r/dsa • u/False_Cookie8226 • 4h ago
r/dsa • u/helpprogram2 • 3h ago
Discussion America hates moderates because they are cowards. They stand for nothing and will give us nothing.
reddit.comr/dsa • u/False_Cookie8226 • 21h ago
💉🩺🌹Medicare For All🌹🩺💉 I love TrumpCare, only the smartest president could do it...
r/dsa • u/Small_Dog_8699 • 6h ago
Discussion Democrats’ Next Chapter, Brought To You By Billionaires
Best keep an eye on the opposition.
r/dsa • u/newgoddessdivine • 22h ago
Electoral Politics [OC] Mapping All 820 Current & Former DSA Public Officeholders by County (1965–2027)
r/dsa • u/orangecatsocialclub • 1d ago
Shitpost Me, a person who doesn't live in NY, reading every new Zohran for New York City email
[ID: Three studio portraits of a little kid in pastel clothes, posing different but looking grumpy in every shot with the captions “CONGRATS”, “HAPPY FOR YOU, and “NICE”.]
r/dsa • u/Ok_Crazy1195 • 1d ago
🌹 DSA news Two Democratic socialists could hold major power in Georgia’s state house
instagram.comr/dsa • u/IndieJones0804 • 1d ago
Theory 2026 will be remembered as the beginning of the American Socialist revolution.
reddit.comr/dsa • u/YogurtClosetThinnest • 2d ago
News Zohran Mamdani announces plan to close NYC’s Rikers Island jail
r/dsa
•
u/gayish_boyish
•
1d ago
Theory A Liberal Case For Democratic Socialism (pls critique)
“Capitalism is dying. It will not, however, disappear on a given day, or in a given month or even year. Its demise will take place as a historic process that could lead to democratic socialism—or to a new kind of collectivist and authoritarian society” (Harrington). With these words, Michael Harrington, a democratic socialist and founder of the Democratic Socialists of America, started the first section of his essay titled “What Socialists Would Do in America–If They Could.” In America today, we are seeing a rise of that latter option, an authoritarian government and president unlike any before him. However, due to the recent elections of more progressive leaders such as Zohran Mamdani, it seems that America is seeing a shift towards democratic socialism, and if America, a country whose core principles center around liberalism, is seemingly proving Harrington’s statement, perhaps liberalism must be more deeply understood.
Liberalism is defined as “a political and economic doctrine that emphasizes individual autonomy, equality of opportunity, and the protection of individual rights”(Ball et al.). Most of the modern world was built upon this belief, and it remains one of the most influential modern doctrines. Democratic socialism is a far harder term to define, but put simply, it is a politically democratic philosophy with both a restricted private market and certain socialist reforms. These policies function as a bridge between the interests of capitalism and socialism while allowing certain enrichment of the overall society from both systems. Liberalism and the utilitarianism that heavily influenced it hold within themselves the seeds of this democratic socialism.
John Stuart Mill was the epitome of a classical liberal, fully enamored by thoughts of freedom of the individual and the great innovation that capitalism promised. Furthermore, as the godson of Jeremy Bentham, he was one of the founding thinkers on utilitarianism. As one of the founding liberal thinkers, Mill set the course for many who followed to shape the liberal world we live in today. His most credited idea was that of his harm principle. This was a principle aimed at discovering true “utility” in government policy and can be summed up in Chapter 1 of On Liberty, where he states, “the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others”(Mill 1859). This principle guided all his works as well as shaping much of modern-day ethics and policy decisions. Under this principle, founded both in the belief of liberalism that freedom should be prioritized and in utilitarian thought, Mill believed that close to true utility could be found, utility acting for him as the “ultimate appeal on all ethical questions” (Mill 1859). The harm principle also shaped his path away from other classical liberals, who moved toward laissez-faire capitalism, as it is a fundamentally egalitarian principle, weighing all individuals as morally equal and focusing on the benefit of the community, taking the classic capitalist idea of freedom and showing the hypocrisy within it. Mill says, “The only freedom which deserves the name, is that of pursuing our own good in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, or impede their efforts to obtain it” (Mill,1859). Therefore, in capitalism, the only ones with true freedom, by Mill’s definition, are the upper class, as the working class does not have the freedom to pursue their own good explicitly because of the actions of those above. Within this belief, the idealism of capitalist thinking begins to give way.
