r/classicwow • • 5h ago

Forever Why did Blizzard design and implement all these new dungeons with the intention of them only being touched once(ish)?

Genuine question; has it been brought up in any of the interviews/podcasts?

It seems like such a colossal waste of resources, and honestly a bit sad to have built these brand new dungeons and bosses/fights only to have people skip through them one time as quickly as possible since there’s zero incentive for clearing/exploring them more.

Edit: People seem to think this is a whining post. I assure you it’s not. I couldn’t care less how people want to play the game, it just seems like the changes they made to dungeons were counter-intuitive to trying to get people to experience all this new content they created so I was curious what their thought process was.

Edit2: Maybe I should have clarified, this largely relates to dungeons during the leveling process. If the idea was for people to run through these multiple times it seems like it would have been better to make the newer dungeons 60 content so people would feel more inclined to run them multiple times.

148 Upvotes

214 comments sorted by

65

u/ISmellHats 5h ago • Bravo

You're catching a lot of flak in the comments, as do the other "dungeon posters" but people are so hyperfixated on their own anecdotal experience that they're ignoring something the devs themselves had brought up. The "invisible hand" that prods players into certain content over others.
There is a very clear incentive at play to only run the dungeons once for the quests. Whether someone actually does or doesn't run it more than once is irrelevant, the point is that the incentives drop off significantly after the initial run.

In addition to other people's anecdotes, my own experience is that the vast majority of my guild is interested in running each dungeon 1-2 times at most. The only exception is when we are working to pull other guild members up and are helping carry them through the content to finish quests but individually, it's significantly less efficient than just questing, especially given the rewards really aren't "that" far apart.

•

u/SellGameRent 2h ago

I told my guild today I would gquit before I run drowned city a 2nd time haha. Terrible exp terrible dungeon

•

u/OnAnotherWon 2h ago

Whoever designed that underwater section should never have a say in this game again.

•

u/BloederFuchs 1h ago

That part is optional, at least. I actually liked the dungeon's design. Stronghold however is absolute trash

•

u/DeskCrumbs 47m ago

Stronghold feels like the most retail dungeon so far

•

u/21stGun 2h ago

You can make alts. Those can run any dungeons you want too. I intend to play most of the dungeons I skipped on my main when I level alts.

12

u/McKnightmare24 5h ago

I have literally ran every dungeon multiple times. You guys need to stop believing that everyone is only running a dungeon once.

8

u/scrumdidlyumpscious 5h ago

Can you elaborate on why? Genuinely asking as I’ve tanked/DPS’d every dungeon up to ST now and I don’t see any reason to go back after I’ve completed the quests (which sans a couple of the egregious drop-based ones I’ve completed in one go).

The loot gets replaced with the next dungeon or two which I can sometimes straight up chain back-to-back or maybe level once in between, and the exp is hardly noticeable.

•

u/Belial91 2h ago

A friend of min ran ZF 10 times for the epic sword.

A friend of mine ran cathedral 12 times because he never got the shield to drop.

•

u/scrumdidlyumpscious 2h ago

Fair. Ironically, I got both swords my first and only run so my luck may have something to do my my perception.

6

u/Kiu88 5h ago

I've tanked every easter kingdom dungeon ava7lable to me at 45 2-5 times, except drowned city, fuck that place.

My reasons are simple, I enjoy dungeons, I've wanted drops, I've helped out groups with quests/other dungeons(twice I ran all of SM for different groups because fuck it, I'm already there) and lastly to round up any drop quests/kill quests.

•

u/GerardTheButler 4h ago

is the SM confounder because the 30-40 levelling experience incidentally also sucks?

•

u/Kiu88 4h ago

Nah, honestly a mix of habbit from pre cata / classic, having run all the way up there might aswell get your moneys worth, many of the groups wanting to do another wing and I don't mind helping. Not in a rush to 60, between work, marriage and children I can't commit to raiding so fuck speed, fun/h is more important to me

•

u/GerardTheButler 4h ago

Ya know mate, that's entirely fair enough. I hope you're enjoying yourself.

•

u/Inside-Associate-729 3h ago

Arent there two brand new zones for that level range which people are saying are pretty sick?

•

u/GerardTheButler 3h ago

Riverglades is 35-45, I like it but it definitely isn't designed for you to walk in just at 35.

2

u/Visible-Complaint-60 5h ago

Just like trades. I've been level 60 for a week and i did not forge a single of the new blue recipe because its too much gold for something that will be obsolete in a few level or that goves +2stam and +3 strength vs my questing gear. Yet i see plenty of people forging them and delaying mount.

1

u/thejudgmental 5h ago

People find them fun?

1

u/Kaztiell 5h ago

What dungeons give full set of gear?

1

u/abowlofrice1 5h ago

Because we are playing this game?

•

u/Sudden-Ad-307 0m ago

Man what are you talking about? SFK gear for casters will genuienly last you till 30 plus and the xp from dungeons is actually not that bad. People just see the xp is not as good as it used to be therefore its shit, when this is not the case at all.

