TW: mentions of suicide, sh and possibly others of the sorts
I want to prefice that when I say "stays" I am (obviously) not refering to all stays, just many that I've encountered. It's completly exhausting to have to write "some stays", "a lot of stays", etc every time.
Okay, I'm sure a lot of people are really tired of the talk about stray kids but this is something that I've thought a LOT about. I myself used to be stay, about 5 years ago they became my life and when I say my life I really mean it. At the peak of my depression 13 year old me needed something to obbsess about, to find enjoyable, a reason to keep going. To me, stray kids "saved" me, I truly believed so, and maybe, to an extent, there was truth to that, but I've come to realise that the fandom was perfectly designed to keep me from getting better.
Of course, not all stays are as deppresed as I once was, but many were and still are. When you are miserable, and finding comfort is a drug, that you believe is curing you. Music, and kpop is something that brings many people happiness, I mean that's why most of us are active in the kpop community, but if your life has very little things to be happy about, finding something that brings you happines becomes a need, an obbsession.
Okay well, so far none of this has been really specific to stray kids, kpop fans are obbsessive, we know. But to me, what stands out about stray kids is the culture that apart of the fandom as built around mental health. Maybe I'm on the wrong side of the internet but I cannot put into words just how many 'edits' I've seen of stays (usually very young ones) making edits with a text that sounds something a long the lines of "I broke our promise to stop *insert something about hurting yourself or trying to off yourself* I made with you *insert "stray kids" or one of the members (usually Chan, we'll also get to this in a moment)*" and although that may sound all nice and dandy in hindsight, we need to realise how goddamn parasocial that is, and how badly it can effect a young teen/preteen. When you live in deppresion, it can easily become your whole life, and especially for someone young, who's still trying to figure out who they are, it becomes their identity, it definetly was for me. Telling yourself that you'll "get better" FOR A KPOP IDOL YOU DONT KNOW, is never going to work, because you've romantisised your illness so much and connected it to the idol that getting better means letting go of that obbsession that you've formed and actually finding an identity out of your deppression and stan life.
This romantisization of mental health is also so obviously reflected onto the members themselves. Stays absoluetly LOVE Han's anxiety, god, the things you see people say about him are so degrading but they do it because they find it relatable, they find comfort in seeing the members struggle, because it makes you feel like you're closer to them, almost like you really know them. I remember I made a rant here a while back about how annoying I found it that people kept insisting that Hyunjin was deppressed and had attempted suicide just because he wore a safety pin necklace (that was probably not a styling choice he made either), and although I'm not saying any of these things couldn't be true, things like this are often said by people who see nothing but their own suffering and are so desperetly trying to see their struggles in the people they idolize.
Telling yourself that the members are struggling also gives you a sense of power. When you believe that someone is having a hard time, and that everybody is pushing them down, EXCEPT YOU, you've become their savior, the who supports them. It's the illusion of closeness, you've come to believe that you can make as big a difference to these people as they can for you. But you're not parasocial!!!! Because you don't want to date them!!! This is also why so many stays love to act like everybody hates the members, because then you're the voctim. And thus, critisism turns into hate, and everybody is againts you... And if I'm being honest, it's almost like the members themself believe you're right.
Remember that speech Chan made..."I'm going to protect you all",, most people did find that pretty cringe worthy, but god did it fuel some people. He's basically telling you that we're more than just a fan and an artist. I reallllyy hate to say something negative, and honestly I wouldnt be suprised if I got a death threat or two for saying this (but I guess that would prove my point), but Chan, to me seemed to (atleast in the past) push this parasocialism as well. I'm sorry but the amount of stays that consider him "a father figure" is worrying. I think he's made it clear that he has some issues, and even though I think conversation about mental health is important, saying this like "I hate myself too so we have something in common" is only going to make your fans run to talk about how they feel sooo bad for you and how you're just like him. In his defense this was a long time ago, and atleast to my knowledge he doesn't really do stuff like this anymore. I'm just more worried about how these past things STILL TO THIS DAY fuels so many stays parasocialism. A lot of people also treat him like some sort of savior. I'll give him the credit that I think he has made some much needed points regarding important issues, I just hate how this entire fandom treats him like god himself for it. Of course, this is not Chans fault, and it's not like he can completly control the relationship the fandom has decided to have with him, it's just really stood out to me as especially odd.
Theres also the fact that they're close. Or appear to be. So many people talk about how they wish they had a friendship like the members do. I'm sorry but it's become borderline emotional porn. Stays are wayyyy to attached to the thought of stray kids being "family", thats also why the shipping culture is so strong (well, aswell as the fact that the members are veryy good at fanservice) istg you're emotional well-being shouldn't rely on the whether or not a bunch of 30 year old men actually like each other.
I think many agree that stays are a pretty "toxic" fandom, but oh my god is it annoying how much pride they take in it. Does anybody remember that random ahh pole where stays were voted as "the worst" fandom in kpop? I hate how pretty much every stay took that as "they hate us cause they aint us" instead of, yk, maybe a sign that we need to change? I mean in defense of a lot of eyekons, at least I've seen many people say "we really need a fandom cleanse". Have I seen strays say this? Yeah for sure, but not for the reason they should be saying it. Stays have attached themselves so closely to the members that they have become apart of them, and any critisism or expression of opinion is a direct attack on them and they're well being. But to be fair, that's not a lot different to most other fandoms either so...
YES I'm still going, I didn't think this would be so long but oh well I'm already in this deep might as well keep going. I think the main point of conversation with stray kids is their recently declining music quality, to put it nicely, and their lack of rest. It's probably not crazy to say that these two things may be related. As much as stays love to advocate for rest and the well-being of the members, it's hard to believe most stays actually want them to take a break. Again, the members exhausting schedule gives them a reason to be pittied, and it's easier to victimize them in conversation. Stays believe Stray kids deserve awards because they are overworked. You cannot genuenly be againts them being overworked and then use it as a justification for awards. Working hard doesn't make you more desrving of awards, because working constantly doesnt make your work good, actually, quite the opposite. I've seen this same argument been used for enhypen too and it's just so infuriating. I'm sorry but celebration was objectively slop but stays cant admit that because they're so attached to stray kids and they believe that it deserved awards just because they work their asses off. That argument only gives the company (or them idk apparently this is their own choice) a bigger incentive to overwork them even more. Crazy idea, but... maybe... your works value is not determined by how fast you made it and how much you made of it, but rather, on it's quality? Absolutely crazy I know.
I mean, parasocialism and general shittiness (for a lack of a better word) is a pretty big staple for kpop fans overall but this is just something very personal to me because I've been all of the things above, and I hate to admit it, and I hate to admit that I'll truly never go back to stray kids, because I dont believe all of they're music is bad, nor do I believe they're bad producers, I mean they're japanese albums are proof that if they put time and effort into something and dont just mass produce, they do make good music. Hollow and I am YOU will always be some of my favourite kpop albums and I do have a lot of love towards the members, it's just that the fandom has become so unbearable and filled with different issues that I don't think can be fixed. It's really quite dissapointing honestly.
Sorry if some of this is poorly written it's way too late and I'm tired....anyways,, live laugh love and don't let your mental well-being rely on, well preferably anybody, but especially a kpop idol ♡