r/keyhouse • u/samayisnoob • 1d ago
Just finished Locke & Key and I finally get why the ratings are so low
(Haven't read the comics yet, I just looked up some of the differences after finishing Season 3.)
I liked the world enough to already order the first book, but man, Netflix handled this series in the most annoying way possible. Season 1 was a bit slow, which I didn't mind at all because it needed time to build up the characters, their friend groups, and the mystery of the keys. Seasons 2 and 3 picked up the speed and leaned way harder into the thriller and horror side, which I loved. The problem is this story easily had 6 or 7 seasons in it (especially with 40+ keys in the comics compared to the 24 we got), and instead they just tried to finish it as fast as possible and left a ton of plot holes.
Nobody ever explains why only Lockes can hear Whispering Iron or forge keys. Uncle Duncan just casually drops rules about how the family finds keys when they need them, and Benjamin Locke magically hears the metal to make the Omega Key and the Black Door with zero explanation. Same thing with who even built the Wellhouse, or why Chamberlin Locke is the only Locke ancestor hanging around the graveyard out of 250 years of family history. And how did Captain Frederick Gideon walk up to a bare cave wall in 1775 and activate the blue portal just by touching it, like there's an invisible fingerprint scanner built into a rock? Then they tell us magic can only be undone by magic, right up until Gabe collapses the cave in Season 2 and the Black Door randomly swings open without the Omega Key so Ellie can walk out. Just pure lazy writing.
Half the conflict only exists because this family refuses to talk to each other. Keeping Nina completely in the dark turned her into a total liability in a house full of lethal magic, when introducing the Memory Key back in Season 1 so she could actually help would have made way more sense. Tyler refusing to use it out of grief felt like forced drama too, since everyone knew he was going to cave eventually anyway. They also kept brushing off Bode even though he figured out half the stuff first, and they completely wasted the Ghost Key. Their great great grandfather is literally sitting right there in the graveyard watching Keyhouse, and nobody thought to ask him about the family history or the keys.
It's even more annoying because the show proved it could write solid arcs when it actually tried. Sam going from Rendell's killer under Dodge's control to trying to protect the Lockes was great, and Kinsey learning to actually live with her fear instead of locking it out of her head really landed.
A few of Netflix's changes from the comics actually ended up being my favorite parts. Adding the Memory Key was a huge win, and the Gabe twist was GOATED. Sure, if you watch enough thrillers you could clock him as sketchy halfway through Season 1, and I know Dodge infiltrated their circle in the comics too, but inventing the Identity Key so she could hide in plain sight as Kinsey's boyfriend with a totally new face was a sick move. I even liked the Timeshift Key change in Season 3. Making people in the past able to see, touch, and kill you instead of just watching like a ghost made the suspense way higher. When Dodge jumped forward in Bode's body, I really thought they were setting her up as a grey character who teams up with the Lockes to take down Gideon, and then she just vanished way too fast.
For anyone who has read the books, do they actually explain all the lore Netflix skipped, or am I about to get pissed off all over again???