I often hear of “Preparation vs Improvisation”, telling DMs to minimise their prep time and instead trust themselves and their group to figure it out during the session. While this is great advice that I agree with, it’s only half true.
Let’s say that the DM is the driving instructor and the players are the learners. We have a set destination, and the DM has a route in mind for how to reach that destination. But sometimes the learners miss an exit, forget a rule, or there might even be construction blocking the route.
In these situations, the better the instructor knows the area, the easier it is for them to adapt, weigh suggestions from the learner and arrive at the destination no matter the detour. If the instructor doesn’t know the area, though, things can quickly become messy, having the learner drive off into the opposite direction, and leaving the instructor panicked and stressed. Sure, they can try and improvise a new route with the learner, but it’s mostly the blind leading the blind.
It’s the same in D&D, the better the DM knows the world, the NPCs, their goals and motivations, and the rules, the more they’re able to improvise themselves or go along with player ideas without cornering themselves or going too far adrift from the story they had in mind.
Preparation enables improvisation, as long as you prepare the right things. Preparing specific outcomes and how they shall be achieved is what leads to what is classically thought of as “unfun railroading”, since it takes away from Player agency and creativity.
So what is the “right” preparation? Common advice is to prepare situations, not solutions, which is definitely correct and great advice, as it gives players a clear direction and the freedom to drive that direction their way. But it still leaves the DM having to improvise heavily with little guidance, or in other words, without a map.
Building the map can be done by preparing the following:
What do the NPCs want?
Creating goals and intentions for the people around the players doesn’t just help the DM in knowing how they will interact with the players (what information they may know and offer, how helpful they would be, if they would fight to the death or try to escape, etc.), but it also makes the world feel more alive. This will make improvised roleplaying a lot easier on the DM, even if the players ask unexpected questions.
What is common knowledge?
Players love to go places you didn’t plan on going, and talking to people you didn’t prep for. Having a general idea of what is common knowledge and preparing pieces of information that random people might be able to offer lets the DM reward player agency while not having to prep every direction they might go.
Last resort
Build a random occurrence that brings players back on track. Having a general plot is fine, otherwise campaigns wouldn’t exist, and having players go off-road for a bit is part of the game and should be encouraged, but at some point you need to get back to the plot if you want to continue the campaign. Planning for some occurrences that push the players back to the “main questline” gives the DM the freedom to go as off-road as they want, knowing that as soon as the side quest is over, or stops being fun, they can head back to the main questline.
Prepare drop-in surroundings and encounters
Having drop-in content prepped that you can throw into any scenario that the players find themselves in lets the players explore beyond the current area without the DM having to come up with a world in a moments notice. These should be specific enough to run as written, with a notes on what you can be swapped on the fly and what has to stay.
Gazetteers vs lore-dumps
If you do like creating detailed cities or areas, use physical and written Gazetteers instead of lore-dumping verbally. Listening to a monologue of details can be tough to interact with and stressful to keep track of. Providing written resources that the players can reference and browse at their own pace is a lot easier to handle.
What NOT to do
Have scripted dialogue, planned player reactions, or anything that relies on players doing specific things unprompted.
--
The right preparation sets up the DM to improvise easier and with more confidence, without backing themselves into a corner and enables the players to have agency.
Some of this can be outsourced. Drop-in encounters especially, since they’re not tied to your world or your plot. I’ve been building a few of these, scenarios with lairs, environmental options, secondary objectives and a few ways they can end, meant to slot into whatever you’re already running. The first I’ve released is Goblin Roadblock, free on my site at orivor.net.
I’m working on more of those, plus some writing aimed at first-time DMs and at players who want to run something but don’t feel ready yet. All of this will also be available on orivor.net, and if there’s a resource you keep needing and can’t find, let me know in the comments or via my website.