r/comp_chem • • Dec 12 '22

META: Would it be cool if we had a weekly/monthly paper review/club?

120 Upvotes

I think it would be pretty interesting, and would be a nice break from the standard content on this subreddit.


r/comp_chem • • 9h ago

Theory study-buddy

7 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am a fresh BSc. graduate. I did my undergrad in petroleum chemistry and got really into comp chem (DFT) in my final year, even publishing two papers in Q1 journals. I really love the field and want to go further. The obvious next step is a PhD in comp or phys chem. Finally getting to the point, my problem is that I don't have a rigorous foundation in QM or mathematics. I started McQuarrie's Quantum Chemistry, but I keep struggling. So, I was wondering if anyone's going through the same thing right now and maybe we can struggle together.

Thank you!


r/comp_chem • • 1h ago

Help in molecular docking error

1 Upvotes

Hi ! Im using Dockey GUI and Autodock4 to run docking. I got this issue error. However the first time i ran this docking it was successful, the second time this error appeared everytime. Anyone can help? I tried so may things fixing the protein or ligand but nothing worked. Tried different ligands too so im guesing the main issue is the software itself

error code
UnicodeDecodeError: 'charmap' codec can't decode byte 0x90 in position 2: character maps to <undefined> inside param.py (make_dpf_file, line 798).


r/comp_chem • • 17h ago

30 Years of Grimme Method Development in 9 Minutes: A Film by Claude and Me

18 Upvotes

I spent some of my best and most enlightening scientific years in Stefan Grimme’s group in Bonn. This short film is a thank-you to Stefan and the group for 30 years of computational chemistry method development: from D3/D4 and GMTKN55 to r2SCAN-3c, CREST, CENSO, xtb, and now g-xTB. I was lucky to contribute to some of these projects, and I’m glad I still feel at home in the MCTC community.

Watch the film on YouTube - I think it provides a nice overview of the group's most important developments (from my personal POV).

Almost all the results in the film, animated by Claude, came from calculations that ran overnight on two cores of my four-year-old laptop. That says a lot about the methods and codes behind them, including xtb and ORCA.

This is useful well beyond making films. In my daily work on lanthanide materials at beeOLED, fast methods that cover the whole periodic table make much of the work possible in the first place.

Also, it was insane to see how good Claude is at turning prompts into polished educational material. Definitely something I am going to use much more in the future.


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Im looking for connections in the DFT -SQS computational research community.

7 Upvotes

I'm a PhD student in Physics working on DFT-based computational materials research, and lately I've been doing a lot with SQS (special quasirandom structures) for modeling disordered systems, mainly high-entropy alloys for sodium-ion battery anodes.

I'm looking to connect with people in the DFT and SQS community, whether you're just starting out or have been at it for years. Here's what I'd like to do:

  • Swap ideas and workflows (SQS generation, supercell size choices, convergence headaches, etc.)
  • Talk through problems we're each stuck on
  • Share tips on tools like VASP, Quantum ESPRESSO, ATAT/mcsqs, icet, pymatgen
  • Maybe collaborate on projects or papers down the line

Honestly, I'd also just like to have people to nerd out with about this stuff. Computational work can get a bit isolating, and it helps a lot to have people to bounce ideas off.

If you're working on alloys, disordered materials, battery materials, or anything along those lines, drop a comment or DM me. I'd love to hear what you're working on! 🙂


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Connections in the DFT -SQS computational research community.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Help for QM/MM with highly charged zone

5 Upvotes

I am trying to set up a QM/MM simulation of a biochemical system.

I have already minimized, heated, and equilibrated my system using full MD. I then selected my QM region based on a previously published paper.

However, my active site is extremely negatively charged (-4), even though the overall QM region has a charge of -1. As a result, the water molecules included in the QM region are strongly attracted to the active site, get pulled too close, and the QM/MM simulation eventually blows up and crashes.

To try to prevent this, I added the following restraints to my Amber input:

  ! Test restraint
  ntr = 1,
  restraint_wt = 20.0,
  restraintmask = '@17459-17461,17951-17953,16487-16489,17651-17653,16291-16293,17915-17917,17699-17701,15847-15849,15855-15857,16895-16897,17011-17013,18723-18725,15795-15797',

However, I am still experiencing the same issue.

