r/composer • • Apr 24 '26

Meta New rules about the use of AI in the sub

184 Upvotes

If you look in the sidebar where the rules are, there is a new rule about AI. Here is the text:

  1. You may not post music generated by AI using apps like Suno.
  2. You may post computer generated/algorithmic music.

You may use AI to create the text for your posts.

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

4. You may not post apps generated using “vibe coding” where AI writes the entire program.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Reddit does not supply enough room to provide explanations for all of these rules so if you have questions, comments, or suggestions please don't hesitate to comment below.

Here are some notes about some of these:

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

Posts are not art. Using AI to create a text post isn't taking any money away from another composer or artist. Some people just aren't good at writing and/or don't speak English natively. Using AI is one way to improve their chances at communicating clearly.

That said, we strongly encourage everyone to not use AI in this instance. A significant number of users here will react badly to this and you won't get the kind of responses you are hoping for.

Unfortunately it's a Catch 22. People also react badly to posters who are poor at communicating. For folks like that there is no winning.

Update: We've changed the wording to reflect some of the comments below. We still have very limited space but hopefully admitting to using AI and providing an explanation will, in a subtle way, discourage people from doing so (for their own sake) or perhaps they will have a good reason that will mollify the crowd.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

It is standard today for programmers at all levels to use AI to assist in some aspects of programming. In the past people would ask questions at places like Stack Exchange or Reddit but now it's so much faster to ask an AI. The results often aren't great but they provide a good start toward a solution.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Almost all discussions about AI in this sub go horribly wrong. However, there is nothing inherently bad about discussing the subject and we will try to allow those discussions. There are interesting discussions to be had.

However, we will remove all posts that ask whether AI will replace composers. This has been asked many, many times and because those posts generally go badly we're just not going to deal with them.

Posts asking for links to AI apps to use will be removed. While AI has its uses, asking for or providing links to AI that generates music are not allowed.

A final note. The rules of civility apply when responding to questions, comments, posts, etc, about AI. We remove lots of comments where people attack others with accusations of AI usage or whatever. Don't do this. If you have an actual useful comment about someone's use of AI then please express it in a civil manner.

Update: I asked Google Gemini to clean up that rule. Here is the result:

AI Content Guidelines

  • ❌ Banned: Music fully generated by AI (e.g., Suno) and "vibe-coded" apps where AI writes the entire program.
  • ✅ Allowed: Computer-generated/algorithmic music and apps where AI is used as a tool (standard for 80%+ of devs).
  • 📝 Posts: AI can be used for post text. Discussions about AI and music are welcome.
  • 🚫 Note: Threads asking "Will AI replace composers?" will be removed.

We're going to stick with what I wrote.


r/composer • • Jul 29 '25

Resource Updated and expanded Resources Section at r/composer

28 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Just a quick update: this sub now has an updated and expanded Resource Section!

It includes a curated list of helpful materials for composers of all levels, including books, YouTube channels, websites, and more.

It can be accessed here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/composer/wiki/resources/

...or by clicking on 'Wiki' at the top of the sub (in the mobile app) or by clicking 'Resources' under Community Bookmarks (on desktop).

Thank you to those who gave suggestions for new additions to the Resource Section.

If anyone else spots anything that needs correcting or has suggestions for additional resources, feel free to let us know!

P.S. The Resource Section can also be found at r/composition, a smaller "sibling" community to this one. If you're not a member there yet, do consider stopping by!

Thanks,

u/RichMusic81


r/composer • • 5h ago

Music Art Song

5 Upvotes

Here's me singing an art song I recently composed. Let me know what you think!

Video
Score


r/composer • • 1h ago

Music City Pop/Fusion Song

2 Upvotes

Here's a City Pop/Fusion song that I've been working on and off on. Please excuse the video quality and solos (piano isn't my first instrument). Would love feedback!

https://youtu.be/tMvvazJipsg?si=fXFGb0XhPxg9VoTf

https://musescore.com/user/32367037/scores/40809570/s/QNsI39?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 13h ago

Music Advice on String Quartet?

5 Upvotes

Still working on polishing this piece. I’m a beginner composer and was wanting some feedback if possible.