•

u/firememble 4h ago

Because you see a cool set and wanna have it, because you want some trinket or ring, because going in as a full low level party is fun and you actually struggle especially in the new dungeons. Getting good gear at a level that's not 60 might be useless to you and only "slow you down" but it makes you really powerful in the open world for pvp and questing. I really don't understand why everything revolves around being level 60 it's so stupid.

39

u/tarzan1376 5h ago

It's not everyone, but its the vast majority of players. They added the armory to wow forever and we are able to get the actual data. 83% of players enter a dungeon once and never re-enter it.

https://classicarmory.gg/forever/dungeons

•

u/Beltox2pointO 4h ago

This data doesn't mean much if you don't have the comparable data of 2019 classic or classic anniversary.

•

u/tarzan1376 3h ago

I don't see how that would add to the discussion at all?

•

u/Beltox2pointO 3h ago

You don't see how comparing it to before the change would contextualise it appropriately???

How would you ever know it's changed

•

u/tarzan1376 3h ago

What would that change about the current situation?

•

u/Beltox2pointO 3h ago

Imagine you had the other data sets and it was a similar number, what would you say then?

•

u/tarzan1376 3h ago

Data for the other versions matters very little when we are trying to address claims in this version.

•

u/Beltox2pointO 3h ago

The claim was made in response to the post.

Of course it matters.

•

u/tarzan1376 2h ago

Just cause you insist it matters doesn't mean much if you can't even explain why it matters.

→ More replies

•

u/Belial91 3h ago

Are you daft? People say low experience is the reason dungeons are ran only once. If they wer also only run once in classic the XP change doesn't make a difference.

•

u/tarzan1376 2h ago

It does make a difference when Aggrend stated he doesn't want dungeons to be a one and done deal. 83% of players not re-entering a dungeon is a huge miss on their goal.

it sounds like it only matters because the current data doesn't fit the narrative that the changes haven't affected dungeon participation.

→ More replies

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

You'd probably take off your pseudo-intellectual "erm actually no cross examined data" and use your brain to think how many dungeons were ran back in 2019.

•

u/Beltox2pointO 3h ago

Or I could just point out that if we don't have the data, we can't really know. Because we can't.

It's just as likely the amount of dungeons that were ran was severely over-stated because of a small number of people running magnitudes more.

You also have outliers like SM, the 30-40 stretch was improved so maybe people wouldn't spam them even if they could. But hey, don't worry about facts or evidence, just make up claims!

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

Sure bro we all hallucinated the amount of dungeons ran in 2019. We also pretended that it was meta. Did you perhaps not play in 2019? Or wow in general before now? It would be a widely known fact that people did dungeons much more back then. You can even look up screenshots of SM or videos during the 2019 launch. There was more people waiting outside dungeons there for I guess their "one run" as you'd assume than in any quest zone now.

But if we can't retroactively go back and get the data I guess we can all just be dumb as fuck as think we run dungeons at similar rates!

And yeah people not doing repeat dungoens because its a waste of time. Not because questing got better. But I guess you need to run a poll about that too before you make an educated guess? Bahaha

•

u/Beltox2pointO 3h ago

It's hilarious that you're getting this mad about me wanting a comparison.

You could very easily level without having to spam dungeons in other versions.

•

u/Belial91 2h ago

This sub when you want comparable statistics:

( 。 •̀ ᴖ •́ 。)

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

And now you have to? And can't level in dungeons? And I'm not mad. Your blood pressure rising because of my words on your screen actually indicates you are upset :) but by all means go deflect and project more mr graphs and charts.

→ More replies

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

LMAO do you actually fucking think for a second with all the pitching about how everyone only did dungeons that its anywhere near a one and done dungeon experience? I bet 2019 release had probably 4000% more dungeons being ran from 1-50 than now. At LEAST 4000%.

23

u/Fun_Literature_2710 5h ago

and you're probably level 23. Most people are only running them once

1

u/Fuyukage 5h ago

I’m level 40. Ran probably half of them multiple times 🤷‍♂️

•

u/ISmellHats 4h ago

You are the exception to the rule. The overwhelming majority of players run each dungeon once. Most people are not farming leveling dungeons repeatedly to get a minor gear upgrade.

11

u/Ok-Virus-5921 5h ago

I’m 60, I could earn triple the exp doing quests

-1

u/CrimsonGoose1408 5h ago

Cool. Not everyone is in a rush

10

u/Ok-Virus-5921 5h ago

Everyone faster then me is in a rush, everyone slower than me is an unc.

-2

u/DHGaming18 5h ago

And I can guarantee absolutely 0 people will care that you’ve cleared the raid before them. I’d say go back to retail like the average classic wow Reddit user would, but you’d probably get slept by a normal raid boss in that game.