I also tried increasing qmcut, so that my QM/MM input now includes:

  qmcharge=-1,
  qmcut=15.0,
  qmshake=1,
  qm_ewald=0,
  writepdb=1,
  qm_theory='EXTERN',
/

I am genuinely confused about how to address this problem. My QM method is GFN1-xTB.

Thanks for your help guys

EDIT: I forgot to mention that, as pointed out in one of the comments, I am trying to reproduce a paper in which water molecules are included in the QM region, so I do not want to remove them.

Regarding the setup, I am using:

  nstlim = 2000,
  dt = 0.0005,
  nscm = 100,                ! Remove COM motion

! Temperature Control
  ntt = 3,                   ! Sets the thermostat to be used, 3 = Langevin dynamics
  gamma_ln = 5.0,             ! Collision frequency for Langevin dynamics
  ig = -1,                    ! Sets pseudo-random seed based on wallclock

! Pressure Control
  ntp = 0,                 ! Isotropic position scaling

! Miscellaneous
  cut = 10.0,              ! Non-bonded interaction cutoff (in A)

! Periodic Boundary Conditions
  ntb = 1,                 ! Sets periodic boundary conditions, 0=none, 1=const_V, 2=const_P
  iwrap = 0,               ! Makes sure wrapping is off 

! SHAKE
  ntc = 2,                 ! Sets SHAKE to constrain Hs
  ntf = 2,                 ! Omit bond interactions involving Hs (use with ntc = 2)

  ! QM/MM
  ifqnt=1,                 ! Enable QM/MM calculations

r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

Computational Drug Design Project, need urgent help

0 Upvotes

I am a biotechnology student. I’ve been assigned a drug designing project by my professor. Unfortunately, the initial instructions and information provided were limited, so I’m having to figure out almost the entire computational workflow independently.

If anyone has completed a similar academic project, I’d genuinely appreciate advice, recommended resources, or even a simplified workflow that I can follow.

I’m familiar with the basic concepts but not practically, so I need practical guidance on the software, databases, and tools required to carry out steps and presenting.


r/comp_chem • • 1d ago

I built a tool to help search research faster — looking for feedback

0 Upvotes

I’m building Citation Atlas to make it easier to find relevant research. It lets you explore papers that cite a selected paper and find related work through shared references.

I’d be interested in feedback from computational chemists: when you try a paper you know well, do the connections help you find useful reading?

https://mycitationatlas.com

I’m the developer—if you’re interested in free access, just DM me.


r/comp_chem • • 2d ago

Why is my defective SiO₂ structure so difficult to converge during vc-relax in Quantum ESPRESSO?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/comp_chem • • 2d ago

Help with Computational Chemistry Project – Recommended Software, Books and Resources

9 Upvotes

I'm currently working on an undergraduate computational chemistry project involving the phytochemical constituents of medicinal plants used for wound healing and checking for cyclodextrin complexation in formulation to improve some of it's physicochemical properties. (The comp bit is checking compatibility with some cyclodextrin types if any limitations are found)

I already have access to BIOVIA Discovery Studio and PyRx, but I'd like to know what other software, tools, books, textbooks, or learning resources would be useful for carrying out the project effectively.

I'd particularly appreciate recommendations on:

- Essential computational chemistry and molecular docking software.

- Tools for ADMET, molecular dynamics and drug-likeness studies.

- Books or textbooks for understanding the underlying concepts.

- YouTube channels, tutorials and websites for beginners.

- Any other resources or advice that could improve the quality of the research.

I'm looking to understand the science behind the tools, not just learn how to operate the software.

