r/classicwow • u/scrumdidlyumpscious • 5h ago
Forever Why did Blizzard design and implement all these new dungeons with the intention of them only being touched once(ish)?
Genuine question; has it been brought up in any of the interviews/podcasts?
It seems like such a colossal waste of resources, and honestly a bit sad to have built these brand new dungeons and bosses/fights only to have people skip through them one time as quickly as possible since there’s zero incentive for clearing/exploring them more.
Edit: People seem to think this is a whining post. I assure you it’s not. I couldn’t care less how people want to play the game, it just seems like the changes they made to dungeons were counter-intuitive to trying to get people to experience all this new content they created so I was curious what their thought process was.
Edit2: Maybe I should have clarified, this largely relates to dungeons during the leveling process. If the idea was for people to run through these multiple times it seems like it would have been better to make the newer dungeons 60 content so people would feel more inclined to run them multiple times.
65
u/ISmellHats 5h ago •
You're catching a lot of flak in the comments, as do the other "dungeon posters" but people are so hyperfixated on their own anecdotal experience that they're ignoring something the devs themselves had brought up. The "invisible hand" that prods players into certain content over others.
There is a very clear incentive at play to only run the dungeons once for the quests. Whether someone actually does or doesn't run it more than once is irrelevant, the point is that the incentives drop off significantly after the initial run.
In addition to other people's anecdotes, my own experience is that the vast majority of my guild is interested in running each dungeon 1-2 times at most. The only exception is when we are working to pull other guild members up and are helping carry them through the content to finish quests but individually, it's significantly less efficient than just questing, especially given the rewards really aren't "that" far apart.
12
u/McKnightmare24 5h ago
I have literally ran every dungeon multiple times. You guys need to stop believing that everyone is only running a dungeon once.
20
u/Bluemoo25 5h ago
I like the new dungeons but sweet baby Christmas they're harder than the regular ones
•
u/TheClassicAndyDev 3h ago
Because the people who are "designing" the game don't know what they are doing.
It's that simple.
2
u/rinkydinkis 5h ago
Once per alt
•
u/pigzyf5 4h ago
Because it is easy low hanging fruit since it is just an instance portal in the over world.
6
u/Dry-Olive4621 5h ago
Just remember these folks dont play their own games like we do. If they have more than a hundred hours on a toon id be surprised. Its just a thing they sell us to get more sub time.
17
u/Thin_Mousse4149 5h ago
They didn’t. They want you to make alts. I don’t know how people aren’t getting that. The entire game is built around replayability with alts.
3
u/Low_Cancel_6930 5h ago
I did every dungeon exactly once for the quests as a di priest then I came to Zul'Farrack and troll temper does not drop in sufficient amounts to give 5 players the 20 they need so I ran it again, and again... and now maraudon is in sight and I honestly cant wait for the 2 runs that will take
•
u/Raghul86 2h ago
I think there are opposing forces within the dev team. I think the dungeon designers were hoping to see their work get all the milage it could get, but someone higher up are pushing their means against the botting/boosting with little respect for this
•
u/Jooylo 3h ago
In vanilla wow I don’t think the intention ever was for people to run a dungeon more than once, and from what I recall I don’t think most people did because the process of forming a group and traversing through it took a lot of time and a lot of work. I could have just had a different experience, but spamming dungeons feels like a more modern thing.
Additionally, there is the expectation that you level alts in forever, which would mean running them more than once - just on a different characters.
2
u/Lazyseer 5h ago
I think it came up briefly in the podcast episode about dungeons. The pair of dungeon designers that were there said that they hoped people did them more then once. But clearly the people pouring all their time into making cool dungeons don't get to make the exp rules for them.
•
u/peepjv 2h ago
My hope is that we get heroics so there’s a reason to go back to them.
1
u/Praktos 5h ago
To be fair as first time wow player entering game with like 20-30 dungs and hoping from 1 to the other exploring them might have been the peak lvling content
•
u/Potential-Juice-8060 4h ago
They expect people to make a LOT of alts and the game does go “forever”
•
u/Smelly-Elf 1h ago
My guess is that the devs are split between dungeon supporters and anti dungeon supporters. Probably sole senior designers forced the change ladt minute
•
u/fizzlefade 1h ago
Many might disagree but if we are doing horizontal progression I would like to see heroic dungeons each with their gear drops that have different use cases. For example items that are better on beasts, undead, etc think of it like pokemon element types grass fire water etc.
Then new raid content would be a specific mob type like undead so you’d want to go farm those dungeons for a gear set that will help you clear that raid. So with each new raid you would be incentivized to farm the dungeons that have the gear that helps against that specific raid.
This is what horizontal progression looks like to me and what I honestly want for this game. It would mean these dungeons and gear would stay relevant forever essentially.
New gear can still be released but there has to be like an upgrade progression for it where the previous BiS piece is required to obtain the new one which keeps the old content alive still and keeping any progression you’ve done relevant with newer content.
The problem with this is that it is hard to get right and I’m worried that they won’t.
