Disclaimers: I received this Y2 unit from Innoasis in my capacity as a moderator of the r/innioasis subreddit. I am not an employee of the company. I am not receiving financial compensation for this review. My views are my own and do not reflect upon any organization I am a part of or my employer. I will attempt to be unbiased and present only the facts as I have observed them. If I make any errors, please let me know, and I will edit the review accordingly.
That out of the way, let’s proceed.
BEHOLD:
The Innioasis Y2 in its Retail Packaging
The Innioasis Y2 comes in a box that is very reminiscent of Apple packaging for iPods, iPhones, and iPads (I’m writing this on a 10th generation iPad, so I recently had packaging for comparison), but it is different from the Y1 packaging I received around 2023.
The Back of the Y2 Packaging
The back of the packaging has some information about the companies involved with the Y2 and no technical specifications. It’s interesting to note that none of the companies listed are Innioasis proper, just the importers.
The Contents of the Y2 Packaging
Inside the packaging, there is:
1 x USB-A to USB-C cable, approx 36”
1 x Innioasis Y2 DAP in plastic baggie (with plastic screen protector. This is important for later)
1 x Information Card (with broken links)
The Y2 does not come with headphones like the Y1 did. I was fortunate to obtain a Y1 before they reduced the quality of the headphones, so I was a little disappointed there was none in the box. The information card does not link to a usable webpage just yet, and there is no manual. The packaging is modern, but the lack of a manual is an issue (it may be fixed by the time you read this review) that can cause some confusion. It did for me.
The Y2 compared to the Y1.
Out of the box, the Y2 has a light theme by default. This can be changed pretty quickly, but let’s look at the differences in size and shape.
A side by side comparison of Y1 and Y2 thicknessY2 Width, 2.465 inchesY2 Height, 4.001 inchesY2 Thickness, 0.437 inches
Dimensionally, and mass wise, there is more weight to the Y2 than the Y1. It is still ABS plastic, but the size is closer to an iPod than it was before. It is definitely a step in the right direction.
Now, lets’s get into the meat and bones of hardware before we discuss the software.
Y2 Internal Photos, showing RF shielded electronicsY2 Internal View, Front Plate, (more traces from wheel)Y2 Internals Removed from CaseY2 Internals, Back View, Removed from Case
From these internal views, we can see that there are many changes. I am still waiting on the internal photos from Innioasis from under the RF shields, but the changes give me hope there is a CS43131 DAC on the chip as Innioasis claims. The speaker, mic, headphone jack, and other smaller components are the same on the Y2 as they are on the Y1. The memory card slot is different since it can be accessed externally, while before it was an internal slot.
At this point, I didn’t like that I received a pink player, so I took matters into my own hands and painted it. If anyone plans on doing this, FYI there is a plastic screen protector on the case already, and it acts as a PERFECT mask for painting.
Colors Courtesy of Rustoleum
Now, for the software. First major change: You can take screenshots by holding the power and volume down button, sort of like a cell phone. This made this part of the review 100 times easier.
The Main Menu
The main menu is the same as the Y1, minus the FM radio option and the Bluetooth option. The Bluetooth option moved to Settings. Let’s look at the settings!
Settings options 1.
Users will notice that many settings are missing, notably the Equalizer. Turns out, they’ve been moved.
If you go to Music, Videos, or Audiobooks, there is a settings option for all of them. The equalizer is in the Music settings. Also, the options for sorting or shuffling are located in the respective settings menus.
Music Settings 1Music Settings 2
Moving over to the Music settings, we can see that the sort options are largely the same as they were on the Y1, but there is a HUGE change. When you look at an artist, you can see albums instead of a full list of songs. This is a game changer for functionality in the default software.
Equalizer Options
The equalizer options are the same as they were on the Y1. To set a custom EQ, you hold down a key (IIRC, it’s the menu key) and it allows you to edit the equalizer. The Y2 is designed for higher impedance headphones, so I had to turn down the equalizer to avoid blowing out my eardrums with my IEMs. ***THIS IS IMPORTANT.
Playing a Legally Obtained FLAC file.
It plays music and videos just fine.
