I made a post a few days ago when I began season 5 but was told most of my questions would be answered when I had finished the series. But there's still some things I'm confused by. There's probably stuff I'm forgetting but this is at the forefront of my mind as I make this post.
The Boy
Ok so I know now "the boy" mentioned since the beginning was referring to Michael / the Child Observer and not Peter. But other than being a misdirect, what were the Observers doing in the alternate universe if the 12 were sent to the prime universe for its planned invasion? And what was Peter's significance to the plan?
As of season 5 I assume it's to give prime Bishop an understanding of fatherly love into his older years (where Walternate instead became cynical not having his son) and why September did what he did. But that argument gets undermined by Peter being erased when the two universes fuse and the original invasion never happening in the first place (unless it still did but they were defeated much sooner without September's plan).
Also how did the other members of the 12 factor into this? It seemed like they were aware of what was going on as early as the original crossover, but that raises another question of why December was hesitant to aid in his own erasure in season 5. I did consider this might be the group from after the invasion began and they agreed to help September, but he would have lost his ability to time travel and been devolved back to a normal human by this point so it can't be.
I'm also confused why September hid him in that underground cavern and then either he or the boy telepathically influenced that construction worker to go look for him. There was probably a better place to send him or get him into Fringe Division custody.
Paradoxes
So this show has a LOT of paradoxes that seemingly get resolved, but I'm not sure how because it doesn't seem to touch on them for too long. And when it does it's usually handwaved as "this is Fringe Division, don't think about it".
Starting with Peter being erased after using the device, what happened there? Future Bishop says he can't just not send the pieces of the machine back in time because he had already done so and it would destroy the universe if he doesn't carry it out. Ok that's paradox 1; bootstrap. But somehow the future after the machine is activated can be changed because if it's the past witnessing the future then it voids a different paradox that the negative future must come to pass, which makes more sense though is still a paradox of effect before cause; a violation of causality.
But assuming these paradoxes are fine and the universe self-corrects for them, what causes Peter's erasure? The only way I can see that outcome is if the machine had been built after the original crossing or for the original crossing. The next season confirms he died after coming back through the Reiden Lake portal, but no explanation is given as to why. What's different in the merged reality that September didn't intervene? Do the observers not invade in that merged reality and thus he and Walter had no plan to change the future? It seems like the 12 had a problem with Peter's existence continuing to linger, which just raises further questions about September's actions when he witnessed the creation of the cure and intervention in Peter's drowning. Even the machine's design changes due to the paradox, no longer being linked to Peter's DNA which should create a new paradox in terms of the bootstrap paradox mentioned in the previous paragraph.
The season 5 situation is more confusing cause there should be more paradoxes going on but there doesn't seem to be. Firstly the presence of the observers doesn't seem to be affecting their own future. They chose 2015 so they had the maximum probability of a successful takeover, but they don't clarify if that's regarding resistance or ripple effects to the timeline. The former makes more sense, cause the Observers' kind don't get created until at least the 2100s and that will be a primitive form form with emotions still intact. When we see the future it doesn't seem like it's any different than the original, otherwise I would think one of the Observers would mention it. So I'm thinking their future is set in stone; either the invasion always happened or their attempt to prevent a paradox in their own creation guarantees the climate still gets destroyed by the 2600s but with more "descendants" from those living in the 2000s.
The final outcome of season 5 has the Observers being designed differently, so they never go back in time to invade in the first place. But that creates a different chain of events that I'm so confused about. If the Observers were designed differently:
- then they never send the 12 back in time to scout ahead of the invasion
- which means September never interrupts the creation of the cure for Peter
- so prime Bishop has no reason to cross universes to save Peter
- the fabric between universes remains intact
- none of the fringe events in either universe ever take place (also RIP to Lincoln and alternate Dunham's relationship)
- paradoxically the machine never gets built and sent back in time before the two universes split
- and September has a "son" nor saves him to allow for this new timeline to come to fruition in the first place
And how is prime Bishop's sudden disappearance explained? When in the new timeline does he just disappear? Season 5 was more interesting but ended more disappointingly for me cause it has "it was all a dream" energy from the timeline resetting and none of its events mattering in the end.
Universes and Timeline
More of a simpler question; how do the different universes and timelines work? It originally seemed like the two universes were just different timelines, but in a later season we get told universes vibrate at different frequencies and that when one universe lacks matter it pulls the excess from one with too much matter. Then when timeline stuff gets involved we get told it's still the same universe just with a different outcome, and confusingly some timelines seem to affect both universes (hence why Lincoln and alt Dunham's relationship was almost certainly erased)?
So if universes and timelines aren't the same, then how do universes "split"? How far back in time did Bishop send the pieces of the machine to ensure they'd be in both universes instead of remaining in the same timeline?
Where was William Bell when Peter died?
I've seen a theory floating around which I also came to, which is that Bell actually travelled to the other universe first before Bishop crossed over at Reiden Lake, and that was why he wasn't at Peter's funeral because he was already on the other side.
Sam Weiss Lineage and the First People
This is more of a nitpick / disappointment with the show itself, but it's sad we never got to see Bishop planting the parts of the machine at various points in history and planting clues for the Sam Weiss lineage to uncover. I know why they left it vague, but it still would have been neat to see even a montage of the machine being constructed or the parts being sent through the wormhole(s).
Why was the alternate universe more degraded than the prime universe?
I remember a loose explanation that the first crossing punctured a hole in the alternate side while only leaving a wrinkle in the prime side, so they got a 20 years headstart on the decay. But then in another episode a different explanation says the shapeshifters being sent to the prime universe also degrade it further. Which makes it seem like the alternate universe is just more unstable when it comes to crossings, regardless of which direction the travel happens.