r/fantanoforever • • Oct 22 '26

Subreddit Rules Rule 2 Reminder

98 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Polite reminder that rule 2 exists, which is to specify the album/artist name when making a post if either is not on the album and/or photo. This has been a problem that has been popping up more than we would like, as of late. Even if the album or artist is well known, please do not assume that everyone will know who they are/what the album is. Having the name helps the discussion by allowing people who dont know these artists or albums to find them easily so they can start listening to them.

Thank you.


r/fantanoforever • • Sep 23 '26

Subreddit Rules Rule Updates and State of the Subreddit

79 Upvotes

Hi all!

Over the past couple of years, the content on this subreddit has changed - often to the detriment to the quality of the forum. Over the past couple of days, the mod group have discussed freshening up our guidance on a range of topics, to respond to these changes. In effort to improve the subreddit, we have updated our rules on politics, drama, AI, and low effort posting.

Fundamentally, this is a music subreddit about a music reviewer. We want to maintain the best parts of discussion we see on this forum, and try and reduce the worst parts. The intention of the updated guidance is to do exactly that. To be precise - we want to reduce the amount of Fauxmoi discussion posts here. There are other subreddits for that discussion.

There have also been some changes to the types of posts that are allowed - requirements around body text as well as post flairs have been turned on, as well as the introduction of bot bouncer to reduce bots on the subreddit.

If anyone has any further suggestions for improving this community please reach out!


r/fantanoforever • • 1h ago

JOKE Colleen Ballinger's "hi." hit roughly 8 million views in one week. If it had been released on streaming services at the time, it would have charted on the Billboard Hot 100.

Post image
114 Upvotes

In 2023, the lowest-charting songs on the Billboard Hot 100 averaged roughly 1 million streams. If Toxic Gossip Train had been released on streaming services from the start and thus was tracked by Nielsen, it would likely have hit the Top 40. Incidentally, it would have also briefly been the longest song to ever chart, until Andre 3000 beat it a few months later.


r/fantanoforever • • 6h ago

Discussion who are some artists whose sound completely changed overtime, yet you still manage to like most of what they’ve put out?

Thumbnail
gallery
148 Upvotes

I think the two big examples for me are Modest Mouse and Cage The Elephant

I do find myself going back more to older Modest Mouse (Long Drive/Crowded West/Moon + Antarctica) but I do find their poppier sound to still be pleasant

Cage admittedly did start to sound kind of generic once they started going in the opposite direction of their crazy sound they established with their first two albums but I still like all of them (outside of Neon Pill, that one did nothing for me)


r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Discussion thoughts on Doja Cats legacy ??

Post image
152 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Discussion Spoon doesn’t get nearly enough love these days.

Post image
66 Upvotes

30 years in. Multiple 00s indie rock CLASSICS. Never dropped a bad album—distinct eras. Britt Danirls is a strong songwriter, and Jim Eno is one of the best Indie drummers of all time. Somehow slept on by a lot of folks. Their discography's consistency and peaks make them a strong contender for the greatest 21st-century indie rock bands. They were the highest-rated act of the ‘00s on Metacritic. And they had legit indie hits


r/fantanoforever • • 5h ago

Discussion Thoughts on Billy Talent?

Post image
42 Upvotes

I threw this album on earlier this week and it took me back. I remember when this band was everywhere in Canada and I saw them live a bunch of times.

Curious for others’ thoughts and experiences.


r/fantanoforever • • 1h ago

Discussion I fucking hate people who shout “song requests” at concerts

17 Upvotes

I saw Neurosis and this chode kept shouting “LOCUST STAR!” Dude, they have a playlist, they’ll play it or not. They’re also spending 1-3 minutes between songs fucking around with their equipment to get the sound they need so it’s not like they can just burst into Locust Star, which they haven’t played in ~10 years. The guy also looked like a Redditor and had his camera out for the majority of the concert, I hope he puts the videos up so I can call him out. He was with a girl who was too young to be his girlfriend but too old to be his daughter. Eventually an older guy looked at him with a look of disgust and he stopped shouting.

The same thing happened when I saw PJ Harvey, she was playing her recent album in its entirety but the same four people kept shouting songs from her back catalogue. These songs are pretty intricate and have specific arrangements that the bands cant just pull out of their ass, do these people shouting requests not realize this or do they just want attention? FWIW I think that heckling or shouting “you suck” is less disrespectful than trying to be the center of attention because at least you’re being honest about how you feel.


r/fantanoforever • • 11h ago

Discussion Bands/artists who released 2 (or more!) classic albums in the same year?

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Worst Thing You Can Say: Day 36

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 1h ago

Discussion Vitalogy (1994) Hits 32 This Year. What Are Your Thoughts On It?

Post image
13 Upvotes

Probably their 4th or 5th best record imo, right after Ten, Dark Matter, Vs. and maybe Yield.