As for functionality, there are some quirks. The Y2 only has volume control with the buttons on the side, not the scroll wheel. I hate it. I don’t mind the power button being there, but the main draw of the Y1 was the iPod-like control scheme. This loses most of that, but it can be fixed with software. I also miss the FM radio, which I used!!! I even recorded songs from the radio to my Y1 like we used to do on cassette tapes in the before times.
The scroll wheel is more responsive. The buttons work fine and have a sufficient, satisfying click to them. It’s a working, competent, DAP that sounds great… but I’ll have to post a reply to this message with the audio portion because I cannot attach any more photos to this post. Part Two is HERE
As the header says... I'm thoroughly unhappy with how clunky and ugly Rockbox is. Is there a better and more capable program I should be running? Or a tried and true combination of skins and settings I'm missing? Anything I apply to it literally only makes it look worse, harder to read, more cumbersome to use, etc etc.
I didn't expect this combo to slap. I tried it because I've had the headphones forever, and it works better than anything else I've tried.
I looked it up and found that any DJ headphones are easy to power.
What I tried before:
- Salnotes Zero, fiddled around for about 3 days, returned. Surgical sound, no life detected.
- Sony WH-900n, my desktop headphones I use for meetings. Awful sound if just wired. Wired + power on works okayish, but no comparison with how they sound connected to my MacBook.
- Airpods Pro 3. Works well, only when stationary. Even a short walk, let alone a commute bike ride, causes the combo to drop audio, and eventually it drops completely. I tried raising an issue, but apparently this is not fixable due to the miniature device size and the total Wi-Fi + BT module power.
Music I listen to (to understand the genre): Haggard, Metallica, In Flames, Air, Infected Mushroom, Prodigy, God Is An Astronaut.
is there any way to manage podcasts in a different way rather than downloading as a mp3 file as a regular track-song. I mean, like subscribing to a RSS or something to download them different, it is just because news podcasts are an every-day stuff, and the ritual of downloading music is more time-consuming.
I've heard some good things about the Y1 so i decided to look into it, and I'm getting mixed reviews about it, between the Y1 and Y2, some people say the Y1 is good, but I'm also seeing a lot of people say its "cheap garbage", but I'm also seeing the same amount of reviews for the Y2. So I'm wondering is it even worth it to buy a innioasis?
I got an innioasis y2 mp3 player and my airpods will connect and work once but after I turn it off, the next time I use them my airpods will only connect but no sound will come through.
How far you have to scroll on the wheel before the cursor moves is pretty bad imo. I understand the y2 has a better click wheel. Does it make a meaningful difference or no?
I downloaded handbrake to resize videos for my Y2 so that I could then flash reborn on it but I cannot figure out how to get the height and width to show or where it is on handbrake. I looked up that I have to change some of the boxes under dimension for the height and width to show, but I remember “maximum size “ I think was what popped up instead
I just got the innioasis y2 this morning and I can’t seem to find the theme setting even when I click on setting it’s not even there and it won’t tell me when I go on about what firmware I’m on I asked and showes chatgbt and it says it’s 3.2.8 I haven’t seen this anywhereeeeebi need help I was really excited and now I feel sad that I can’t make my y2 cute
For context, I’ve had my Y1 for almost a year now but I stopped using it because of the crashes. I do own an iPod touch now but I’m running out of storage. So please, tell me about any bugs or if the Y2 has similar issues to its counterpart
Added a photo because it took forever to figure out how to add a theme also lol
If anyone also has any recommendations for how to convert Spotify downloads into mp3 files it would be really appreciated. I have some downloaded but I’m unable to extract or alter the files due to permission access or something (very new to this)
If getting songs from SoundCloud or any other reliable sites is easier that would also be nice to know!
A few months ago now I had posted here that I was working on a Y1 Rockbox theme heavily inspired by the Metal Gear Solid codec screen.
That ballooned a little when I tried to tie it together with what ended up being a MGS2:Subsistance menu style screen, as well as some other bug fixing relating to the fonts.
But haven taken a week or two away from this little project, I feel like the time needed to add anything new, or smooth out any of the quirks that I am not fond of will take a significant amount of time and result in a bit more stress than I would like for something that so far has been a lot of fun!
If anyone is considering writing their own theme, just go for it!
The github page below has a link to the theming guide on the rockbox page as well as a few already existing themes that were really well laid out and relatively easy to understand.
