r/gamedev • • 15d ago

Community Highlight I interviewed the former Technical Director of Rockstar Games and the developer of the GTA games!

Thumbnail x.com
102 Upvotes

My interview with Obbe Vermeij, former Rockstar Games Technical Director who played a key role in the development of iconic games like GTA III, Vice City, San Andreas, and GTA IV 👇🏻

1-) 🗣️ What do you think about GTA 6?

"I'm really looking forward to it. I think it's exciting that the whole world will be playing the same game at the same time. That doesn't happen very often anymore.

I think the game looks amazing. The variety of NPCs is mind-blowing. The graphics also look beautiful for a PS5 game."

2-) 🗣️ If you were the Technical Director responsible for GTA 6, what would you do, and what are you most curious about regarding the game?

"I'm interested to see what they're doing with GTA 6 Online.

I wonder whether they're going to set up servers this time that can support hundreds of players at once, like in an MMO.

If I were still there, that's exactly what I would be aiming for.

Many of the people I worked with are still at Rockstar, and they're very good."

3-) 🗣️ Among the GTA games you worked on, which one had the most challenging development process?

"GTA 3 was the most challenging because we had to write everything from scratch. We didn't use any GTA 2 code.

The biggest challenge was the streaming system. We had to load models from the DVD as the player moved through the city. Adam Fowler wrote that system.

He worked on it for a long time, but even then, the DVD wasn't quite fast enough.

We had to slow the player down; otherwise, they could move forward before the models had loaded, making it look like they were driving through the sky.

We placed buildings strategically to make the roads less straight. We also increased the air resistance of the player's car to help with streaming.

It was a little scary."

4-) 🗣️ You previously mentioned that Rockstar Games considered making a GTA game set in Istanbul but abandoned the idea shortly afterwards. How did that process unfold?

"We always wanted to set a GTA game outside America, and the same cities were often suggested: London, Moscow, Istanbul, Rio de Janeiro, and Tokyo.

Unfortunately, setting a mainline GTA game in one of these cities would have been too risky. Simply because players all over the world already know what American cities look like from TV and movies.

I've been to Istanbul a couple of times, and it's a really fun, lively city. It would have been a great setting for GTA. Unfortunately, the Istanbul idea was never seriously pursued. The only idea that was seriously considered was Tokyo, but that didn't happen either."

5-) 🗣️ GTA 3 was a relatively limited game in terms of missions and was more focused on driving. However, starting with GTA 4, the series gradually evolved into something closer to a real-life simulation. How did the decision-making process behind this transition work?

"For San Andreas, we felt we had added too many features, which made the game a little messy.

For the Xbox 360 and PS3 generation, new shaders were introduced that made graphics look a lot more realistic.

Right from the start, we decided to keep the game smaller, with a smaller map and fewer gameplay features, and focus more on improving its visuals and making the experience more realistic.

So we added NaturalMotion animations, more realistic car physics, and better graphics.

These decisions were made during discussions between the team at Rockstar New York (the Houser brothers) and us (Leslie Benzies and a few others). We never really disagreed."

6-) 🗣️ Why did you leave Rockstar Games? Was there any disagreement behind your departure?

"No disagreements. I left because my wife and I wanted to move to Canada.

I also didn't enjoy working on GTA 4 as much because the team had become so big that I didn't have much influence on the final result. Also, the story and missions were decided by Rockstar New York, so fewer decisions were made by us.

I left on good terms. No drama."

(Those who don't believe the interview is real can see Obbe's comment on my post in the "replies" section of his Twitter page.) [Twitter](https://x.com/ObbeVermeij/status/2118347154691649815)


r/gamedev • • Oct 15 '26

Announcement /r/GameDev Updates to Rule 3: No Showcasing Projects

161 Upvotes

This community has often allowed people to share free tools and assets but it has always been subjective about where the line crosses regarding self-promotion or showing off a project. We have updated rule 3 to make the following clarification about sharing tools in our community:

  1. All of your own tools you share must be free (this is reinforced by rule 6)
  2. You must provide discussion or technical takeaways regarding the tool.