Any recommendations or guidance would be greatly appreciated. Thanks


r/comp_chem • • 2d ago

Charmm GUI Ligand recognize as glycan

1 Upvotes

After the docking process i have make the protein ligand as complex file and upload the charmm gui solvation builder module, it will recognize the my ligand as glycan is there any solution for this


r/comp_chem • • 3d ago

Help me name my molecular visualization software (my first two names failed)

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm a PhD student in computational materials science, and I've been building a desktop molecular visualization program for Windows and macOS. It's aimed at people working with MD trajectories and nanostructures (my own use case is colloidal quantum dots), with a focus on: fast rendering, publication-quality images, Trajectory Visualization, ....

The problem is the name:

- **Onyx**: there are already a lot of GitHub repos with that name, so it would be hard to find.

- **Morion** (a black quartz variety): I liked it, but my colleagues pointed out it sounds a lot like "moron". That's hard to forget once you've heard it.

What I'm looking for:

- Short, easy to say in English and other languages

- Not already taken on GitHub / PyPI / conda-forge

- No awkward sound-alikes

If you've ever had to name a scientific tool, I'd also like to hear how you chose. Which names do you think work well ?

Thanks!


r/comp_chem • • 5d ago

Would you be interested in a virtual "Density Functional Theory and Application" Lecture?

8 Upvotes

Having thought about this for a while, I need your opinion/feedback:

A few years back, I gave a DFT&A lecture (title) as a guest lecturer at the University of Regensburg (14\*90 minutes). Since my academic carrier didn't work out, the slides are aging in my documents folder after giving the lecture just twice. Having poured a lot of love into this project, I thought there might be enough interest in this sub to give the slides a second life (before that are hopelessly outdated :D).

Much of what I learned researching for and preparing the slides eventually went into "Best-Practice DFT" article in Angewandte, which has become kind of a meme here (which am I very proud of, thanks guys!). Because of this relation between lecture and best-practice, I thought there might be an interest here. However, even compared to this long paper, a 14\*90 minute lecture goes way beyond. It's a kind of deep dive, starting with the history and foundations (HK theorem, KS approach etc) and then moving towards modern DFT (Jacobs ladder, DFT-D with 1/3 of the lectures on benchmarking and modern functional development), with a few excursions into semiempirical and composite methods, periodic systems and pseudo potentials/ECPs. It helps if you have a basic knowledge of HF theory, but I don't think its necessary to follow.

If you know me here, you might guess it, but I should presumably mention as a kind of disclaimer that there may be some Grimme bias: A) because I am a big fan of the man and B) because I have been associated with his group for several years.

My idea is to make this a live lecture in the form of a video call. I want to be presenting to people, answer questions, and generally prefer interactive over one-way sessions. I'll probably get a Zoom account for that (any better suggestions? I am open to ideas) and give the lecture on a biweekly basis at the weekends (If I manage. I do have a full-time job, and the slides need to be translated from German to English). I am also thinking about splitting this up into more and shorter sessions of 30-45 minutes, which should make it easier to find a time slot (we'll figure this out once/if we manage to get a core audience together).

Please let me know what you think by commenting or giving this an upvote. Depending on how much feedback this gets, I might be motivated to start this project, perhaps even before the summer really kicks in. Suggestions are highly welcome. Man, I am excited to see if this takes off :)

Finally, here is a short summary of the lecture provided by ChatGPT: The Density Functional Theory (DFT) lecture outlines a logical progression starting from traditional Hartree-Fock/Wavefunction Theory (WFT), which is theoretically accurate but computationally demanding (1/2). It introduces the revolutionary Hohenberg-Kohn (HK) theorem, highlighting density as a simpler and more efficient computational approach (3). The Kohn-Sham (KS) method further simplifies calculations using auxiliary wavefunctions and the practical Local Density Approximation (LDA) (3). Advancements proceed to Generalized Gradient Approximations (GGA), significantly improving thermochemical accuracy (4), and dispersion-corrected functionals (DFT+D), which enhance calculations for non-covalent interactions and large molecular systems (5). The inclusion of Hartree-Fock exchange (GGA+HF) leads to hybrid functionals that mitigate self-interaction errors, marking a significant breakthrough in DFT (6). Range-separated hybrids effectively combine short-range DFT exchange and long-range Hartree-Fock exchange, optimizing kinetic and thermochemical properties (7). Double-hybrid functionals incorporate explicit correlation through MP2, providing accurate but computationally intensive solutions (7). The lecture concludes with practical applications—benchmarking for systematic method improvement (10), semiempirical and composite methods (11/12), and specialized methods for solid-state physics applications, including pseudopotentials and band-structure calculations (13/14).

