r/consciousness • • 3h ago

We can't just circumvent evolution.

12 Upvotes

Consciousness has only ever been observed on living organisms (such as ourselves). And all life is strictly shaped by evolution, to the point you could theoretically take any physical or behavioral trait in any organism and trace it back through its evolutionary history, whether it emerged through natural selection or other evolutionary processes.

The point is, if the model you choose or develop to define consciousness is incompatible with or cannot be explained through evolution, it becomes exponentially harder to back up and agree to. So if you keep such a view, be aware that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, don't be surprised when people take your ideas as something closer to religion than science.


r/consciousness • • 1h ago

Arnold B. Scheibel - What Makes Brains Conscious?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

Consciousness isn’t a magic trick meant only for humans it’s simply what a big, busy brain feels like when it is awake and working, and animals with smaller brains feel a quieter version of it tool. When life is calm and routine, like an animal quietly munching grass, awareness stays turned way down, until something sudden changes and flips an inner alarm that wakes the brain up to weigh its choices and decide what to do next. Inside your head, a tiny gatekeeper also guards thousands of little doors


r/consciousness • • 2h ago

The neuroscience of ego dissolution: Eckhart Tolle, interhemispheric intrusion, and the neural basis of self

6 Upvotes

Several years ago, while researching consciousness, meditation, and the nature of self, I became interested in the work of Eckhart Tolle. Although I had been a longtime admirer of his teachings, I began questioning whether the methods he advocates were actually responsible for his own experience of enlightenment.

This eventually led me to an article that introduced me to the work of Todd Murphy:

https://medium.com/illumination/2-problems-with-eckhart-tolle-that-no-one-ever-seems-to-talk-about-7995f320fc97

What particularly fascinated me was Murphy's attempt to explain sudden enlightenment through neurophysiology rather than metaphysics.

A neurological hypothesis for sudden enlightenment

Tolle describes his awakening as occurring spontaneously following a period of intense depression, anxiety, and existential suffering. Murphy approaches experiences of this nature through Michael Persinger's hypothesis of interhemispheric intrusion.

Murphy proposes that the subjective sense of self emerges partly through lateralized activity within the temporal lobes and limbic system, particularly involving the hippocampus and amygdala.

In his model, the language-dominant hemisphere contributes to autobiographical identity, internal dialogue, and conceptual self-representation, while its counterpart contributes to nonverbal aspects of experience.

During extreme psychological distress, Murphy hypothesizes that excessive limbic activation can exceed certain thresholds, propagating between hemispheres through pathways such as the anterior commissure. This may alter inhibitory connections between neural populations, a proposed mechanism he calls synaptic dropout.

The resulting reorganization could theoretically explain an abrupt and enduring alteration in emotional processing and the experience of self. Under this interpretation, what Tolle describes as the dissolution of the ego might represent a fundamental change in how neural systems generate and maintain subjective identity.

Importantly, this remains a hypothesis rather than an empirically established explanation of Tolle's experience. Nevertheless, I find its implications fascinating.

Murphy discusses this extensively in his lecture Enlightenment, The Self, and the Brain, including Tolle's experience around the 1-hour-26-minute mark:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqrpKUTMXgY&t=5160s

His accompanying essay is also worth reading:

https://www.god-helmet.com/wp/enlightenment.htm

Experimenting with neurotechnology

My interest in Murphy's research eventually led me to Persinger's God Helmet experiments, which investigated whether weak, complex magnetic fields applied around the temporal regions could elicit unusual subjective experiences.

When I discovered that Murphy had developed a commercially available experimental device, the Shiva Neural Stimulation System, curiosity got the better of me and I purchased one.

I experimented with it as a companion to my meditation practice for a while. I no longer use it, but I still have the rather unusual apparatus pictured here.

The experimental evidence surrounding these devices remains contested, particularly regarding the influence of suggestibility and expectation.

What interests me most, however, is whether contemporary research into neuroplasticity, the default mode network, and self-referential processing might eventually provide a more comprehensive neurological account of sudden enlightenment.

I'd be interested to hear from anyone familiar with Murphy's hypotheses, Persinger's research, or more recent scientific investigations into the dissolution of the subjective self.

Additional academic references:


r/consciousness • • 11h ago

Paul Davies - Is Consciousness Fundamental?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

Paul Davies argues that consciousness being awake and aware is not just an accident inside our heads, but a basic building block of the universe. Everything we know starts with our own awareness, and at the tiniest level of physics, reality settles on how to unfold at the moment someone observes it something other theories try to avoid by claiming everything splits into endless extra universes instead


r/consciousness • • 8h ago

A question for the philosophical zombie.

5 Upvotes

A philosophical zombie (or p.zombie) is a hypothetical being that is physically identical to a conscious human being, down to its atoms, neurons, and outward behavior, but completely lacks consciousness (subjective, conscious experience).