Later in life, Mill had cemented some of these anti-capitalist ideas into his book Socialism and, through reading Owen and Fourier, had landed on liberal or democratic socialism as his chosen political affiliation. He arrives at this conclusion by attacking the current capitalist system through the lens of liberalism and his harm principle. In attacking capitalism, he says, “The very idea of distributive justice, or of any proportionality between success and merit, or between success and exertion, is in the present state of society so manifestly chimerical as to be relegated to the regions of romance” (Mill 1879). This attack illuminates a fundamental flaw with capitalism that separates it from the liberal ideal of an equality of opportunity and explicitly goes against the harm principle, as capitalism creates extreme power disparity regardless of individual merit. Mill argues that just as important as the equality of opportunity is the ability of people to exercise said opportunity; this belief, among others–such as the egalitarian views of utilitarianism–shows that distributive justice, being at best an idealistic vision rather than anything tangible, is fundamentally against everything Mill stands for.
The harm principle illuminates why this absence of distributive justice is morally indefensible, for if capitalism’s underlying structures determine who suffers, then that suffering should not be condemned as a personal failing but rather as a systemic institutional one. A truth baked into the ideology of a capitalist society is that the rich work for every cent they have and that the poor are only such due to laziness or lack of talent. Mill pushes sharply against this, saying that “Next to birth the chief cause of success in life is accident and opportunity”(Mill 1879), and even if this belief of those at the bottom of society being inferior in some way was true, “Is weakness a justification of suffering?” (Mill 1879). Does a true utilitarian lose all care for harm when that harm could have theoretically been avoided? These problems are inherent in the system of capitalism; they aren’t bugs; they exist by design, and Mill sees this.
From here, the logical next step is to question why Mill chose democratic socialism over capitalism, because unlike many, Mill did not believe capitalism to be the least bad system by any means. This is due to his unwavering belief in the equal value of all human lives. He could not accept a societal structure that institutionally requires suffering from the lower class. He believed that by bringing up those near the bottom of society, all of society prospers (Mill 1879). In Socialism, Mill argues that though revolutionary socialism is attractive due to its promises of radical change to the status quo, those promises are mostly backed by faith in the system and risk all that capitalism has gained humanity in years past. However, he does not throw away socialism outright; he believes that democratic socialism is where society is going to land, but he is not fundamentally against a socialism similar to Fourierism as long as it is implemented slowly and democratically (Mill 1879). Mill rejected revolutionary socialism because it risked everything capitalism had built in pursuit of an untested ideal, so a gradualist democratic socialism was the only path consistent with his harm principle.
Free-market capitalism, though flawed, does look superficially stable. It has held power over the world for centuries now and has systematically crushed any and all rising anti-capitalist countries in its path. However, this system, Michael Harrington believed, is not in fact stable and rests on a bedrock of contradiction and crawls towards an antisocial ideal. He arrived independently at Mill’s conclusion on democratic socialism as the logical destination and proved its practical necessity. While talking about modern capitalism, he says, “This new guise capitalism remains dangerously and fundamentally antisocial. Capacity is expanded in good times as if there were no tomorrow –-or more precisely, as if the ability of the society to consume were not limited by the very income structure that capitalist production enforces.” (Harrington) This critique is founded on capitalism’s unending urge to grow and expand, its urge to produce and consume all; an urge that, though pleasing, is ecologically unsustainable and socially destabilizing. To expand capitalism efficiently, those at the bottom of society, the workers, must be given barely living wages, going directly against Mill’s harm principle, while the workers end up being the ones paying for expansion by consuming. Those of the capitalist class do not need to worry about any of that due to capitalism placing them in positions where they are “appropriating surplus value in the guise of wages” (Harrington). Effectively taking the value produced by the exploited lower class as wages for themselves. This does not match liberalism’s values of equal opportunity, as, with few exceptions, those at the top were put into that position by their parents or chance. These fundamental contradictions lead to unrest in the public, intermittent crises, and an upper class feeding on the exploitation of those below. This can by no means be called a stable system and, Harrington believes, it is a perfect birthplace for democratic socialism.
America is hailed as the epicenter of free-market capitalism; therefore, it should be the perfect spot for democratic socialism to grow. It is due to this fact that Harrington focused much of his time on the application of his ideas to American society. He believes that “the American liberals (including labor liberals) who unconsciously accept the corporate premise are often also hostile to corporations and in the future could become socialist” (Harrington). This contradiction in American ideals sets up a voting base that is ready for change and ready to move left. However, there are a few problems with regard to the integration of democratic socialism into modern-day America. One problem would be the seemingly infinite patience and belief that American citizens have with the capitalist system, though, as corruption becomes more and more apparent, this belief is being tested. Another would be the issue that in order to produce a democratic socialist state, large systematic changes would have to be put into place. These would be put in slowly as the American system tends to work, and during this transitional phase, “elements of both traditional capitalism and corporate collectivism will coexist with, and threaten, socialist innovations”(Harrington). This means that the powerful, corrupt capitalist powers that benefit from the system would not be exterminated but rather slowly weakened; a thing that they will fight tooth and nail to avoid, leveraging all of the power given to them in our current system. These roadblocks, as well as others, pose a major threat to the possibility of democratic socialism soon, but there are undeniable benefits that will and are being shown to the public that have the power to fundamentally change things.
