r/interesting • • 4d ago • Bravo 1

SOCIETY California has passed a law requiring age verification to buy creatine

Post image
4.8k Upvotes

4.3k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hello u/UnknownVellichor! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.9k

u/david1610 4d ago • Bravo Mindblown

If creatine needs to be locked up for young people's health then sugary drinks and McDonald's, which arguably leads to more sickness should also be banned.

We don't want to get into a situation where we ban perfectly fine things for young people while forgetting about the really genuinely damaging things like obesity etc

430

u/ElderberryPrior27648 4d ago • This Bravo

The article title is a little disingenuous

Creatine was caught in a wide cast net requiring age verification for the purchase of various supplements.

Whether or not blanket bans/restrictions are acceptable is another animal though

76

u/RsnCondition 4d ago

You know that clarification would really help it's cause with the head lines.

48

u/ElderberryPrior27648 4d ago edited 4d ago

I think it’s intentional

Folks are villainizing it on purpose. Banning creatine as part of a catch-all is silly. It shoulda been reworked before it passed. But if you get enough folks worked up over the silly parts of a bill, it’ll never come close to passing.

Maybe adding creatine to the catch-all is their way of making sure supplements don’t all just rebrand to creatine since there’s no real regulation anyways.

Regulating supplements takes a whole demographic out of the market. I’d assume there’s large monetary incentive for this to not pass or to get overturned

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

81

u/manicmonkeys 4d ago

Exactly...side effects of something as well-studied and overall beneficial as creatine are SO much less worth worrying about as compared to high-sugar products that anybody can buy.

26

u/DefinitelyNotAliens 4d ago

Cities in California are already taxing sugary drinks to fund health programs. People also look at limiting max sugary drink size if it's sold in a to-go cup.

Most fail because they try and limit to 16oz and people want their large Dunkin and Starbucks drinks so cutting to 24 oz would likely be easier and limit those like half-gallon gas station drinks.

→ More replies (26)

72

u/BlueRedGreenNumber5 4d ago

The movie industry threw a fit when mayor Bloomberg tried to ban huge size sodas in movie theaters in NYC. Capitalism prevents progress when it cuts into corporate profits.

22

u/SovietFreeMarket 4d ago

Everyone threw a fit cause it was fucking stupid and implemented badly

25

u/Russian-8ias 4d ago

Or, maybe people just like the product that was getting banned (huge shocker)? Theaters know that people like to buy the large drink. If the large drink gets banned, less people go to theaters to watch movies and theaters are forced to increase the price of the smaller drinks (or price increases elsewhere) to make up for lost drink profits, driving more people away.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (21)

8

u/JAT_Cbus1080 4d ago

San Fransisco did something similar like a decade ago. They put a tax on sugary drinks to up the price and discourage excessive consumption, and the right called them Nazis.

→ More replies (48)

172

u/Top_Kaleidoscope3248 4d ago

i'm completely out of the loop
what's the controversy with creatine and why does it need an ID?

158

u/SpaceGhost4004 4d ago

It's dumb. It has to do with body image and eating disorders.

Creatine is one of the most studied supplements. I take it and noticed a big difference in my strength, and muscle growth. Apparently newer studies are showing it's good for your brain and potentially can reduce the risk of concussions. The only real downside is that it can upset your stomach if you take too much.

77

u/FlamesOfDespair 4d ago • Bravo

Creatine is safe. Teenagers can't be trusted to drink enough water.

17

u/INDE_Tex 4d ago

20 years ago a dude on the wrestling team drank his creatine with everclear. After class. It was 8AM.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

27

u/Sintobus 4d ago edited 4d ago

It's more an issue of dosage in younger adults and kids. Not so much an issue lf the supplement it's self. Apparently there has been an upwards trend of young adults with shot livers kidneys from over usage.

Last post I saw about it a week or two ago had a number of people commenting on their medical experience and seeing it for themselves at hospitals.

→ More replies (10)

6

u/MrCornBluff 4d ago

I mean the real question is what are benefits and risks for minors? Adults can still get it even with this law

→ More replies (8)

9

u/whoitis77 4d ago

Ok so one of my kids are high-school age last year 4kids in there school that thay know how got gallstones because of overdoing creatine and not drinking enough water and thats only the kids that they know of.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Warden18 4d ago

I appreciate this info. Generally, what is considered too much? I've taken a break from lifting in the last 4 months, but was considering taking whatever minimum amount might help with brain function. I think the only other thing I heard was that you need to drink a lot of water or it could hurt your kidneys? That's conjecture of mine, I may be confusing creatine with something else.