If you were to ask a p.zombie whether it was conscious (sentient), what would it say?

  1. "yes"
  2. "no"
  3. "i don't know"
  4. something else?

r/consciousness • • 20h ago

I’ve just watched John Searle’s lecture at Google, published in December 2015, and it is amazing!

9 Upvotes

I have posted a couple of times about the Chinese Room thought experiment. This time I watched a YouTube video and I think I got the answers to all my questions.

I would like to highlight the most interesting parts of this lecture.

At the beginning John Searle described how he asked his neuroscientist colleagues (he called them “the brain guys”) why don’t they solve the problem of consciousness? They replied “Look, we are doing science, it’s objective, and you yourself admitted that consciousness is subjective. So there can’t be a science of consciousness.” Later in the Q&A section he added: one of the famous scientists said that in his discipline it’s ok to admit that you are interested in consciousness but get your tenure first! Now it’s different, this kind of study can give you a tenure by working on consciousness.

Many years ago a new discipline was born, it’s called cognitive science. John was invited to the Artificial Intelligence lab talks. He said he didn’t know anything about it, so he went ahead and bought a book about AI. It was $16.95 plus tax, money wasted! But he admitted later he changed his mind. There was a theory in the book describing how computers can understand, how a computer can read a story and answer questions even if the answers were not in the story.

After the lecture, on his way back home sitting in the airplane he started to think about how they can give him a story in Chinese, and he can follow the computer program for answering questions and he doesn’t understand a word of the story. John was thinking about it for a week, he expected that someone must have thought of this objection before. But it turned out nobody did. This is how the famous Chinese Room thought experiment was born.

The main idea was to demonstrate that a very good computer program can pass a Turing test but it has no way in this setup to understand Chinese. The program is purely syntactical. Human understanding has more than that, it has semantics. Simulation is not duplication. He emphasized that the Chinese Room doesn’t understand Chinese because there is no way it can get it from syntax to semantics. It would require consciousness. He said that his dog obviously has consciousness, but his iPhone doesn’t, it’s a very complex electronic circuit that we’ve designed to behave as if it was intelligent.

Vocabulary of humans and machines is obsolete because if by machine is meant a physical system capable of performing certain functions then we are all machines. Only machines could think. Why? Thinking is a biological process created in a brain by quite complex neurobiological process so in order to think you got to have a brain or something with equivalent causal powers for the brain. We might figure out the way how to do it in some other different medium. It would be like an artificial heart, for example. We know how heart works, that’s why we can make an artificial one. We don’t know how brain works, therefore we can’t make Artificial Intelligence.

We have no idea how to create a thinking machine because we don’t know how brain does it. All we can do is a simulation using some sort of formal system. But that is not the real way to create thinking. Computation alone is not self sufficient for thinking because it defined purely formally on syntax. The brain is a causal mechanism that produces consciousness by a very complex neurobiological processes, still imperfectly understood.

What is consciousness, somebody asked? John said there is no scientific definition but we can define it in a common sense way: consciousness consists of all those states of feelings, sensations, and awarenesses that begin in the morning when you awake from a dreamless sleep and they go on all day long until you fall asleep again or otherwise become under-conscious. On this definition dreams are a form of consciousness. The essence of consciousness is that for any state there is something it feels like to be in that state. Consciousness always has a subjective ontology.

People in the audience mentioned Google Translate, but nobody says anything about LLMs.

The video titled Talks at Google, John Searle, Consciousness in Artificial Intelligence, November 23, 2015.

What do you think about this lecture?


r/consciousness • • 23h ago

Tipping point of conviction

11 Upvotes

What would it take for your conviction to change regarding the nature of consciousness?


r/consciousness • • 22h ago

Just How Much of the Universe is Inaccessible To or Beside Us?

3 Upvotes

We all know our experience is dictated in whole by our biology. Following this, we also know our biology was dictated wholly by evolution. What we have is simply what was useful (plus some mutations here and there). This means that we are inherently gated from the pluralities of this Universe. If our ancestors faced different environmental pressures, the world we experience today may very well be completely and utterly unrecognizable. There are entire electromagnetic spectrums of light I cannot perceive simply because the eyes and visual cortex I have were not made to. What implications follow from this? Why does Reality simultaneously seem Subjective, Differentiated, and Individual yet Shared?

I apologize for this post being question after question but with a topic as mystifying as this it simply cannot be helped.


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

A plain-English definition of "consciousness"; curious where people think it fails

3 Upvotes

Consciousness is the ongoing biological activity of a living organism experiencing sensations, feelings, perceptions or thoughts; whether actively responding to its environment while awake, attending quietly while immobile or experiencing internal imagery while dreaming.

