r/classicwow
•
u/reasonablejim2000
•
13h ago
•
1
Forever What's the point in extremely trash heavy dungeons with the mob xp so low?
Drowned City and Krol'Dok are on average 2 hour dungeons with insane amounts of trash. Multiple of packs more than any other dungeon in Classic. And in those two hours you probably only clear 30% of trash.
What exactly is the point of this design? It's not fun, the pack variety is minimal and it's bad xp. It feels like they packed these dungeons with trash just to make them longer for no reason other than a lazy attempt to make them feel "epic".
EDIT: to the people posting you are doing the dungeon in 1 hour and anyone taking 2 hours is "trash", cool good job bro, but you are completely missing the point. It's still not fun, the dungeon design is still lazy and boring, and the xp is still trash.
14
u/moht81 12h ago
2 hour dungeons… that’s a whole raid cleared in retail. It’s too long for a rebooted dad game to be spending in small group content.
98
u/nyxpuppet 12h ago •
The dungeon xp nerf pretty much killed the game for me. I unsubbed. I hope they restore the xp to the way it was in classic. I think that with the way it is right now, it's going to stop Forever from being a long term success and the population will decline heavily after a few months. Blizz want Forever to be a altoholic game, but since dungeons are a one and done and questing is the way they want you to play as a 95-5 questing-dungeon split; it just makes the entire thing incredibly monotonous and boring.
My levelling experience has always been something like 70-30 in favour of dungeons-questing. Even if I did choose to come back, I'd get my priest to 60 and never touch the levelling "journey" ever again on another character. The way they've disincentivized player choice this heavy handedly will not bode well for the long term imo.
228
u/Lyoss 12h ago •
I agree they need to revert the exp nerfs but neither dungeon is 2 hours unless the group is exceptionally slow
35
u/gorillagrip913 9h ago
Because game designers did not know that the 3 clown podcast council would remove all XP from dungeons when they added the trash.
They wanted to make drowned city something that could compete with SM. All the trash before the XP removal would have done that. Now with the clown council making last minute decisions, the entire design of drowned city makes no sense.
36
u/Kbearforlife 12h ago
There needs to be incentive to clear the trash they are putting in the new dungeons apart from the nerfed xp if they want players to engage with them.
40
u/SimpleGuy4141 8h ago
The road to Hell is paved with the best intentions. They had good intentions with the XP nerf. They wanted people questing. They wanted boosting curbed.
What they got was a tank/healer shortage. Dungeon meta of skip everything that is unnecessary. New Dungeon design that falls in line with prior xp philosophy, but makes no sense with curbed xp gains. Splintering of a whole group of players who like to just hang with friends in discord and dungeon spam because they wanted to skip a zone or because they wanted to have fun.
My hope is they cut bait now, revert the changes, tone down the dungeon quest xp, and just let the system work the way it was intended. They tried to reinvent the wheel and it backfired. Move on.
17
u/memekid2007 10h ago
Get Frictioned on xDDDDDD
Blizzard special
•
u/Moddingspreee 3h ago
I did the stronghold with a top tier tank and he knew how to skip almost every pack. It's the new way blizz intends us to play, aka retail speedrun but without the rewards.
4
u/Smelly-Elf 12h ago
I am gonna assume not every dev unanimously decided to nerf dungeon xp. It's possible they made the dungeon before that decision was made.
17
u/Legitimate_Post_8807 12h ago
So that working class folks don't run dungeons
6
u/Klutzy-Caramel-9777 12h ago
I run Stronghold today for first time. It was 1:20 with realy averege groupe, we get lost few times, one wipe and i feel like it ok.
Its true that same packs are really repetetive but you can mount up in dungeos soo its nice that you can use mount inside when you get him. And its feel unique and like real ogre stronghold ( its cant be small).
+ you get skip key in the end.
Soo i kinda like it but yes, there can be less mobs or same more unique "minibosses" insted.
3
u/Equanimity_779 11h ago
Drowned city is like 75 min and I thought it was awesome
6
u/xMoneymonster 11h ago
if krol dok takes you two hours get a better group or look inward and improve
4
u/r3turn_null 13h ago
Great question.
6
u/rodrigo8008 12h ago
My drowned city run was long around 55 minutes, but not sure where you’re getting 2 hours from lol. Why do all of these posts make shit up?
2
u/Zadiuz 12h ago
Everyone in my group just said the same thing about Krol'Dok. But to be fair... it also only took us like just under an hour... and we were all lost and had no idea of where to go for the whole thing.