Thank you for your time!!

https://youtu.be/g9PJGtKLQ6Q?is=C8m34YIWn4Fjgy-7


r/composer • • 15h ago

Discussion Twin Peaks theme bass sound

4 Upvotes

Hello!

I tried to look it up but failed to find any info on how exactly Angelo achieved that bass sound. Any help?

Thanks!


r/composer • • 1d ago

Notation Anyone still on Sibelius, or has everyone moved to Dorico?

25 Upvotes

Been putting off switching for years. Dorico seems to be a lot cheaper and it seems like development is advancing rapidly. On the other hand, it looks counterintuitive to me whenever I look at friends' screens when using it.

I'd mostly use it for straightforward tonal orchestral music.

Curious if people who made the jump think it was worth it.


r/composer • • 17h ago

Music The Bride, or Quattro matrimoni e un prelievo di organi

0 Upvotes

The Bride

Musescore audio and pdf version of the score and composer notes available for viewing and download from the article.


r/composer • • 18h ago

Music I scribbled part of the piece, okay

0 Upvotes

r/composer • • 19h ago

Music Wrote a cello sonata for the first time

1 Upvotes

You can find sheet music and audio here:

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1KPyi8YUhSVzcL7I_i2O-4go55Iqv3vBn?usp=sharing

This is the first time I've ever written something for cello in general (and I'm not a cello player although I have played violin for a little bit before. I mainly play the piano, which'll probably show in the music lol), and it was actually kinda hard at times with the note range of the cello and I kinda did stretch it a bit.


r/composer • • 20h ago

Music Canon in g dur for wind quartet

1 Upvotes

r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion Composer Opportunties Survey

2 Upvotes

Hi all. I’m Jon Mayse, I run Stomping Ground (Insta, Website), a London-based production company that puts on new-music concerts.

We're running a survey on composer experiences of calls-for-scores and other opportunities: https://tinyurl.com/2uc6d4e8

As composers ourselves, we often apply to opportunities and calls for scores. However, it's not well examined how these opportunities/calls for scores affect composers and shape compositional practices.

This survey looks at the attitudes and approaches that practicing composers have towards opportunities (schemes, residencies, and other professional/creative development) and calls for scores (commissions, festivals, performances, etc).

Your contribution will provide important knowledge about what is and isn't working with composer opportunities and how the field might improve going forward. The findings here will serve as a baseline for other enquiries into the ecology of new music and how the field of contemporary composition is structured. We will publish these findings anonymously later this year.

It only takes about 10 minutes and is entirely anonymous.

https://tinyurl.com/2uc6d4e8

Happy to answer questions in the comments. And if you think calls for scores are fine as they are, we want to hear that too.


r/composer • • 20h ago

Discussion Looking to Interview professionnal composers

0 Upvotes

Hello redditors,

I am currently completing a bachelor in sound engineering, with a specialization in sound-to-image production. I am writing a memoire on the importance of human intervention and craftsmanship in the age of automation and machine generation. To support this effort, I would like to interview a few professionnals with any type of relationship with AI plugins, softwares or pure generation. The idea is to analyse how these new tools affect your work, and what is the impact on your creative research and artistic decisions.

The interview can be done via video call, normal call or simply through written exchange. Feel free to DM me if you are interested 🙌 , and I will send you the details !

Have a good day ~


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion Where can I commission a composer? (spanish)

7 Upvotes

¿Dónde puedo encargar a un compositor una pieza original? Me gustaría encargar una canción para cantar, pero no tengo idea de cuánto cuesta ni dónde puedo encontrar a alguien.

No sé mucho de música, así que necesito a alguien que sepa componer.


r/composer • • 1d ago

Notation Anybody has experience with Dorico Elements?

2 Upvotes

I am a 3rd year composition student at university, (hopefully) will graduate late 2027-early 2028. Currently use Musescore, but I know I have to eventually transition to something more professional (nothing against musescore, is great but is very inconsistent and buggy)

This year I don’t have any software budget for Black Friday but I saw Steinberg has a %50 discount on Dorico, so I am considering getting Dorico elements right now (credit card lol) and next year save up to upgrade or wait for next BF, but I wanted to know if anybody has experience with Dorico Elements, if it’s worth it at least for a year or a little longer, or if it’s not worth getting Dorico unless is the Pro version.