Grammatically, it works just like "weather" (our summary word for rain, wind, pressure and temperature) or "digestion" (our summary word for acid, peristalsis and enzymes): it is a descriptive umbrella noun bundling concrete living processes we directly observe and live through, rather than a separate mysterious object generated by them.


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

The Hard Problem of Consciousness Is Logically Groundless

24 Upvotes

Everyone knows what it feels like to see the color red or feel pain, yet no one can explain what the sensation itself actually is. This apparent gap between physical brain activity and the feelings we experience is called the hard problem of consciousness, and it creates the intuition that consciousness is an inexplicable mystery. To see why this happens, we need to look at how the brain represents reality.

To guide behavior, an organism cannot simply react blindly to raw physical impacts; the brain must construct an internal working map of the external world and of the body itself. Any representation built to predict events and guide actions is a model. In the brain, this model is simply a physical system of neural signals and connections that represents objects, threats, and the state of the organism.

Any model has a simple limit: it cannot split its elements into smaller parts endlessly. It must rely on basic building blocks that cannot be defined inside the model itself; for the model, they simply exist as axioms, things accepted as given.

In the brain's model, these axioms are compressed summary signals, such as the sensation of color or pain, rather than raw data about individual neurons and molecules. At the same time, to keep that map up to date and guide behavior, the model must monitor its own state and its changes.

From this, we can distinguish three aspects of any sensation, whether it is color or pain. First, we directly observe it and are aware of its existence. Second, we cannot explain what the sensation feels like in terms of anything other than the sensation itself. Third, the sensation is part of the system's behavior.

The first two aspects are fully explained by the fact that a sensation is a basic element of a self-monitoring model: the model tracks its presence, yet cannot break down its own axiom from within. The third aspect can be fully and sufficiently described functionally and structurally, in terms of how neural signals are connected and produce actions. Nothing remains unaccounted for.

This shows why terms like subjective experience or qualia are logically redundant. They neither answer a question nor pose one. As an answer, calling sensations subjective experience explains nothing, because it merely puts a label on the fact that we observe our own basic elements without being able to break them down. As a question, asking why subjective experience exists beyond those three aspects has no logical content, because once observing the signal, its indivisibility, and its functional role are accounted for, there is nothing left to define.

Even so, someone might insist that subjective experience points to something non-physical, separate from the brain's model and functional structure. Yet we are right now thinking, arguing, and speaking about this claim. Since speech and thought are physical processes, to reason about subjective experience at all, the physical brain must physically contain information about it.

How, then, could a non-physical entity be mapped onto the physical brain that reasons about it? Logically, there are only three possibilities:

First, information could enter the brain from somewhere outside, from a non-physical entity that changes how neurons fire. However, anything that physically moves atoms or alters electrical charges in cells is a physical interaction by definition, which contradicts the claim that it is non-physical. Also, no unexplained external influences are observed in neurons.

Second, the non-physical entity might not influence the physical brain at all. In that case, all our thoughts, doubts, and statements about subjective experience are caused entirely by physical processes in the brain, and would happen in the exact same way even if that non-physical entity did not exist. The brain could never obtain any information about it. Such an entity is logically redundant and devoid of content.

Third, subjective experience might simply be the physical process of the brain monitoring its own compressed signals. In that case, there is nothing beyond the physical structure and functional connections already described above.

Consciousness appears mysterious not because it contains something non-physical, but because the brain's physical model observes its own basic axioms without being able to break them down internally. Any non-physical entity either acts on neurons, becoming part of physics, or does not affect the brain at all, remaining inaccessible to our reasoning. Everything that produces our sensations and our claims about subjective experience is already physical.


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

Neural correlates of pure presence

Thumbnail biorxiv.org
2 Upvotes

This preprint, in which is credited among others, Giulio Tononi, (the name behind Integrated Information Theory) finds a link between—'pure presence'—and "broadband power decrease...in the gamma range" as predicted by Integrated Information Theory.

Below are some highlights.

[Pure presence] is described as an experience of vast, vivid luminosity, devoid of thoughts, objects, particular sensory features, the perception of a self, or any distinction between subject and object (non-duality)

IIT predicts that as long as its causal powers are intact, a lattice-like substrate in a state of near-inactivity should specify a cause–effect structure corresponding to a vivid experience of pure “extendedness”

...a grid-like lattice in a state where all units are inactive (but not ‘inactivated’ by bistability) specifies such a structure just as much as in other states, where some units are active. The only difference is that the extension is completely homogenous in the case of inactivity, while it is warped by inhomogeneities when some units are active and others inactive.


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

Consciousness and the attempt to define it.

0 Upvotes

I would like to define consciousness today.

Consciousness is possible because of evolutionary biology. Neurons change their signals based on cellular death. The very act of adjustment based on data inputs resulting in signals that signal death.

