r/comicbookgrading • • Jul 30 '25 Bravo

Should I get this third-party graded?

31 Upvotes

Going to take a stab at creating a pinned response to this and see if it helps.

In my opinion, you would only get a comic third-party graded in the following situation:

  1. You plan on selling it soon AND
  2. The average recent sale price of the book slabbed, in the book's grade, is at least $100 more than the average recent sale price of the book "raw" (unslabbed).

This $100 number represents all of the costs of having the book graded - the shipping to the grader, the costs for grading, the shipping back, insurance, pressing/cleaning fees, etc. Not to mention your time. AND a little bit of profit. So this $100 is a bare minimum number that will hopefully enable you to sell at the graded level and actually make a greater profit than just selling raw.

To get to these numbers, first consider posting some pictures of the book and asking "Can I get a grade?" See the Rules section for rule #4 - Take good pictures.

Take the average grade that you get in responses and then head over to CovrPrice.com and look up the book in that grade. For safety purposes, assume the third-party grader will give it a step lower grade than you're looking at for raw.

So for example if you think your book is an 8.0, and the VF raw value is $50 and the 7.5 graded value is $75, then it's probably not worth the time, money, and risk (shipping back and forth) to have it graded.

If in the above example however the book is worth $150 at 7.5, that's about the minimum point that you should consider doing it.

Q: But couldn't I get the book graded to hang on the wall? Or just to protect it?

A: You can, but there are cheaper options that don't involve letting the book leave your hands - see https://www.reddit.com/r/comicbookgrading/comments/1fylp3w/home_slabbing_options/ If you want protection/preservation, you could also stick with Mylar and a fullback. If you want a stiffer shell, you could always put that in a top loader. Some say Mylar and a fullback looks nicer than slabbed, due to difference in how the colors show up, the lack of Newton rings, and the lack of the label. There is also the added benefit that the book never leaves your possession.

MORE INFORMATION: STOP SLABBING (Seriously)

BUT ALSO: Should You Stop Slabbing?


r/comicbookgrading • • Oct 07 '24

Home Slabbing Options

12 Upvotes

r/comicbookgrading • • 9h ago

Sent my first comic off for grading. Daredevil #1

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

Belonged to my father, I didn’t do anything as far as grade prepping. It’s my first graded comic and I don’t know how to prepare them to increase grade. I know it’s rough shape. I’m sure it’ll be a cgc .5 but happy to have it


r/comicbookgrading • • 11h ago

How is this Batman Adventures #12?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

I was looking through my comics and found out this one seems pretty cool with the first appearance of Harley Quinn. I am honestly not knowledgeable about comics (I used to buy wizard price guides and think my comics would be worth something but most aren’t) and think this looks decent but definitely has some creases and wrinkles but I think it’ll look good graded.


r/comicbookgrading • • 19h ago

Spare a Grade - Secret Wars #8

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

Picked up a personal grail in what looks to me to be a mid grade, 7.5 or so. I would love for someone(s) to provide alternate opinions as I never fully trust my judgement on a book I really wanted. I'd say it could probably stand a pressing, which I'll probably undertake soon.


r/comicbookgrading • • 19h ago

Spare a Grade - Captain Marvel #8 (First App Carol Danvers)

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Second of two personal grails I picked up today. I'm thinking a 6.5 but this one is also square bound and I'm not experienced in judging that type of book.


r/comicbookgrading • • 1d ago

Grade estimate based on these scans?

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

r/comicbookgrading • • 1d ago

Help

Post image
10 Upvotes

I need more info on the comic before i make a decision, should i get this graded or should i just read it like i was planning when i got it. Or should i just read it then just send it for grading


r/comicbookgrading • • 2d ago

LEGIT FIRST PRINT? apparently newsstand edition ?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Picked this one up and i have been told that is a first print but rather than direct sale is a Newsstand Edition.

Is it a thing? Is the value lower because is not direct sales?


r/comicbookgrading • • 3d ago

About to submit these...