Democratic socialism presents two benefits that could shift the majority opinion to the left: the effective right to participate in government and the ability to make more use of the opportunity promised to them in a liberal state. This effective right was a major idea that Harrington talked about, saying, “socialism proposes a national planning process in which all the people would have an effective right to participate”(Harrington). Practically, this is saying that the people are given a lot of civic power and responsibility, along with the time and energy to participate fully in it. This would allow for far higher civic engagement and systems that work for the people because they were built by the people, with the people’s interest in mind, through democratic debate. This would mean that likely more egalitarian tax laws would be put in place, the minimum wage would be lifted, the cost of living would go down, and free public services would be a priority. The second benefit is the ability to move towards actualizing this “equality of opportunity” that any truly liberal system should seek to actualize. This would mean that even those at the bottom of the economic ladder would have enough surplus capital and time to use many private and public goods given by the restricted capitalist framework. Without this, all benefits of capitalism are lost as its accomplishments can only be enjoyed by a shrinking few.
These policies, as Harrington and Mill pointed out, must be brought in slowly and democratically, or they will hold no ground, but we are already seeing this happen in America. The American populace is becoming more and more disillusioned with our current system each day. We are a country founded on liberalism, a country falling into the same authoritarianism Harrington warned about, and a country full of voters who are ready for change. Mill believed in capitalism more than most Americans today do, but due to liberal thought and utilitarian principles, he found his way onto the left; this is a shift that many Americans will make in the coming years, and it is a shift that is necessary for this country if we are ever to be a liberal nation.
Works Cited
Ball, Terence, Harry K Girvetz, Richard Dagger, and Kenneth Minogue. 2025. “Liberalism.” In Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/topic/liberalism.
Harrington, Michael . 1978. “What Socialists Would Do in America If They Could.” Dissent. https://dissentmagazine.org/article/what-socialists-would-do-in-america-if-they-could/.
Mill, John Stuart. 1859. On Liberty. London: J. W. Parker and Son.
———. 1879. Socialism.
r/dsa • u/Green_Day_1878 • 2d ago
Discussion Most and least progressive Democratic governors/governors-elect?
I'm curious how people would rank current Democratic governors in terms of progressivism. Who would you consider the most progressive and who would you consider the least progressive?
I'm surprised I haven't been able to find a comprehensive list or ranking comparing them. Curious to hear people's thoughts and what criteria you'd use (economic policy, social issues, labor, climate, etc.).
r/dsa • u/mikelmon99 • 3d ago
📺📹Video📹📺 Zohran Mamdani: The best deal in town? Donating to NYC-DSA.
r/dsa • u/pbrdreams • 2d ago
Discussion They will answer to money
https://www.instagram.com/reel/Df56RlFxzUk/
I had already cut off streaming services, cancelled subscriptions, and minimized corporate spending earlier this year. Not everyone can afford a general strike, but this is an incredibly easy mechanic to execute. We don't need all this shit!
Also implement this into your shopping
r/dsa • u/mikelmon99 • 3d ago
Twitter HYSTERICAL 😭
We need to run her again for Senate in 2028
r/dsa • u/Medization • 1d ago
History Bernie Sanders falsifies the political legacy of Rosa Luxemburg
Sanders seeks to transform Luxemburg into a bourgeois liberal like himself. Sanders strips Luxemburg’s stark alternative—socialism or barbarism—of its revolutionary content, reducing it to a vague humanist appeal to “the better angels of people” so that everyone can set aside their differences and “learn to live together.”
The 85-year-old senator has spent his entire career channeling working-class anger back into the Democratic Party and defending the profit system with a veneer of socialist rhetoric. Sanders’ attempt to enlist Luxemburg in this enterprise is an affront to everything she stood for.
Luxemburg and her great comrade, Karl Liebknecht, were murdered, not in the mid or late 1920s but on January 15, 1919. Just two weeks earlier they had founded the German Communist Party (KPD) to lead the working class in the revolution that was erupting across the country to overthrow capitalism, the system responsible for the mass slaughter of the First World War.