•

u/Ok-Virus-5921 3h ago

Hey tourist, I know you dont keep up with the boards and have a narcissistic problem of manufacturing false group consent, but if you read the boards or Reddit you’ll see people are losing their minds about not hitting the first raid on time.

Also you can’t read because literally that’s not what the comment or my response is about.

Truly amazing work here.

•

u/DHGaming18 3h ago

You’re right, I don’t live on Reddit. I actually play the game.

•

u/Tankzorx 3h ago

“I actually play the game”
He wrote while replying to a comment deep in the thread about a game change that doesn’t affect his own gameplay. Clown..

•

u/Ok-Virus-5921 1h ago

Do you? So you’re 60? So why are you upset about doing raids week 1? 

Unless you don’t really play and don’t really go on boards, and are in fact a tourist.

-1

u/CrimsonGoose1408 5h ago

Viewing dungeons purely as a waste of xp with no reason to run twice is rushing. That’s viewing the game from a mentality of rushing.

Edit: I’m also not saying there is anything wrong with that. Likewise spending time and not viewing every game action by its efficiency is also not wrong.

•

u/Ok-Virus-5921 3h ago

Okay I can be out in a fully narrated world with spoken with new partial effects and ray traced lighting in groups seeing story content I forgot about or never read and get 3x the exp.

Or I can grind for nothing and some loot that won’t matter tomorrow.

•

u/MonsieurHorny 4h ago

Well there’s effort vs reward. I ran dungeons a few times on my way to 60, the reward is not worth the effort. If my goal is to level up I would do the dungeon once for quest and continue onto the next open world hub. I RP and try to immerse myself in the world but still play in a way that respects my time.

Dungeons do not respect the time and effort I put in past the one run. City of Dalaran is a big offender of this. Why would I do a mara run again if everyone’s doing their quest run and it’ll take 2 hours for shit exp?

•

u/CrimsonGoose1408 3h ago

And that’s fine. I already have in my comment that I don’t see an issue with that. Many many people don’t view the game as xp bar that needs filled and instead are doing what they find fun, in spite of xp gains. Why run Mara twice? Bc Mara is fun and I’m in no rush to get past it.

-1

u/Kaztiell 5h ago

Noone cares. Noone will miss raids. No need to rush

•

u/Ok-Virus-5921 3h ago

What about my comment said raids.

What if you just want a spectral bear mount.

What if you just don’t want to spend 30 hours of your life in dungeons for no gain towards your personal goals.

•

u/Kaztiell 2h ago

then dont spend time in dungeons if you dont have any goal in them, I dont see the problem

-1

u/randomCAguy 5h ago

Maybe the first batch of more dedicated/hardcore players are running them once. The laid back slower crowd are probably open to multiple runs.

•

u/ISmellHats 4h ago

Open to it? Maybe. Statistically repeating them? Not at all.

-3

u/MXC_Vic_Romano 5h ago

48 and have ran each dungeon on the way at least 3 times.

•

u/Tankzorx 3h ago

Call the police, we have a dungeon spammer at our hands.

•

u/MrPoopMonster 2h ago edited 2h ago

A very large portion of the player base is though. Enough that the devs talked about it.

It's also a weird disconnect that at the end game they tie very significant rewards to running dungeons over and over(not just loot drops), but completely disincentivise you from doing that while leveling.

-6

u/EXPLODING-SPUD 5h ago

How is this possible? The Internet says it's not the most efficient way to play? Are you saying you are playing the game in a less than perfectly optimal fashion!? Oh it's horrifying!

6

u/LatentSchref 5h ago

What he isn't telling you is he ran them twice and he only did that because Blizzard has intentionally set up some dungeon quests so that you must run them twice to complete them.

20

u/Bluemoo25 5h ago

I like the new dungeons but sweet baby Christmas they're harder than the regular ones

3

u/solitarium 5h ago

Sounds like I need to get a move on. Only lvl 30

•

u/Tankzorx 3h ago

So because someone is ahead of you, you conclude you have to rush yourself. You sound stupid.

•

u/baraboosh 3h ago

Or he's just excited to try the new dungeons after hearing they're more challenging

•

u/JayThee 36m ago

What is wrong with you. Can you only make negative assumptions and can think of nothing else? You sound stupid.

•

u/Dankennsteinn 3h ago

Which ones have been more difficult? I’ve done City of Dalaran and below and they’ve all seemed pretty run of the mill as far as difficulty. Would look forward to some more challenging ones honestly.

•

u/Jooylo 2h ago

Drowned City and Krol’dok are a step up, I’ve heard people having trouble in them but the groups I was in got through without any deaths. Did have to CC a bit in Krol’dok. Part of that’s largely also luck of the draw with the people in my dungeon groups of course.

•

u/ribombeeee 2h ago

Drowned city was really easy, I stuck around to help other people do it and no one died, even had some underleveled people. The only time I’ve wiped in any dungeon is when the tank is retailedpilled and never looks at my mana or reads chat, and just pulls pulls pulls

•

u/fromfrodotogollum 2h ago

Neither of those were tougher than excavation site wetlands for me, a healer.

