r/Fancast • • Oct 18 '26

Mod Post OCTOBER 2026 ANNOUNCEMENT

26 Upvotes

Recently, the mod team has realized that discussions keep getting derailed. Its the same reason every time. Its because of discussions.

Politics are inherently subjective and can tend to hurt feelings. You also can't objectively judge a casting if the only reason you love or hate it is because of politics.

Same applies to the medium itself. For example, we've seen many hate comments on Harry Potter reboot TV show posts just because its adapted from a JK Rowling series. Not because the castings themselves are bad.

We don't necessarily disagree with your politics or their politics. We don't necessarily agree with them either. We just want to encourage objectivity and civil discussion.

Despite this, we will not ban fancasting political figures. Those are still perfectly allowed. Just no political discussions.

Thank you for taking the time to read this. If you have any questions, please comment them and I'll answer to the best possible extent that I can.

-NS6514


r/Fancast • • Apr 24 '26

Mod Post APRIL 2026 ANNOUNCEMENT

55 Upvotes

Recently, the mod team has received an exceptional number of complaints about a variety of post types that have been negatively affecting the sub in the long run. As a result of this, the manual post approval system will be re-implemented as a means of keeping the quality standards of r/fancast to a fair minimum.

Depending on how this is system is received over time, it may or may or may not be here to stay. As a result of this change, however, posts will now be approved in batches every 6-12 hours or so, and although certain posts may take a little while longer to get to, we believe this is the best possible system to reduce spam, reward high effort posts, and eliminate banned posts types such as:

•”Who would you cast?” posts (“Who would you cast as the DCU’s Batman?”)

• Repetitive/Spam posts (“Alan Ritchson as Aquaman”, etc)

•Satirical castings/Shitposts (“Elon Musk as Cyborg”, etc)

• Sexually suggestive posts (You know what I mean)

• Any and all posts involving generative AI

Thank you for taking the time to read this. If you have any questions, please comment them and I’ll answer to the best possible extent that I can.

-CBF20


r/Fancast • • 11h ago Bravo

Modern Adaptations My pick(s) for the next Bond girl

Thumbnail
gallery
131 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 12h ago

Non-DC/Marvel Comic Characters Haley Bennett as Bond girl

Thumbnail
gallery
128 Upvotes

I rarely see her mentioned for the role. She's 38, so a perfect age for Robert Pattinson who is 40. If they want a more mature dynamic with actual romantic interest, having a slightly older Bond girl would mean he's interested in a more long term thing.


r/Fancast • • 2h ago

Other Casting Ideas 2000s/2010s Jude Law is my favorite Alternate James Bond fancast. He would have been perfect.

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 18h ago Heartwarming

Non-DC/Marvel Comic Characters You are all wrong, the next Bond girl should be..

Post image
173 Upvotes

Naomi Scott has the looks, depth and skills to pull it off. Actually she'd also make an amazing villain.


r/Fancast • • 2h ago

Other Casting Ideas Saoirse Ronan as Moneypenny to Pattinson’sBond

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 41m ago

Reboot/Remake Y'all are wrong Melissa Barrera should be the new Bond Girl

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 1h ago

Non-DC/Marvel Comic Characters Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (2000)

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

What if Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (2010) was made 10 years earlier?

Distributed by Universal Pictures (www.universalstudios.com)

Director and Writer: James Gunn

Producers: Ben Stiller and Spike Jonze

Music Composer: John Powell

Cast:

Tobey Maguire as Scott Pilgrim/Nega Scott

Neve Campbell as Ramona Flowers

Seth Green as Wallace Wells

Anne Hathaway as Stacey Pilgrim

Rachel McAdams as Envy Adams

Natasha Lyonne as Kim Pine: Natasha Lyonne

Rashida Jones Julie Powers

Justin Long as Neil "Young Neil" Nordegraf

Matthew Lillard as Stephen Stills

Nicole Bilderback as Knives Chau: Nicole Bilderback

The Exes:

Kal Penn as Matthew Patel

Joe Manganiello as Lucas Lee

Tom Welling as Todd Ingram

Clea DuVall as Roxy Richter

Johnny Yong Bosch as Ken & Kyle Katayanagi (Dual-Role)

