r/fermentation • • 6h ago

Weekly "Is this safe" Megathread

2 Upvotes

Welcome to this week’s dedicated space for all your questions and concerns regarding questionable ferments.

Fermentation can sometimes look a little strange, and it is not always easy to tell what is safe, and what needs to be tossed and started over. To help keep the subreddit clean and avoid repeat posts, please use this thread for:

  • Sharing photos of surface growth you’re unsure about.
  • Asking if your ferment has gone wrong.
  • Getting second opinions from experienced fermenters regarding questionable ferments.

‼️Tips Before Posting‼️:

  • Mention what you’re fermenting (e.g., kraut, kimchi, kombucha, pickles, etc.).
  • Note how long it has been fermenting, and at what temperature.
  • Describe any smells, textures, or off flavors.

Remember that community members can offer advice, but ultimately you are responsible for deciding if your ferment is safe to eat or discard. When in doubt, trust your senses.

Happy fermenting!


r/fermentation • • 6h ago

Weekly Commercial Resources and Events MEGATHREAD

1 Upvotes

Because we get a lot of individual requests for posts that may violate rule 6 about limited self promotion, we have decided that we will have a weekly MEGATHREAD for people who want to post events, (virtual and in person), products and apps related to fermentation. The general rules about using this channel for self promotion still apply and the thread will be moderated.

Thread specific rules:

  1. NO SPAM still applies. Don't be posting your event multiple times and every single week.
  2. If you have produced a fermentation specific software or app and are looking for beta testers or the app is free, this is generally ok. Posts that for monetary gain (ie trying simply gain customers but not really contributing the sub) will be removed.
  3. You must fully describe what your post is about and should disclose what you have to gain from it. If you are hosting a regional fermentation conference and a inviting folks to register, for instance, make sure that it's clear what the costs, etc will be.

Finally - this idea is a TEST. If it is a total catastrophe, we will go back to a simple case by case system.


r/fermentation • • 1h ago

Other Life Hack: Keep the lids for broken glass jars! They make wonderful weights!!

Post image
10 Upvotes

We all break our Saurkraut jars from time to time. Don’t throw the lids with the jars. The metal collars on Kilner etc detaches and you have yourself a glass weight!


r/fermentation • • 5h ago

Other New to fermenting, what can I ferment to get umami, without specific starters?

6 Upvotes

Sorry if this isn't the right place for this. I'm essentially trying to find/make my perfect homemade noodle recipe, as a vegan, and I love umami but find it shallow if it's from soy sauce. I came across a fermentation recipe where you blend chilli and ginger and add some salt and let it sit in a jar for a week, burping as needed, which could potentially be added to the broth/noodles for depth. Because of where I live, specific mushrooms and fermentation starters are not easily available, so google search wasn't very helpful, I can't make most of the things I come across. Is there anything that I could ferment with just home ingredients, to get something umami?

Update: I looked up a tutorial and have got some tomatoes fermenting. Thanks for the responses!


r/fermentation • • 17h ago

Other Re-using fermented beancurd claypot?

Thumbnail
gallery
33 Upvotes

Yesterday I bought some fermented red beancurd at the Asian supermarket. It came in a lovely claypot. The beancurd itself was wrapped in a plastic bag inside the pot.

I'd love to re-use this pot, ideally for fermenting stuff. The inside of the jar is glazed, but I've read that glaze isn't always food safe. Apparently you can test it by leaving something acidic (vinegar or lemon juice) inside it for a while and see if it changes visually, but I'm not sure how accurate that is.

Has anyone ever had a jar like this? What did you end up using it for? The seal is not airtight. I was thinking it could work for something like miso, doubanjiang, douchi, chilipaste, or just plain old kimchi.


r/fermentation • • 3h ago

Meat/Fish/Garum Can you make an egg white garum, without using Koji?

2 Upvotes

I know you can make an egg white garum with Koji, water, and salt. I’ve recently started a new job, and they allowing me to have a lot more creative freedom than I’m used to. And I’m just a line cook so it’s not like I’m putting dishes on the menu or anything, but I’m trying to solidify myself a spot as like head of fermentation/ preservation or whatever. Any help, or experience you guys have to share will be appreciated.


r/fermentation • • 6h ago

Has anyone tried fermented papaya?