•

u/Dietberd 2h ago

Krol'dok with a melee grp can be difficult because the mobs cleave a lot. With a range grp it's not that bad.

•

u/Demmandred 1h ago

It's fine if people actually move out or stun but this is classic so they die to 3 grunts doing a bladestorm and say HEAL?

•

u/Elfeden 2h ago

The raptors do twice the damage other elites do at that level I'm quite sure.

•

u/Markgormley69 1h ago

I just tanked it at level 50 for my buddies and the raptors were still hitting me decently hard lol

•

u/TheClassicAndyDev 3h ago

Because the people who are "designing" the game don't know what they are doing.

It's that simple.

•

u/EnigmaticQuote 1h ago

Not like the perfect idea of posters here lmaoooo

2

u/rinkydinkis 5h ago

Once per alt

•

u/pigzyf5 4h ago

Because it is easy low hanging fruit since it is just an instance portal in the over world.

6

u/Dry-Olive4621 5h ago

Just remember these folks dont play their own games like we do. If they have more than a hundred hours on a toon id be surprised. Its just a thing they sell us to get more sub time. 

17

u/Thin_Mousse4149 5h ago

They didn’t. They want you to make alts. I don’t know how people aren’t getting that. The entire game is built around replayability with alts.

•

u/Robofcourse 1h ago

Can you explain? I read this a lot on the sub but the only alt thing I've seen is the legacy points. How else is the game designed around alts?

•

u/Character-Revenue-44 1h ago

There isno end game, the entire game as of now is leveling. So its based around having alts

•

u/Robofcourse 1h ago

Having no end game doesn't mean the game is pushing for alts, it means there is not much to do at 60. But at level 60 people can gear up for raids, no? Or do dungeons? There is still profession gear to grind, gold to make, etc?

15

u/kjhgglk 5h ago

Lol.

I will never make an alt as long as dungeons give shit xp like they are now.

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 4h ago

Ok well enjoy your one play through. Bye.

•

u/kjhgglk 4h ago

No chance for that in this quest meta.

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 4h ago

The fact that you’re looking for a meta says everything. Forget about the meta. Just fucking enjoy what you have. If you can’t enjoy it, then maybe this game isn’t for you. Not everything needs to be for you.

•

u/kjhgglk 4h ago

I want to enjoy dungeons by getting xp from them.

I want to stay inside dungeons starting from RFC all the way to 60 and only play with the same 4 people the entire time.

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 1h ago

Also fwiw I have absolutely leveled once in every dungeon

•

u/JustATextBox 1h ago

Also fwiw I have absolutely leveled once in every dungeon

What does this mean exactly? Yeah, if you do the dungeon quests, you'll probably level. Without the quests however, you'll get maybe 20% of a level per dungeon run

•

u/Every_Ad_6168 1h ago

Then do so. If you enjoy dungeons that much more than the rest of the game then surely getting to play more of them isn't a bad thing?

•

u/PucThePuc 4h ago

That just makes you weird as fuck for picking up this game at all

•

u/Global-Resident-647 4h ago

Why? Dungeon exp was hardly advertised to be massively nerfed..

•

u/PucThePuc 3h ago

Uh yes? It's been like this since very early beta

•

u/kjhgglk 3h ago

Not at all, thats what a friendless loser might think of it. But its quite fun.

•

u/PucThePuc 3h ago

Exactly what I'm saying. It's fun - despite the experience nerf. That's reason enough and if you opt out because it's not the fastest way to 60 your weird as fuck

•

u/kjhgglk 3h ago

The only weird one here is you for judging how other people play a video game lmao. Such a loser attitude.

→ More replies

•

u/Tankzorx 3h ago

If you’re a friendless loser that is not so good at the game, you shouldn’t level as fast as a full premade who knows how to play and that’s okay.

→ More replies

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

Yea its also fun getting to 60 before the game shuts down but with people like you policing its downfall I fear that day is coming faster and faster. And the xp is not getting any better.

How long do you think 14-60 would take in just dungeons? What if they nerfed questing to take as long? Would you play? Nope.

→ More replies

3

u/Raminax 5h ago

That's stupid 

6

u/Thin_Mousse4149 5h ago

It isn’t stupid. It is literally what they want you to do. That’s why the legacy points are set up in the way that they are. It helps you get involved in the world rather than just rushing levels in dungeons over and over again having the exact same experience over and over and over again. That’s why retail is not very fun.

•

u/Magehunter_Skassi 4h ago

WoW Forever doesn't have the replayability for that until they add years of more content. WoW Retail can design around alts because you have so many options in where you want level. The game is way too half-baked to support this dungeon change.

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 4h ago

Highly disagree. Wow has TONS of content in classic. It would be nice if Reddit wasn’t filled with a bunch of negative, pessimistic losers. Enjoy the fucking game or don’t play damn it.