Have to add that we have Dorico Pro at school computers so I could technically use Elements in my projects and use the Pro features at school (but we are about to go to break until march)

PD:

I know it might sound cheap and not such a big deal but I am from a third world country so a Dorico license is like a full minimum wage here lol


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music A modern tonal piece of orchestra

8 Upvotes

Something I wrote a while back but may finally be getting performed by a Canadian orchestra in the new year! I do have an updated (less error ridden) version of the score available, but this is still perfectly legible. Enjoy!

video score


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion How can I get better at software notation (without a midi keyboard)?

0 Upvotes

Consider this a beginner software and theory question but how do you notate melodies without MIDI? Do you draw it, use shortcuts, virtual piano, click track?

Admittedly, I’m not very good at sight reading but it still seems software complex, and I work in software. Even with piano roll types I feel like I’m guessing. And with MIDI, is a click track the standard way to notate? I apologize if this doesn’t make any sense but I don’t get the user experience of notation or haven’t tried enough.


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Finally gotten back to composing! 'Album Leaf' (2026)

6 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oB5tWUFiX3I

Love writing bite sized stuff, things I can write in one day and then learn it in a day as well :)


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Echoes of the Lost Woods – Variations on a Theme by Koji Kondo for Solo Piano (Zelda: Ocarina of Time)

6 Upvotes

Hi all, longtime lurker, first time poster here. I'm a hobbyist composer, and with the Ocarina of Time remake out, it felt like a good time to share a set of variations for piano I wrote based on the Lost Woods ("Saria's Song") theme. The time stamps for each variation are included in the video description.

Score video: https://youtu.be/13oG2ngVojg?is=orzd2gwlppjJEvpU

Given the repetitious nature of video game music, I thought it would be a natural fit for a theme and variations piece. The music is somewhat programmatic in nature (with the names of each variation roughly telling the story of a hero's journey). I found it was easier to write with this extramusical narrative, though I realize it's all subjective and someone might hear it completely differently.

For Zelda fans, there are a number of Easter eggs hidden throughout the piece (some being more obvious than others).

Feedback and critiques are welcome. Thanks for listening!


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion Competitions for young composers?

0 Upvotes

Ive been thinking about joining a competition for a while now but have no idea on which one I should join. If anyone has any suggestions for competitions where I can make a brand new orchestral piece to submit that would be amazing


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Ruby's Prayer (Ballad in Eb Major for Piano)

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I tried composing for the first time a jazz ballad tune and, from the lead sheet, I composed and performed this arrangement for piano.
I used really easy techniques for the arrangement (mostly 1-3-5-7 arpeggios and 5-notes voicings) so it sounds more classical than jazzy.

Any feedback is more than welcome!

Piano Score Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9xWluA27lCQ
Jazz Lead Sheet: https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/10jw9kb17f15hddyhvsst/Ruby-s_Prayer_Ballad_Lead_Sheet.pdf?rlkey=x9qsb8db67rq5hfvasto2vaja&st=bow3qnir&dl=0


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music How do you handle that line between expressive and schmaltzy? I have a third movement that I really want to make spectacular but I’m finding this line to be quite difficult.

1 Upvotes

Overall, I am on a quest to reduce the amount of notes I use. So I am putting that to the test in the third movement of this Sinfonietta for String Quartet + String Orchestra (btw, to the commenter last time; thanks for pointing out the whole “The” article thing, I did not know english wise haha)

I am wanting to avoid two specific comparisons that I know are inevitable because they somewhat share similar goals: bruckner 8 adagio, and barber adagio for strings. i don’t want it to come off as a pastiche or overly sentimental so i’ve been playing with interlocking and textural tension-release, as well as a pattern of circular geometry that exists in Islamic architecture (which includes the arabesque largely).

I also set the tempo quite slow (MM=46-50) to drive home the severity of it instead of parody. But part of me still feels it is too fluffed and I wanted to get feedback on that before continuing because it has a special place for me personally speaking.