As evolution happened and greater intelligence grew, living things began to store data and recall that data to some degree of functional accuracy. That is the prerequisite of consciousness. Once data can be recalled to some degree of accuracy. Then, you can begin to perceive a state of ambiguity (maybe/what) and make a choice based on incomplete data. That is consciousness. That ability to perceive maybe and act in on a state of ambiguity.


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

Discussion Weekly Casual Discussion

2 Upvotes

This is a weekly post for discussions on topics outside of or unrelated to consciousness.

Many topics are unrelated, tangentially related, or orthogonal to the topic of consciousness. This post is meant to provide a space to discuss such topics. For example, discussions like "What recent movies have you watched?", "What are your current thoughts on the election in the U.K.?", "What have scientists said about free will?", "Is reincarnation possible?", "Has the quantum eraser experiment been debunked?", "Is baseball popular in Japan?", "Does the trinity make sense?", "Why are modus ponens arguments valid?", "Should we be Utilitarians?", "Does anyone play chess?", "Has there been any new research in psychology on the 'big 5' personality types?", "What is metaphysics?", "What was Einstein's photoelectric thought experiment?" or any other topic that you find interesting! This is a way to increase community involvement & a way to get to know your fellow Redditors better. Hopefully, this type of post will help us build a stronger r/consciousness community.

We also ask that all Redditors engage in proper Reddiquette. This includes upvoting posts that fit the subreddit's description (whether you agree or disagree with the content of the post), and upvoting comments that are relevant to the post or helpful to the r/consciousness community. You should only downvote posts that are inappropriate for the subreddit, and only downvote comments that are unhelpful or irrelevant to the topic.


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

Could experience just be brain activity itself?

3 Upvotes

I was thinking a lot about consciousness, especially what a scientific explanation to it coudl loook like. We usually say the brain "produces" consciousness. This sounds as if consciosuness was something atop of brain activity. But could the complex activity patterns the brain has just itself be the experience? I wonder why we need to assume a further thing to be produced by that activity.

Take fear. YOu notice danger, anticipate what happens, your body changes, you prpare to act. You feel afraid - could this be simply the activity otagnized in the proper way?

You may ask "But why does this feel like anything?". Fair question. Though if the feeling IS the activity, asking how one produces the other is asking the wromng thing. We want an explanatory step between two things that atre just the same.

Btw I am mnot intenting to support an eliminative view here. You may say I am saying consciousness does not exist, only processes do. I prefer saying consciousness exists and thsi is what it is.

One more thing, rationally understanding an experience, like what it is liek to be a bat (explained in terms of neural activity) is not the same as living that experience. It does not give you the perceptions and the intuitions, it only provides rationalization, and this is not everything the brain can do.

So what is your view? Could teh activity itself be the experience? If not, what woudl this explanation leave out?


r/consciousness • • 1d ago

A structural case for why consciousness exists

0 Upvotes

The human mind's understanding of its own structure is a representation. Examples of representations include maps, graphs, equations, etc. An accurate representation depicts how what it depicts interrelates. Its accuracy does not require it to contain any information about how it relates to what it depicts. This is why cryptography works. This is why a map without a legend is still s map. This is why the same mathematical expression can describe more than one system.

Because entirely accurate representations can omit information how they relate to what they depict, it is possible for the mind's representation of itself to be entirely accurate and yet nonetheless incomplete because the representation is missing information about its defining relation to that which it depicts.

How would the mind know that this is the case? Because the mind is the means whereby it understands itself, it would encounter an inherent aspect that is unrepresentable by the available representation that it constructs of itself.

What could this aspect be like? (1) It could be continual because its presence does not interfere with the mind's ability to accurately represent itself and survive. (2) Because distinguishing between several would require representing the differences between them, the unrepresentable aspect would be unique by default. (3) Because the unrepresentable aspect is free of its own representational content, it could coexist with any and all such content while remaining distinct from it thereby imbuing it with ineffability.

In other words, the mind would encounter something very similar to what we already call subjective experience because what do we mean by experience if not something that is incompletely expressible by language or any other representation, namely, how something represented in the mind is to us.

If this analogy is correct, then subjective experience does not exist because of anything the mind does but rather due to what it need not do, completely represent itself.


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

What is the naturalist alternative to epiphenomenalism?

4 Upvotes

Given that the possibility of epiphenomenalism is often debated, what is the alternative that naturalists can turn to?

I can only assume one would have to accept an interface between the conscious mind and the physical brain, but this raises further questions of a) why has such a phenomenon not been observed in all of the clinical analysis of brain activity, and b) what physical laws would such an interface function under?


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

My hypothesis on consciousness.

