r/financialmodelling • • 4h ago

Does anyone else feel like their model is just a clean way to deliver bad news?

2 Upvotes

i built the model that killed our acquisition of a small competitor. The numbers said synergies turned negative by year three, and the partners actually listened. Now the founder is badmouthing us to clients and i feel weirdly guilty for just doing my job. My manager says it was the right call, but i keep thinking about the 40 people there. i even caught myself scrolling Recruiterbase for lateral roles last night, like i want to run away from the model. Do you ever feel like a model is just a clean way to deliver bad news?


r/financialmodelling • • 51m ago

Are spreadsheets still doing most of the heavy lifting in financial planning?

1 Upvotes

First, credit to the finance professionals who build and maintain these models. It's not easy work.

But I've been thinking about how interconnected financial variables are.

Change pricing, and it could affect revenue, churn and customer acquisition. Increase hiring, and payroll, burn and runway change too.

How well do current financial models capture these relationships?

I've been exploring how software could make this modelling more connected and less dependent on manually updating multiple assumptions.

Would love to hear how experienced finance teams handle this.


r/financialmodelling • • 2d ago

Institutions don't model like CFI

47 Upvotes

My investment analyst job doesn't involve 3-statement modeling (our holdings are ultra-short so I can generally just take management forecasts and adjust when I need to to forecast credit metrics). I am trying to re-learn though because I want to switch jobs and believe this is gonna be a deal breaker for a lot of places.

I'm in the process of earning the FMVA certification, about halfway through. Their models are very simple, and their guidance is keep models as simple as possible.

However, I can download DCF models from institutional research providers at my company and they are waaaaayyyy more complicated than FMVA examples. And I'm sure FMVA models are overly simple for learning purposes, but I'd expect real-world models to make be twice as complex, not 10x. There's no way you can make 50 different assumptions accurately, I don't see the point.

Why are institutional DCFs so complex when it seems the simpler approach would be more efficient?


r/financialmodelling • • 3d ago

QUESTION: forecast AUM/AUA growth when company disclosures are limited?

4 Upvotes

How do experienced equity research analysts forecast AUM/AUA growth when company disclosures are limited?

I’m an independent equity researcher currently building a financial model on SEI Investments (SEIC), specifically its Investment Managers segment.
I’ve built out the historical financials and am now trying to forecast assets under administration (AUA) through 2031, which is a major driver of the segment’s revenue.
My difficulty is determining how much future AUA growth should come from:
Market appreciation
New client mandates
Expansion of existing client relationships
Broader growth in the fund administration industry

SEI reports historical AUA and net recurring sales events, but the latter are expressed in estimated annualized revenue rather than incremental administered assets. There’s also limited disclosure on the underlying investment strategy mix, making it difficult to estimate market-driven growth independently.

I’ve experimented with statistical forecasting methods and industry growth projections, but I keep running into the same problem: eventually I’m making assumptions that feel somewhat arbitrary.
I’ve also started running valuation sensitivities to determine whether the uncertainty is even material enough to justify additional research.
My question for people with professional equity research or financial modeling experience:
How would you approach this?

Would you try to obtain more granular industry data, contact investor relations, speak with industry participants, or simply develop reasonable assumptions based on historical performance and run sensitivities?
More broadly, how do you decide when you’ve done enough research on a particular forecast driver and it’s time to move forward?
I’m trying to develop the research process and judgment of a professional analyst, so I’d really appreciate hearing how people working in the industry handle situations like this.


r/financialmodelling • • 5d ago

Bond Valuation Question: Should I Use Historical and Current Interest Rates Separately?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/financialmodelling • • 6d ago

My first dashboard - reviews

Post image
82 Upvotes

Took a little from this, a little from that and ended up here. My first dashboard.


r/financialmodelling • • 7d ago

Where do I learn practical skills?

8 Upvotes

Hey guys I am a second year college student and I want to build a career in equity research, I am having trouble figuring out where do I learn practical skills from such as financial statement analysis and financial modelling to get started. It would of great help I you guys could suggest relevant videos/playlists or channels.


r/financialmodelling • • 8d ago

WACC: Target capital structure with (growing) capitalised operating leases

29 Upvotes

Hi all, I have a peculiar situation I do not know how to address. For context, I am doing a university level valuation project.