Cheers,

Jan

EDIT: Okay - Wow. I did not expect anywhere near as much feedback (was hoping for 20 upvotes haha). As I am writing this, this has 113 upvotes and 53 comments. People have reached out and offered help to translate slides and with "Orgakram". You guys are great! I just had a brief glance at the first couple of slides, and I must say I feel it already. Let's do this!

I will sort a few things out over the weekend and be back next week with a post with more details. So long, you can start familiarizing yourself with Hartree-Fock theory :)

One of the most requested things in the comments was to record an upload. I don't have any fundamental problem with that, but I am not sure about copyright issues. If anyone of you has experience with this aspect and can help, please PM me!


r/comp_chem • • 6d ago

Looking for a roadmap to learn DFT calculations as a second-year PhD student

15 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm a second-year PhD candidate in Chemistry, working primarily with the synthesis and characterization of nanomaterials. My research focuses on sustainable nanomaterials and their interactions with useful adsorbates, such as heavy metal ions and pesticides, for environmental remediation applications. So far, my work has been entirely experimental. I want to incorporate computational chemistry, such as DFT, into my research to understand interactions between my synthesized materials and various adsorbates at the atomic and molecular levels. My background is in Chemistry and Materials Science, with some familiarity with Python for data analysis.

None of the professors at my institute, including those in the research lab I'm in, work in DFT or computational materials science. Fortunately, I've been in touch with a professor at another university who specializes in computational chemistry. He has kindly offered to teach me and allow me to spend approximately two months working with his group, with the work scheduled for February 2027. I am very excited about this opportunity, but I think I need to learn the basics at least so I can learn more when I visit them.

I want to model the interactions between my synthesized nanomaterials and adsorbates such as heavy metal ions and pesticides, investigate adsorption energies, preferred adsorption configurations, charge transfer, changes in the electronic structure, and the nature of interactions between the adsorbate and the material surface.

I don't know where to start, which fundamental concepts I should learn, or what level of programming knowledge I need to get started. I would like to build a strong foundation to independently understand, set up, run, and interpret basic calculations relevant to my experimental research. Therefore, I would appreciate advice from people who have done something similar before or who might be able to help me with this.

Thanks!


r/comp_chem • • 6d ago

Advice for a HS Senior?

3 Upvotes

Hi!

Really nice to meet you guys :D I’ve been lurking on this subreddit for some time actually haha.

About a year ago(junior year!), I had the opportunity to do research at a local university, and they needed someone to build a pipeline for free-energy calculations so I read some nifty documentation and have gotten acquainted with tons of really cool softwares in comp chem(GROMACS(awesome puns btw), AMBER, CHARMM, VMD, Biopython, and obviously pdb file handling/translation and the regular terminal handling). I’m not perfect at it but documentation has become my savior because there’s very little online on YouTube, and I’m independently doing a lot of this.

I always had a pretty strong computer science background, but i think this experience really solidified how much I love this field specifically since even before entering it a lot of my interests were similar(file handling, open-source code, complex-math calculators, etc.).

My favorite thing I got to learn from this whole experience is how much I do not know. Everyday somebody posts something new on this subreddit and I’m fascinated by how much more I want to study. But, I have absolutely no clue about how to enter this field(and I’m also a little nervous consequently).

I’m sorta spiraling because everyone is denying I can make it in comp chem. I’ve never met anyone in the field minus my PI and my chem teachers know sparsely. My parents are skeptical.

I see legitimately barren fields in undergrad and super duper tiny populations of people in this field. Like even in large state schools the kids into this is so small.

What do I need to do in undergrad? Can I actually pursue this. Can you tell me what I am pursuing? What even happens in undergrad, what about grad/phd, what about onwards? I’m very confused.

I learned CS around 10 so I’m easily able to learn languages if you’re curious why and how all of this happened.