    1. What unique challenges did you run into when making it?
    2. How did you solve them? Any unique formula, feature, or workaround?
    3. Examples of using the tool and how it improved your workflow.
  3. You must engage the best you can with comments asking about the tool. This does not mean replying to every comment but proving you want to interact with the community.

However we are still left with the open-ended question of what to do with assets. People often share free assets made by others, but what is the line to draw here? We had reports come in because free creators have tip jars or linked patreon accounts. Other reports reference paid products elsewhere on their website.

What do you all feel is appropriate for a developer wishing to share a free asset they made with the community? We will update rule 6 accordingly in the near future as we debate this.

Thank you all for your continued contributions to this community.

Edit: Since there is some confusion this is us expanding what is allowed and we are wanting feedback on if we should allow more posts or not. This stuff has been banned for years already.


r/gamedev • • 8h ago

Question Is anyone else getting emails begging their studio to donate a console with GTA6?

98 Upvotes

I appreciate that this sounds like guerilla marketing for GTA6 but I'm just SO puzzled about this that I had to investigate if this is happening to other game studios.

I'm the creative director of a small AA studio.

Since yesterday, our contact email has been getting these emails from various senders essentially begging us to donate a Playstation or Xbox with GTA6 to them.

Needless to say we have nothing to do with GTA6 or rockstar. We make CRPGs.

They give minimal personal info about the sender and kind of contain certain similar wording: "I know/appreciate this is a big ask" and "thanks for taking the time to read this". I wonder if it's LLM generated?

WHAT could possibly be the purpose of this? 😅 I can't imagine how this could be a scam, it feels so dumb. Are they just mass mailing game studios to beg for free stuff, hoping someone will bite? Please let me know if you've received an email like this; I'm just deleting them (after laughing about them with the team) but they do have me very very puzzled and curious.


r/gamedev • • 1h ago

Question Would it be smart to learn how to code a game on the web before making a web software?

6 Upvotes

Hey, my name's Aiden, and I really want to do some web development, for games and animation software. I don't know how to code, so it would be nice if I could get told where to start, too
But my main question is; Would it be smart to learn to make a short game in the web or doing something else?
I genuinely don't want to use Godot or Gdevelop, they don't seem to be capable of making animation websites, so please don't recommend them, I want to try purely web


r/gamedev • • 43m ago

Discussion Borges, philosophy and video game storytelling why do so many games remind me of his work?

5 Upvotes

I studied philology at university where I spent quite a bit of time studying Borges.

Later I also had the chance to work in AAA game development at a well known studio.

I've always been fascinated by the relationship between literature and video game storytelling.

Recently I started thinking about how many ideas explored by Jorge Luis Borges can be found in modern games.

For anyone unfamiliar with him, Borges was an Argentine writer fascinated by time, identity, infinity, destiny and the nature of reality.

His stories often play with concepts that are genuinely difficult to wrap your head around, but that's exactly what makes them so interesting.

A few examples that came to mind.

God of War (2018)

What I find particularly interesting about the Norse saga is its treatment of fate.

Kratos and Atreus are constantly confronted with prophecies about their future. Can you actually escape your destiny once you know what it is?

It reminded me of Borges' The Garden of Forking Paths, a story built around the idea that time can branch into countless possibilities, with different outcomes existing simultaneously.

BioShock Infinite

This one is probably the easiest connection to make.

Alternate realities, different versions of the same people, and timelines branching into other timelines. A lot of the ideas feel very close to The Garden of Forking Paths.

Control

Borges wrote a short story called The Library of Babel, about an infinite library containing every possible combination of letters and therefore every possible book.

Somewhere in that endless collection is supposedly the answer to everything but finding it is practically impossible.

