Hey all,
I wanted to share my express replacement experience to provide some insight into what the process is like at the moment and some potential shortfalls. Fair warning, it’s a lengthy read below. I put a TLDR at the end.
Long lengthy version
Overall I’ve had a very negative experience going through the process. It’s been a nightmare trying to get a replacement.
For some context behind the replacement, I’ve been having massive battery drain issues with my Black Titanium iPhone 16 Pro despite it still being at 90% capacity. I’ve been getting 4 hours of screen on-time very consistently despite getting 7-8 hours with identical use from when I got the phone to January 2026. I don’t do heavy use tasks on my iPhone such as gaming or editing. Just basic apps, music, safari and social media.
I’ve had many appointment at the Genius Bar and with Apple support online only to have no success with resolving the drain issues. Pretty much tried everything software wise to resolve the issue.
At this point an express replacement seems like the logical next step for me. So I escalate to a Senior advisor and they offer to do an express replacement for me.
The first express replacement came quickly and in the correct configuration. However.. the replacement 16 Pro had multiple scuffs and scratches on the Titanium frame. It looked worse than my OG 16 Pro from 2024 after 2 years of use…
So I called to see what they could do and they told me to return the device and once they receive it to call back and they’d start the process anew.
I did just that and they ordered another express replacement. This time, Apple messaged me saying they had no Black 16 Pros in stock so they were shipping me a White 16 Pro with upgraded storage.
It was really nice of them to up the storage but I’m not a fan of the colour. So I reached out to see if there was any possibility of waiting for a black one to come back in stock.
They said I could either get an email listing what they have in stock for me to choose from, I can opt to wait for a black 16 Pro restock, or choose appeasement where they wave the fee. I asked how much the fee was, they told me, and I told them I’d like to proceed with an email of options or to wait for a black one and cancel the shipping request (Said the phone wasn’t out yet at that point). She confirmed the shipping request was cancelled and that I would get an email.
A few hours later I get a notification from FedEx that the white 16 Pro shipped. I was confused since they just told me they cancelled it. So I called back and they told me that the previous advisor said I chose the appeasement option (I did not). I told him that this was incorrect and relayed the previous events. He apologized and told me to return the white iPhone and give them a call after so they can start the process again.
I receive the white iPhone a few days later and return it as instructed. Get confirmation it’s received by them and processed.
At this point I noticed my AppleCare transferred to the iPhone they told me to return and that it did not transfer back to my original phone I still have.
I called them to see if they could resolve it. They got the AppleCare returned to my device, and then told me to call back later so I could get another replacement started.
I call again and the Senior Advisor tells me that the other Senior Advisor told me incorrect information. They don’t guarantee the colour, and she should have not have given me that option. He tries to order me another express replacement and informed me the system wouldn’t let him due to an error and to call again to try with another Senior Advisor.
Then my AppleCare disappears again… I call Apple support and the senior advisor tells me they have to escalate the issue to get my AppleCare resolved since it’s still on the replacement phone and is not going back like it’s supposed to. Their engineering team checks it out, I’m told to wait a few days. I then get a call later in the week and then the support advisor asks me for my IMEI and then I’m told to wait another day for a scheduled call.
The schedule time comes and I’m ghosted. So I call support again and they confirm the AppleCare is back on my original iPhone and start the express replacement process again.
Finally, I get an email for the express replacement and it looks alright. They tell me the link expires on November 30th (Which is confirmed again on the email).
I was pretty busy so I waited two days to go through the link and order the new phone.
I try again on November 22nd and it tells me that the case was closed… Now I have to call them AGAIN to restart it.
Overall, I am appalled by the service I have been getting. The support agents themselves have been helpful and empathetic. But there are so many issues that happened and conflicting information that should not happen with a process like this.
TLDR
The ESR process has been a nightmare. 1st replacement was scuffed up. Was told to return and they would try again. They sent me a differently colour and storage. Wasn’t a fan of the colour so I asked what my options are. They told me incorrect information and told me to return it. I returned it as instructed. My AppleCare then got stuck on the returned device. Was a nightmare getting it back. Luckily I did.
Finally they got a ESR ready and then the link erroneously closed..
Curious if anyone else has had trouble with this service? Hopefully you have/had better luck than me, but heads up that this has been at least my experience.