•
u/Anipsy 53m ago
Probably because dungeons were designed by a different team from the one that decided to make them obsolete
•
u/Zorewin 53m ago
Cause there stupid... they should restore dungeon xp and let people play however they want, that is the spirit of classic.. the world wide open every possibility do wat you want
•
u/PpOo-QG 26m ago
RPG solo games like FF or Zelda have a ton of donjon and content with the intention of being touched once.
It’s just that you are used to replay donjon in retail so for you it should be the same in forever.
•
u/Vento_of_the_Front 6m ago
Two different developer teams being out of touch with each other, and for whatever reason their leads aren't allowed to either talk about their work or are way too polite and can't ask "what the hell are you doing?".
It kinda feels the same as with Starfield - there, your main "ability" is to replay the game with the same character(NG+), something that wasn't a thing in TES/Fallout, but for some reason devs also felt the need to retain the core "player should be able to do everything in one playthrough" logic, which quite literally doesn't work at all with NG+ system.
Same here - new dungeons are fun, but there is little to no reason to do them after first run, double so because drops are, at times, questionable.
•
u/Excellent_Rule_2778 5m ago
I’ve ran most dungeon twice simply because I wanted a specific item, or because one of the quests couldn’t be done in one go.
But the idea of Forever is that you’d eventually want to level alts.
1
u/Notris 5h ago
I think replayability is at the core of what Forever is supposed to be. The legacy system strongly hints at this.
There are 27 specs, but only two specs per character, so one would have to make about 14 characters to truly experience them all, and that doesn't even take into account niche specs such as shockadin.
Moreover, new races and classes, as well as race-class combinations have all been stated to be in the works, so that number is just going to keep going up.
Outside of a leveling context, though, I truly don't see most of them mattering, unfortunately, but again: plenty of that to be had across alts.
•
u/Zestymonserellastick 3h ago
Designing a dungeon for one player to run once it a waste of time. Several million people play this game. If 2 million people do a dungeon once. That dungeon has more game time in it alone from 1 run from everyone then entire games have.
It no longer a waste of time of 2 million people run it once.
0
u/Dahamuran 5h ago
It’s like these posts never end…I think I’ve entered the algorithm death spiral for dungeon xp posts.

-2
u/Trackback_ 5h ago
Why did Blizzard make all these new quests with the intention of them only being touched once?
I want to spam the boar killing quest in Durotar until level 60 with my friends, why is Blizzard forcing me to play another way?!?
0
u/CharacterBalance4187 5h ago
Because its the players saying that and not blizzard maybe. Idk.
0
u/Greendayy77 5h ago
Tbh, I am so happy I dinged 55 and now I can FINALLY run 55+ dungeons more than once since we get currency daily.
-3
u/Buttliquors 5h ago
Can we rename this subreddit to wowforeverdungeoncomplaints
-6
u/Rappyfan 5h ago
The idea of „it’s only worth doing once“ is a thing brought up by min maxers. You can do them for fun, for loot and even for exp if you don’t mind it being a little slower.
-6
u/EXPLODING-SPUD 5h ago
God you people complaining about the same non-issue on and on are insufferable.
-5
u/pleasuredunes 5h ago
•
u/PucThePuc 4h ago
I think they just failed to realize how many wow players are fucked up in the head, jumping into a game designed to enjoy the leveling while they absolutely hate it
-4
u/GL2U22 5h ago
Feels like I’ve seen this exact question asked 20+ times on the wow subreddits over the past couple of weeks.
-2
u/ThatMoth420 5h ago
I’m glad they added them. Gives players more options to pick from while leveling.
Doesn’t seem like a waste of resources to me, not all players want to zoom through dungeons. In every group I’ve been we take our time, kill optional bosses, and help each other with quests. Complete randoms. If someone is whining about us taking too long and it becomes a problem the leader will usually just kick them and list the group again.
-2
u/According_Ride1646 5h ago
It was my turn to post the “every 5 minute whining about dungeons post”
-1
u/pillbinge 5h ago
Because horizontal improvement means you run it more than once across multiple characters.
-1
u/Yikidee 5h ago
Cause people that continue to play will have multiple alts, so will see them again and again.
Personally I love it. Keeps you in the world.
-1
u/Scurb00 5h ago
I run dungeons many times as a healer. The exp isnt terrible and I want the loot to make my life easier while questing.
This one and done mentality is why so many people are struggling with their characters and coming to reddit to complain that they feel weak.
-5
u/Remote-Guest2587 5h ago
i’ve ran all the dungeons available to me, new and old, multiple times for loot and fun. just bc you skip them for whatever reason doesn’t mean most people do.
in fact they give too much xp, i wish it was less and give me a chance at all the cool leveling gear.
-8
u/PureCauliflower6758 5h ago
Whine forever.
•
u/losetrich777 3h ago
there are 35 dungeons in the game from lvl 13 to 60 and doing the quests would probably give at least 1-1.5 lvls (with the dungeon xp).
If spamming same dungeons was a classic thing then that is miserable as hell lol and don’t want to take part in that lol.
I’d rather get to 60 doing them all one time than getting to 60 missing half and spamming the other half ten times.
Also, I don’t mind doing dungeons again to help guildies and friends.