15

u/hotchiplow 4d ago

I would say at least 16 truckloads would be too far, but I’m not a doctor

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (40)

133

u/Onebraintwoheads 4d ago • Bravo

Creatine is a chemical required for your muscles to function; they literally would not be able to contract without this chemical. It's generated by your body automatically, but you can take it as a supplement. It's good for going to the gym and getting in more exercise each visit. The thing is your body burns through it and creates a waste product called creatinine. Your kidneys process creatinine and piss it out at a very specific rate, so there are blood tests which look at the amount of creatinine in your blood to see how effective your kidneys are. High creatinine levels normally indicate some form of kidney disease.

As with any substance, there is a dose where medicine becomes poison. Kids think they can take a fuck load of creatine and be jacked in a couple weeks, or do that whole alpha thing because they think it will give them more energy. To be clear, it doesn't give more energy. It gives the muscles more fuel so they can function just a little bit longer. And it's not often that a person works themselves to complete muscular exhaustion. And kids taking far too much creatine end up poisoning themselves and causing kidney failure. It's sort of like how too much Tylenol could cause liver failure, but I don't think it's prohibited for kids to purchase tylenol, is it?

12

u/ProteinPapi777 4d ago

Got it wrong chief

Taking creatine commonly triggers a "false alarm" on standard kidney function blood tests, it doesn’t actually cause kidney damage

→ More replies (1)

74

u/Weekly_Broccoli1161 4d ago

No one is overdosing on creatine. Caffeine is literally more dangerous. 

37

u/Cool-Coat8412 4d ago • Bravo

It looks like the actual law is more comprehensive and does include caffeine heavy supplements like pre-workout

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (38)

17

u/Raven019 4d ago edited 4d ago • Mindblown

It is also good for the brain.

Edit: for

→ More replies (13)

8

u/TommyTwoTxmes 4d ago

Creatine has other benefits when it comes to cognitive function. Some abuse it and take too damn much. I take it every day and i dont work out daily. I run and i lift weights at home once in a while.

→ More replies (39)

10

u/footluvr688 4d ago edited 3d ago

Controversy:

1: idiots who don't understand what creatine is or what it does and are in hysterics, commonly grouping it inappropriately with anabolic steroids.

2: idiots who think restricting sale of one of the most well-known, documented, and studied supplements will somehow help people with body dysmorphia or eating disorders

3: idiots who think kids and teens are rampantly buying and consuming creatine to ill-effect

7

u/MitigatedHope 4d ago

I think it’s a bit of a tik tok/clavicular thing. I just got routine bloodwork recently and my very young doctor asked me if I was taking any because it could throw off my labs. But I also saw a post on here about kidney failure or something, so maybe that’s it.

5

u/Onebraintwoheads 4d ago

Creatinine is the waste product left in your bloodstream when it breaks down creatine. Your body creates creatine at a very specific rate, and your kidneys dispose of creatinine at a very specific rate. So, if you take creatine as a supplement, there will be excess creatinine in your bloodstream. If you were not taking it as a supplement, high creatinine levels mean your kidneys aren't working well. Therefore, creatine as a supplement can fool tests into looking like you are going into kidney failure when you are not. At the same time if you seriously OD on creatine, it will cause kidney failure.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/FullofLovingSpite 4d ago

It adds water to your muscles so they are more hydrated.

That's my understanding. There must be something related to a real steroid that's causing the politicians to do this stupid shit. And yes, I'm upset because now I have to provide ID to some jackass online or only use Amazon, which isn't cool.

3

u/danawhitesthrowaway 4d ago

That's just one of ancillary benefits, the real benefit is increased ATP production which is one of the primary sources of fuel for muscles. Having higher hydration cells is beneficial, but if that was the primary concern you'd be much better off taking glycerol as a preworkout, which is far more effective at hydrating your cells (and gives you great pumps).

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Curious_Avocado2399 4d ago

So people don’t get their undies in a bunch.

CA will require buyers to be 18 years and older for covered products, which include creatine, diet pills, steroids, green tea extract, and other supplements explicitly labeled, marketed, or represented for muscle building or weight loss.