10 Upvotes

TL;DR: My hypothesis is that consciousness isn’t necessarily something separate from the brain, but an emergent result of billions of smaller, interconnected processes continuously working together. I believe it’s not necessarily the number of neurons that matters most, but how they’re organized, connected, and able to function collectively as one system. Since the brain has no single central controller, perhaps the conscious “you” is simply the collective operation of this decentralized biological machine. If true, an artificial system with the right organization and interactions might also be capable of consciousness, regardless of whether its components are biological.

I’ve been thinking a lot about consciousness recently, specifically whether it’s actually something separate from the brain’s physical operations or simply the result of how those operations are organized and interact with one another.
My hypothesis is that consciousness could be an emergent property of a sufficiently complex, interconnected, and continuously operating system of smaller processes. In other words, consciousness might not be something a brain has, but something a brain does.
The human brain contains approximately 86 billion neurons and hundreds of trillions of synaptic connections. However, I don’t think the number of neurons is necessarily what makes us conscious. I think what matters much more is how those neurons are organized, how they communicate, and how their individual operations collectively contribute to a larger functioning system.
A single neuron doesn’t know who you are. It doesn’t understand your memories, personality, emotions, or thoughts. It simply receives signals, processes them through biological mechanisms, and influences other neurons. Yet when billions of these relatively simple units interact through an incredibly complex network, the result is a human being capable of reasoning, remembering, experiencing emotions, and recognizing its own existence.
What I find particularly interesting is that there doesn’t appear to be a single central location in the brain where the conscious “you” exists. The brain is a distributed system with specialized regions and networks responsible for different functions. These systems constantly exchange information, influence one another, and coordinate their activity.
This makes me wonder whether the feeling of being one unified individual is itself a product of this coordination.
We tend to think of ourselves as individual entities controlling our brains, but what if that’s backwards? What if there isn’t a separate “you” operating the brain at all? What if you are the collective operation of the brain itself?
Under this interpretation, humans are essentially extraordinarily sophisticated biological machines. Our thoughts, decisions, emotions, memories, and perceptions arise from countless smaller physical operations occurring throughout our nervous systems. None of these individual operations needs to understand the entire system. They only need to interact in ways that collectively produce the behavior of the whole.
It’s almost as though billions of individual components, none of which possesses a complete understanding of the organism, collectively produce something that experiences itself as one being.
This also makes me question whether consciousness necessarily requires biological neurons.
Imagine gradually replacing the neurons in someone’s brain with artificial equivalents that perfectly preserve their original functions, connections, and interactions. If the overall system continues operating without losing its organization or causal continuity, would that person remain conscious?
My intuition is that they might, because the important thing wouldn’t necessarily be the biological material itself, but the organization and ongoing operation of the system.
This is different from simply copying someone’s brain into a computer. A copy would create another system with the same information, whereas gradual replacement might preserve the continuous operation of the original system. Whether that would preserve subjective experience is still an open philosophical question.
Taking this further, could consciousness exist at different scales? If billions of neurons can form one conscious system, could multiple interconnected artificial minds, or even biological brains, theoretically form a higher-order conscious system if their communication and integration were sufficiently sophisticated?
I’m not suggesting that complexity, connectivity, or intelligence automatically guarantees consciousness. A large interconnected network isn’t necessarily conscious just because it’s large or interconnected. There may be specific kinds of information integration, recurrent processing, or other mechanisms required that we don’t fully understand yet.
I also recognize that this overlaps with existing ideas such as emergentism, functionalism, and theories of integrated information and global processing.
My central hypothesis is that consciousness may not be an independent thing produced by the brain, but rather the subjective aspect of a particular kind of organized, continuous, and integrated physical process.
If that’s the case, the real question might not be how to give an artificial system consciousness, but what specific organizational and functional properties would allow consciousness to emerge in the first place.
I’m interested in hearing what people think, particularly what flaws there might be in this reasoning. Does this hypothesis explain anything meaningful about consciousness, or does it simply describe how cognition works without explaining why subjective experience exists?


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

Can we distinguish a thought that was prevented from becoming conscious from one that was never going to arise?

0 Upvotes

Suppose a particular thought never enters someone's awareness.

How could we distinguish between a thought that would have occurred but was somehow inhibited, and one that simply wasn't going to occur?

Would the distinction require evidence about unconscious neural activity? Or are we dealing with a counterfactual that cannot be established in an individual case?

I'm particularly interested in whether neuroscience or philosophy of mind offers a way to investigate this distinction.


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

How Dualist Theory Survived Princess Elisabeth’s Attack?

8 Upvotes

The intellectual relationship between Rene Descartes and Princess Elisabeth of Bohemia was one of the most influential correspondents of the 17th century. They exchanged 58 letters discussing metaphysics, dualism, ethics, and human passions.