•

u/Potential-Juice-8060 4h ago

“Enjoy it the way I want you to or not at all” the comment

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 4h ago

Sorry, the world does not get served to you on a silver platter. Enjoy what you’ve been given or be miserable. Those are literally your options. You can have whatever opinion you want, but that doesn’t change the reality.

•

u/Bulky-Nectarine1402 4h ago

It’s honestly insane. The devs have been so clear about the intentions. There’s an audience of players they want, and it’s not the people who want to fast-forward to 60, min-max, farm exploits until they have more money than god, and raid log.

•

u/AsaraHS 55m ago

saying wow forever doesnt have the replayability for that, when wow forever is classic wow, and we're in the classic wow community where a large chunk of us are on our like 20th fresh classic experience is REALLY funny

•

u/Global-Resident-647 4h ago

Yeah but if I want to only do dungeons, and I enjoy that, why punish it?

I play for fun. And leveling a priest out in the world currently is not fun. At least not compared to a hunter, shaman, druid, rogue, paladin.

•

u/Thin_Mousse4149 4h ago

Then go play fucking retail. That’s literally what retail is now. Your dream game exists

•

u/EstablishmentNo7761 1h ago

Do you have zero common sense? There's so many things wrong with your statement. Perhaps they don't like retail??? Maybe they like classic wow but just want to play their intended role: healer.

Like god damn some of you people are so ignorant on purpose I swear.

•

u/Rare_Paper_2089 3h ago

off your meds?

•

u/Global-Resident-647 4h ago

What?

•

u/Imaginary_Wait9762 2h ago

That guy is a goof, don't bother.

I agree that Priest feeling very unplayable until Shadowform is a big problem. A problem that can easily be solved by making dungeons reward meaningful xp again and even prepares Priest players that do go Shadow how versatile they are.

You're not really teaching that or much of anything with wanding to death for 40 levels.

•

u/Elfeden 2h ago

He's not wrong. You level in lfd then do mythic plus.

3

u/Low_Cancel_6930 5h ago

I did every dungeon exactly once for the quests as a di priest then I came to Zul'Farrack and troll temper does not drop in sufficient amounts to give 5 players the 20 they need so I ran it again, and again... and now maraudon is in sight and I honestly cant wait for the 2 runs that will take

•

u/Raghul86 2h ago

I think there are opposing forces within the dev team. I think the dungeon designers were hoping to see their work get all the milage it could get, but someone higher up are pushing their means against the botting/boosting with little respect for this

•

u/Jooylo 3h ago

In vanilla wow I don’t think the intention ever was for people to run a dungeon more than once, and from what I recall I don’t think most people did because the process of forming a group and traversing through it took a lot of time and a lot of work. I could have just had a different experience, but spamming dungeons feels like a more modern thing.

Additionally, there is the expectation that you level alts in forever, which would mean running them more than once - just on a different characters.

•

u/nvmvoidrays 2h ago

this is exactly it. people did dungeons once, maybe twice, and then moved on and continued questing. there was no handy lfg tool, or anything else to form dungeons. the population was also much smaller. you had to sit in SW/IF/Orgrimmar and spam you were looking for <x>, and it could take almost an hour to get a group, and then you all had to run/fly there.

i'm sure people "dungeon spammed", as they like to call it, back in the day, but only in established groups. with how much of a fucking chore it was to find groups, no one really bothered spamming dungeons. this only really became a thing in 2019 Classic.

in my experience, leveling back in '04, i did the dungeons once or twice and then kept questing.

•

u/Vylkor 1h ago

Leveled as an hpal back in 2005. I spammed DM, prison, SM, ZF and BRD while leveling by spamming /2 in SW or /1 in front of dungeons, groups were filled in less than 30 minutes even on Khaz Modan, a mid population french server.

How could I fucking do quest in holy spec then, when killing a single mob at my level was a 2min task ?

•

u/Ruger15 1h ago

What? This is not true at all. Running dungeons multiple times absolutely happened more than not.

•

u/JayThee 34m ago

Right. i dont know what these people are saying. I remember grinding the same dungeons hard with randoms for gear.

All these takes talk in extremes with 0 nuance. its crazy.

•

u/InducedLobotomy 26m ago

These are people who never experienced OG vanilla WoW, commenting to imply they were indeed there with some of the most wrong information out there. It's almost as if they're bots or children who are 15 and physically couldn't experience vanilla WoW

I remember dinging 60 in Scholo back in the day(2005ish), and the reason I dinged in there, was because I was running it multiple times specifically to lvl up because I was tired of questing lmao

•

u/whoopsmybad1111 2h ago

It became a thing the first time the LFG tool made the group and ported you to the dungeon, right? That'd be in wotlk or cata, whenever it came.

2

u/Lazyseer 5h ago

I think it came up briefly in the podcast episode about dungeons. The pair of dungeon designers that were there said that they hoped people did them more then once. But clearly the people pouring all their time into making cool dungeons don't get to make the exp rules for them.