The specific law is AB2030. It looks like it was largely passed without too much opposition. 6 and 2 nays in the assembly and senate respectively. If you want to get into the weeds there’s 12 different analyses from the health and judicial committees from both chambers and more from the chambers at large. It was filed on 2/17 and approved on 9/28. So people had over 6months to submit their objections.

5

u/trackdaybruh 4d ago

Also wanted to add that it’s not illegal for those under 18 to use, their parents simply need to buy it for them.

I buy my creatine on Amazon, wonder how that is going to get delivered next year.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

2

u/reality72 4d ago

Toddlers are getting too swole

→ More replies (25)

31

u/Shadow_Sable 4d ago • Bravo

Now you need a license to bear them arms??

3

u/Cliffinati 4d ago

In California you can't bare arms nor have arms worth showing bare

→ More replies (1)

479

u/Skinnersteamedmyham 4d ago • Bravo

The post is missing context. The age verification requirement is for all supplements marketed for muscle growth which includes creatine. The law isn’t specifically enforcing creatine sales to minors.

166

u/AmyDeferred 4d ago • Mindblown

Pretty soon I'll need a license for these guns kisses biceps

18

u/Dependent-Edge-5713 4d ago

Nah

Just a new "assault weapons" ban

Yes for your arms

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Dragonnstuff 4d ago

Does this include protein?

39

u/MirandaScribes 4d ago

Yep. Gotta show ID to buy chicken breast

23

u/LawrenceOfMeadonia 4d ago

"Hey Kids,, I got some whole grain rice in the back of the truck"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Mathberis 4d ago

Believe it or not : ID to buy milk and eggs.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/maphes86 4d ago

No. It only applies to unregulated supplements that are specifically marketed for rapid weight loss or muscle gain. Creatine Monohydrate isn’t being controlled. Only products like “Gains EXTREME Max Strength Patented Formula” or “PSYCHOTIC DIABLO INTENSE WEIGHT LOSS* THERMO**” and other such products that might appeal to an easily influenced lil’ kid.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/Reddt-iz-cancer 4d ago

So it's yet more dumb overly-broad nanny state enforced control?

Yes, it is. 

→ More replies (23)

2

u/Ok-Squirrel795 4d ago

Thanks for that.i was worried.

3

u/Fabulous_Log844 4d ago

Thank you. Heaven forbid we are accurately reading this and not just triggered.

→ More replies (26)

22

u/valpal1237 4d ago

When I was in high school (99-02), there were 2 guys in my class that got expelled for an entire year for bringing creatine. Everyone was "wtf?" about it at the time.

6

u/Warden18 4d ago

That's wild! I remember using creatine when I was in high school. An entire year? I had heard of less harsh responses involving a kid selling Ritalin in school. What the heck..

3

u/valpal1237 4d ago

Right! I remember the kid running for class body president that year made it a part of his platform for elections, something along the lines of fighting against administration for expelling students for dietary supplements, and getting a standing ovation lmao.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/Lies-and-Alibis-Inc 4d ago

This is making me think of Finn from SVU explaining how the kids are mixing creatine with Robitussin to get high.

5

u/Valleygurl99 4d ago

The dissociative pumps are amazing

→ More replies (1)

73

u/SilentPossibility438 4d ago

I swear i remember an article about creatine being healthy. Not just for bodybuilding stuff, but like helped the body in some way

5

u/AdSweet4217 4d ago

apparently it's great for the elderly to keep muscle strength and cognitive ability in moderate doses.

3

u/Gloomfang_ 4d ago

You body produces around 1g a day so it's not like you are taking something alien

9

u/randompersonx 4d ago

It is, but everything has its limits. Too much can cause all kinds of problems which can land you in the hospital, or worse.

No healthy adult is gonna have a problem with 5-15g… but if some dumb kid tries taking 100+… not good.

7

u/Sudden-Ad-307 4d ago

Should we ban sugar for the same reason then?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Clams_On_Welfare 4d ago

100g is like a quarter of the average container size, this is like banning tide pods because idiots kept eating them. You’re not supposed to do that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (24)

80

u/trer24 4d ago • Popcorn

Be careful when you do your pre-load though. I did more than 20 grams in a day and it caused me to poop violently. Leaked in the underwear and everything before I could make it to the toilet. That was an awkward day in the office.