Playing Control, especially exploring the Oldest House, gave me a similar feeling.

Dark Souls

The endless cycle of fire and darkness, civilizations rising and falling, and the feeling that everything has happened before and will happen again.

Borges was fascinated by circular time and the possibility that history is an endless repetition. I think Dark Souls captures that feeling incredibly well.

I'm not claiming these games directly borrowed from Borges. I'm just pointing out some interesting parallels.

I will be happy to explain more and how it works in writing.

In the end, we have a framework borrowed from literature basics we are using in modern AAA development.

Ask me questions- I will be happy to answer your questions.

I have not seen this topic here, so I thought it would be interesting to discuss.


r/gamedev • • 15h ago

Discussion Give me your most interesting solutions for the 'invisible wall' problem

48 Upvotes

Game I'm working on will require the player to figure out how to infiltrate a building from multiple potential angles and attack vectors.

These buildings will likely be in the middle of cities. I can't have the player deciding to turn around and walk in the opposite direction forever

However, the two solutions I've come up with is a big no-no wall that says 'IRRELEVANT' in scrolling text, if they approach the boundary, or piling up a bunch of plausible props to get in their way, but both solutions really suck, so I'm looking for ideas.

This seems to be an eternal problem in game dev and almost every solution is the least bad of many options. You don't have infinite dev, you have to cut them off somewhere.


r/gamedev • • 8h ago

Discussion Solo/small team devs how do you actually solve UI? I tried 3D-modeling mine and I'm stuck

8 Upvotes

I'm a solo dev working on a card-based tower defense game, and UI has

been the hardest art problem for me by far. Curious how other solo /

tiny-team devs deal with it.

What I tried:

  1. **UI asset packs** – I went through a lot of them. Some were goodquality, but they all felt generic. None of them had the character my game needed
  2. **Making it myself (2D)** – A few attempts, all pretty much failures. I'm not a 2D artist, and it showed.
  3. **Using Blender for UI** – I have some Blender experience, so I thought: why not use it here? My current pipeline is Model buttons, frames and containers in Blender - Texture them in Substance Painter - Back to Blender for lighting + render - Refine in Photoshop (color tweaks, cleanup)

The result is *way* better than anything I had before, it finally

feels like it belongs to the game. But it's still not at the level I

want, and honestly I feel like I've hit a wall. I don't know if the

problem is the pipeline, my skills, or that I'm missing some

fundamental UI design knowledge.

So my questions:

- Solo / small team devs: what's your UI workflow?

- Did you hire a UI artist, use packs and customize them, or build

everything yourself?

Would love to hear what worked and what didn't for you.


r/gamedev • • 1h ago

Question Looking for good articles/books on security for browser (web) games

2 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right place to ask, so sorry in advance if it isn't.

Can you recommend any good articles or books about security in browser games? I mean beyond the standard practices used in regular web development.

I'd especially like to read about real cases from people who've built web games. Part of the game code inevitably lives in the browser, so how do you decide what to keep on the backend and what's fine on the frontend? What mistakes did people make, and how did players exploit them?

Would really appreciate any recommendations. Thanks!


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Question Steamworks identity verification "pending" for 2+ weeks, page says up to 45 business days. How long did yours take?

3 Upvotes

Solo dev from India here, first time going through Steam Direct.

Timeline so far:

  • Paid the Steam Direct fee and did the tax interview in early November
  • Got an "additional documents needed" email on Nov 5, uploaded them Nov 6
  • Since then: "Identity Verification Pending. It may take up to 45 business days… please do not contact Valve via the Steamworks support tool during this time."

"Create new app" is blocked until it clears, so I can't even start the store page yet. I was hoping to make the February Next Fest, and registration closes around Jan 10, so the worst case cuts it very close.