I would love to hear some thoughts and feedback! Even if that feedback is “this sucks” lol. Here is the:

- Score PDF
- Audio MIDI

Btw I found out the hard way, “tools > optimize harmonics” is NOT for the open key signatures 😭 sorry about any crazy enharmonic spellings i fixed up to a certain point before realizing i’ll have to do it again anyways.


r/composer • • 2d ago

Commission Commission: Three-voice theatrical number with free canon — full notation, $800–$1,500

14 Upvotes

I'm a lyricist and playwright developing an indie musical. I have the book and lyrics. I'm commissioning the composition for the opening number. I'm looking for a composer who writes counterpoint and through-composed theatrical music. I need a composer who writes melody, harmony, voice leading and delivers it in notation.

First things first: Absolutely ZERO AI involved. I don’t want any AI created music at all.

Story of the song:

Three sirens — Opie (maiden), Noelle (mother), Leia (crone) — perform a daily ritual of waking the sun god Helios. Opie attempts the ritual alone and fails. Noelle enters; they argue. Leia enters; all three begin to sing, each invoking Helios according to their stage in the life cycle: Opie (birth, learning, first light), Noelle (striving, security, holding the light steady), Leia (death, destruction, clearing the way for the next generation). The number builds to a three-voice free canon in which the melodic lines enter sequentially and overlap.

Structure (as written in my lyrics):

Chorus (interrupted — Opie's attempt fails, the chorus is cut short)

Verse (the argument, two voices in tension, call-and-response, slight rhythmic offset)

Chorus (repeated, three voices enter)

[Chorus / verse material varied as needed to build]

Bridge (three voices overlapping, different rhythmic feel, building tension)

Canon (three-voice round, sequential entries, the climax of the number)

What I need:

Three distinct melodic lines (Opie, Noelle, Leia) for the verse, the chorus, the bridge, and the canon. Each line should be individually singable and carry its own character. They should be harmonically complementary when they overlap, but they do not need to share a register, a rhythmic cell, or a contour. I am thinking of these as three characters in counterpoint, not a three-part choral texture. Voice leading should be clean where the voices converge and free where they diverge.

Chord progressions under each section. Functional or Roman-numeral or specific pitches, whichever you find clearest. I need the harmonic skeleton. I do not need a four-part SATB arrangement or orchestration.

Rhythmic framework: time signature, feel (straight, swung, free, additive), any metric modulations or rhythmic displacements, especially in the bridge and the build into the canon.

The canon, notated clearly with entry order, entry interval, and any alterations or modulations between entries. This is the single most technically involved part of the number and I'd like to see how you'd handle it in your reply (more on that below).

File format: Delivered in MuseScore (.mscz) or MusicXML, or as a clean, readable PDF if that's your workflow. I will handle playback and any rough audio reference myself.

A short written note (bullets are fine) flagging any non-obvious harmonic, rhythmic, or voice-leading choices so I can communicate them accurately to my singers.

What I do not need:

A studio production, a DAW mock-up, a MIDI render, a mixed track.

A four-part choral score or orchestration.

A pop verse-chorus-bridge hook. This is not a single.

General References: “Road to Hell” – Hadestown, “Keep Breathing” and “The Chain” by Ingrid Michaelson.

 

The three voices should sound like three people in a room, not a choir. When they overlap, it is drama. The canon at the climax should feel like three people saying the same invocation from three different angles, and the overlap becomes a chord none of them could make alone.

 

Budget:

$800–$1,500 for the full delivery described above (three melodic lines, harmony, rhythmic framework, canon, notation in .mscz/MusicXML/PDF, composer's note). Includes two rounds of revision.

 

Timeline:

I'd like a first set of melodic lines and harmonic sketch by Jan 1, 2027. I understand if that's a tight timeframe and I'm open to a slightly longer window if it means a better first draft.

 

How to reply:

DM me or comment with:

A link to a piece you've written that has multiple overlapping melodic lines.

One or two pieces that show your harmonic and rhythmic range.

Two or three sentences on how you'd approach the canon specifically.

Your rate for the scope above.

I'm in Los Angles and prefer to work entirely remote. I'll reply to every serious inquiry within 48 hours.

 


r/composer • • 2d ago

Discussion Need advice on reverbation!

2 Upvotes

If we are using some flexible library like Cinematic Studio Series in which we can adjust the room mic along with the other libraries that are recorded in different spaces. So in this case, will I have to reduce the room mic from the libraries to prevent washing out the sound before putting a convolution reverb (like Synchron Stage Reverb) to make them sound one followed by an algorithmic reverb?