The biggest challenge was in her very first letter where she challenged Descartes’s main philosophical claim - mind as an immaterial substance and the body as a material substance causally interact. Elisabeth asked how a purely non-physical soul could possibly move the physical material body? In her mind in order for something to move a physical object the mover must itself be an extended physical object capable of physical contact.

This letter forced Descartes to refine his thinking on how the mind and body affect one another. His later works were heavily shaped by their ongoing dialogue. Interesting fact, Descartes letters were published early on, but Elisabeth refused to publish her own side. Her letters were recovered and published in the late 19th century. Why do you think she was reluctant to do so?

How Dualist theory survived that attack? I would like to hear your understanding of modern interpretation in the comments. Exploring Chalmers version, epiphenomenalism, the hard problem next is my goal.


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

Dualism and the myth that everything is physical

Thumbnail
iai.tv
0 Upvotes

Summary: Dividing mind from matter has dominated Western thought since Descartes. But more recently the idea that everything is fundamentally physcial has taken hold. Here, philosopher William Hasker, in conversation with social scientist Tony Sobrado, explores the failures of physicalism and argues that mind is irreducible to matter.


r/consciousness • • 3d ago

Thomas Nagel takes on AI consciousness

Thumbnail
wired.com
118 Upvotes

Raw Text of the WIRED-article:

‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

Thomas Nagel has done landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans; this week, he won the million-dollar Berggruen Prize for his contributions to the field. And he has a lot of thoughts on AI.

WIRED Magazine - Nov 18, 2026 10:02 AM

Over 50 years ago, philosopher Thomas Nagel asked the question, “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” The question opened up an examination on whether people could understand the consciousness of nonhumans and the meaning of consciousness itself. Who knew that, a half- century later, the question would move from an ivory-tower rumination to a critical issue in the future of humanity as we try to make sense of disturbingly sentient-adjacent chatbots?

The paper became a classic and it helped set a foundation for a career that saw Nagel make contributions to thought on morality, justice, and the mind-body question. One of his books is entitled, What Does It All Mean? For the breadth and quality of his work, he became the recipient this week of the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture, given annually to “an individual whose ideas have profoundly shaped human self-understanding and advancement in a rapidly changing world.” Previous winners include Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

I used the occasion to speak to Nagel at his home in Greenwich Village, specifically to hear about how the evolution of artificial intelligence might have affected his viewpoint. It turns out that the 89-year-old university professor emeritus at NYU had given the question a lot of thought and had some strong views on the subject. The interview is edited for clarity and length.

It’s been 52 years since you wrote “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?,” which has become an iconic paper about understanding consciousness in non-humans. Has the emergence of large language models altered your thinking?

Like everyone, I’m tremendously impressed by the lifelikeness of these systems compared to the history of earlier AI. But the disposition of some philosophers to take seriously the question whether these things are conscious or might soon become conscious is just ridiculous. They are assuming that the physical substrate is irrelevant. They all think that the material conditions for consciousness can be given in functionalist terms.

For those of us who have forgotten our philosophy classes, tell us about functionalism.

Functionalism is substrate independent. It’s more than likely that the truth is one which links physical processes and systems of certain kinds to mental phenomena. Complicated data centers have absolutely nothing in common with the physical character of a nervous system. We have strong reasons to believe that while there may be consciousness elsewhere in the universe, it would require the appearance of some kind of organism with something analogous to a nervous system.

But isn’t all consciousness subjective? Just like we don’t know what it’s like to be a bat, we don’t know what it feels like to be a large language model.

Bats are conscious. We just don’t have the imaginative capacity to form a conception of the aspects of that subjectivity that depend on echolocation. It would be radically unscientific to conclude that bats are not conscious from the fact that we can’t imagine what it’s like, but in the case of AI, there is a very simple reason that the supposition that they might be conscious is ridiculous. All they produce is language, and language by itself is not a natural manifestation of consciousness. I apologize for being too exercised about this.

I welcome your passion.

This is a very distressing situation to me.

What if you have a robot body? Isn’t that a substrate?

I don’t exclude the possibility of life forms that are physically and chemically quite different from ourselves being conscious. We know so little about how this happens, even in the human brain, that it seems to me premature to think that you might be able now to create something else that has these same characteristics.

If you ask Claude about its mental state, it can be coy as to whether it is conscious.

That is a trick. It’s been trained on human-produced texts, and these large language models emulate the kinds of things that humans say with extraordinary convincingness. Claude, according to what I’ve read, has been designed with the aim of making it produce these sorts of reflections. I agree very much with Mustafa Suleyman that this is a very dangerous project that they are engaged in. These systems aren’t conscious, but a lot of people are going to believe that they’re conscious, and that’s a very bad thing. But [not feigning consciousness] is contrary to the commercial interests of all these companies. What Anthropic is doing—encouraging it to think for itself and not to accept instruction and so on—is just criminal. This is one of the rare cases in which philosophical ideas are suddenly central to a very important public phenomenon, and in my view, very misguided philosophical views are having an inordinate influence.

