I just want to leave this here, and to know that I put it out into the world.
17/01/2008
It was a Thursday. I was fourteen years old, and must have been at school that day. I was home now, and was alone in the apartment. My mom called the house phone around 5 PM or so. I answered. She said, “Grandma is dying; we have to let grandma go.”
Initially, I put up some resistance and said, “why can’t they put her on life support; why can’t they drain the fluid?,” and my mom said, “her heart is too weak.” she then laid out a few options for me, saying, “Do you want to go to auntie Sh.——‘s ?”, to which I said no. Then she asked if I wanted to go to J.—— and B.——‘s? to which I also said no. Finally she asked, “Do you want to be there?” and I said yes. She may have even asked, “are you sure?” and I said yes. She picked me up shortly after.
I remember arriving at the on the ICU floor of Saint B.—— Hospital. Grandma was about 3 or four rooms down from the entrance, on the left hand side of the long, wide corridor, just past the nurses’ station situated in the middle of the corridor. Her room had a window which faced Northwest, toward Taché and La Verandrye Park. My mom and I were the first to arrive.
For a period of time, I was left alone with grandma. I sat on her left side. The room was darkened. There was something vaguely marine about the tiling of the floor, about the wainscotting. I remember her hands were swollen with edema , and her skin seemed so fragile and thin; it was stretched so tightly against the back of her hand. Although she was intubated, I saw her struggle to say said, “Hi, B.——” through her endotracheal tube. She was still conscious but looked so tired. I think I may have said, “Hi, Grandma.” I sat in silence and held her hand, trying to hide my eyes; I couldn’t look at her for long. Her nose was packed with gauze and covered in dried blood. I remember her grey hair with patches that retained some auburn tint tucked behind her ears.
I remember looking at the clock, I think it was perhaps across the room, above an alcove next to the sliding doors. It was probably around 6 PM when we arrived.
I am not sure at which point during the night it was relayed to me that T.—— would delaying his arrival until after his daughter’s basketball game; a game that he was refereeing. My mother was furious, and her voice was sharp, through gritted teeth. I remember asking why, I am not sure how rhetorical my question was. I was angry for my mother; I was angry for my Grandmother. My mother stifled her rage—“his own mother, his own mother.”
Subsequently, she redirected much of this anger at Sh.——, who has chosen not to be there. “She said that she made her peace with mom earlier’,” and “we should be here together as a family.”
I think there was a lot of suppressed anger toward T.—— for my mother, especially during the illness. This was around the time when my mother had began telling me how he would ignore Grandma’s phone calls, telling Sandra to answer, to tell his mother he wasn’t at home. Apparently, he didn’t like getting ‘stuck’ on the phone, that she talked for too long. During the early stages of Grandma’s hospitalization, T.—— was taken with the idea of a long-term ventilator clinic, where we could keep Grandma. During this time, the story of Sam Golubchuk was in the news, bringing to the fore questions about the ethics of long-term life support and the right to withdraw medical treatment. I was young, and I trusted the adults in my life, so I repeated the idea to my mother. She responded quickly and, citing the case of “that poor Jewish man,” told me that T.—— was in denial. “The body is an empty shell; it wouldn’t be your Grandmother anymore.” I silently considered, a little embarrassed, that she was right.
My uncle M.—— arrived next, accompanied by his ex-wife, S.——. They had split up only two years earlier, a year after my own parents had divorced. At this time they lived only blocks away from the hospital, albeit in separate houses, both infill bungalows built after the second world war.
I was immediately put off at S.——‘s presence, considering that she had essentially become persona non-gratia in our house, and (I assume) others’, as well. I felt she had little right to be there, as she wasn’t blood, and she wasn’t family anymore; and she had hurt my uncle who I held in high esteem at the time.
At this point, the sequence of events becomes blurred. I remember episodic detail, but not their sequence, only little snippets.
My grandmother was motionless in her bed. She couldn’t talk, and even if she could, I don’t think she had the energy to.
I remember the nurse came in to administer scheduled morphine via IV., although I seem to recall that she was receiving less than the maximum dose because we were waiting for T.——. As well, there was a risk, were an extubation attempt to be made, that the delicate membranes of her throat would bleed. We were shuffled from the room, and Despite this risk, the extubation went ahead and was ultimately successful.
Time moved by. Her breathing became slower. The numbers on the ECG mounted at the head of her bed decreased. I remember the ECG was a phosphorescent green. I think it was reading around fifty bpm when we arrived, and it only become slower. My mom said, “they’re keeping her alive for him!”, referring to T.——. “This is just prolonging her suffering!”, “doesn’t he know that she’s suffering?”