I edited for clarity- really tired rn.


r/comp_chem • • 7d ago

Benchmarked performance eight quantum chemistry codes for DFT calculations

27 Upvotes

Every DFT code is fast in its own paper.

So I did what I had wanted to do for a long time: put eight of them on the same workstation and let them race. Claude was really helpful in installing/compiling them.

I used water clusters (with up to 139 molecules, 417 atoms), the same PBE/def2-SVP, same RI auxiliary basis, matched DFT grids, 4 cores, best of two runs.

Full disclosure before anyone asks: I am one of the developers of TURBOMOLE (TM) and I wrote PyFock. That is exactly why every input file is in the PDF. Let me know in the comments if I got something wrong.

Here are the results

  1. TM took the first three places at every cluster size. Our TM RIPER development build did the 139-water cluster in 156 s. TM RIDFT from the released v8.0 needed 265 s, TM RIPER from the upcoming v8.1 took 279 s. The slowest established code needed over two hours.
  2. TM RIPER needs 10 SCF iterations for every case; from 20 waters on, nobody else gets below 11.
  3. Per iteration, the TM RIPER dev build and TM RIDFT v8.0 are tied at 15.6 s: 3x faster than ORCA, 16x faster than PySCF. And the RIPER dev build is 1.8x faster than v8.1's while using 5x less memory. Good things are coming.
  4. Something I found really interesting was that PyFock is pure Python, compiled on the fly with Numba. And yet takes only 21.9 s per iteration. That is 2.2x faster than ORCA, almost 10x faster than Psi4 and 12x faster than PySCF, and it scales better than every other code here. It beats ORCA, Psi4, NWChem and VeloxChem at every size. Only TURBOMOLE is faster. The 4.8x speed-up per iteration since the version in our JPCA paper came with AI assistance.
  5. Which brings me to vibe coding. AI is a fantastic tool when you know exactly what you are optimizing. vibe-qc needed a massive 3490 s for just 32 water molecules. TURBOMOLE needed just 12 s. So I did not run any larger systems with vibe-qc. It is not in the same league as others. The vibe-qc paper in JCC did not have any performance benchmarks except for one calculation where they compared with ORCA. So I'm not sure if performance is one of their priorities or not at the moment.
  6. On accuracy, mostly everyone did fine. TURBOMOLE, ORCA, and PyFock agree with PySCF to within 30 µEh. NWChem and VeloxChem, however, drift a little as the clusters grow.

BTW to be fair to VeloxChem and NWChem: they are built to scale to thousands of cores. A 4-core workstation is not where they shine. But its almost cubic scaling is still an issue tbh.

If you develop one of these codes and think I held it wrong, send me your settings, and I will rerun.

Which result surprised you? Check the last slide for key takeaways.

Results in the PDF shown here: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/manassharma07_dft-programs-performance-comparison-ugcPost-7527647358013317120-Lixc/


r/comp_chem • • 7d ago

Psi4 pcm problem

5 Upvotes

Good afternoon, colleagues!

Does anyone here use Psi4 in their primary research?

I'm facing a major issue with SCF convergence in PCM calculations. I initially tried using the conventional PCM implementation, but encountered an S-matrix error. It turns out this issue has been documented for quite some time in a GitHub issue and is apparently related to legacy Fortran code. According to the developers, the problem occurs during cavity construction.

One of the suggested workarounds was to use the DDX-PCM approach. However, I ran into another problem there. I optimized two states of the same system, whose energy difference in vacuum is only a few kcal/mol. After performing single-point DDX calculations on the resulting geometries, I obtained an energy difference of several tens of atomic units, which is clearly unreasonable.

I haven't been able to find a reliable guide or explanation of how to obtain properly converged and physically meaningful PCM calculations in Psi4.

For now, we're using ORCA, but I'd really prefer not to change our computational workflow and would like to stick with the same engine.


r/comp_chem • • 7d ago

Introducing TUNA — a streamlined quantum chemistry program for atoms and diatomics

29 Upvotes

For the last few years (yes, since before AI!) I've been working on a Python quantum chemistry program mostly to develop my own understanding, but also to try a new take on a quantum chemistry program — one that has as seamless a user experience as possible.