55

u/NadesGG_Tim 4d ago edited 1d ago

20g/day is an insane preload. And it's honestly not even necessarily.
People, you've spent 30 years of your life unhealthy. No need to try and catch it all up within a week... lol

I love Creatine, but it is NOT a fit for everyone... Both mentally and physically... It can just depend...

BTW, it's been a gout trigger for me recently so I've had to temporarily part ways until my Uric Acid levels come down.

EDIT: Tired of people replying. 20g/day is so fucking unnecessary. Just do 10g max and save yourself the diarrhea and risks that can happen to some people (mainly insomnia - I love the stuff but 10g of creatine too late in the day will cause it for me) when they take too much creatine. The muscle saturation time saved between 10g and 20g is 2-4 days... so 1-2 workouts with a slight edge... cool.... I love the stuff but holy shit loading isn't really gaining you anything. Everyone acts like loading is essential -- IT'S NOT. Don't be tempted to rush to results.

If you wanna FAFO with 20g, be my guest. If it works out, great! If diarrhea or insomnia shows up, well now you know!... Don't put pressure on yourself to persist for the infinitesimally small advantage... Listen to your body.

20

u/HotTubSexVirgin22 4d ago edited 4d ago

“Too fast, too soon does not make up for doing too little for too long.”

(Edit: this quote did not apply directly to the use of creatine, you meatheads. It’s just a good rule in general.)

→ More replies (8)

3

u/AdSelect6571 4d ago

i thought my 10g scoop was 4g so i did 40g preload. 7 days later i figured it was wrong because my 180day bag was half empty

→ More replies (50)

15

u/B1ggBoss 4d ago

Preloads were proven to be unnecessary

13

u/johnsonfromsconsin 3d ago • Heartwarming

At some point in every man’s life you’re gonna trust a fart…and lose.

5

u/PlutoJones42 3d ago

Luckily mine happened in the shower so I just shit on the floor a little bit

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Whole_Opinion8211 3d ago

Which point? I'm 28, how much longer do I have lol?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/LairdPeon 4d ago

Yea its typically not recommened to take 4-5x the recommend dose/serving of anything. Drink 5x the amount of water recommend every day and see what happens. Eat 5x the recommended salt, meat, fruits, ibuprofen, literally anything.

9

u/TheOGRedline 4d ago

“An apple a day keeps the doctor away”
(Eats 87 apples)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Simple-Sun2608 4d ago

Pre loading is old school. You can use it without preloading according to latest information.

15

u/xCaliburghost 4d ago

Pre loading periods are totally unnecessary

7

u/Certain-Towel-9487 4d ago

I'm on the toilet constipated as fuck and jealous how easy it was for you to shit that day.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/average_parking_lot 4d ago

Preloading is a dumb scam, take 5g and be fucking patient for like 2 weeks. I don't even know who invented that, its like you get prescribed a new medicine take 4 pills a day so you can wean off to 1 after a couple weeks, defies basic logic.

6

u/Important_Capital875 4d ago

Just a bunch of dumbasses, so you go through product quicker and have to buy more so you spend more money and make them more money

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/KeyClacksNSnacks 4d ago

Bad day to be a yoga instructor.

8

u/RDX_Rainmaker 3d ago

You deadass might just be getting old, man. Never trust a fart after age 25 ong

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Vlad_of_yesterday 4d ago

Your preload downloaded sporadically? 😉

4

u/BDunnn 4d ago

Creatine preloading phases are unneccesary as a whole. taking 5 grams daily reaches the exact same muscle saturation point. It takes a little bit more time, but its the same thing.

4

u/Important_Capital875 4d ago

Yeah, that’s because you weren’t drinking enough water.

However, much water you drink normally, when you take creatine, you need to drink 25% more at least minimum

3

u/StumblingBlockson 4d ago

Preloading is nonsense and is known to be ineffective... unless your fitness goals include intestinal expediency.

4

u/another_jackhole 4d ago

Orifice, you mean? :D

I'm sorry for your pain. 