For those who went through this in 2025/2026:

  1. How long did "Identity Verification Pending" actually take for you? (Bonus points if you're outside the US/EU.)
  2. Did anything you did make a difference, like a second document request, or a name-format mismatch between ID / bank / tax form that you had to fix?
  3. If verification made you miss a Next Fest, what did you do instead? Wait for the next one, or launch the Coming Soon page later and push wishlists harder?
  4. Anything you wish you'd prepared while waiting (capsules, trailer, demo build) so that day one after approval goes fast?

I'll post my own timeline here when it clears so the next person has a data point. Thanks!


r/gamedev • • 9m ago

Discussion How would you guys go about structuring a game with no OOP at all?

2 Upvotes

I was reflecting about how gamedev is heavily dependant on oop and wanted to know how yall would do it without it. Mainly talking about, for example, on Godot, how you have Node3D's that inherit from Nodes but they have more properties, etc.


r/gamedev • • 1h ago

Postmortem Why My Game's Tutorial Was Absolute Garbage

1 Upvotes

The tutorial is the very first thing players experience when they enter your game.

Just like first impressions matter when meeting someone for the first time, how much do you think players judge a game by its tutorial?

My tutorial wasn't memorable.

So I decided to identify its problems and improve it.

Our original tutorial was made mainly to explain the game's systems, back when we hadn't fully decided what direction the game would take.

Problems
- The tutorial text was not visible enough
- Players ended up just clicking wherever the highlight appeared, like monkeys in an experiment
- It didn't feel like a town-building game

Goals of the new tutorial
- Not just show the game to players, but let them experience it
- Convey the town-building genre through dialogue and presentation
- Help players form an attachment to the villagers and the town
- Make it clear why the player is receiving rewards

1. We realized how important it is to communicate the game's genre.

Before selling the concept or hook, players need to know what kind of game they're playing.We thought "Cursor is God" was the hook, but the real reason to play is simple: it's a desktop game about growing a town

2. Connecting the creature system to the tutorial actually hurt the genre.

We thought hatching an egg would be a great first goal and a good way to guide players through the game.

But it shifted the focus from "growing a town" to "raising a creature".

Town-building ⭕
Creature-raising ❌

3. New player can't have fun with a game right away.

A tutorial doesn't need to be fun. It just needs to not be boring.
Even an interested player is still in the learning phase when they first start. Trying too hard to make everything fun only makes things confusing.

A boring or frustrating tutorial makes players quit.
But if there's always something to do and the game keeps talking to them, they'll keep playing.

Once they're attached to the game, even complex systems won't feel frustrating enough to make them quit.

So here's what I'll do from now on:
- Introduce the genre first
- Keep players from feeling frustrated
- Give players a role in the game
- Then highlight the game's unique hook!


r/gamedev • • 18h ago

Question Is it necessary to be a content creator to become a mid-successful game dev?

15 Upvotes

Hello guys,

I am a solo game dev making my first mobile game. It is not something very out of the box, and I know it will most likely fail because this type of game is out of fashion now, considering how powerful phones are getting and how easily they can run good games. Still, I tried to get my game in front of people on different platforms like YouTube, TikTok, etc.

I am camera shy and not very confident when it comes to talking, so I mainly posted faceless videos of gameplay and the systems I was making as dev logs. Of course, they didn't get much attention. Yes, the game is not very unique, but the videos I was making were also very bad in quality, and making content for social media platforms is not something I am very interested in either.

But I have seen a lot of game developers who also make amazing content and basically know how to present their game in videos. So I want to discuss this and get your opinions: do you have to be good at making content to sell your game, even if the game itself is very good? I mean, of course players will buy your game when it comes in front of them somehow or in other words, they know something of their interest got released. You have to target that audience, and to target an audience you have to make content.

Again, I know my game is not very unique or good. I am asking this because it is something I cannot wrap my head around, and it is confusing me for future projects too.


r/gamedev • • 4h ago

Marketing A study of game length and how many players finish

1 Upvotes

Chart: https://steammaho.com/static/charts/finish-share-by-length-2026-11.png

We all expect that the longer a game is, the fewer people finish it. Price, quality and genre come on top of that. Good short linear stories are probably finished by more players. Long RPGs, especially with a bad rating, are probably finished by few. And the cheaper a game is, the less seriously players take it. It's all speculations and assumptions, and I wanted to find out what is closer to real situation on Steam.

