r/gameofthrones • u/miggovortensens • 14h ago
The cracks were already showing in season 5
I used to agree with most people that the show really went downhill in its final seasons, but after rewatching it from scratch, I began tio notice this decline started back in Season 5.
Tywin's death at the end of season 4 meant losing a genuinely dangerous man who understood power and also removed Varys from King's Landing, where he'd spent years manipulating people and playing his own political game; he then became basically a supporting character in Tyrion's storyline, and having Tyrion's plot merge with Daenerys's made room for fan service to drive the narrative more and more. (I remember one of the big Season 5 posters showing Peter Dinklage's silhouette facing a dragon. It was basically, "Look! Tyrion and Daenerys! Two fan favorites finally coming together! Isn't that exciting?")
That more sensationalist approach became increasingly obvious from then on. Characters like Littlefinger and Olenna, who used to be fascinating because of how they manipulated people and political alliances, were either sidelined or became much less sophisticated. We got more sassy one-liners from them, but fewer scenes showing what made them so clever in the first place.
In terms of "Big Bads", Ramsay Bolton was basically just a sadistic monster who, unlike Joffrey, didn't have a bunch of smart people around him to make the Winterfell storyline politically interesting. Take the Battle of the Bastards: we never got to see Sansa negotiate Littlefinger's support because the writers wanted to surprise us with the Knights of the Vale showing up. And considering Sansa was supposed to become a major political player, that's a pretty big missed opportunity to actually show us how clever she'd become.
We also had the progression of the supernatural storylines, like Bran and Hodor's, and they were exciting mostly because we were finally getting answers and approaching the endgame. But they didn't exist in the same show that we got in the first 4 seasons, when the time we spent beyond the wall was balanced with a truly solid game of politics.
Those seasons are still entertaining to watch and overall a great piece of television, but they were certainly inferior to the four seasons that came before.