I am replaying MGS2 at the moment and every time I played it I found a new something that inspired a little tweak to the theme which was a lot of fun!
Some of the background text references game over screens, VR mission complete screens, random text graphics found on the textures within VR levels. Lots of little bits.
It was really fun trying to tie these elements together into a visually cohesive theme. I know I was not 100% successful, and I was not expecting to be. I am not a creative person so it took a lot of self awareness and corrections to get the theme this far. One thing that will always bug me is, despite the alert inspired battery meter on the main menu being authentic to the game, the colours just don't sit well with the rest of the elemets on the screen.
But like I say, the time to really iron out this last 5-10% of things would really suck the fun out of this project so I am happy to share it in this state thinking it may be of interest to a few of you.
If anyone can get a joke "FISSION MAILED" screen to work and not bork the device, you have my respect. That was the 1 easter egg I just could not get my head around. I don't know if its a rockbox limitation or a me limitation but yea I ran out of ideas on that one after a few days.
Some caveats, the text fonts are not perfect. Striking a balance between readability, authenticity to the games, and mono spacing for the numbers so the timers behaved like the frequency readout in the game took a lot of tinkering and you very well may find limitations depending on how you prefer your music to be presented/use any special glyphs. Sorry if this is the case.
The main menu also has a few elements hidden as I do not use them (FM radio for example). The default list can be turned back on if you have a read of the readme file on the github.
If this bothers you, I encourage you to get into the .sbs & .wps files and make it work for you. I wont be insulted :)
Finally, what is next:
I do not expect to be working on this rockbox theme any further.
It was a lot of fun but I think I have bumped into a few limitations with the rockbox theme engine that will limit anything else I want to do.
Going forward, I am looking into making themes for Y2Reborn.
There seems to be a few elements / functionality in there that might be really interesting to explore. Also, the implementation of .ttf files and not rockbox formatted font files will be a significant improvement based off of testing so far.
I have been developing a Linux based Rockbox port that has gotten stable enough that I am willing to share and ask for testers.
It is a hosted Rockbox port, but instead of Android, it runs in Linux userspace with the original Android kernel. It has extra features, like Bluetooth receiver, better battery and QoL features like iTunes syncing. This leads to better battery life, performance and even more app potential, as we are no longer restricted by Android 4.2.2.
Information
Not working
WiFi
Vibration motor
FM Radio
Microphone
Internal speaker
Working
Bluetooth (TX, RX / SBC, SBC XQ / AVRCP)
Headphone audio (with inline controls)
Display
SD Card
eMMC (unused, Android is intact)
USB
Etc.
READ BEFORE INSTALLING
I only build for the Y1, TypeA, pre 3.0.7. However, if you are willing, please test on a variation of the device and make an issue on GitHub with diagnostic info (can be retrieved in Bootpicker Menu -> Debug Info)
Everything is open source (except MTK files). You can build yourself.
Of course, this is experimental. If you are unfamiliar with the terms, I suggest not to install.
Open Bootpicker menu by rapidly clicking MENU until shown
Edit: I understand the overall sentiment that AI is used and means it is bad. However, please do note that other Y1 custom firmware projects also use AI, to varying degrees. (Rondo, inniclassic, better-y, etc. i am not stating that they are 100% AI or bad because of this. I feel like this is unjust. If you will not use my firmware because of AI, you also shouldn’t use any of those firmwares too.
I am more transparency about AI usage, but it does not mean that I have used AI for every part of the steps. For example, I test the firmware on device and I create all the presentations.
I understand if you do not choose to use the firmware because of AI. But, you should be at least kind about it, and keep both perspectives in mind. If you are concerned for its safety, since it only flashed BOOTIMG, if anything goes wrong, you can flash BOOTIMG from an official stock image and everything will go back to normal, because you only flashed BOOTIMG and not other partitions
Hello, so I recently got the Y1 and hooked up Rockbox to it along with a bunch of songs. I have Skullcandy ANC 2’s as bluetooth headphones, and for whatever reason, it will “connect” to the player and the headphones will audibly say “Connected” for a few seconds (while playing no audio through the headphones nor player), and then the headphones say they were disconnected, but the player still thinks they’re connected.
I’ve heard the Bluetooth is a little finicky, but does anyone know a solution to this? Anything helps.