•

u/peepjv 2h ago

My hope is that we get heroics so there’s a reason to go back to them.

•

u/scrumdidlyumpscious 2h ago

This was my thought too. I figured they’d introduce heroics or something to make the lower level dungeons relevant again at some point.

•

u/Every_Ad_6168 1h ago

They should add more high level content to lower level areas. Maybe have quests for summoning high level foes in the low level dungeons so you have a reason to return to them.

•

u/Difficult-Ask9856 2h ago

if the classic andys have their way we wont get anything new, itll just be rehashed raids with almost no new content

•

u/BuxaPlentus 4m ago

I don't know one of my friends who truly enjoyed classic that is happy with 90% of the changes they have made, 'classic andys' haven't got almost anything they actually wanted, this broad sort of 'classic remix' isn't working for a lot of people, including classic fans

•

u/Rerkoy 33m ago

something new, looks inside, retail slop

•

u/Whole_Risk_2695 8m ago

Go play era

1

u/Praktos 5h ago

To be fair as first time wow player entering game with like 20-30 dungs and hoping from 1 to the other exploring them might have been the peak lvling content

•

u/Potential-Juice-8060 4h ago

They expect people to make a LOT of alts and the game does go “forever”

•

u/Smelly-Elf 1h ago

My guess is that the devs are split between dungeon supporters and anti dungeon supporters. Probably sole senior designers forced the change ladt minute

•

u/fizzlefade 1h ago

Many might disagree but if we are doing horizontal progression I would like to see heroic dungeons each with their gear drops that have different use cases. For example items that are better on beasts, undead, etc think of it like pokemon element types grass fire water etc.

Then new raid content would be a specific mob type like undead so you’d want to go farm those dungeons for a gear set that will help you clear that raid. So with each new raid you would be incentivized to farm the dungeons that have the gear that helps against that specific raid.

This is what horizontal progression looks like to me and what I honestly want for this game. It would mean these dungeons and gear would stay relevant forever essentially.

New gear can still be released but there has to be like an upgrade progression for it where the previous BiS piece is required to obtain the new one which keeps the old content alive still and keeping any progression you’ve done relevant with newer content.

The problem with this is that it is hard to get right and I’m worried that they won’t.

•

u/Anipsy 53m ago

Probably because dungeons were designed by a different team from the one that decided to make them obsolete

•

u/Zorewin 53m ago

Cause there stupid... they should restore dungeon xp and let people play however they want, that is the spirit of classic.. the world wide open every possibility do wat you want

•

u/PpOo-QG 26m ago

RPG solo games like FF or Zelda have a ton of donjon and content with the intention of being touched once.

It’s just that you are used to replay donjon in retail so for you it should be the same in forever.

•

u/Vento_of_the_Front 6m ago

Two different developer teams being out of touch with each other, and for whatever reason their leads aren't allowed to either talk about their work or are way too polite and can't ask "what the hell are you doing?".

It kinda feels the same as with Starfield - there, your main "ability" is to replay the game with the same character(NG+), something that wasn't a thing in TES/Fallout, but for some reason devs also felt the need to retain the core "player should be able to do everything in one playthrough" logic, which quite literally doesn't work at all with NG+ system.

Same here - new dungeons are fun, but there is little to no reason to do them after first run, double so because drops are, at times, questionable.

•

u/Excellent_Rule_2778 5m ago

I’ve ran most dungeon twice simply because I wanted a specific item, or because one of the quests couldn’t be done in one go.

But the idea of Forever is that you’d eventually want to level alts.

1

u/Notris 5h ago

I think replayability is at the core of what Forever is supposed to be. The legacy system strongly hints at this.

There are 27 specs, but only two specs per character, so one would have to make about 14 characters to truly experience them all, and that doesn't even take into account niche specs such as shockadin.

Moreover, new races and classes, as well as race-class combinations have all been stated to be in the works, so that number is just going to keep going up.

Outside of a leveling context, though, I truly don't see most of them mattering, unfortunately, but again: plenty of that to be had across alts.

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

You're assuming most people would even be interested in al the specs. Many wont touch healer or tank. You can respec as well. And who said replayability for forever? Its honestly no different than vanilla which I mean sure. You can replay it but its going to be the same every shot.

I doubt they're going to have any meaningful races added at this rate. Let alone classes. Many right now have a fucked identity and need a lot of work.

Pvp is fucked, which is one of the most replayable parts of the game.

Not seeing where forever changes anything for it other than trust me's and people who are chill with slamming 1-60 again... before they even have one.

•

u/Zestymonserellastick 3h ago

Designing a dungeon for one player to run once it a waste of time. Several million people play this game. If 2 million people do a dungeon once. That dungeon has more game time in it alone from 1 run from everyone then entire games have.

It no longer a waste of time of 2 million people run it once.

•

u/Technical-Risk1812 1h ago

Its the better design as it is. Retail is nothing but dungeon spam at every level with a very railroad quest chain to unlock a few. Pure ass.