Unlike general purpose programs like ORCA, the humble TUNA code is specifically designed with diatomic molecules in mind. These molecules are complex enough to expose many challenges for electronic structure methods, but have simplicity that brings many benefits.

Due to the one-dimensional geometry of diatomics, unlike all (?) other quantum chemistry programs, TUNA does not use input files and is run directly from the command line, by:

TUNA [Calculation Type] : [Atom 1] [Atom 2] [Distance] : [Method] [Basis Set]

For example, a single point calculation with Hartree–Fock theory on the hydrogen molecule is:

TUNA SPE : H H 1.0 : HF cc-pVDZ

And an optimisation of carbon monoxide with CCSD is:

TUNA OPT : C O 1.1 : CCSD cc-pVDZ

The output is then printed directly to the terminal, in what I believe to be an attractive and clear way! With this approach, you can easily compare different quantum chemical methods and basis sets, of which TUNA contains many. We have various exchange–correlation functionals for DFT, perturbation theory methods up to MP4, coupled cluster up to CCSDTQ, and recently configuration interaction methods like CASSCF.

While TUNA is not primarily designed for speed, its slow steps use NumPy, so it can be surprisingly swift. Since diatomics are small enough to avoid writing to disk, and lots of symmetry can be exploited, TUNA calculations are often faster than other programs, sometimes much faster.

Another unique benefit of TUNA is that diatomics mean that numerical differentiation of the energy is viable as a general strategy for property calculations, rather than a fallback. This means that any of the implemented electronic structure methods automatically works with the whole program to calculate any implemented energy-derivative property.

Basis set extrapolation enables these derivatives to be taken at the complete basis set level for all methods and properties. For example, an approximate complete basis set polarisability calculation via fourth-order perturbation theory is:

TUNA SPE : Li H 1.6 : MP4 cc-pVTZ : POLAR EXTRAPOLATE

Without rambling on too much further, available calculation types in TUNA include single point energies (SPE), coordinate scans (SCAN), optimisations (OPT), harmonic frequency (FREQ), molecular dynamics* (MD), and full (or perturbative) anharmonic frequencies (ANHARM) through solving the nuclear Schrödinger equation on the whole potential energy surface. Lots of methods and basis sets are implemented.

If TUNA sounds interesting, please try it out with pip install quantumtuna, check out the GitHub repository, which contains a detailed manual with tons of copy-and-pasteable command line examples, or read the ArXiv paper, which gets into more of the technical aspects of the program!

Please give the GitHub page a star if you think it's warranted! I hope TUNA can be useful for quantum chemical education going forwards, and provide a low friction environment for students to experiment with methods and code as I have done while developing it.

By this point, TUNA has become quite a feature-rich program, despite its narrow molecular scope. I'd be really grateful for any feedback, whether about the program itself, the installation, documentation or my attempt at marketing it!

* Because why not!

Edit: Not any molecular property.


r/comp_chem • • 7d ago

Looking for Gaussian 16 / GaussView 6 access or research collaboration

0 Upvotes

Looking for Academic Access to Gaussian 16 and GaussView 6 (Windows)

Hello everyone!

I'm a Master's student in Theoretical and Computational Chemistry, currently working on my Master's thesis involving DFT calculations, molecular interactions, and DNA–ligand systems.

I'm looking for Gaussian 16 and GaussView 6 for Windows, preferably with an academic licence that would allow me to install and use the software on my personal laptop.

Unfortunately, my university cannot currently provide me with individual access to these programs.

I wanted to ask the community:

Does anyone know of researchers, universities, or research groups that could help a Master's student obtain legitimate academic access?

Is there a possibility of obtaining an individual academic licence or being authorized to use an existing institutional licence?

Has anyone been in a similar situation and found a solution?

I'm not looking for an unauthorized or pirated copy. I would really appreciate any guidance, contacts, or opportunities to obtain legitimate access.