What do you guys think about this one?


r/fantanoforever • • 55m ago

JOKE Fergie announces 3rd studio album 'Triple Dutchess' coming 2027 on an undisclosed date.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Discussion Days appreciation post

Post image
38 Upvotes

As we journey back to our suburban childhood homes for Thanksgiving this week I just wanted to pay homage to the ultimate suburban hipster indie record, Real Estate's 'Days.' This thing is magnificent. Nothing captures the nostalgia of returning to where you grew up more than this record. Real Estate caught lightning in a bottle with this one and locked in harder than at any point in their career. If you haven't heard it before give it a spin as you drive in or take the train (more hipster) to your childhood neighborhood and see what I mean. And after a nice Thanksgiving meal take a cruise on your bike with a good pair of headphones and possibly experience these beautiful lyrics in real life:

"I rode right pass the train tracks on
Ancient as the stone
Blacked out on a bicycle
I made my way back home"

Happy Thanksgiving, hipsters :)


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Who do you think is the best drummer of the 2000s indie/garage rock scene? And why?

Post image
26 Upvotes

For me, the best is Ronnie Vannucci Jr. from The Killers, maybe they aren't the greatest band ever, but their drummer is monstrous.


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Discussion Ray Manzarek with hair?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Greetings, people, does anyone have pictures of Ray Manzarek, with a beard or mustache? I can't find anything on social networks.


r/fantanoforever • • 22h ago

Discussion Proud of y’all

Post image
272 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 10h ago

Discussion Album closers that have a change in tone from the rest of the album?

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

I was listening to Odessey and Oracle yesterday (what a masterpiece) and I was struck by Time of the Season at the end and how an album that was primarily made up of melodic, ethereal, baroque tracks was closed with a song of such psychedelic, almost modish swagger. It then made me think of Tomorrow Never Knows from Revolver, which of course is a psychedelic, experimental album but that song is a different level of sonic experimentation and quite a statement to close an album. Are there any others you can think of? I suppose A Day In The Life is similar, just a real artistic statement that fits perfectly with the album but is also completely different from the tone (both musically and lyrically) that came before. Any other examples of this?


r/fantanoforever • • 5h ago

Discussion Songs where the Artist went "Theatre Kid mode"

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Weezer - Greatest Man that ever lived

Red hot chili peppers - Even You Brutus?


r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Recommendations How to discover more music?

8 Upvotes

I always see many people here posting their favourite albums and recommendations that have a lot of genre variety and/or less known album and musicians, and when I do mine, it ends up being 2 or 3 albums of the same band (which in turn ends up being 3 or 4 bands in total). That made me realize I end up being too "stuck" at one artist and not properly exploring different genres and musicians. I barely listen to some genres (except for one song here and there) because of not even knowing where to start. I understand that this comes from my particular habit of "hyperfocusing" on specific bands and listen to all of their discography, overlistening even their less known songs. For example, my most listened-to bands in 1st and 2nd place have 8,000 and 4,000 individual songs listened to, respectively, while the 3rd has only 600, and from 4th onwards, up to around 15th, they have about 300-500 songs.

That said, I'd like to know how to listen to a great variety of musicians, albums and genres like most people here. I usually used Spotify and notice that its algorithm (at least for me) isn't very efficient in recommending stuff, since I discovered my favorite albums/songs on my own. In the past I used YouTube but can't anymore because of the trashy UI and ads.

I'd also like to ask what do you do while listening to entire albums? I find it particularly difficult to listen to music for an extended period while just sitting there doing nothing.

And sorry for my English, not my first language.


r/fantanoforever • • 10h ago

Discussion Which artists managed to make more than one debut album?

10 Upvotes

So there's that adage that an artist gets a lifetime to make a debut album and six months to make their follow up.

I have been thinking about artists who managed to sidestep this. Not always by taking decades between albums but by creating something that feels like a new creative statement rather than just another album.

An example that comes to mind is The Avalanches. They released Since I Left You in 2000, then took another 16 years to release Wildflower. And to my ears, Wildflower is even better. Sacrilege, I know...

What catches me about Wildflower is that it doesnt feel like they are trying to make another SILY. Yes its still sample based and dense but to me its an entirely new world.

As a bit of a stan I'm aware that they didn't spend sixteen years chipping away at a new album. They had a lot of ups and downs on the way.

It makes me wonder who else has this special ability to approach subsequent albums with the patience, focus and attention to detail as that which is usually associated with a debut.

So who else makes the cut? And no this isn't about artists that took forever to make a second album or knocked out a great second album. There's plenty of both.

Thinking of artists who managed to make multiple albums that felt like the natural culmination of an entire creative journey, not just another album.


r/fantanoforever • • 10h ago

Discussion Such an underrated song from this year

Post image
7 Upvotes

This is one of my favourite Florence Road songs already. It's a massive switch up from their usual formula, both in their sound and lyrical themes. This is my favourite thing they've put out since their debut EP last year.

The structure feels unique, but when you take a look at it, it really isn't that different from other songs, maybe I'm just crazy but it feels like that. It's not repetitive at all, I could eat listen to this on loop for ages. For a cliche love song, the lyrics (at least to me) don't feel *overly* cheesy. I don't know what I prefer, the drums or the bassline. Neither are that technical, but work together with the rest of the song.