Forever has world focus and the dungeons are ran several times as youa alt up, help friends, or farm drops. 

0

u/Dahamuran 5h ago

It’s like these posts never end…I think I’ve entered the algorithm death spiral for dungeon xp posts.

-2

u/Trackback_ 5h ago

Why did Blizzard make all these new quests with the intention of them only being touched once?

I want to spam the boar killing quest in Durotar until level 60 with my friends, why is Blizzard forcing me to play another way?!?

0

u/CharacterBalance4187 5h ago

Because its the players saying that and not blizzard maybe. Idk.

0

u/Greendayy77 5h ago

Tbh, I am so happy I dinged 55 and now I can FINALLY run 55+ dungeons more than once since we get currency daily.

1

u/BboySparrow 5h ago

What currency do you get and what do you do with it? Buy gear?

•

u/Radiant_Cucumber215 4h ago

Reals, and yes. I think theres vendors in boots bay

-3

u/Buttliquors 5h ago

Can we rename this subreddit to wowforeverdungeoncomplaints

•

u/Everdale 3h ago

Can we rename the comment section to wowforeverdungeoncomplaintscomplaints

-6

u/Rappyfan 5h ago

The idea of „it’s only worth doing once“ is a thing brought up by min maxers. You can do them for fun, for loot and even for exp if you don’t mind it being a little slower.

0

u/Money-Literature2065 5h ago

Oh you can, good luck convincing others though, y'know, the people you need to do the dungeons

2

u/Lumillis94949 5h ago

You can use the in game group finder to do the dungeon any number of times. Or you can play with friends (people who like you) and run it a few times to get some loot before moving on.

-1

u/Rappyfan 5h ago

luckily there are endless people to run dungeons with. But thanks ☺️

1

u/kjhgglk 5h ago

Saving comments like this for when the game is dead like the other classic versions lmao

0

u/Rappyfan 5h ago

but we live in the now and not in the future. but do what you want lol

•

u/kjhgglk 4h ago

Yeah but if i dont prepare now i wont have this awesome montage of obtuse comments for when this classic version is dead, and how u guys killed it

•

u/Rappyfan 4h ago

That doesn’t even make sense. But yeah, do that while i run dungeons.

•

u/kjhgglk 4h ago

As i said, obtuse

-6

u/EXPLODING-SPUD 5h ago

God you people complaining about the same non-issue on and on are insufferable.

•

u/PucThePuc 4h ago

I think they just failed to realize how many wow players are fucked up in the head, jumping into a game designed to enjoy the leveling while they absolutely hate it

•

u/EvilLamp 31m ago

People just want a new version of classic to play with friends while the hype is still around. There hasn't been anything but re-releases since SOD 3 years ago.

-4

u/GL2U22 5h ago

Feels like I’ve seen this exact question asked 20+ times on the wow subreddits over the past couple of weeks.

-3

u/According_Ride1646 5h ago

I feel like there is a cult for these people honestly. Would be nice if mods starting banning/cleaning up these subreddits so that we can get back to seeing useful information.

-2

u/ThatMoth420 5h ago

I’m glad they added them. Gives players more options to pick from while leveling.
Doesn’t seem like a waste of resources to me, not all players want to zoom through dungeons. In every group I’ve been we take our time, kill optional bosses, and help each other with quests. Complete randoms. If someone is whining about us taking too long and it becomes a problem the leader will usually just kick them and list the group again.

-2

u/According_Ride1646 5h ago

It was my turn to post the “every 5 minute whining about dungeons post”

-1

u/pillbinge 5h ago

Because horizontal improvement means you run it more than once across multiple characters.

-1

u/Yikidee 5h ago

Cause people that continue to play will have multiple alts, so will see them again and again.

Personally I love it. Keeps you in the world.

-1

u/Scurb00 5h ago

I run dungeons many times as a healer. The exp isnt terrible and I want the loot to make my life easier while questing.

This one and done mentality is why so many people are struggling with their characters and coming to reddit to complain that they feel weak.

-5

u/Remote-Guest2587 5h ago

i’ve ran all the dungeons available to me, new and old, multiple times for loot and fun. just bc you skip them for whatever reason doesn’t mean most people do.

in fact they give too much xp, i wish it was less and give me a chance at all the cool leveling gear.

•

u/JustATextBox 1h ago

in fact they give too much xp, i wish it was less and give me a chance at all the cool leveling gear.

Dungeons do not give too much XP. 20% of a level for an entire dungeon run killing almost all of the mobs is not too much XP

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

Except there is hard data that most people do, and you're being sorta weird trying to equate your experience as the correct one. Bit of an ego. But then again, gotta do something to keep that top 1% commenter. If only there was a quality commenter tag

•

u/Remote-Guest2587 3h ago

i think the tag takes into account number of upvotes tbh, but that’s not why i commented. because it’s simply not the experience of most people. link me the “hard data” if you want but i’ve been in so many groups of people rerunning for gear 

•

u/MaintenanceRich5810 3h ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwow/s/CAYLgJExCE for one. You can use that and maybe look into further if you want but there's your data. With a whole post put behind it. Took as long as it takes to write the Google search to find it btw. First result too.