The company:

  • has no debt
  • the only form of debt is operating leases which are treated as debt equivalent
  • The only driver of operating leases are stores (lululemon), which the company has steadily been expanding
  • The share price has dropped significantly over the period.
  • Has no target capital structure, since operating leases are treated as operating leases

How to do a proper target capital structure when:

  1. The store count is growing
  2. Share price is unstable

It makes little sense to me use the current D/E ratio, when the absolute D keeps going up and E % keeps going down as a consequence of price movements.


r/financialmodelling • • 11d ago

Debt schedule

Post image
49 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I was working on a debt schedule for one of the case studies I'm preparing which is about a 6 table cafe restaurant. This schedule takes Principal debt , ROI, tenure as the input and provides closing balance and interest expense as outputs. I'm yet to add a credit line into the model if needed. What are your reviews? Does this fits ur standards?


r/financialmodelling • • 12d ago

Title: Balancing CFA Level II Preparation with Maintaining Financial Modeling Skills

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone!
I’m feeling a bit confused about how to balance my CFA Level II preparation with maintaining my financial modeling skills.
For some background, I have around one year of investment banking experience, but I recently terminated my employment contract and am currently not working.
I’m dedicating around 5 hours a day, 6 days a week to CFA Level II preparation. However, I’m concerned that spending most of my time studying for the CFA might cause me to lose some of my practical financial modeling skills, especially when it comes to building cash flow forecasts, financial models, and handling technical questions in future interviews.
For those who’ve been in a similar situation:
How did you balance CFA preparation with keeping your financial modeling skills sharp?
How much time would you dedicate weekly to practical modeling alongside CFA studies?
Would you recommend working on one financial modeling project regularly or practicing smaller exercises?
I’d really appreciate advice from anyone who has gone through a similar experience, particularly investment banking professionals who prepared for CFA Level II while between jobs.
Thanks!


r/financialmodelling • • 12d ago

Starting out with Financial Modelling & DCF Valuation – Need some guidance from people in the industry

16 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I'm currently interning at a top-tier CA firm in India, in the M&A / Transaction Advisory space.

A little about my background:

  • Undergraduate student pursuing Economics.
  • Cleared CFA Level 1.
  • Have a basic understanding of Excel and financial analysis.

I've also completed a few practical financial modelling projects as part of my learning, including:

  1. Investment & Loan Decision Analysis: Worked with NPV, IRR, sensitivity analysis, loan EMIs, interest calculations and amortisation schedules.
  2. Advanced Excel Sales Analysis: Used SUMIFS, VLOOKUP, INDEX-MATCH, Goal Seek, PivotTables and data tables.
  3. Sales Performance Dashboard: Built an interactive dashboard using PivotTables, slicers and GETPIVOTDATA.

However, I understand that completing these projects and actually working on financial models in a professional environment are two very different things.

Here's my current situation.

There's an ongoing DCF valuation assignment at my firm. An article assistant is currently working on the model, and she's someone I can approach for guidance whenever I get stuck.

I'm not officially assigned any responsibilities on this project. My opportunity is essentially to study the model, understand the assumptions, follow the valuation process and help out with smaller tasks wherever possible.

For instance, she recently gave me a task (if I could manage it) involving consolidating capital spares. The existing consolidated figure had references running across numerous sheets, with formulas linking to other sheets and those sheets linking further elsewhere. Essentially, I had to make sense of this rather complicated chain of references and see if I could simplify it.

These are the kinds of small but meaningful tasks I'd love to become capable of handling independently.

I'm not expecting to master financial modelling or become an expert overnight. I just want to develop a good enough understanding of DCF valuation, Excel and financial modelling to follow the actual assignment and be useful to the person working on it.

I'd appreciate advice from people who've worked in Valuations, Investment Banking, Transaction Advisory or Equity Research.

In particular, given that I'm not officially assigned to the project, how can I contribute meaningful insights without overstepping my role?

What would you recommend I focus on learning to become useful on an actual live valuation assignment?

Any practical advice or resources would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks!


r/financialmodelling • • 12d ago

Applying the CFI approach to a real-life financial statement

6 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to build a three-statement model using the steps from the FMVA course, but I always find something like a one-time transaction that I don't know how to deal with. How do you forecast the following line items:

PPE impartments

Gain from the sale of PPE

Other comprehensive income line items

Losses from currency exchange rate

Income from subsidiary

And bad debt expenses

Thanks in advance,


r/financialmodelling • • 13d ago

First DCF (Home Depot) – looking for brutal feedback on structure and assumptions

Thumbnail
gallery
90 Upvotes

Hey all, I'm a recent graduate (history degree) and want to start trying to get into a finance career. This weekend I built my first DCF, valuing Home Depot from its FY2025 10-K. I used Claude to help me with the structure and walk me through it, so I'm sure there are things I'm missing. I'd rather hear critiques and things I should look into more for these kinds of models from real people.

