I'm playing through my first Space Age playthrough and noticed something that threw me off when figuring out how to produce things on Gleba for the first time. Generally Factorio does an amazing job of allowing the player to derive complex conclusions from a small number of principles that the game presents to you in simple ways. So I'm pointing this particular thing out as a notable exception to that pattern. Either I missed something that the game told me, or the game actively gives the player an incorrect understanding of how they can build their Gleba factory.
You arrive at Gleba, and eventually you harvest your first Jellynut. You start to look into how to get iron on Gleba, and find the "Iron bacteria" recipe. It takes a lot of jelly, but so far that's the only way you can find to make iron. Then you start making your first bioflux, which unlocks the "Iron bacteria cultivation" recipe.
At around this same time, the game pops up a tip teaching you about how spoilage works: Spoilage percentage in production. It tells you: "Spoil progress of an ingredient affects spoil progress of the product", and shows an animation of two jellynut processing biochambers: one that's taking in mostly-fresh jellynuts and producing mostly-fresh jelly, and one that's taking in mostly-spoiled jellynuts and producing mostly-spoiled jelly. Sure, there are some details left for you to figure out yourself; like what happens when a recipe takes multiple different ingredients with different levels of spoilage. But the lesson seems to unambiguously teach you: the spoil percent of the ingredients transfers directly to the spoil percent of the output.
You look at the "Iron bacteria cultivation" recipe and think through what's possible with it. You think about whether it's possible to build a self-feeding setup that infinitely feeds just-cultivated bacteria back in to produce more with; siphoning off the excess to use for iron ore, and looping just enough of it back into itself to produce an infinite cycle of cultivation.
You think about whether this can theoretically sustain itself forever, and you find that it can't. Because spoilage transfers from ingredients to products. Based on what the game told you about "Spoilage percentage in production", if you put in an iron ore with 3m50s left, you'll get out 4 iron ore that each have 3m50s left. No matter what, you have a 5 minute countdown that starts when you produce the bacteria from jelly, and any value you get out of cultivation comes down to how many times you can run that jelly-produced bacteria through cultivation within the absolute 5 minute window, that's inescapable due to spoilage transfer from ingredients to products. You conclude that the only continuous way to produce iron is directly from jelly, and cultivation can only apply a finite multiplicative factor to your jelly-based production before your bacteria turns into a pumpkin at midnight.
I found this a bit strange when I encountered it, like it felt like it defeats the purpose of "bacteria cultivation". So, luckily, I decided to run an experiment where I fed a single mostly-spoiled bacteria into cultivation to observe the freshness of its outputs. And to my surprise, the produced bacteria were all 100% fresh!
This directly contradicts the only information the game had given me about how production works with spoilage percentages. This discovery meaningfully changes what sort of factory I could design for producing iron on Gleba, and the only information the game gives you about this process is close to actively false. Not ambiguous, not "figure it out yourself from experimentation", but rather, the game tells you something that basically contradicts what is actually true about how to work with bacteria, at exactly the moment where you're figuring out for the first time how to work with bacteria. It doesn't feel like something the game expects you to experiment with yourself, because it explicitly tells you what the result of the experiment would be (a different result than it actually is).
The fact that bacteria cultivation ignores the spoilage percentage of its ingredients feels like a notable exception to an established rule about spoilage, and the game doesn't seem to give any explicit indication that this exception exists (unless I missed something?). And the fact that this exception exists seems to meaningfully impact how you can build your factory.
---
Again, the only reason I'm pointing out something so pedantic is because it seems like a departure from what Factorio is almost always exceptionally good at: playing by its established rules and communicating those rules to the player clearly. I personally didn't get tripped up on this for too long, but my worry is that the way the game presents this information could be actively misleading for many players arriving at Gleba for the first time. Did anyone else get thrown off by this, or did I just miss something?
I feel like this could be fixed by slightly tweaking the phrasing of the "Spoilage percentage in production" tip that pops up. E.g. "Spoil progress of an ingredient sometimes affects spoil progress of the product". Or recipes that are exceptions to this rule could mention something in its tooltip saying that it's an exception, such as "Not affected by ingredient spoilage percentage".
Does anyone else agree that this information could be presented better for players who have just arrived at Gleba for the first time?