-8

u/PureCauliflower6758 5h ago

Whine forever.

•

u/losetrich777 3h ago

there are 35 dungeons in the game from lvl 13 to 60 and doing the quests would probably give at least 1-1.5 lvls (with the dungeon xp). 

If spamming same dungeons was a classic thing then that is miserable as hell lol and don’t want to take part in that lol. 

I’d rather get to 60 doing them all one time than getting to 60 missing half and spamming the other half ten times. 

Also, I don’t mind doing dungeons again to help guildies and friends.

•

u/JustATextBox 1h ago

If spamming same dungeons was a classic thing then that is miserable as hell lol and don’t want to take part in that lol. 

See nothing you said here is necessarily wrong, but it's just missing the point. No one is saying that dungeons should be the only way to play and that you should be forced to spam them from 1-60 with no other content

The issue is that dungeons are only worth doing once. The XP you get from doing a dungeon is awful, and it's only "good" if you have the quests. The quests are where 95% of that XP comes from, so once you've done those, entering the dungeon again is just trolling

For people who do want to run a dungeon again, they're essentially being punished for their choice. You'll get more XP/hr running grey quests 10 levels under you than you would running dungeons multiple times

People aren't asking for dungeons to become the only way to go 1-60, or even for it to be the meta way. They're asking for the XP to be even remotely acceptable so that running a dungeon a few times still feels like it's got at least some amount of value to it

Having multiple ways to play a game is a good thing, for everyone. With things the way they are currently, there's 1 path to 60. You do the quest chains for the dungeons, maybe a couple random other quests, and then you run the dungeon once. Rinse and repeat. Every single player is being funnelled into the same pathway, fighting over the same mobs/resources for the same quests, to then speedrun the dungeon once and hit 60

If you enjoy that, that's great. But for people who want to do something else, there's not really a good reason for them to do so. Dungeons can be a lot of fun, but when people are only willing to run a dungeon once, you're spending 30-50% of your time just waiting for your next group to get to the dungeon. And when your group finally gets there, your reward for doing so is 20% of a level. Something you could've got in ~3 quests out in the world, in half the time

•

u/losetrich777 48m ago

You can always rerun a dungeon to farm a drop, to help a guildie or a irl friend. I did and while I did not get anything, I was still having a good time.

Spamming the same dungeon over and over for xp comparable to open world questing is just bad game design especially with the prior practice of having a max lvl char blast through it very fast.

Allowing different ways to play is ok but should not be at the cost of reiterating bad design. 

Besides playing each of the 35 dungeons once to 70 is still spamming but yes it will never be efficient or fast as open world solo questing. But as someone who aims to hit all the dungeons at least once. I am having a blast so far. Fun over speed for me.

•

u/JustATextBox 27m ago

You can always rerun a dungeon to farm a drop, to help a guildie or a irl friend. I did and while I did not get anything, I was still having a good time.

Why, though? Yeah, you can "help a guildie or friend", but you being there doesn't really help them anymore than a random being there. They could just as easily find a random group and nothing would change from their perspective. And sure, I will and have run dungeons twice because a friend needed it, but it wasn't exactly worth the time. I was just taking a loss on my progress in order to play with a friend

It's the same as doing an elite quest 15 levels under you to help a friend. Yeah, you can do it, but you're not really getting anything out of it other than the knowledge that you helped a friend

For items? No, dungeons aren't worth running for items. It's not worth levelling 2-3x slower in order to get an upgrade that you would've already had a comparable replacement for in that same time if you had just been questing. I ran Ruins of Lordaeron for 5.5 hours trying to get the Rotmender set, I didn't even see 2 of the pieces drop. In that same time I could've just gone elsewhere, gained 2-3 levels, and found something better

Spamming the same dungeon over and over for xp comparable to open world questing is just bad game design especially with the prior practice of having a max lvl char blast through it very fast

Not even asking for it to be comparable. I'm asking for it to not be significantly worse, which it currently is. Make it so that running a dungeon multiple times is not slower than doing grey quests 10 levels under me.

No idea what a max level char blasting things has to do with anything - if someone is 12 levels higher than you then you get no XP. Actually, if anything, with the current design you're more likely to see boosting. 95% of the XP from doing a dungeon comes from the quests, not from the mobs. As such, getting boosted through in 10 minutes to get all the quests actually makes a lot of sense, even if you lose out on the tiny amount of mob XP

If I wanted to help a low level friend get to 60, that's exactly what my strat would be. Get him all of the dungeon quests, blast the dungeon, and repeat on the next one. Lowering the quest XP and redistributing that XP back into the dungeon mobs would literally fix that, the thing that you're calling bad game design, which currently exists within the game