But first I needed data. As you probably know, Steam gives no direct numbers on completion or play time. There are sites with such data, but as usual nobody hands it over for a large number of games. So I had to build my own estimates. I started from the hours that review authors had played, plus the achievement a game gives for finishing it. Its percentage is usually the share of players who finished. Then I calibrated the numbers on about 1,800 games with a known completion time. The result is not perfect, but it works: two thirds of my estimates are off by no more than 50%.

Which games are in the sample

Steam has about 154,000 released games. But most of them I couldn't use:

  • First, I took only games with 100 or more reviews. The estimate of hours to finish is more accurate that way. That leaves 33,800.
  • Second, only about 22,200 of them have achievements, and only about 12,000 have an achievement for finishing the game.
  • Third, I took games from 2018 on, which leaves 9,000. Before that year many games were run for trading cards, and that lowered the achievement percentages.
  • And last, I dropped strategy games and run-based games (roguelikes and the like). Hours played in these games say little about the length of one playthrough.
  • In total: 6,800 games.

The typical game has about 400 reviews, costs $14 and takes a bit over 3 hours to finish. 8 in 10 of these games have a story.

Length

Hours to finishGamesShare who finishedHalf of the games fall between
Under 22,15838%18 to 57%
2 to 41,77626%13 to 42%
4 to 81,54121%11 to 34%
8 to 1687417%9 to 30%
16 to 3233416%10 to 28%
32 and more11723%12 to 36%

Which assumptions were true

Each one is checked among games of the same length.

AssumptionWhat I found
Longer games are finished less38% under 2 hours, 21% at 4 to 8 hours, then no further drop
Better games are finished moreGames rated 95% or more are finished about twice as often as games under 70% (a bit less than twice among the longest games)
Good short linear stories are finished mostShort games with a story: 42%. Short games without one: 27%. Linear stories are finished no more often than stories whose branches rejoin.
Long RPGs with a bad rating are finished by fewLong RPGs rated under 70%: 18%. Rated 85% or more: 20%.
Cheaper games are taken less seriouslyFrom $5 to $40 the price makes no difference. Among short games the cheapest are finished most.

Finish share by review score:

Hours to finishRated under 70%70 to 79%80 to 89%90 to 94%95% or more
Under 225%29%37%41%51%
2 to 415%20%26%31%33%
4 to 812%14%20%26%30%
8 to 1612%11%18%24%28%
16 and more16%14%18%22%26%

Finish share by price:

Hours to finishUnder $5$5 to 9.99$10 to 19.99$20 to 39.99$40 and more
Under 245%37%28%too fewtoo few
2 to 426%28%25%25%too few
4 to 823%21%20%22%24%
8 to 16too few16%17%17%21%
16 and moretoo fewtoo few13%17%28%

Among long games, the ones that cost $40 or more are finished about twice as often as games at $10 to $20. That is the opposite of what I assumed.

Another thing I did not expect: how much it matters whether the game can be failed at all. Games that cannot be failed are finished about twice as often as games of the same length where you can be defeated.

Limits. My estimate is too high for very short games and too low for very long ones, so the real differences between rows are probably a bit larger than in the table.

Does this match your own game's achievement page? I would especially like to hear numbers from people who shipped a long game.


r/gamedev • • 10h ago

Question Is it worth it to continue marketing a free steam game to help justify a sequel?

3 Upvotes

Hey there, I'm the lead developer of a horror game by the name of Solipsistic, it's a free 4th wall psychological horror game. I've worked on developing this game for around a year with a small team and we published it on steam back in august. We had been trying to market the game since June with pre and post marketing for 4 months straight, since then the game didn't really achieve what we wanted. The little player base that played the game enjoyed it and it's currently sitting on 27 steam reviews with a 100% positive reviews and very few YouTube Videos/Streams covering the game. Our discord also has around 31 members.

