons took about an hour and 15 min each the first time we ran than. And I'm tanking on a bloody shaman so it's not like we are min maxing anything. Both were pretty fun. I enjoyed having to use cc and worrying about peons running into more adds.

•

u/No-Association42069 2h ago

You can always pay retail if you don’t like it.

•

u/Crasp27 1h ago

The dungeons were likely designed independently of the XP adjustments. Their only goal was likely to try to make vanilla feeling dungeons (with mixed results), but yeah if dungeon mob XP were at vanilla rates, these mob-dense dungeons would be fine. 

•

u/TacticalPigeons 1h ago

If drowned city takes you two hours I think you might have other problems to worry about

•

u/JJenJenny 1h ago

2 hours is wild

•

u/TaxProfessional9132 55m ago

Every other vanilla dungeon is trash heavy, I thought these two fit nicely into the game. My only criticism is there are no prequests from random NPC scattered throughout the world that takes you through a chain, I would like it if drowned city was connected to the other troll tablet quest chain in steamwheedle. Shaper's terrace is on the opposite side of the spectrum, barely need to kill any trash and it doesn't feel like it fits purely because of that.

•

u/Cripplechip 42m ago

Because it's fun.

•

u/rubyrider1 25m ago

Krom dok took you two hours to finnish? First time i did it it took exactly one hour, with a group full of randoms. You must be extremely underleveled or lying.

•

u/nexodnb 5m ago

2 hours for 25k xp without quests is insane

1

u/Steel_Serpent_Davos 11h ago

There’s this thing called loot that can drop off mobs, you should read about it.

1

u/Particular_Raise3803 12h ago

Classic = Friction
I guess, which I like. But I recognize that others can feel differently.

0

u/kittentarentino 12h ago

Drops.

Trash mobs actually have some of the best drops in dungeons for a fair bit of them. Super rare, incredibly annoying to get on purpose.

1

u/shanepain0 11h ago

Krol'Dok gives way faster XP than mobbing outside

1

u/ResponsibleAd8978 10h ago

I thought this same thing so I’m happy someone else thought it. The dungeons were really lazy and I don’t think I’d ever do them again on an alt while leveling

0

u/koolex 12h ago

Dungeon xp feels fine, it’s 60% of era

0

u/Kelynill 12h ago

Because it isn’t that low.

0

u/WettestNoodle 12h ago

2 hours if half your group’s brain is leaking out of your ears maybe.

0

u/Shneckos 10h ago

If you’re spending 2 hours in those dungeons you’re doing it wrong

Because Blizz nerfed the crap out of dungeon mob exp, it doesn’t make much sense to pull every mob you see

With skipping packs and the right pathing, Krol’dok will take you 45 minutes

0

u/ExSuntime 8h ago

Because the game isn't designed around the most efficient exp farms and methods. Pretty simple to understand

-1

u/PuddingCupPirate 12h ago

Just go play retail. Just leave.

-1

u/imnotactuallyaperson 12h ago

What's the point of putting enemies to fight in the dungeon? Are you serious?

You guys are batshit crazy at this point.

Also if it's taking 2 hours, that's on you

0

u/Perceptive45 12h ago

If you are spending 2 hours in either of those dungeons your tank is taking you on a wild ride lol

0

u/Whitechix 12h ago

So your group tries to skip and fails further solidifying how awful this dungeon change is.

0

u/SportBoring3533 12h ago

they obviously made the game slower, so it isnt so obvious that they didnt do shit but degenerates leveled to 60 in 3 days anyway, only to see its just a worse version of classic.

0

u/Bohya 11h ago

Artificially inflated playtime metrics that they can show off at the shareholder meetings.

0

u/WheelingWisp 11h ago

My guess is encounter/dungeon design was uninformed of the ridiculous choices whoever is in charge of Dungeon XP would make

0

u/WashedWashingMachine 10h ago

its very good xp

ppl who skip packs are just stupid , clear it lmao

0

u/RoundTechnical8838 9h ago

We been playing them like m+ dungeons and figuring out the skippable packs. Did a drowned city in like 15-20 minutes.

0

u/Diligent-Space-2109 8h ago

lol 2 hour long Krol and DC? Bro just tell us you haven’t been there no need to lie

0

u/SargntNoodlez 5h ago

Then don't run the dungeon that you're clearly bad at anyway. Who gives a shit.

-2

u/WhatupBreak 12h ago

What I’m hearing is that you guys want to run 60 dungeons and be level 60. Complaining about only getting 2-3 bars per run wo quest smh. This is what you’re getting if you don’t like it go play gtv 6 I hear it’s “game of the year” 3 weeks in and still complaining about xp.

1

u/reasonablejim2000 12h ago

What I'm saying is make the dungeons either

  1. Give good xp for the ridiculous amounts of trash packs or
  2. make the dungeons less boring and have more variety.

The two dungeons I mentioned are lazy open world retail design with the same 2 or 3 trash packs repeated over a hundred time in the area. It's terrible dungeon design.

-3

u/KnavoCor 13h ago

To make them very long. Because it is vanilla and they take a long time. This is absolutely the design reason. The journey. Not the reward.

As an anecdote today I saw retail players talking about wanting slower leveling but they all kept saying there had to be a big reward to it as well.

5

u/ibsnuggs 12h ago

Both dungeons op mentioned were not in vanilla.

→ More replies (3)

-4

u/AlexanderAsanaski 12h ago

Dungeon xp is not low lol

I do a dungeon one time with quests and blow through 2 levels usually and end up doing grey and green zone quests

I truly don’t get what you guys are complaining about with dungeon exp

→ More replies (3)