But we did skip like 80% of the dungeon.
3
u/Jakebaris 13h ago
Yup
3
u/AltruisticFilm4466 12h ago
Im more worried you take 2hours to clear drowned city and kroldok maybe you shouldn’t be posting here and question game design
2
u/rr770 10h ago
There is no point. Blizzard devs simply don't know what they are doing
1
u/FroztyBeard 12h ago
After doing Drowned City: It felt like a mini-raid, similar to BRDs and the like. So feels like Drowned City was a early first taste of a mini-raid dungeon
Managed to tank it to full completion, took around 1 hour-ish and I enjoyed the dungeon for what it was
1
u/aglock 12h ago
My first runs on both Drowned City and KrolDok where all bosses in about an hour. They could be 30 minutes runs if you know the path and play quickly. 2 hours is not the normal clear time.
1
u/Coulstwolf 10h ago
Drowned city took my group 47 mins it was all of our first time there, we did all quests
1
u/thexzmeh 10h ago
To waste your time
1
u/BIitzez 9h ago
no incentive. in blackmaw hold, kroldok and drowned city we ran right by 70% of the trash.
i was told getting the collection quest done from the pirates wasnt possible in one run so we just skipped that shit too.
1
u/thrillho145 9h ago
They need to nerf the hp of some of the dungeon mobs. They're really high
1
u/MoreLikeGaewyn 8h ago
Blizzard not knowing what the fuck they're are doing.
1
u/jamesbongsixtynine 8h ago
to spite you lol
1
u/No_Ticket2438 7h ago
80% of those mobs dont have to be pulled unless you want to, without even doing any crazy skips. The drowned -->city<-- and the ogre stronghold are populated with mobs mainly for aesthetic, what point is a city or a stronghold unless it has people in it.
Both dungeons can be done in under 40 minutes with random pugs
1
u/FluffyWuffyVolibear 7h ago
Idk I enjoy it. Doing a dungeon is a real investment and takes real thought and collaboration. There's a lot of downtime that often gets filled by idle chatting and joking. I've had a great time in every dungeon so far.
1
u/GL2U22 7h ago
Yeah you’re doing something wrong if it’s taking you 2 hours to clear those dungeons. The xp probably feels even worse because you’re taking twice as long to clear something 😂
Get good, nerd. Nah, jk but seriously, even with a bunch of wipes the very first time I went through Kroldok, it still only took like an hour and 15/20.
1
u/MinimumFeedback219 7h ago
My fun is not dependant on mob xp lmfao
1
u/smashisbeast 6h ago
you dont have to pull all the mobs
1
u/Deliverme314 6h ago
I havent done drown city; I skipped it
But you call krol'dok lazy design. It is anything but. Its a seriously awesome dungeon. And, by design, yes its huge. But you can skip 2/3 of the trash mobs.
I am not calling you a bad player. Idgaf. But you have judged this dungeon unfairly.
1
u/guimontag 6h ago
Brother if it takes you 2 hours to do either of those the issue isn't with the devs lol
1
u/Human_Bison579 5h ago
If Drowned City and Krol'Dok are taking you 2 hours, get good.
1
u/polaris112 5h ago
I ran drowned city twice and only took 1 hr each time, that's with clearing all the mobs for the voodoo artifacts and getting lost
•
u/Greedy-Quantity4062 4h ago
Do not do them, lol. Who cares?
•
u/scorcherdarkly 4h ago
Mechanically, yeah, it kinda sucks.
Thematically, both of these areas are supposed to be CITIES. They should be full of the citizens of that city. So I think it's more of a flavor thing.
•
u/Glupscher 4h ago
Drowned City isn't a 2h dungeon on average lol.
•
u/xharxhojin 3h ago
Get better? These dungeons took about an hour and 15 min each the first time we ran than. And I'm tanking on a bloody shaman so it's not like we are min maxing anything. Both were pretty fun. I enjoyed having to use cc and worrying about peons running into more adds.
•
u/No-Association42069 2h ago
You can always pay retail if you don’t like it.
•
u/Crasp27 1h ago
The dungeons were likely designed independently of the XP adjustments. Their only goal was likely to try to make vanilla feeling dungeons (with mixed results), but yeah if dungeon mob XP were at vanilla rates, these mob-dense dungeons would be fine.