Around the time M.—— and S.—— arrived, I moved from sitting on my Grandmother’s left side to sitting at the foot of her bed, although at some distance removed, to allow for movement from one side of her bed to the other. M.—— and S.—— sat to my left, closer to Grandma’s right side. I saw my uncle crying, and it seemed a shock to me. S.—— seemed to hover above M.——, standing behind him at his back as he sat, as if she were the master of ceremonies.
There were many boxes of tissues. I cried from deep within my stomach, almost feeling that I might vomit from continued guttural crying. My whole body was coming apart. My eyes were swollen and puffy from crying and wiping my tears over and over. I remember looking over at my gandmother as I sobbed; it felt like I was looking through a fog, a haze. As the nurse was leaving the room after giving the morphine, I mouthed the words, “I love you, I love you, I love you,” in my grandmother’s direction, and I momentarily caught the nurse’s eye. I saw the pity cross her face as she smiled at me. I felt embarrassed. My expression, the words I had said, they felt somehow shameful and pathetic to me.
People told anecdotes about Grandma. S.—— was particularly vocal at this time, often telling stories that rang false against the knowledge of her split with M.—— and all I had heard from my mother and my cousins. She recalled how at Grandma’s house, everyone had their own teacup—a well-known practice of my grandmother’s. Yet, later on, my mother told me that when S.—— had spoken of her mug, she had claimed a cup that had already been claimed by someone else. Years later, I was told by Sh.—— that she called S.—— and demanded she return the mug because she had no legitimate right to it. I can’t help but view the teacup story as emblematic of S.——‘s role that night: she wasn’t family, and her interjections were those of a familial interloper. She forced her way into a place she did not belong.
Finally, T.—— arrived. It must have been close to 9 or 10 PM. I remember wondering why his wife was absent. We all left the room to give T.—— time alone with his mother. Looking back, I felt a knot in my stomach: after all the waiting, we all silently accommodated T.——. But he had been a source of significant distress and suffering that night. It felt unjust; it felt wrong. It felt unfair: why did he deserve more time alone with her when he was the one artificially prolonging her suffering? It felt like rewarding him for denial.
All the while in that room I had been struggling to speak to her. I had so much that I needed to say. I couldn’t find the words; I felt the eyes of my family around me, of the staff. I couldn’t work up the courage. I wanted to say that I didn’t want her to go, that I wasn’t ready to lose her; I wanted to tell her how much I loved her, how important she was to me. I couldn’t vocalize any of it.
While T.—— was alone with Grandma, we went down to the lobby. M.—— said something like, “this is how powerful music gets written. Music like ‘Tears in Heaven’.” Even then, I felt this comment fell flat in the room, although I certainly understood that one could turn terrible experiences into something beautiful. Now, I’m not sure it’s a fair trade—pain for music.
We returned to the ICU. The numbers of the ECG sank lower and lower. I remember watching them dip to 19 bpm. I knew it wouldn’t be long now. I needed to say something. I needed to say one more thing because I knew I wouldn’t get another opportunity. I went to the side of her bed and I said, “I love you, Grandma.” Then I looked at her and saw that her chest was sunken and motionless. She wasn’t breathing. Had she heard me? I was terrified. Was I too late? I remember asking my mom why there was still a pulse on the ECG. She replied that it was just residual current passing through her system, that she was gone.
I remember her eyes staring blankly. The nurse came in some time later and began to shut down the equipment and removed her lines. Her skin was waxy, pale. I felt a brief moment of shock as the nurse closed her eyes. In an instant, the lifelessness became so apparent to me. This was a body, this was her body, and she was no long alive. At some point the florescent overhead lights were switched on. The room became effuse with a cold sterility; shocking after hours in the dark. The white sheet that covered her was pulled up, leaving only her head visible. I have an oddly specific recollection that it must have been around a quarter past eleven when she died.
It was well past eleven when my mother and I left. T.—— remained behind, saying he wanted to stay there alone for a while. It was cold outside. I remember my mother turning the car from Taché onto Marion avenue. The wind was whipping snow along the road.
I rambled anxiously to my mother in the car; I was almost agitated, trying to make some sense of what I had just experienced. I recall feeling like I was repeating what I thought I was supposed to say. I said I was relieved, that I was glad it was over, that she was no longer suffering or in pain. I think I was probably glad to be out of the oppressive atmosphere of the room. I was exhausted, grasping for something. I think I wanted her to give me something, something to hold on, some sort of validation.
When I got home, I called my father while sitting on the edge of my mother’s bed, pulling out the bottom drawer of her dresser with my toes. At some point I got on my knees and looked down into the drawer as I told my dad that my grandmother had died. I remember I told him the time she had passed away. His response was sort of non-committal and forgettable.
I don’t remember going to sleep. I don’t remember anything else about the night or the coming days.