Thumbnail
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
2 Upvotes

I hadn’t heard of it, but randomly came this study which really glows it up. I’d be interested in hearing this community’s thoughts! Is this a common food in specific countries?


r/fermentation • • 13h ago

Cloudy, dark brine?

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’ve had these cucumbers in a 4% salt brine for 3 days now. Added peppercorns, mustard seed, dill, celery leaves and bay leaves. Is the color/cloudiness normal? It’s my first time fermenting cucumbers and don’t want to screw it up or make my gf sick lol


r/fermentation • • 11h ago

Legumes Mushy pickle

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I tried making pickles recently, and followed Sandor Katz's art of fermentation guidelines, using 4 spoons of salt per liter I think, dill, garlic, peppercorns and mustard seeds, I also gave the cucumber an ice bath and cut the top off. It smelled really good after a few days but one week after it had a very very subtle unpleasant smell and I saw that one of them had decided to disintegrate, I tasted one of the good ones and it was alright but I was expecting more flavor besides just being sour, and even though I didn't add any sugar I missed that sweetness that I associate with pickles, in the end I decided to bin everything because that one mushy pickle ruined the smell of the batch for me. I was wondering what could be the reason for that mushiness, I know that people recommend tannins like grape leaves but the dill was hard enough to find so I went without that, I also read something about picking smaller cucumbers because they have less water content, I don't think I picked the ideal variety for pickling but I tried to get the ones that seemed more firm. I am left a bit dumbfounded because I've made kimchi, sauerkraut, garlic, keffir etc. and it wasn't my first time fermenting so I thought pickles would be easier than this lol, I appreciate any tips you have!


r/fermentation • • 8h ago

Is making water kefir pretty easy? Does anyone wanna sell me grains?

0 Upvotes

Im in the US. I can’t buy any locally, someone’s giving them away but it’s like an hour away, and online sources seem kinda sketchy and overpriced. I don’t love milk kefir only bc of the dairy causing issues for me so i’m hoping this will be better. I do like the taste of the ones i’ve tried at trader joe’s but idk if homemade will taste like that.


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Beer/Wine/Mead/Cider/Tepache/Kombucha Homemade Beetroot kanji .

Post image
29 Upvotes

My first batch of beetroot kanji for winter. Who all make this at home?.. sharing standard recipe for reference .

Beetroot Kanji is a traditional North Indian, probiotic-rich fermented drink known for its deep ruby-red color, tangy flavor, and digestive benefits.

Ingredients

• 2 medium-sized Beetroot (peeled and cut into batons or slices)

• 1 medium Carrot (peeled and cut into batons)

• 2 liters of filtered or boiled and cooled water

• 2 tablespoons yellow or black mustard seeds (rai), coarsely or finely ground

• 1 teaspoon black salt (kala namak)

• 1/2 to 1 teaspoon regular or pink salt

• 1 teaspoon red chili powder

• 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon asafoetida (heeng)

How to Make It

  1. Combine the ingredients: Place the cut beetroot and carrot batons into a clean glass or ceramic jar. Add the ground mustard powder, black salt, regular salt, red chili powder, and heeng.
  2. Add water: Pour in the 2 liters of water and stir everything well using a clean wooden or steel spoon.
  3. Ferment: Cover the jar with a muslin cloth or a loose lid. Keep it in a warm, sunny spot for 2 to 4 days to ferment.
  4. Stir and check: Open and stir the mixture with a clean spoon once a day.
  5. Serve and store: Once the liquid turns tangy, sour, and deeply colored, strain it into clean bottles and refrigerate. It stays fresh in the fridge for up to a week.

r/fermentation • • 13h ago

Dairy Hibiscus + Oat milk

1 Upvotes

I get that this sounds off and it likely is, but I was experimenting with hibiscus in high concentrations in just plain water and decided I wanted to try and experiment. Problem is I wasn't thinking about the oat milk.

It smells awesome, well just like floral hibiscus. It seems like it's not as thick but the oat milk makes me concerned. Just thinking about that shelf life even though it's oats and sugar and water.

I wasn't sure how to tag plant milk


r/fermentation • • 13h ago

Is it normal for pickled cucumbers to hiss on their own after taking one out of the jar)?

1 Upvotes

r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Pickles/Vegetables in brine A Treat For My Treats

Post image
35 Upvotes

I wanted to get a nice vodka for my pao cai since we're approaching the 6 month mark. It's funny because I don't drink alcohol, so this is the only way I get to look around the liquor store 😆 I wanted to get a baijiu but there was only one brand of that, so I just decided to stick with vodka.