This band have amazing chemistry together, and it could just be me, but I feel like they have such a unique new sound, which is very refreshing to hear in an era for indie where every band is trying to be eachother.

I'll be seeing them next year in L*verpool, and this is the one I'm excited to hear the most.


r/fantanoforever • • 9h ago

Discussion An interview with Emma Ruth Rundle

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I interviewed Emma a couple of weeks ago. We talked about her latest album, These Killing Times, but quickly moved on to other topics, like fear of climate catastrophe, violence, religion, responsibility for others, and why it's so hard to believe the future might still hold something good.

I think it's one of my best interviews so far, and I'd love to hear what you think about it! Hope you enjoy the read!

https://undrtn.pl/2026/11/whats-worth-saving-an-interview-with-emma-ruth-rundle/


r/fantanoforever • • 1d ago

Discussion Albums you think should get a Shaggs' "Philosophy of the World" style reappraisal?

Post image
150 Upvotes

A.k.a the albums that are so astonishingly bad that they sort of wrap around to being avant-garde in their own right and therefore becoming unironically good or most commonly absolutely hilarious?

17 by The Island Boys is an album I think exemplifies this archetype. If you haven't heard the experimental-psychedelic-progressive-free-rap crown jewel that is [Head](https://youtu.be/50gldPTaxGs) then 1. I give condolences and 2. An urge to immediately listen to it in full.


r/fantanoforever • • 4h ago

Discussion What do you guys think of The Guilt Trip by Kramer?

Post image
2 Upvotes

"The work shows that Kramer was not merely a shrewd entrepreneur exploiting the talents of his partners; rather, the thirty-six songs (many instrumental) serve as his definitive testament to how one can mediate between avant-garde and pop (or vice versa), how psychedelic rock laid the groundwork for such an operation, and how a restless psyche can manifest itself without resorting to confessional music, transforming it into neutral sounds. Like Jackson Pollock’s murals, the album aims to convey everything through abstraction.
The Ouverture condenses the musical synthesis and tragicomic mood of nearly all of Kramer’s art: the theme might be that of a surf instrumental, yet it is weighed down, slowed, and repeated until it takes on dark and stormy tones. The same can be said of the solemn, martial crescendo of the title track, featuring pop-leaning organ, a “Ravelian” bolero snare, and a “cosmic” synth to darken everything. Kramer’s inscrutable instrumentals (and near-instrumentals) constitute an art of their own: Hello Music (one of the masterpieces), Wish I Were In Heaven, Thank You Music, The Well Hung Jury reference traditional genres but immerse them in alienating, often minimalist or even homey arrangements. The goal is, of course, to generate dreamlike effects, but the dense lexical apparatus often seems overwhelming, risking emotional collapse due to information overload.
On top of that, Kramer indulges his guitar desires in a whirl of Clapton-esque wah-wah, Hendrixian glissandos, Page-like riffs, along with demonstrative numbers: jazz-inflected flubs à la Henry Kaiser (The Murder of God), neurotic Neil Young-style distortions (I've Seen The End), acrobatic rock and roll (My Friend Daniel), Wagnerian “frippertronics” (The Maximus Poems), culminating in the dizzying, verbose solo of Ball Five, the zenith of his megalomania.
Whatever device he employs, Kramer can freely pursue the right thread in the immense tangle he has created, endlessly lose himself in a labyrinth of sounds ranging from the dark mass of The Seven Seizures to the majestic hard rock chimes of Mudd Hutt Four (a miniature compendium of references).
Vocals largely take a back seat, though hypnotic Roger-Waters-like chant in Welcome Home, languid nostalgic melody in Stupid Summer, and Wyatt-inspired agonized, dreamlike register in Not Guilty reveal some truths behind this partisan self-parody.
Formally, all tracks are essentially novelties: from the rhythmic nursery rhyme of Wisdom Sits to the almost Western fatalistic grandeur of Won’t Get Far Without Me, from the 78-rpm-style demented chorus of I’m Your Fan to the power-pop of Next Time Try Compassion.
The stylistic palette is vast. Always skillfully orchestrated (baroque organ, romantic sonata, African tribalism…), the songs are the result of careful editing, often evoking Half Japanese and Residents crossed with Jonathan Richman.
Monumental and “larger than life,” despite its twists and discontinuities, The Guilt Trip remains a unified project, whose guiding principle could be self-indulgence, chosen as an allegory of the human condition.
Taken together, the episodes of this crucible form a broad social fresco, so that the album functions as a sort of Tommy for Generation X, in which there is no story to tell, only an existence to capture. There are no new stories to tell—they’ve all been told—nor new lives to live—they’ve all been lived. Kramer describes himself almost reluctantly, almost desperately seeking something else to do. He describes himself because he finds nothing better to do or say. Introspection is no longer the height of communication; it is its minimum. It is the most impersonal way to make personal art. In this sense, the album title is ironic: if there is one thing that can no longer exist, it is guilt."