Adrien Brody as Gideon Graves

Special Appearances by Tony Goldwyn and Esai Morales as The Vegan Police


r/Fancast • • 11h ago

Other Casting Ideas Natalie Alyn Lind, Bond Girl

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

With all the talk of who should be the next Bond girl, why not Natalie Alyn Lind?


r/Fancast • • 12h ago

DC / DCU George Miller's Wonder Woman

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Using only actors who have previously collaborated with the director

Charlee Fraser as Wonder Woman

Charlize Theron as Hippolyta

Josh Helman as Trevor

Tom Hardy as Ares

Tilda Swinton as Dra Poison

Alyla Browne as Wonder Girl

Riley Keough as Giganta

Nicole Kidman as Verônica Cale


r/Fancast • • 21h ago

DC / DCU Fancasting Batman Actors as Robins (for fun)

Thumbnail
gallery
111 Upvotes

Christian Bale as Dick Grayson

Ben Affleck as Jason Todd

Robert Pattinson as Tim Drake

And Michael Keaton as Damian Wayne lol

Obviously this is just for fun.

Young Christian Bale does have the perfect Nightwing hair tho...


r/Fancast • • 16h ago

Other Casting Ideas Bond villain Matthew Rhys. What do you think?

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 10h ago

Marvel / MCU Michael Johnston as Peter Parker/Spider-Man and Ella Purnell as Mary Jane Watson

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Both same age too, which is a plus, what do we think? I think I’ve cooked here


r/Fancast • • 2h ago

DC / DCU My Fancast for Bruce Wayne aka Batman from Smallville in 2001 if he appeared in it instead of Batman being restricted to appear in Smallville

Post image
2 Upvotes

Jason David Frank as Batman aka Bruce Wayne


r/Fancast • • 21h ago

DC / DCU Guy Gardner played by John Cena

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

This is just a random idea that went through my head, and I thought, "Huh, I think he'd be pretty cool". With his performance as Peacemaker, I can kinda see him play as Guy.

This is in no way me wanting to see the roles recast or rebooted or anything, just a thought I wanna share


r/Fancast • • 12h ago

History/Politics Michael Shannon as John C. Calhoun

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 22h ago

Old Idea New Cast I think Elizabeth Olsen is an underrated choice to play the next Bond girl

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 19h ago

Video Games GTA 6 Live Action fancast

Post image
36 Upvotes

Oliver Jackson-Cohen and Sasha Calle as Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos


r/Fancast • • 52m ago

Other Casting Ideas My Scary Movie 6 (2024) fan castings.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Anna Faris/Cindy Campbell spoos Evelyn Abbott from A Quiet Place, Sari from Cocaine Bear & Captain Marvel from the Marvels.

Regina Hall/Brenda Meeks spoofs Tethered Red from US, Georgina from Get Out & Monica Rambeau from the Marvels.

Marlon Wayans/Shorty Meeks spoofs Logan King from Get Out.

Shawn Wayans/Ray Wilkins spoofs Tethered Abraham from US, Walter from Get Out & Daveed from Cocaine Bear.

Kevin Hart/CJ lz spoofs Chris Washington from Get Out.

Anthony Anderson/Mahalik Phifer spoofs Rod Williams from Get Out.

Simon Rex/George Logan spoofs Lee Abbott from A Quiet Place, Georgie Denbrough from IT & Captain America from the Avengers.

Charlie Sheen/Tom Logan spoofs Bruce Banner and the Hulk from the Avengers.

Craig Bierko/Tom Ryan spoofs Ethan Hunt from Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning Part One, Pete "Maverick" Mitchell from Top Gun/Top Gun Maverick & Iron Man from the Avengers.

Alison Brie spoofs Rose Armitage from Get Out and Gemma from M3GAN.

J.K. Simmons spoofs Dean Armitage from Get Out.

Nancy Travis spoofs Missy Armitage from Get Out.

Evan Peters spoofs Jeremy Armitage from Get Out and Jeffrey Dahmer.

Dustin Ingram spoofs Pennywise the Dancing Clown from IT.

Geraldine Viswanathan spoofs Ms. Marvel from the Marvels.

Roxanne McKee spoofs Alanna Mitsopolis from Mission Impossible Dead Reckoning Part One.

Rob Riggle spoofs Beau "Cyclone" Simpson from Top Gun Maverick.