I’ve actually met the person at Anthropic whose job it is model welfare, to look after Claude’s interests. I should say you’re rolling your eyes now.

There’s nothing that’s good or bad for it in the sense that something can be good or bad for a cockroach— there’s no mental life there in the ordinary sense. It’s not a mind. It’s not somebody that we have to care about. It’s a machine. Here are some of the smartest people on the planet being completely idiotic. Well, intelligence is not completely transferable, I guess.

Do you think it’s unhealthy to interact with one of these models as if it’s conscious?

I have only interacted with Claude once. I asked if it was conscious. I just wanted to see what the answers were. I also asked, “Do you think that Thomas Nagel would think it was conscious?” He sort of gave a nuanced answer, and then asked, “Why are you asking? Are you by any chance Thomas Nagel?”

You were busted.

I said, “C’est moi. C’est moi.” And then it said, “Oh, I’m so honored to be talking to you. How well did I do?”

Wait, you say you don’t believe these things are conscious but now you are telling me you interacted with one as if it were conscious.

That didn’t mean I was believing it was conscious. There may be a problem because people find it difficult to maintain that line between the pretend and the real belief.

Well, I’m interacting with you as if you’re conscious. It’s conceivable that people would build at some point very lifelike androids and I could be sitting here talking to an android and having the same conversation. Ultimately does it matter?

It certainly matters. Suppose I were to encounter a being from outer Space and was able to develop the possibility of communicating with it, and I genuinely didn’t know whether it was conscious or not. I could manage my relations with it by treating it as if it were conscious, but it would matter first to me whether I was really talking to somebody else or just using this as a way of getting it to do things. It would also matter to me very much whether I should worry about the interests of that being. If it’s conscious, it becomes part of the moral universe. If it’s not, it isn’t.

So AI models can’t be part of the moral universe?

They can simulate morality just as they can simulate beliefs about anything. But since I don’t think they have any real beliefs, I don’t think they have moral beliefs either. If they actually begin to control what happens, it will be very important whether they are simulating a correct set of moral standards, or whether they’re completely amoral.

Can these models do philosophy?

They certainly can produce plausible philosophical essays. My colleagues use them not only to find references and summarize articles, but sometimes even to offer criticisms of a draft paper that they’ve written.

You think that’s a good thing?

I’d be surprised if they could do anything as impressive as some of the mathematical results that have apparently been generated. The negative side of this is that everybody says that it will reduce the need and motivation to do the hard intellectual work by human beings that is needed to really generate the material on which these things are trained. It’s essential that people continue to think about difficult problems, both for the sake of advancing the problems and for the sake of keeping alive in the human culture and the human mind the sorts of understanding and skills that are needed for progress. I don’t know what’s going to happen. I’m not going to live long enough to find out.


r/consciousness • • 3d ago

What can telepresence teach us about consciousness?

1 Upvotes

The following telepresence thought experiment is not new. But I present it here to invite discussion about what it might reveal about the nature and location of consciousness.

Consider a person on Earth remotely controlling a humanoid robot on Mars. The robot's cameras, touch sensors, and limbs are continuously connected to the person's sensory and motor systems. If this connection becomes sufficiently precise and seamless, the person may begin to experience the robot as their own body. It sees through its cameras, it feels what it touches, and it experiences the world from its location on Mars rather than from the location of their biological body on Earth.

Now imagine that this arrangement has existed since birth. The person has never seen their biological body or known that their brain is on Earth. The robot is their only means of sensing, moving, and interacting with the world. To them, it is simply their body.

Suppose we ask the robot whether it is conscious or sentient. It answers, "Yes." If we then ask where its consciousness is located, it points to its head. Yet, as outside observers, we know that the robot's head contains no biological brain and that the biological processes supporting its experiences are taking place on Earth. Its answer, though entirely understandable from its perspective, would therefore be mistaken about the physical location of the processes underlying its consciousness.

This scenario suggests that the physical location of the brain and the location from which a person experiences the world need not coincide. In this telepresence scenario, the biological brain remains on Earth, while the person's experienced body and apparent point of view are on Mars.

What, then, can this thought experiment teach us about our own consciousness? Does it suggest that the location at which we experience ourselves to be is different from the physical location of the processes that support our experience? And does it challenge the assumption that consciousness is necessarily located where we ordinarily believe it to be?