Thank you for your help!


r/comp_chem • • 6d ago

Free tool for small DFT jobs

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

I built a website where you can run small DFT, xTB and Quantum ESPRESSO jobs straight from your browser: https://chemdft.com.

It is free for anyone to use, no tip-jar, no licence, no "contact sales".

My wallet was never the target audience :)

What it runs: PySCF (HF, B3LYP, PBE, from STO-3G up to def2-SVPD), xTB GFN2, CREST conformer search, and Quantum ESPRESSO for periodic PBE and PBE+U with DOS and bands.

Limits are small on purpose: 12 atoms for PySCF optimisation and orbitals, 6 for frequencies and TD-DFT, 20 for periodic jobs. It is almost Gaussian replacement in future.

Full disclosure, since rule 2 exists for good reason: AI helped me build the site and helps set up jobs. It does not do the chemistry. Every number comes from the real engines, and there is a validation page on the site that compares results with reference runs.

If anything looks wrong to you, I want to know.

What I would love feedback on:

- Where do the results disagree with your own runs?

- Which limit or missing feature would stop you from using it?

- Is anything on the validation page misleading?

Be blunt. I would rather hear it here than from a reviewer later. Thanks for reading, Tabriz

ChemDFT Free tool for small DFT jobs


r/comp_chem • • 7d ago

What is a good QM/MM model that is easy to use for beginners?

8 Upvotes

Specifically i am trying to do inverse analysis on RuBisCo. I have a separate program for optimization so just for modeling, whats's a beginner friendly QM/MM model thats good with large enzymes?


r/comp_chem • • 8d ago

A scientific take on Matt Pocock's skills

15 Upvotes

Hey all. Like I guess a lot of you, I've been handing more and more of my research to Claude Code and Codex, which aren't really just coding tools anymore. What I've found is that you can trust these agents about as far as you've made your intention clear: what you want to do, and how.

Matt Pocock turned that idea into a really nice set of skills (instruction files the agent loads; 300k+ stars on GitHub). You start from a blank map, an unexplored territory, and as you talk with the agent it uncovers more and more of the part you actually want to explore. Once the map is clear, the workflow goes all the way down to the final implementation: idea → spec → tickets → code.

The problem is that this workflow assumes the territory is unknown only at the start: make a handful of good choices and you know the whole map. That may hold for engineering, but in science it mostly doesn't. Research has fog: you can't know the next step until the last result is in, and every result can redraw the whole map.

So I built a science layer on top. A study starts from a loose question and a small map of possible experiments, which I call probes, and they're run one after another:

  1. It grills you first. Before each probe, the agent asks you a few rounds of questions until you both agree on what the probe should test and why. That's what keeps every probe aligned with what you actually want, not with what the agent assumes.
  2. It writes a prediction. Before anything runs, the agent writes down what it expects. That's its default guess, the most banal outcome, the centre of its own distribution. Writing it down makes the bias visible: when the result matches, fine; when it doesn't, that's where something interesting (or a bug) is hiding.
  3. It runs the probe in its own folder, with the scripts, inputs, exact commands and software versions, so anyone can rerun it.
  4. It shows you plots and a short brief, and says whether the prediction held. For a scientist the plots matter most: they're the quickest way to check the agent's work, and a weird curve is much harder to miss than a wrong number in a sentence.
  5. It stops. You decide what happens next: continue, branch, drop, or promote.
  6. You promote what holds up. Promoting means you've decided the probe's piece of the map is right, so its scripts leave the scratch folder and move into your protocol, in a folder layout you agree on with the agent. The probes are working memory, full of attempts that may not last; the protocol is long-term memory, the part you'll write up and publish.

Everything else lives in the lab notebook: every probe, decision, fix and dead end, committed to git as the study goes, without you touching git. A short record keeps the question you started with, so you can see how far the study drifted from it. That drift is interesting in itself: looking back at it can open new research questions.

Built on top of Matt Pocock's skills.

Repo: Skills for Real Scientists

Enjoy!


r/comp_chem • • 8d ago

LFT in orca?

5 Upvotes

Does anyone have any article recommendations for LFT in orca? My advisor said we can work with LFT in orca but I can't seem to find any works that have done this.