•
u/TacticalPigeons 1h ago
If drowned city takes you two hours I think you might have other problems to worry about
•
u/JJenJenny 1h ago
2 hours is wild
•
u/TaxProfessional9132 55m ago
Every other vanilla dungeon is trash heavy, I thought these two fit nicely into the game. My only criticism is there are no prequests from random NPC scattered throughout the world that takes you through a chain, I would like it if drowned city was connected to the other troll tablet quest chain in steamwheedle. Shaper's terrace is on the opposite side of the spectrum, barely need to kill any trash and it doesn't feel like it fits purely because of that.
•
u/Cripplechip 42m ago
Because it's fun.
•
u/rubyrider1 25m ago
Krom dok took you two hours to finnish? First time i did it it took exactly one hour, with a group full of randoms. You must be extremely underleveled or lying.
•
u/nexodnb 5m ago
2 hours for 25k xp without quests is insane
1
u/Steel_Serpent_Davos 11h ago
There’s this thing called loot that can drop off mobs, you should read about it.
1
u/Particular_Raise3803 12h ago
Classic = Friction
I guess, which I like. But I recognize that others can feel differently.
0
u/kittentarentino 12h ago
Drops.
Trash mobs actually have some of the best drops in dungeons for a fair bit of them. Super rare, incredibly annoying to get on purpose.
1
u/shanepain0 11h ago
Krol'Dok gives way faster XP than mobbing outside
1
u/ResponsibleAd8978 10h ago
I thought this same thing so I’m happy someone else thought it. The dungeons were really lazy and I don’t think I’d ever do them again on an alt while leveling
0
u/koolex 12h ago
Dungeon xp feels fine, it’s 60% of era
0
u/Kelynill 12h ago
Because it isn’t that low.
0
u/WettestNoodle 12h ago
2 hours if half your group’s brain is leaking out of your ears maybe.
0
u/Shneckos 10h ago
If you’re spending 2 hours in those dungeons you’re doing it wrong
Because Blizz nerfed the crap out of dungeon mob exp, it doesn’t make much sense to pull every mob you see
With skipping packs and the right pathing, Krol’dok will take you 45 minutes
0
u/ExSuntime 8h ago
Because the game isn't designed around the most efficient exp farms and methods. Pretty simple to understand
-1
u/PuddingCupPirate 12h ago
Just go play retail. Just leave.
-1
u/imnotactuallyaperson 12h ago
What's the point of putting enemies to fight in the dungeon? Are you serious?
You guys are batshit crazy at this point.
Also if it's taking 2 hours, that's on you
0
u/TheClassicAndyDev 12h ago
Suffering.
0
u/Perceptive45 12h ago
If you are spending 2 hours in either of those dungeons your tank is taking you on a wild ride lol
0
u/Whitechix 12h ago
So your group tries to skip and fails further solidifying how awful this dungeon change is.
0
u/SportBoring3533 12h ago
they obviously made the game slower, so it isnt so obvious that they didnt do shit but degenerates leveled to 60 in 3 days anyway, only to see its just a worse version of classic.
0
u/Bohya 11h ago
Artificially inflated playtime metrics that they can show off at the shareholder meetings.
0
u/WheelingWisp 11h ago
My guess is encounter/dungeon design was uninformed of the ridiculous choices whoever is in charge of Dungeon XP would make
0
u/WashedWashingMachine 10h ago
its very good xp
ppl who skip packs are just stupid , clear it lmao
0
u/RoundTechnical8838 9h ago
We been playing them like m+ dungeons and figuring out the skippable packs. Did a drowned city in like 15-20 minutes.
0
u/Diligent-Space-2109 8h ago
lol 2 hour long Krol and DC? Bro just tell us you haven’t been there no need to lie
0
u/SargntNoodlez 5h ago
Then don't run the dungeon that you're clearly bad at anyway. Who gives a shit.
-2
u/WhatupBreak 12h ago
What I’m hearing is that you guys want to run 60 dungeons and be level 60. Complaining about only getting 2-3 bars per run wo quest smh. This is what you’re getting if you don’t like it go play gtv 6 I hear it’s “game of the year” 3 weeks in and still complaining about xp.
-3
u/KnavoCor 13h ago
To make them very long. Because it is vanilla and they take a long time. This is absolutely the design reason. The journey. Not the reward.
As an anecdote today I saw retail players talking about wanting slower leveling but they all kept saying there had to be a big reward to it as well.
-4
u/AlexanderAsanaski 12h ago
Dungeon xp is not low lol
I do a dungeon one time with quests and blow through 2 levels usually and end up doing grey and green zone quests
I truly don’t get what you guys are complaining about with dungeon exp