Specific questions:

  1. Is my WACC approach reasonable?
  2. I excluded operating leases and stock-based comp. For a retailer like HD, how much does ignoring leases distort things?
  3. My exit multiple implies 3.5% perpetual growth vs. 2.5% in my perpetuity method. Which would you lead with?
  4. Are these the right comps for HD?
  5. Anything about the layout or formatting that would make this look amateur to someone in the industry?

Thanks in advance. Happy to take harsh feedback.


r/financialmodelling • • 16d ago

What do most entry level or senior level PM’s use for portfolio management in Excel software? V-lookup or Index/Match?

8 Upvotes

I live in Canada, if that makes a difference. I’m trying to brush up on my Excel and Python software skills to apply for roles.


r/financialmodelling • • 16d ago

Comps for the 9 HK-listed automakers (BYD, Geely, NIO, XPeng, Li...). Couldn't find one that wasn't six months old or mixing H and A share caps, so I built it. What would you add?

Post image
9 Upvotes

Wind data, Nov 5 close. Table attached.

The choices, because that's where the arguments are:

- Market cap is the HK line only. BYD and Great Wall also have A-shares. Blending gives a bigger number on a price nobody can actually buy.

- Revenue YoY is computed from the quarterly series, not the vendor's growth field. The field gave BYD 0.0067, which is either 0.67% or a unit bug. The series says +13.6%.

- Net margin is attributable profit over revenue, same reason. Seres is the row where the vendor's margin field and its own quarterly series disagree (-20% vs +5%), so it's flagged instead of picked.

- "Latest quarter" isn't the same for everyone. Five have Q3 in, three are still on Q2. It gets its own column instead of being hidden.

- Leapmotor's quarterly series didn't come back. n/a, not filled from memory.

Quick read: the legacy names sit on 7-10x with mid-teens gross margins. The pure-play EVs are all loss-making on the latest quarter, NIO growing fastest (+69%) and Li shrinking (-15%). Whether 7x Geely is cheap or a China-discount trap is exactly the thing a comps table can't tell you.

Two questions. For cross-listed names, do you show H only, A only, or blended, and do you label it? And is there any source for HK/China consensus that isn't a terminal?

No position.


r/financialmodelling • • 17d ago

Depreciation and Amortization not reconciling with the schedules

2 Upvotes

The breakdown and totals of all the schedules for D&A reconcile with the annual reports of my subject company, but summing the same depreciation and amortization for the Income Statement does not reconcile either in my model or the annual reports. I checked all the footnotes thoroughly and yet cannot figure it out.


r/financialmodelling • • 17d ago

Practicality of Revenue Forcasting using Revenue Drivers vs Historical Base Rate

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/financialmodelling • • 19d ago

Hi, can someone please review a sample Financial Model I’ve made?

9 Upvotes

I am planning on applying to an IB firm, I have worked in a VC for a small amount of time. But I have never done Financial Modelling professionally, can someone please review the sample I made to send out to IB/PE firms??

Please comment here or DM me your email, I will send it over
Thanks in advance! :)


r/financialmodelling • • 21d ago

How to separate depreciation and amortization from OPEX and COGS

23 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to build a three-statement model, and I need a separate line in the income statement for depreciation and amortization. The problem is that depreciation and amortization are included in operating expenses and cost of goods sold, and I don't know the exact proportions. How do you separate them from OPEX and COGS to avoid double counting?

Thanks in advance,


r/financialmodelling • • 23d ago

Best AI for Excel Modeling Classess/Tutorials?

21 Upvotes

What are some of the best AI for excel modeling classess/tutorials? What are people currently using in order to get trained in AI for excel modeling? I am looking for courses/tutorials that go beyond just what is available on YouTube - i.e. well articulated, well thought-out material


r/financialmodelling • • 23d ago

Emperical analysis (accounting and finance)

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm working on my this and just got worried about something here. I'm calculating per patent outcomes and this forces the calculation to only survive with patenting firms. I am worried because I do not have enough time to fix it by coming up with new hypothesis to code. I can acknowledge this bias, limit interpretation to the coverage and run some robustness tests, but is that emperically allowed? I just hate seeing my H1 drop at H2 to be honest. It gets worse... Research doesn't allow you to use R&D intensity as a moderator if some values are imputed, so my H3 reduced even further. Any suggestions?


r/financialmodelling • • 25d ago

Quarterly Update

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

Please Rate my equity research report


r/financialmodelling • • 27d ago

proctoring FMVA final exam

4 Upvotes

Question to those who passed FMVA this week

Is it true that the final exam becomes proctored ?