I was avoiding it for so long because people's opinion on the season seemed overwhelmingly bad lol. And that even the show itself later called it the gas leak year!
After watching it, I think people had a few points about it right. But my overall take is that people decided to make a 7 or 8 out of 10 season (which tbf, the first 3 seasons were all 10/10 so it is a noticeable drop) sound like a 4 or 5 out of 10 season lol.
Like, it's mostly that there's 1 or 2 eps that drag the average down, but most eps are at least a 7/10, and some of them are great!
Some of the criticisms I heard people make did not make sense. That it was too cartoony. Did they not watch season 2 and 3? I thought the show felt just as grounded as at least those seasons! I mean season 2 had a goddamn claymation episode and a nonsensical paintball game against a rival community college lol.
Another criticism I've heard is the characters acting out of character. Eh. They all felt normal to me except for a few moments with Annie. And also how Shirley's puppet confession made her too unlikeable
The main difference of this season I think was less jokes per minute and less actual belly laugh kind of moments. But they're still in there! Like Annie running through a glass door and the "pop pop" origin moment.
I think this season actually has one quality to it that is superior from the others, which is dramatic writing. When Jeff tells off his dad I was really impressed with it!
I have a fandom criticism. I feel like people probably heard dan harmon had left the show and then predisposed themselves to disliking the subsequent season. At that point, lighter criticisms turns into the season being outright bad.
Lastly, the eps I didn't like were the Pierce's mansion one and the one with the German guys. The mansion one was the worst ep the season imo. Idk about the puppet one tho cuz I watched it while really high