4

u/SolfulSin 4d ago

Preloading causes premature unloading?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BeenDragonn 4d ago

Ah creatine shits. Mac mentioned these in an Always Sunny episode!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Relevant_Bed_9743 4d ago

comes with the Territory i shit my pants every day at work

2

u/Manawah 4d ago

Yea pre loading creatine isn’t necessary at all and probably isn’t good for you

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MaroonHawk27 4d ago

It’s because you’re supposed to boof it

2

u/MyOthrNameIsBetter 3d ago

You only need 5-10g tops. Your body is going to flush the extra creatine out. Add a little fiber powder to your diet. 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hungry_Site_3636 4d ago

lol what I do 20g daily and never had issue

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (42)

573

u/Digndagn 4d ago • Bravo

lol, I did a quick google search and it's because looksmaxxing is putting boys into hospitals with eating disorders, that's the impetus for the bill. The creatine restriction is about concern about the impact of muscle gain on bone plates. This is fine. I don't mind if my 14 yo can't go to vons and buy hella creatine

181

u/LordGold_33 4d ago • Bravo

That's not at all how creatine works. It's not a steroid. It's in the food we eat everyday. You can take creatine everyday and be thin as a rail. The muscle gain comes from actually working out, and that doesn't come abnormally fast unless you're taking steroids or growth hormones. Creatine is one of the few well-studied supplements that's shown numerous benefits to both the body and mind in terms of energy and cognitive performance. A lot of people even take creatine just for the cognitive benefits.

51

u/eonblu 4d ago

Yeah, this age check is confusing to me. Is there a problem with kids eating too much powder? I've heard the only risk is gut issues if your body doesn't tolerate it or if you consume too much and not enough water.

Can confirm, I don't work out much, but I take creatine every day for other benefits. I'm slim.

I'd sooner like to see age bans on the ridiculous skin care products that kids are going mad for.

21

u/LordGold_33 4d ago

It's definitely a case of picking the wrong battles. There's so much stuff we have access to that's actually terrible for us. The creatine thing is just weird. I suppose you can take too much and not hydrate enough, but overconsumption of anything has negative effects, so I don't see that as a strong argument. And yeah, it can unsettle sensitive stomachs. That's how it was for me at first before getting used to it and eating better in general. Also a slim guy here!

→ More replies (2)

13

u/serestar 4d ago

Not an expert but from what I saw, it is due to overconsumption and not enough water and it causing issues with kidneys or something like that. Kids are taking copious amounts, several times a day, and like most things too much causes issues.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/bblaine223 4d ago

I put my parents on it just for the cognitive benefits that have been studied. If it gives them a little boost and keeps neurological issues at bay for a little while, hell yea. And if they get jacked and start body building as seniors, hell yea. But really, it’s not an anabolic steroid, it just helps replenish the cells with ATP during the Krebs cycle.

11

u/Chagdoo 4d ago

Looksmaxxers hit themselves in the face with a hammer. Do you think they know fuck all about creatine?

10

u/PsillyFunGuy2 4d ago

Well it’s obvious. We need to ban hammers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

20

u/leandrobrossard 4d ago

If only taking creatine meant my muscles started growing uncontrollably to the point of fucking with my bones

31

u/mattydrinkwater 4d ago

If creatine could make you grow that much muscle that fast it would have been illegal decades ago.

44

u/[deleted] 4d ago

And so what the fuck does creatine have to do with any of this? Do you think creatine is an anabolic steroid or something?

7

u/Several-Sandwich4692 4d ago

Newsome suggested as much. Too lazy to google it, but he thinks these kids over index on steroid abuse later.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Futuramoist 4d ago

Because laws don't have to make sense they just have to look like you care about a problem 

→ More replies (11)

46

u/MagicPigGames 4d ago

How dare you do a google search instead of just responding.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/RobKohr 4d ago

Kids putting on muscle impacting bone plates has long been debunked. Creatine has been shown in numerous studies to be safe. 

→ More replies (7)

6

u/No_Cold296 4d ago

The real problem here is childhood obesity, not creatine and fitness lmfao. If Newsome and any of his supports actually gave a fuck they’d be more prone to limiting fast food.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/radioborderland 4d ago

Lifting doesn't stunt growth, and even if it did, you're not getting rid of lifting by banning the sale of creatine.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/TiddyFukMyButtcheeks 4d ago

Its weird how that works. A controversial law suddenly makes sense when you know the why.

66

u/MotherTeresaOnlyfans 4d ago

But it *doesn't* make sense.

Creatine is not going to give you so much muscle it damages the "bone plates".

That's not how anything works or has ever worked.

This is like treating cappuccino as if it's meth.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (38)

208

u/Shpion007 4d ago

wtf. Creatine is super safe and they recommend you take it daily now.