Our goal with the game was and still is, to release a free fun experience with a unique twist/mechanic, hoping to expand it into a much larger game taking place in the same universe. (So basically a series of upcoming games, all taking place in the same universe with recurring characters but different stories all tied together in the lore of Solipsistic). So yes, this means Solipsistic has a clear ending to it with no cliff hangers, and the same thing will be applied to future games. Best example of this I can give is Resident Evil 7 and 8 and 9, or outlast 1 and 2 and trials. Same universe, but different stories in each game.

It's currently the 22th of November, almost around 3 months since release (Published in 28th of August), currently I'm currently working on the writing of the next game with the team, since then, I've been going back to Solipsistic wondering if I'm missing potential.

Is it worth it to reignite the game's marketing and start daily and actively promoting it? If yes, what advice would you give? I've tried everything from Contacting hundreds of content creators, organic reach from steam visibility rounds, steam curators, youtube and instagram content, reddit promotions, and I even got one of the voice actors who are a decently sized influencer to promote the game on their instagram and on their youtube! all of that and we barley got around 800 plays and 27 steam reviews. For indepth analysis of the game, the game itself is around an hour in length, the average playtime of the game is 48 minutes with the median playtime being 20 minutes.

Are we just really unlucky? Or Are we missing an important fundemental of marketing? Or is it possible that the game is just not good enough to hit at the very least a small fanbase? Our main goal with Solipsistic was not Virality, it was just to get a small enough fanbase that actually cares about the game that it would justify us spending even more time and money developing the next game.

Thank you so much for reading in advance, and I would appreciate any tips whatsoever. I won't share the game's link to comply with the subreddit rules, I just want to know if this game is still worth marketing or should I just drop it and start working on the next and market that alone.

Quick Edit note: Solipsistic isn't considered a demo for an upcoming game. It's a short full game that doesn't relate much to upcoming releases and has it's own full ending(s), meaning if someone where to play the game and complete it, they wouldn't be any plot holes for that current story, future games are just an expand on the same universe.


r/gamedev • • 13h ago

Discussion My demo ends right before my game gets hard, and now players say it's too easy

5 Upvotes

I'm solo making a packing puzzle roguelite. A run is one week, Monday to Friday, three boxes a day, and the difficulty climbs across the week. Wednesday has a mid-week boss and Friday has the final one.

When I cut the demo I stopped it on Wednesday evening. The idea was to give people a full little arc with a real boss at the end, and keep Thursday and Friday for the full game.

The feedback from the last two weeks is pretty consistent : people like it, and a lot of them say it's too easy. Which makes sense, the demo is the gentle half of the curve.

I can see three ways out. Raise the demo's targets so it feels like the full game, even if that's not how those days play in the full game. End the demo later, on Thursday or Friday, and give away more of the game. Or keep it like this and make it clearer that it gets harder after.

For those who shipped a demo, how did you decide where to cut it ? Did you tune the demo differently from the full game ?


r/gamedev • • 1d ago

Discussion Nine People Playing My Game Instead of GTAVI

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

I know GTAVI sold 20 million copies in 24 hours but I'm just a guy who devs on the side from his dayjob, so seeing nine people from around the world make the active decision to play my game still brings me some joy.


r/gamedev • • 5h ago

Question GameDev in India

1 Upvotes

How do I start/ work towards getting myself ready to get hired professionally in India... I am currently pursuing a bTech.. however gd is my hobby and i want to give myself a chance at doing it professionally. If you are a dev in India I'd love to know ur journey


r/gamedev • • 1d ago

Discussion I counted 607 incremental games. They are getting shorter, and more of them are paid.