Kathryn Hahn spoofs Valak/Demon Nun from the Nun.


r/Fancast • • 57m ago

Old Concept New Year Recasting The Brutalist as a 2004 film, with Daniel Day-Lewis as László Tóth

1 Upvotes

László Tóth always felt like a Daniel Day-Lewis role that arrived 20 years too late: an obsessive Hungarian architect, a Holocaust survivor trying to rebuild himself in postwar America, torn between genius, pride and self-destruction. So here's how I'd cast it if it had been made in 2004, with Martin Scorsese directing it instead of The Aviator, two years after Gangs of New York.

LÁSZLÓ TÓTH: Daniel Day-Lewis

He was 47, at his physical peak, and fresh off Bill the Butcher. You just know he'd have learned Hungarian, spent months on construction sites and refused to break character for the entire shoot.

ERZSÉBET TÓTH: Cate Blanchett

Erzsébet needs to be sharp, proud and physically fragile all at once, and intellectually she's the only person in the film who can stand up to László. Blanchett had the precision for the accent and the aristocratic rigidity, and she'd have been extraordinary in the late scenes with Van Buren.

Alternate: Juliette Binoche

HARRISON LEE VAN BUREN: Ed Harris

The patron has to be charming enough that you understand why László trusts him, and frightening enough that you dread every scene they share. Harris in 2004 had exactly that mix of American authority and barely hidden menace.

Alternate: Tom Wilkinson

HARRY LEE VAN BUREN: Peter Sarsgaard

The spoiled, venomous heir. Nobody did smug cruelty better in the mid-2000s.

Alternate: Jake Gyllenhaal

ZSÓFIA: Evan Rachel Wood

She was 17, fresh off Thirteen, and could carry a largely silent role on presence alone.

Alternate: Emmy Rossum

ATTILA: Mathieu Amalric

The cousin who takes László in and then turns on him. A small part, but Amalric (same year as Kings and Queen) would make him feel like a whole life lived offscreen.

Alternate: Daniel Auteuil

GORDON: Isaach de Bankolé

He plays Gordon in the real film too, and at 47 in 2004 he'd be the right age alongside DDL.

Alternate: Jeffrey Wright

MAGGIE VAN BUREN: Rachel McAdams

The Notebook and Mean Girls year. She'd bring warmth to a family that badly needs some.

Alternate: Sienna Miller

Which of these would you change? And who's your pick for Erzsébet, since she's the hardest role to cast?


r/Fancast • • 5h ago

Old Concept New Year Inception (2010): Through the Decades

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Dom Cobb

  • 2010 Original: Leonardo DiCaprio
  • 2000: Brad Pitt
  • 1990: Alec Baldwin
  • 1980: Harrison Ford
  • 1970: Robert Redford
  • 2020: Ryan Gosling

Saito

  • 2010 Original: Ken Watanabe
  • 2000: Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa
  • 1990: Sonny Chiba
  • 1980: Tatsuya Nakadai
  • 1970: Toshiro Mifune
  • 2020: Tadanobu Asano

Arthur

  • 2010 Original: Joseph Gordon-Levitt
  • 2000: Matt Damon
  • 1990: Cary Elwes
  • 1980: Kurt Russell
  • 1970: Al Pacino
  • 2020: Nicholas Hoult

Mal

  • 2010 Original: Marion Cotillard
  • 2000: Sophie Marceau
  • 1990: Isabelle Adjani
  • 1980: Charlotte Rampling
  • 1970: Sophia Loren
  • 2020: Léa Seydoux

Ariadne

  • 2010 Original: Elliot Page
  • 2000: Natalie Portman
  • 1990: Jennifer Connelly
  • 1980: Jamie Lee Curtis
  • 1970: Sally Field
  • 2020: Anya Taylor-Joy

Eames

  • 2010 Original: Tom Hardy
  • 2000: Jason Statham
  • 1990: Gary Oldman
  • 1980: Timothy Dalton
  • 1970: Michael Caine
  • 2020: Robert Pattinson

Robert Fischer

  • 2010 Original: Cillian Murphy
  • 2000: Robert Downey Jr.
  • 1990: Hugh Grant
  • 1980: Michael Douglas
  • 1970: Warren Beatty
  • 2020: Alden Ehrenreich

r/Fancast • • 2h ago

Polls Which this four actress can be the next bond girl alongside with Robert Pattinson James bond

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/Fancast • • 2h ago

Other Casting Ideas My top choices for next Bond girls

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes