I love card games, passionately. I still like to stay informed about YGO, but havent played in a few years, and my other game died recently. So, im always looking for a new game... this board is horrible for that.
A recent post gained minor attention, and just happened to be a (100% vibecoded art-prompted) YGO-like, but that also uses a mana/color system... Thats the two types of games i know, so i wanted to see how broken a game like this is. All the cards were listed on the site, and i noticed 2 things immediately..
(OVER DETAILED COMBO EXPLANATIONS)
- Theres a mechanic that lets me start at +2 extra mana on turn 1. I was so shocked by this i had to confirm thats how it worked, u just get basically black lotus for free LOL. Also, spells work like in YGO, you dont spend anything. Once you have 3 "element" you can cast any number of generic 3 drops you want haha whaaat
- Theres like 7 or 8 draw cards in that range, and decks are 30 cards with mulligan... u can run 3 Graceful Charity, 3 upstart goblin, 3 upstart goblin if you control a monster, 3 upstart that gains life, even 1 Pot of Greed that gains life, and when u gain life you trigger the games very own Royal Magical Library function! ...the dev didnt know what Library was when I asked.
Theres even a card to special summon level 1s from hand, to get another Library, or just summon any of 3 lvl1s that draw on summon. After that you can XYZ to extend further to draw 1 again, and set up your GY for the monster reborns you have.
So at this point, we can draw our entire deck, discard anything we want a few times and use the 3 Monster Reborn (another colorless 3 drop) to get literally any set up in the game. Theres a fusion spell, or Miracle Fusion, so any fusion or XYZ should be available, you can even summon a card that ramps 1 of any color (permanantly) 3 or 4 times and hit the very low mana cap of 5 on turn 1.
Lastly, you can either hand rip for 6 or just do a Burn FTK.
Like... theres so many cards that hand-rip, draw, or burn for no restrictions that it was FTKs all the way down.
No passionate TCG player would ever make something like this. Its clearly just another grift. And thats almost every post here. It needs to be addressed.
Lastly, i think there can be some nuance here, but there needs to be rules. There was a recent post of someone turning their childhood solodev TCG into a digital client. If thats true, i think that implementation is basically fine. AI coding is more moral than AI art gen, which i think should be fully banned on the subreddit, but AI-coding majorly enables grifters and its something that needs watched.