54 Upvotes

I keep a catalog of 607 incremental games on my site and finally ran some numbers on it. Two trends stood out.

Games are getting shorter. 35% of this year's releases are short games you can finish. For 2018-2021 it was 9%. Games with RPG systems went the other way, from 33% to 13%.

More of them cost money. 48% of the 2026 games are paid. For games from 2020 and earlier it was 8%.

A few other numbers:

  • 67% of the 2025-26 games are on itch.io, against 27% of older ones
  • 64% of recent games still run in a browser
  • Most Steam reviews: Cookie Clicker (89k), then Shelldiver, Scritchy Scratchy and Melvor Idle

These numbers only cover my catalog. It leans toward recent and well-liked games, and a lot of old browser games have no reliable release date, so they are missing from the yearly numbers.

Charts and the full breakdown: https://incrementalgames.net/state-of-incremental-games

Do you like the shift toward shorter paid games, or do you miss the endless free browser ones?


r/gamedev • • 19h ago

Discussion How long to get store page approved? (NOT THE TAX REVIEW!)

6 Upvotes

I know that the tax review is taking like two months now for people signing up, but I'm talking about the storage page review. They say it takes like three days but probably takes much longer

does anyone know how _much_ longer?


r/gamedev • • 23h ago

Postmortem PSA and Postmortem about the (adverse) effects of a botched Content Questionary review on Steam

12 Upvotes

I thought a lot about posting this here, but I guess I'd rather other developers not do my same mistake - hence I'll share my experience.

TL;DR

I followed a request from Steam support regarding the Content Questionary and complying with that without asking for details first had severe effects - effects that you might want to avoid for your game if you can.

The full story

I have recently finished working on a commercial visual novel and prepared it for the Steam release. Store page verification went fine, the demo was approved without a itch. The usual 2-3 things to change about capsules, but nothing else. I have been through this song and dance several times so far (2 free games + 2 commercial games + around 15 DLCs).

The game has very revealing character designs (think Kill la Kill, if you are familiar with the anime) but nothing close to explicit nudity. I intended this version to be marked as 16+ and worked to keep it like that. So, I correctly marked the age options that applied to the build in the Content Questionary ('Some Nudity') and submitted it to the best of my knowledge.

A separate adult content patch for the game, developed by a collaborator of mine, was also approved as an official DLC on Steam without issues and without any notes from Steam support.

For what concerns the base game, however...

  • On September 23, I submitted my build for verification
  • On October 1, Steam Support answered that I needed to add a 'Frequent Nudity' tag to my game through the content questionary, because of unspecified "nudity"
  • I complied, thinking that maybe my definition and their definition of it was different and to streamline the approval process. After the change was applied, I saw that the German rating was still shown as USK 16 even after the change and thought that everything went fine
  • (!) This is what happened immediately after applying the new change (!):

    • The game's store page was delisted in China, Germany (where I live), and Saudi Arabia. Furthermore it was heavily restricted in UK and Australia (behind credit card verification)
    • The demo was delisted from those countries too, even if it was previously approved for distribution there - this also affected its visibility during Next Fest
    • Users that aren't logged in cannot see the game's store page at all, independent on the country they reside in
    • The game is automatically hidden for all players who filtered out the "nudity" tag (which is automatically added when one checks the 'Frequent Nudity' box in the questionary)
    • The game has now an age gate pop-up and a prominent disclaimer under the screenshots
    • The tag can also only be removed by Steam support at this point - once the Content Questionary is approved, you can't edit that specific part manually anymore
  • I worked on the base game to aim at a 16+/mature rating, but nothing above that. However, that tag basically marked it as "adult only" instead. After noticing this, I panicked, requested a content re-review to Steam support in the same ticket and asked what triggered that specific request
  • On October 7, Steam support approved my game's build but didn't address my request for clarification. The age gate remained in place as if I didn't ask anything
  • I opened a new support ticket the same day
  • Around one week later, Steam support told me that they won't disclose what issues they found, limiting their answer to "because of the content" and that is not part of their policies to disclose the problems
  • On October 23, I was told that the game will be re-reviewed, without an explicit deadline. I was told that the review team would get in touch with me as soon as a verdict was reached
  • As of today, November 21, I still have not received a final verdict from Steam support. The game already launched with the age gate. It's still not available for purchase in the countries above

