r/dune • • 20h ago

General Discussion Anyone been to the Dune the Experience in LA?

26 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on it? How were the food and drink options? What do the items (bag and water bottle) look like that you get with the VIP ticket? Do they have a store where you can buy more items?


r/dune • • 20h ago

Merchandise My humble Dune Collection 💅🏻

Post image
666 Upvotes

Just thought I would share 🥰


r/dune • • 19h ago

Chapterhouse: Dune One of my favorite Van Gogh painting… thanks to Dune!

Thumbnail
gallery
208 Upvotes

I was re-reading Chapterhouse and it really made me want to see the painting in person (again)!

Just wanted to share some pictures I took of it :P

—

Chaumes de Cordeville à Auvers-sur-Oise, painted by Vincent van Gogh just a few weeks before his death.


r/dune • • 10m ago

General Discussion In Dune Part 2, did the emperor know Paul was Muad’Dib?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! This might be a bit of a dumb question to some (or most) of you, but as much as I believe Dune part 2 to be an absolute masterpiece, I do feel like this was one part of the movie that wasn’t made clear enough. And tbh it’s a relatively small detail anyway. And I’m aware that this was probably explained more in the book. So I’m talking about the 2024 movie, not the book.

So obviously the emperor orders the extermination of the Atreides. Then in part 2, receives a message with the Atreides ducal seal, prompting him to travel to Arrakis, yet seems surprised to see Paul is not only alive but is also Muad’Dib.

After looking through other posts and even reading the script of the scene where Paul confronts the emperor, it does seem like a lot of other viewers were confused, but I feel like i have a theory. But it does seem like no one seems to know for sure and it just wasn’t made clear. The most common theory seems to be that the emperor did know Paul was Muad’Dib, and him questioning Baron Harkonenn was a test to see how much he knew about Paul. And that his shock in the final scene was seeing Paul as a battle hardened fremen leader.

This could very well be the case but I believe I have a better theory that I’d love your input on.
So Paul obviously uses the Atreides seal on the message to the emperor because he won’t read a message from just anyone. And obviously a message baring the seal of a great house that he believes to be completely wiped out by his own hand gets his attention. However we know that he had no knowledge of the Reverend mother’s order to baron Harkonenn to spare Jessica and Paul. It’s also worth noting that Princess Irulan and Reverend mother Mohiam are aware of the prophecy of the lisan al gaib, as it’s their own creation. So their knowledge that Paul and Jessica were spared and that Jessica is bene gesserit probably gave them a clue Paul was alive, and that Jessica was spreading propaganda to increase their power and influence over the fremen.

Additionally when the emperor reads the message from Paul, it becomes immediately clear to irulan that Paul is alive and most likely muad’dib. However we never directly see the message paul wrote and even then, it’s in a fictional language. But since it bears the Atreides seal, I’m sure the emperor suspected either Paul or Leto had survived, or someone was using the Atreides seal to lure them into a trap. Hence why he fortifies himself behind a massive sardukaar army. They travel to Arrakis to question the harkonenn on what knowledge they have of muad’did, the Harkonenns seems to not know or care who Muad’Dib is beyond some mental fremen fanatic.

I think it’s also worth noting that when Paul breaks through the emperors defenses and kills Baron Vladimir Harkonenn in the throne room, his face is completely covered and he speaks to his fremen soldiers in a weird whisper type voice, which I believe to be him hiding his real voice from the emperor. Anyway in the next scene he reveals himself, and Christopher walkin’s acting doesn’t seem to really give us anything. Yet the script says the following “The emperor loses his bravado and becomes livid. Paul Atreides is truly alive.

So my theory is that The emperor suspected Paul could be alive, but had no idea he was Muad’Dib. Did anyone else have any other theories or thoughts? Or was it super obvious and I’ve looked way too deep into it hahaha