123

u/Rude-Collection568 4d ago • Bravo

It is very safe BUT not the way kids and teenagers are drinking it. Since kids are growing to want to be adults at 8 years old they are taking supplements and medicine that is not fit for their tiny bodies

17

u/Sensitive_Bat_9211 4d ago

What 8 year old is purchasing creatine at the store?

This is something that is being given to them by their parents

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

20

u/Ok-Hyena4541 4d ago

They don't want 12 year olds taking triple an adult dose. If a kid needs/wants it then their parents can buy it and oversee them taking it.

77

u/AshRemnants 4d ago

California treats everyone like a stupid toddler.

11

u/Which-Decision 4d ago

Teenagers with eating disorders are stupid toddlers. 

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Thoughts-AndPrayers 4d ago

Every state treats adults like toddlers.

75

u/Strongbow7447 4d ago • Bravo

Well, understandable given how smart the rest of the country is.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (17)

2

u/waterboy8817 4d ago

Who is “they”

4

u/Appeltaart232 4d ago

Super safe if you’re over 18. And can exacerbate gastrointestinal issues. Ask me how I know (even with extra water and taken with breakfast in the morning)

→ More replies (32)

16

u/Hot_Poetry_6475 4d ago

what does creatine do?

27

u/orangepoison_ 4d ago

It makes the cells in your muscles hold more water which will make them recover faster (if you’re actively tearing them a lot from weight lifting) … but your body naturally makes it and you should be drinking plenty of water while lifting anyway.

18

u/seefourslam 4d ago

Why would that require age verification?

37

u/BarracudaFlimsy3855 4d ago

it shouldn't. People are stupid though.

→ More replies (51)
→ More replies (23)

7

u/91gnarnuaatg81 4d ago

It’s also supposedly got some mental benefits like mild mood stabilization and focus. I can’t say if I know how true that is, but I heard that and figured it was harmless enough to try. Maybe it’s placebo, but it’s been working for me. 

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

6

u/SuperCaptSalty 4d ago

Pump you up!

5

u/Realistic-Cress-2364 4d ago

As your body turns ATP into ADP creatine helps convert the ADP back into ATP helping with activity and recovery. They have also studied the effects on your brain helping during stress and the elderly as well

2

u/Reddt-iz-cancer 4d ago

It's good for you, even if you don't lift.

It's literally the most studied supplement ever. 

2

u/Independent-Mud3314 3d ago

its been shown to also help with brain stuff, helping emtional dysregulation etc due to how it helps hydration with the blood brain barrier or something.

→ More replies (21)

22

u/WillyGivens1 4d ago

Oi mate, you got a license for these gains?

→ More replies (3)

14

u/sumeriandisputations 4d ago

I take it primarily for intestinal health.

Really helps keep inflammation down.

Supposed to be good for the brain and neurons too.

5

u/kishenoy 4d ago

Considering I have brain damage from surgery, I'm thankful I'm taking it

7

u/SolfulSin 4d ago

More items for Walmart to lock up in cages. They seem to love this.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/mindgardening 4d ago

Only 1.5 months after California FINALLY made child marriage illegal.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/war-ape 4d ago

So dumb. Caffeine is more dangerous than creatine, and yet it is more readily available

→ More replies (57)

10

u/sumwatovnidiot 4d ago

Beware: I tried creatine just once and I’ve been dead ever since

5

u/theothersideofit1 4d ago

So CA can legally permit a minor to receive gender-transition surgery while prohibiting that same minor from purchasing a muscle-building creatine supplement? Listen i dont care either way, you do you - but this seems stupid.

47

u/Puzzleheaded_Taste39 4d ago

Wow, Homelessness is a all time high, Cost of living is through the roof, fuel through the roof and the state has a mass Exodus.

And this is what they come up with?

6

u/FireFoxUse 4d ago

There's always the bigger issue yet these people focus on these kinds of issues

3

u/Direct_Fennel7500 4d ago edited 4d ago

What makes you think they only focus on this kind of issue?

→ More replies (15)

23

u/Mirikado 4d ago

This line of thinking is stupid af and Reddit always eats it up because it’s snarky bs.

So because a bigger problem exists, we are not allowed to deal with any other problems in the meantime? Wow how dare we fix local potholes when kids in Africa are still starving to death?? How dare we build libraries when cancer still exists?? Damn, why don’t we just cure cancer and solve world poverty first before we pass a bill to make groceries cheaper?