The takeaway

Just to address a possible point of contention: I had some fellow devs theorize that the age gate was triggered by the existence of the DLC patch, but I inquired Steam support about it and I was told that this is not the case - it is perfectly possible to have a base game without age gate and an extra Steam DLC with its own age rating, as long as you don't advertise it in the game's description, discussions or annoucements.

But, as for the final takeaway: if you are requested to add the 'Frequent Nudity' tag to your game by Steam support and it was NOT what you intended for your game, ask for a re-review before complying and not after. After the tag is in place, all the adverse effects I listed above will immediately happen, hence giving your game page's visibility a major hit.

Notice that a re-review might require a longer time than usual. When asked about it, Steam support told me that it could require several weeks and could not give me any timeline.

I know I should have done due diligence and that is completely on me for not asking for clarifications or searching which concrete effects that option would have had before complying. Hence, I'm not looking for sympathy and it was definitely my fault. Lesson learned for the future, I guess.

I still hope this can help another developer not to do my same mistake.


r/gamedev • • 4h ago

Discussion I couldn't find an HTML/CSS UI for Unity without a browser inside, so I made my own

0 Upvotes

I'm making a strategy game in Unity and wanted to write the HUD in plain HTML and CSS: grid, gradients, shadows, blurred glass panels over the game.

What I found when I looked:

- UI Toolkit: close to CSS, but it's a subset. No grid, no gradients, no box shadows, no backdrop blur.

- uGUI: no styles at all, everything by hand.

- Embedded browsers (Chromium web views): real CSS, but you ship a whole browser process with your game, with its memory and its lag.

- Coherent Gameface: does what I wanted, but it's a paid licence aimed at studios.

I didn't find anything free that gives real CSS without a browser inside. So I made my own: Vitrail UI. It takes HTML, CSS and JavaScript, lays them out with Firefox's CSS engine (Stylo, through the Blitz project), and paints them on the game's GPU inside the frame. No browser, no web view. A hover or a changed number costs under 0.3 ms.

It's early (version 0.1.0): Unity 6 with URP only, macOS and Windows, and some CSS is still missing. It's free, also for games you sell (MIT with the Commons Clause, so source-available, not strictly open source).

If that's useful to you, it's on GitHub: https://github.com/Yarik0378/Vitrail-UI

If I missed an alternative, tell me. I'd honestly like to know.


r/gamedev • • 1d ago

Question Everything was approved by steam to release on schedule, but now steam demanding sudden store verification may cause me to miss my deadline

39 Upvotes

Steam had approved every part of my store page, the build and release parameters, yet today, 6 days before release, I woke up to see that somehow my page wasn't approved anymore and needed verification for the library hero, going back on earlier verification that was already approved. Am I screwed for my release??


r/gamedev • • 7h ago

Discussion Where to post updates and whatever?

0 Upvotes

Been working on my game for ages, its hard to describe what it is. Where can I post updates get feedback have a bit of fun with it?


r/gamedev • • 11h ago

Question Steam tax form resubmit missing - any ideas?

1 Upvotes

I applied plied to the Steamworks publisher paid the $100

Got an email after 10 days saying incorrect address and to resubmit the form and email said there would be a link on the page

Or course there is no new tax form link anywhere..

Emailed support no response for 2 weeks..

Any ideas?

Apart from just wait..

I know timelines have moved from 10 days - 30 days and now 45 days

I’m close to 4 weeks as submitted Oct 27 , and there is no tax form to resubmit so I assume this waiting time is lost until they fix the resubmit tax form?