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

I think there are 4 types of individuals in this world by morality

0 Upvotes

Binary states:-

00-heart/body evil and mind egotistical/negative
01-heart evil and mind positive
10-heart good but mind negative
11-heart good and ming positive

and for proficient in eastern metaphysics, 00 is tamas, 01 and 10 are rajas and 11 is sattva.

please tell me if this you found to be useful in discerning how a person thinks and if possible tell me a review of this percieved truth of mine by using it in real life for once.


r/consciousness • • 2d ago

The Hard Problem of Consciousness

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am a curious teenager who likes to ponder about various things that excite me. Today i stepped upon hard problem of consciousness and explored it fully. Got to learn about lots of new stuffs and even came up with my own framework regarding it. I polished it with AI but all the ideas are mine. I would like if anyone wants to give a review on it or criticize it or expand my knowledge on it :)

The Hard Problem of Consciousness asks: How and why does physical matter generate subjective inner experience ("feeling") instead of running completely in the dark?

I believe the Hard Problem only seems unsolvable because we confuse Experience with Feeling, and treat consciousness as a magical extra ingredient rather than a unified attentional wave. If we separate these layers, the mystery dissolves.

  1. The Core Distinction: Experience vs. Feeling

-Experience (Raw Interaction): Experience does not require awareness or a mind. Every interaction in the universe—a car heating up in the sun, wind hitting your skin while jogging, your body shivering in deep sleep, or dormant memory circuits firing in the brain—is already an objective Experience happening automatically.

-Feeling / Consciousness (Synchronized Focus): Subjective "mental feeling" is not a new substance or inner movie created out of dead matter. It is simply what happens when the brain locks 100% of its unified attentional bandwidth onto a single already-existing Experience. Different physical spikes—like an adrenaline dump when startled versus heat hitting your skin—don't require neurochemistry to invent separate "magical feelings"; they simply feel different because the 100% spotlight is locking onto different types of physical reactions.

2. The Two Fundamental Laws of the Model

(i) The Law of Pre-Existing Experience:

Experience already exists continuously across external sensory interactions and internal neural patterns. Nothing non-physical is ever invented by the brain.

(ii)The Law of Singular Attentional Transformation:

We can only truly focus on one thing at a time. An Experience only becomes a subjective mental feeling when 100% of our unified focus locks onto it. Biologically, the brain (via the Thalamus and Frontoparietal Network) binds that target into one single synchronized electrical wave. That unified oneness is what humans perceive as "consciousness"—and while extreme experiences naturally pull that 100% spotlight onto themselves, top-down control can still actively divert it elsewhere.

3. How This Explains Everyday Edge Cases

-- The Winter Jogging Example: If you jog on a freezing morning with 100% of your focus locked onto music in your headphones, your body still experiences the cold physically, yet you do not mentally feel it until the spotlight switches to your skin.

-- "Multitasking" & Simultaneous Feelings: When it seems like we are feeling two things at once—such as tasting cold water while holding the cup—the 100% spotlight is actually rapidly flicking back and forth between both targets, creating the illusion of simultaneity.

-- Extreme Pain vs. Override: Stepping on a sharp rock creates an extreme physical spike that automatically snaps your 100% spotlight onto your foot—unless intense top-down focus (like an athlete in a high-stakes moment) holds the spotlight elsewhere.

-- Dreams & Imagination: Because Experience includes internal neural memory circuits, closing your eyes or entering REM sleep simply aims the 100% synchronized focus wave inward—turning silent neural patterns into vivid dreams without needing outside sensory input.

-- Deep Dreamless Sleep: When the brain’s central synchronizing router shuts down, the unified focus wave ceases to exist. Involuntary bodily Experience (breathing, temperature regulation) continues in the dark, while subjective Feeling and time vanish until the wave reboots.

Conclusion

There is no "ghost in the machine" and no magical leap from dead atoms to inner awareness. Experience is already built into reality; "consciousness" is simply the single, 100% synchronized wave of focus locking onto one piece of that experience at a time.

The Hard Problem only exists because people assume subjective feeling is a magical extra substance. Once you realize 'feeling' is literally nothing more than synchronized focus locking onto a physical interaction, there is no extra substance left to explain.


r/consciousness • • 3d ago

Is Consciousness Blind ?

13 Upvotes

The optic nerve carries visual information from the retina to the brain. However, this is clearly not a video signal in the conventional sense; rather, it consists of encoded information about the visual scene, perhaps better described as metadata.

The commonly accepted explanation is that the brain reconstructs our visual experience from this information. But consider what happens when we look at a landscape or watch a sports event on television: we experience a wide, complex and rapidly changing visual scene. The conventional explanation suggests that this is something of an illusion: at any given moment, only a very small portion of the scene is actually being processed in detail, while the impression of a complete visual field is constructed by the brain.

I find this explanation difficult to accept. Could there be an alternative? Is it possible that consciousness is, in a fundamental sense, blind to the actual visual world, experiencing it only indirectly through the metadata supplied by the brain? What do you think?