Juvenile thinking at its peak.

14

u/CalmSun7903 4d ago

How is creatinine a problem? It’s the most studied supplement and it’s been available for so long. Nobody is really suffering from using it. They should crack down on OH7 instead.

→ More replies (15)

7

u/super7800 4d ago

But this isn't even a problem...

6

u/Justforargumesnts 4d ago

What problem did they solve? This is like banning protein. Creatine is perfectly safe

14

u/AquaRegia 4d ago

This is a made up problem though.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/polarjunkie 4d ago

That would work if this was a real problem. It's not.

→ More replies (22)

7

u/ghost650 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

No, this is just the way you decided to frame it.

CA is a huge state with thousands of employees working for the State government. The fact that this law was passed has nothing to do with the other issues you cited. Yes, those are ongoing issues, but many of them have nothing to do with what the state is doing. For example: CA did not attack Iran and disrupt oil supply which is the primary cause of the price increase of gas.

9

u/SuperWallaby 4d ago • Bravo

What is the cause of Californias gas being much higher than the rest of the country?

→ More replies (33)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (16)

4

u/Formal-Agent87 4d ago

Lmao what a ridiculous thing to even bother wasting time restricting. Its not even harmful and would be beneficial

4

u/Appropriate_Elk_952 4d ago

bring back my menthols newsom

4

u/ClosedL00pSystem 4d ago

My wife’s boyfriend is going to hate this 

4

u/calico810 1d ago

The most harmless supplement lol Protein powder damages kidneys easily and creatine does nothing lol

19

u/Economy_Release_5574 4d ago

California does the most stupid shit🤦🏻‍♂️

7

u/abzlute 4d ago

Tbf I think it's a blanket policy on supplements and creatine is just caught up in that. People abusing preworkout and companies abusing the lack of regulation of supplements are documented and fairly compelling reasons to restrict the market from teenagers.

I think there are compelling arguments for why it's dumb and there are better uses of political capital, but still I kinda get the idea.

3

u/aRandomRedditor9000 4d ago

Age verification makes more sense for pre workout than creatine

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/AffectionNeed 2d ago

The health benefits of creatine and the actual science behind the decades of study show positive benefits across the board for men, women, muscle, cognitive health…. These douchebag politicians don’t care about you or me. Why California keeps voting for the same people over and over again is literal insanity.

6

u/Perfecshionism 1d ago edited 1d ago

Parents can still buy it for children.

But there are some risks. Especially among children taking too much while chasing gains because of influencers.

→ More replies (81)

2

u/SixskinsNot4 10h ago

Well can’t kids just steal it now? It’s not over $999 so nothing anyone will do about it

2

u/pussycrumbs 9h ago

Creatine for brain health!

→ More replies (60)

7

u/BarracudaFlimsy3855 4d ago

Well... IMMA STOCK UP WHILE IT'S STILL LEGAL

6

u/Ok_Dragonfruit_2185 4d ago

You can sell it as "pre-prohibition" creatine

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/SnakeShaft 4d ago

How would one verify their age. With an…ID perhaps?

11

u/sierra-soul 4d ago

can you point to where in the constitution the word creatine is found?

5

u/sfbiker999 4d ago

Right under the section where it says ID has to be presented to purchase alcohol. And sudafed.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Just_Aioli_1233 4d ago

Right next to the part about abortion being a right

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/silvermoka 4d ago

Correct, and our tax dollars should go toward making sure that all eligible creatine purchasers can obtain an ID without obstruction

13

u/OfficialNightFlower 4d ago

Let me tell you how this disproportionately affects black americans

→ More replies (15)

2

u/Earth_Worm_Jimbo 4d ago

Maybe a background check?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Sorry-Value 4d ago

No one in this comment section knows what creatine does. That’s funny

3

u/ImNotNuke 4d ago

What does it do oh wise one from the depths?

2

u/Dtoodlez 4d ago

Exactly.

3

u/PristineAd9986 4d ago

So show ID for creatine, but not for voting?!?!?!?

3

u/starfox-skylab 4d ago

What a loser

15

u/SypeSypher 4d ago

what in the gateway-to-steroids tomfoolery is this?