What are some treats you like to get for your pickles?


r/fermentation • • 18h ago

Vacuum fermentaion in bucket?

1 Upvotes

Looking for ideas for adding a vacuum valve or some other way ot hold slight vacuum on 5 gal plastic bucket lid for fermenting.I use standard air lock first week and want to apply vacuum after most of off gasing. using existing 1/2" hole with gromet and 1/4" vynil tubing with water line check valves? I know plastic can not withstand much force. #vacuum


r/fermentation • • 21h ago

Ginger Bug/Soda Killed my ginger bug?

0 Upvotes

I started my ginger bug using organic ginger and cane sugar and boiled then cooled water. After a few days it started bubbling. To stay on top of things I taste it using a new clean spoon.

Yesterday I made the mistake of liking the taste and putting the spoon back for a second time. I know I know... dumb. Mistake.

Today it stopped bubbling altogether and didn't start back up after feeding it.

Did I kill it?


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Hot Sauce Is this what I suspect it may be?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

This is my third time fermenting peppers and what not. So far I’ve had no issues and everything has turned out great. I’m about to process this ferment and I noticed something that looks alarming.
Any thoughts from any of you more experienced fermenters?


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Kvass is looking fizzy. Day 1 of fermentation.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Beer/Wine/Mead/Cider/Tepache/Kombucha Wild-yeast mead, 12 days later

Post image
13 Upvotes

You may have seen my original post showing the bucket with the honey-water mixture, which sparked quite a bit of skepticism about whether a batch of mead could actually be made successfully without adding commercial yeast.

This is what it looks like on day 12, after encouraging the naturally occurring wild yeast through daily stirring, 2 or 3 times a day.

The Brix reading has only just started to drop, since most alcohol production takes place during the anaerobic phase. However, when working with wild yeast, this initial aerobic phase is essential to allow the yeast population responsible for fermenting our honey wine to develop.


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Fermenting since June 2026, 3% brine

Post image
23 Upvotes

Habaneros, peaches, and garlic. That’s a yeast layer on top, thoughts on if it is good to go? I haven’t opened it yet to test the pH with my Apera yet. Not asking if mold, it isn’t.


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Question about Kvass?

3 Upvotes

I'm currently trying my hand at making traditional kvass. What I've done so far:

  1. Baked 4 slices of cubed pumpernickel bread until dehydrated and crispy.
  2. Applied about 65oz of just boiled distilled hot water.
  3. Covered jar with paper towel held in place with plastic band. Left covered all night.
  4. Strained the bread water in to another container. I used cheesecloth. I don't think I squeezed the bread enough, and I wasn't using a funnel so I fumbled a bit. Ended up with about 45oz of water.
  5. Stirred in 1/4 cup of sugar.
  6. Added handful of raisins
  7. Added about a quarter teaspoon of baker's yeast.
  8. Covered jar with paper towel held in place with plastic band.

Questions:

- What can I expect the alcohol content to be on Sunday afternoon / evening? I want to be able to introduce this to my kids on Monday after I bottle and chill the kvass. But not if the alcohol content is about 1.5% - 2.0%.

- Does everything about the process I laid out seem right? Did anything seem off? By all means I'd love some feedback and tips/tricks.


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

What salt percent is your go to?

25 Upvotes

I’ve done a LOT of lactofermentation recently; Pao Cai (sichuan pickle jar that is currently 61 days old!), sauerkraut (brewing right now), kimchi, and lactofermented garlic at a 3% weight in salt (of brine and veggie) and have found much luck in that! What about you guys? Experiences with 2%? How about at like 5%? Are there salt percents you’ve tried and would NOT try again?

Idk, just curious. Newcomers might be, too. Happy fermenting!


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Uaing viniger

0 Upvotes

When using a lot of viniger does it ferment or not?


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Beer/Wine/Mead/Cider/Tepache/Kombucha I want to make a fermentation using mango and I need some guidance

2 Upvotes

I was thinking about the possibility of mixing two and a half mangos, 100 ml of ginger bug and maybe 200 g of unrefined sugar (panela) with water until I get 2 liters.

could there be any problem using mango for this fermentation?

If you have any tips for this experiment, it would be great.

Thank you all!