Thumbnail
gallery
239 Upvotes

Ok, I'm getting ready to send my first batch ever to cgc. Can I get everyone's opinion on grade for these beforehand. Kind of sweaty over here... Backs are similarly clean, stamps are there, staples are all great, can only upload twenty photos and had to pick and choose. I have an xmen 94 I'm sending too.


r/comicbookgrading • • 2d ago

Which variant?!

Thumbnail
gallery
98 Upvotes

Hi! Slowwwwly going through an inherited collection..this one has many variants, help😅. It has been opened, other than that, I'd guess near mint. Any info is appreciated


r/comicbookgrading • • 2d ago

Would this stable count as printing a error?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Just picked this up from my LCS for $11. Thought it might be worth grading. Let me know if this staple and crease would count as an error. I am probably on some hopium.


r/comicbookgrading • • 4d ago

Web of Spidey 118... Whatnot

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

Bought this comic on Whatnot for $70. The seller only showed the front during the livestream but described it as being in the 9s, saying he couldn't see a single spine tick.

It's arrived, and there's noticeable distress around the staples, some cover misalignment and minor spine/edge wear. The front cover I noticed immediately was not exactly aligned straight to the rest of the book :(

What grade would you realistically give it?

Also, would you consider this an item not as described, given how it was presented, or is this just part of buying through Whatnot?

Not looking to complain unnecessarily, but I'm disappointed given the $70 purchase price...


r/comicbookgrading • • 3d ago

First time grading question

4 Upvotes

I have a few comics in my collection that I have wanted to get graded, but haven't ever sent comics off for grading. Looking for any first time advice and info!

Appreciate any help!


r/comicbookgrading • • 4d ago

Inherited collection

Thumbnail
gallery
160 Upvotes

Hello all, from a quick google search we may have some interesting things here, can anyone help me appraise this? I inherited it from my recently passed uncle who has been a lifelong fan.
Thanks for any help!


r/comicbookgrading • • 5d ago

Huge Find (in one of my closets) - What to get CGC'd

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/comicbookgrading • • 5d ago

Finally Here !

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/comicbookgrading • • 6d ago

To press or not to press?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Hi there, this is my holy grail comic, and it's been with me since little time, but I'm gonna keep it forever, probably. Since I can't keep my hands still, I was planning on cracking this slab, send it to CGC, get it pressed, get both signatures authenticated with JSA, and hope for a higher grade. I know it has some serious colour-breaking ticks and few marks along the top, but still, an incredible copy overall.
I was wondering if it's worth going through all this process, considering that I'm located in Europe, so one should consider all the risky possibilities of it being damaged, swapped, or whatever. In any way, since CBCS is dead, I'd like to have it graded by CGC with both sigs authenticated, regardless trying to get a higher grade.

I hope this doesn't sound much convoluted, but it makes sense to me.

Thanks in advance!


r/comicbookgrading • • 7d ago

Help with a. Grade, please. Thinking about submitting this to CGC for the Steranko private signing

Thumbnail
gallery
91 Upvotes

r/comicbookgrading • • 7d ago

Help Grading This Please?

Thumbnail
gallery
124 Upvotes

I'm not too experienced at grading comics, but we found this, but we were hoping this was in okay condition.


r/comicbookgrading • • 8d ago

Uncanny X-Men #94 (1975)

Thumbnail
gallery
104 Upvotes

Uncanny X-Men #94, August 1975 — the first issue of the new team's regular series, right after Giant-Size #1. Claremont and Cockrum.

My childhood copy, given to me as a gift as a kid. Sending it to CGC regardless as my collection. I'm thinking 3.5-4.5. But down at those numbers i don't really know the criteria for moving from one grade to the next. What would you grade it?


r/comicbookgrading • • 7d ago

Not a great copy but worth grading? Spare a grade please

Thumbnail
gallery
48 Upvotes

Thank you good
People of Reddit