8

u/PreciousTC 4d ago

I didn't realize people still believed in gateway drugs

→ More replies (4)

7

u/mad_pony 4d ago

can we pass the same law for social media instead?

3

u/david1610 4d ago

The problem with social media bans for younger people has never been if it's good or bad for young people, almost everyone agrees it's good, the problem has been inforcing it and what that means for generally using the internet.

For example in Australia, the social media bans for people under 16 is likely working, however it means that everyone has to verify their age now for many websites which is a pain.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pudgelover69 4d ago

Gawd what a nerd

5

u/Reasonable-Donut1879 4d ago

“Son, you pissed hot for creatine. You’re off the football team. ✌️ “

8

u/MaximumImpressiMe337 4d ago • Popcorn Heartwarming

Californians keep winning. Voted no to tax billionaires and now an id for creatine. At least we can have throuples now.

25

u/MCDuds 4d ago • Bravo

lol ID for creatine but if you ask for an ID to vote your racist. This makes all the sense.

→ More replies (13)

9

u/Cliffinati 4d ago

Absolute nanny state nonsense

→ More replies (1)

9

u/strokeright 4d ago

Ridiculous. Leftists politicians are associating getting fit, bodybuilding with the far right. This is just making it worse.

→ More replies (17)

2

u/-haru_haru- 4d ago

This is great! My roommate went to the ER for too much creatine.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/deeper-diver 4d ago

You mean... an ID is required?

2

u/different_produce384 4d ago

Good. That shit stunted my growth in high school.

2

u/SnoopingStuff 4d ago

Kidneys thank you

2

u/Olosabbasolo 2d ago

Here comes the black market creatine....

2

u/Sudden_Buffalo9098 2d ago

California being California. Over regulation. Creatine is simply good for you.

2

u/Various-Muffin4145 1d ago

Worthless individual!

6

u/usernamehudden 4d ago edited 4d ago

Great - if a parent or doctor thinks it is important for their kids to have creatine, they can purchase or prescribe it for them.

This also bans under 18 purchase of supplements and weight loss pills which are notoriously under regulated/tested/verified. Plus, kids that are still going through puberty probably shouldn't be taking half that crap without being under the care of a doctor or monitored by a parent.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/jeropian-moth 4d ago

Moving too far into that UK style of “protecting” their citizens.

3

u/StumblingBlockson 4d ago

It doesn't even do anything if you're not boofing it with an unlubed beer bong and an air compressor. You can find posts from scientific experts and links to peer-reviewed, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials at r/creatine 

3

u/ryukeio 4d ago

This is because of the supplement industry being a Wild West essentially. There’s tons of ways to hide other things in a product labeled as creatine and some of that shit can be extremely harmful.

Implementing and enforcing industry quality standards to change would be far harder to do.

This way actually lets scumbag companies keep being scumbags and just gives a bit of protection to the youth population. And everyone is still free to buy “XXL MegaDEATH Militia CREATINEXMAX”, as long as they’re of legal age.

It’s fascinating that most of the commentators haven’t looked up the why on this. I’d think most of us taking supplements would hopefully stay up to date with the literature and process of what we’re putting down our throats lol.

2

u/Jokuki 4d ago

Supple industry being the Wild West is due in part to the DSHE Act of 1994. Basically lets all supplements be sold unless they have been specifically proven to be harmful. All the health claims are practically unregulated letting companies have the most ridiculous marketing.

3

u/Pootisman16 4d ago

Meanwhile you can buy Monster Energy by the gallon, which promotes diabetes and heart disease.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Conscious-Honey-8078 4d ago

You have to be of age to buy creatine but you can drink an unlimited amount of sugar at any age and blow up to 350lbs as a toddler with zero repercussions.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Cultural-Judgment786 4d ago

I mean It's California, fuckin dorks can identify as being old enough to purchase and they will go with it

→ More replies (2)

3

u/nthensome 4d ago edited 4d ago

I'm sorry but what's wrong with creatine now?

I thought it was being recommended to take daily for physical & mental health now....

Why downvotes? Just honestly asking a question

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ryansports 4d ago

This is soooo high on the list of important shit we need to fix in this state. *insert sarcasm here *she said insert

2

u/wwplkyih 4d ago

A sad day for swolemaxxing.

2

u/Gym_Nut 4d ago

Once again, the government has proven how effective they are at tackling nonexistent problems while ignoring the actual problems in our country.