I've started graduate studies in mathematics. If you're privy to the news coming from around there, you would know about the 700 or so problems solved by AI companies, including some Millennium Prize ones. If you've found yourself deeper in the rabbit hole, you would be familiar with some familiar talking points. Either mathematics was, is, and always will be brought to life by a community of like-minded souls encroaching the limits of human comprehension, or just another case study in the inevitable triumph of machine over man, a sign of superintelligence, benign or malign.
Judging from this post title, you can probably tell where I stand.
I believed in the narratives spun by the figureheads who wanted math to survive. I still do. But my faith wavers. Not by rational argument, of course. No one can reliably predict the future, especially with this much uncertainty. But when the light hits just right, when I parse the magic words, read that ominous headline, witness the machinations with my own two eyes, all in the darkness of night, alone, I crack. I become silent, and spiral. Not like a hurricane, but like water draining from a bathtub. A small, localized, flurry of thoughts, about why I even bothered, why I should continue, why my training started at the critical point before a profession fades into obsolescence and becomes nothing more than idle play for the rich.
It happened again when Levent Alpöge claimed that Claude had proved the generalized Riemann Hypothesis.
The other grad students started cracking jokes. Jokes about Claude flying, dancing, and sparkling while churning out Lean. Jokes about the 250,000 page natural language write-up, jokes about how Claude belaboring an explanation on the well-ordering of the real numbers, and jokes about Anthropic's IPO tanking.
Then, the other announcement came.
From my limited knowledge, a postdoc announced some tentative progress towards a proof of the generalized Riemann hypothesis carried out over the past 12 years, without AI assistance, but with the backing of giants in number theory. In the 940 page draft, the author takes care to note that, despite it all, "We are still here. We are very much alive. We are not going anywhere."
Some took this as a sign of the indomitable human spirit. Others plugged the paper into ChatGPT and claimed it found several unfixable errors. I'm not a number theorist, so the only thing I can say is this: if they fucked up, this looks really bad for the rest of us.
There's a nonzero chance that Alpöge's proof is wrong. There's a chance that, within the 17 million lines of Lean code, there is some bug that causes the entire house of cards to fall. There's a chance that the 940 page draft is unfixable, and that announcement will become the final humiliation of the mathematical establishment.
I'm not sure if I ever liked mathematics. I doze off during seminars, and I'm spending my time writing this screed instead of doing my work. As I read Alpöge's statement, the ecstasy is palpable. Proving the Riemann hypothesis was his dream since undergrad, and he kept on gathering any knowledge that could've led to a proof until this moment. I don't think I've ever had that attachment to mathematics. I don't think I've ever had that attachment towards anything. I went to graduate school because I couldn't get any other job outside of academia. Mathematics was always a means to an end for me. I stayed in mathematics during my undergrad, despite being a horrible student, just because I didn't have the gumption to branch out and do anything else. Even now, I'm considering fanciful exit plans once I'm done.
So why I am enraged at all the results getting scooped? Why I am angry on behalf of the pure mathematicians, whose results I will never understand? Maybe I'm denying myself. Maybe there is a significant part of me that enjoys math. Maybe I'm doing this for more than the prestige. Or maybe I hate big tech and how they vie for power and legitimacy. Maybe I despise the people who gleefully adopt AI, dream of a singularity, and gleefully try to excise the humanity and joy out of life in the name of efficiency.
The only thing that has become clearer is this. I will probably won't get a job where I could do math. Tenure-track jobs were already a pipe dream before AI. All that talk about persisting through math despite everything is just empty chatter. Sure, maybe grades aren't everything. But I can't command respect. Professors at my department think I'm some random undergrad. I don't have any air of competence, I have the charisma of a brick, and I'm too shy to make small talk with anyone. My work won't speak for itself, because I don't have anything to show. I know that I am missing whatever ingredient that successful people have. I'm missing the drive to do math, I'm missing the pedantry needed to find correct proofs, I'm missing the charisma to make connections and collaborate with people, and I'm missing a healthy sense of self-esteem.
I guess I had that beaten out of me during my undergrad. I was told to put my value in myself outside of my achievements, but where else can I place it? I've given up on romance to make time for academics, yet I couldn't escape that sense of unease when I saw all the couples at a holiday social. That feeling that time was running out, and I needed to find someone to prove that I was a functional human being and not some reprobate. I don't think I can feel romantic attraction anymore. That's funny, isn't it? Why don't I have the guts to admit this? Why can't I just say it with my chest and be comfortable with it? No one wanted me anyway.
I'm trying to come to terms with the fact that I'll never be good at anything. That I'll be just another nameless face, forgotten within a generation or so. That the arc of the universe does not bend towards justice, or towards evil, but towards entropy. As much as I would like to give into the narratives of AI bros being anti-human autists, I know that isn't true. They're just people, flowing through one of the currents in the river we call history, without any power to control the consequences they've wrought upon the world. There are no simple narratives. There are no Elders of Zion, turning the economy into female daycares to stop the true successors of the white race (trad-cath Latino zoomers). The tech billionaires have no idea what they're doing, and there will be no socialist uprising. Western imperialism won't end. Capitalism is here to stay until civilization dies, not with a bang, but with a whimper.