Inspired by the Russian Revolution of 1917, sailors in Kiel rose up on November 3, 1918, setting off uprisings across the country that forced the abdication of Kaiser Wilhelm II and the signing of the armistice on November 11. The Social Democratic Party (SPD) government responded to the upsurge with a campaign of incitement and violent repression, culminating in the murders of Luxemburg and Liebknecht.
r/dsa • u/Komrademoth13 • 1d ago
Discussion Why does the DSA want to abolish the president?
I'm curious I just read the DSA platform, and I thought it was good, not as far I'd like in some areas but that's to be expected. I was a little curious about this bit though of abolishing the president I'm not against the idea in theory I'm just curious why the thing that would replace it would be chosen by congress? why wouldn't this new body also be voted in by the people. Also what's up with abolishing the senate? Wouldn't it be better to remove the house? I think it's more fair if everyone just has their two senators, unicameral.
r/dsa • u/CDN-Social-Democrat • 2d ago
Discussion This is already so fucking depressing
We have this - https://www.reddit.com/r/dsa/comments/1xzqfdb/establishment_democrats_announce_their_plans_to/ - About 25 seconds in we have the guy saying people that oppose Jeffries are "Hamas, Hezbollah, and China paid actors"....
We have this - https://www.reddit.com/r/DemocraticSocialism/comments/1y0ek0d/nancy_pelosi_is_confronted_over_jeffries_record/ - It's even written all over Pelosi's face how corrupt and shameful this whole thing has been.
We have this - https://www.reddit.com/r/DemocraticSocialism/comments/1xzwmj3/code_pink_confronts_aoc_on_jefferies_vote/ - AOC like Pelosi has her face telling the whole story. She knows this whole thing has been a mess.
It is becoming more and more clear that the power players of the status quo Democratic Party/DNC are going to do everything they can to waste this opportunity. Period.
These types are bought and paid for and they themselves profit from the status quo and even problems associated with the status quo. They are NOT interested in change/transition past any kind of empty platitude fluff talk. Period.
When it comes to the Labour Movement, Environmentalist Movement, Peace Movement. We are only in the beginning of the fight now. Which is beyond sad.
We are going to have to do a lot of not just domestic networking/solidarity movements but international networking and solidarity movements for punch power.
With the Military-Industrial Complex, Fossil Fuel Industry, and other bad predatory actors that are near Death Cults at this point we have a real real fight and whole system of corruption up against us.
Absolutely and utterly fucking shameful. Shame on all these people. Shame!
r/dsa • u/Cactus-throater69 • 3d ago
RAISING HELL Whether you’re young and activated or older and activated, we’re all tired of this shit. No more WARS! Free Medicare for All! Affordable Necessities for everyone! A Green New Deal! No more billionaires and corporations taking advantage of us! No more status quo.
r/dsa • u/Slow-Foundation7295 • 3d ago
Discussion Should I join the DSA?
I believe that humanity as a whole needs to get past capitalism, peacefully and democratically. I believe it will take a long time, a few decades at the very least. I believe that, in the meantime, as US citizens, we must create the conditions for free and open debate, which means of course rejecting right-wing authoritarianism, but which should center on giving the working class breathing space by raising the minimum wage, enabling widespread union membership, providing universal health care and tuition-free college, and subsidizing housing, child care, and elder care. I believe we should pay for this by levying wealth and corporate taxes that effectively abolish decamillionaires, billionaires, and trillionaires. I believe all of this should be done without reference to or preference for any particular race or sexual orientation -- in other words, that leftists must excuse ourselves from the "culture wars" and leave cultural development to cultural rather than political forces.
Getting money out of politics, pursuing corrupt authoritarians/corporate bosses, and straightening out the immigration system should be pursued as well, but never to the detriment of laser focus on the expressed needs of working people, particularly "fly-over," rural, non-college educated working people.
I want to give those people a generation or two to see quasi-socialist policies at work and to have the space to think about something other than putting food on the table and not getting kicked out of their homes.
What I don't want is to wind up in rooms full of people screaming that I'm not sufficiently Stalinist, that I'm a racist or a homophobe, or that I'm a dirty corporate liberal incrementalist. On the other side, I'm over dealing with people admonishing me for being too utopian in my ultimate goals.
Should I join the DSA? Are my principles too heterodox/idiosyncratic? Or would joining the DSA just mean trading one bunch of people yelling at me (presently, libs and tankies) for another?
r/dsa • u/soalone34 • 2d ago
News Democrats seem to back away from shutdown over Iran war