r/law • • 1d ago • Bravo 1

Legal News Senate Democrat Says He Has Documents Showing Trump FCC Nominee Misled Congress about Jimmy Kimmel Case

https://news.bgov.com/bloomberg-government-news/fcc-nominee-accused-of-misleading-congress-over-kimmel-case
8.8k Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

106

u/bloomberggovernment 1d ago

A Senate Democrat is requesting the Federal Communications Commission provide records to determine whether President Donald Trump’s nominee for commissioner misled Congress.

Danielle Thumann Severs, a senior counsel to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr, gave testimony about her involvement in media-related decisions that contradicts documents obtained by Sen. Ben Ray Lujan (D-N.M.), according to a Friday letter obtained by Bloomberg Government. The dispute concerns the Paramount Global-Skydance Media merger and the controversy surrounding ABC’s suspension of Jimmy Kimmel.

Thumann Severs testified during a committee hearing last week that she hadn’t worked “on any media-related issues” in her time with the agency. Lujan, the ranking member on the Senate Commerce Committee’s telecommunications subcommittee, said that statement and other responses during the hearing “directly contradict documents” he obtained through the Freedom of Information Act.

Read more in the full story.

-Elliot

24

u/TheLZ 1d ago

she hadn’t worked “on any media-related issues”

What has she been doing then? What are we paying her for? Can we ask for a 5 bullet point list of her tasks/projects?

1

u/eats23s 1d ago

Not a defense, but FCC has bureaus. Media is the broadcast and cable one. Wireline deals with wired telecom, wireless with all spectrum matters other than broadcast. She is currently Carr’s Governmental affairs advisor, so could touch any of these issue areas. She clearly knew what the question was and what she was doing by answering it how she did.

1

u/TheLZ 1d ago

But why not say I wasn't involved in that situation. they all sound stupid and my politeness filter is down at this point.

4

u/eats23s 1d ago

Because she was lying and not very experienced in front of adversarial questions? Her entire career has been working for Chairman Carr. She’s completely unqualified for the position.

5

u/mmmtv 1d ago

I'm sure whatever she mislied about was simply a fundamental misinterpretation of either the answer, or the question, or both, or was taken out of context or a thinly veiled attempt by fake news to misrepresent the facts to deceive the American people about the greatness of this administration or <INSERT ANY OF THE USUAL MAGA GASLIGHTING DARVO EXCUSES> ...

429

u/freedfg 1d ago • Bravo

Just remember.

Republicans investigated Jimmy Kimmel and James Comey for criticizing the president.

But see no reason to investigate Epstein or the FAA grounding. Not worth their time.

140

u/Electric_Antimony 1d ago • Bravo Mindblown Regret

Or the state murder of Alex Pretti and Renee Good.

101

u/CTeam19 1d ago

But see no reason to investigate Epstein or the FAA grounding. Not worth their time.

Or the Military having to set off a 5 ton Lead Azide bomb in Iowa.

4

u/jarvisesdios 1d ago

As an Iowan nearby that area, and in the fallout zone... Depending on the model, I'm both extremely mad and want everyone involved fired, fined and let nowhere near anything like this again...

... But I'm also entirely sick of hearing about it. You should see any Iowa subs, that's basically the only thing being discussed and every post is just rehashing the thing I already know.

It's so fucking stupid that they let it get to the point that it did to where the only thing we can do is let it explode. We can't move it, we can't do anything but just blow it up and hope for the best... Even though it's going to poison so so so so many crops and small cities

3

u/PopBulky7023 1d ago

As a country we have allowed too much to slide for too long. This is the result.

1

u/kex 9h ago

It feels like the people with power want to cull the population before unemployment reaches revolutionary levels.

20

u/Decent-Point309 1d ago

Wild in the US that the POTUS is going after people for criticizing him. I understand if you're Republican, but how the fuck can anyone support anything he does at this point?

Many Republicans are outdoors people - and they're trying to sell off land. It's like these people have no morals or standards. As long as it is their team, it's fine.

10

u/YourMumWasRight 1d ago

If only there were checks and balances to stop that kind of thing.

2

u/joesmith127_reddit 1d ago

There are but just mentioning those checks and balances will get you banned by a moderator.

1

u/PopBulky7023 1d ago

You need a fierce opposition party to weild them.

6

u/DontAbideMendacity 1d ago

I understand if you're Republican

I cannot understand ANYONE being that stupid. Republicans are responsible for every recession in the last 100 years. 89 Republicans (including Trump) in the executive branch have been convicted of over 240 felonies since Nixon. The last 4 Republican presidents have added more to the national debt than ever other U.S. President combined. Insurrection, child rape, war crimes... come on!

5

u/PopBulky7023 1d ago

Republicans do not have a coherent ideology beyond "hurt things and people I don't like".

3

u/Decent-Point309 19h ago

That is not at all true.

They must also make the rich richer and the poor more poor.

3

u/mediocrobot 16h ago

Also "Democrats are demons so I have to vote for Republicans or nothing at all"

4

u/TryIsntGoodEnough 1d ago

Oh america remembered... the election results proved that

3

u/dm_me_your_bookshelf 1d ago

No shit. The Epstein files are literally about trump and his lackeys. Reckoning can't come soon enough

309

u/r3dk0w 1d ago

Misled or lied? It’s hard to tell the difference.

122

u/Physical-Dare5059 1d ago

Right, just call it what it is. He lied to Congress.

38

u/Ok-Secretary455 1d ago

At this point I don't really care. We haven't had actual consequences for people in the system for like what? 40 years? Unless you count the one guy that saw any jail time for Iran Contra.

Until we actually hold government officials to the laws its all just theater.

5

u/bebopbrain 1d ago

If he's not confirmed, that's a consequence.

3

u/Fr1toBand1to 1d ago

We literally have not NOT confirmed anyone for like 60 years or something. Every single nominee has either withdrawn themselves or been accepted.

1

u/ncktckr 1d ago

1

u/PopBulky7023 1d ago

But not for any good reason.

3

u/coonwhiz 1d ago

At this point, that’s just a plus to the GOP. They love that they get lied to apparently.

0

u/theapeboy 1d ago

Do you mean she?

14

u/shinyperineum 1d ago

Mislied 

3

u/SundaeFree7010 1d ago

Spewed disinformation from his yapper*

2

u/Protiguous 1d ago

Mislied.

1

u/PopBulky7023 1d ago

It's important to use the right language that clarifies extreme malice. Liberals in particular are very forgiving if they have an ounce of doubt.

32

u/_Bon_Vivant_ 1d ago • Bravo

A Republican lied? Where's my fainting couch?

17

u/KennethTremendous 1d ago

Probably being fucked by JD Vance.

64

u/Custom_Destination 1d ago

Reminder that Kimmel got suspended only because he quoted other people.

23

u/glk3278 1d ago

I have documents showing Trump is an enemy of the state. Can we start with that?

20

u/sweatboxy 1d ago

If lying was a crime, the entire Trump administration is going to jail.

16

u/irrelevantusername24 1d ago

See the problem with the FCC is it isn't doing what it is supposed to do. And because of that, it is causing problems in two ways: by neglecting its actual duty, and distorting the "marketplace of ideas" where it has no business intervening. And that's made worse because, at the same time, they (that I can even say "they" rather than "the FCC" and you know what I mean is part of the issue) argue for a kind of "free speech absolutism"... then do things such as this, which is "enforcement" by way of standardless discretion.

I can buy in to the idea that there should be no limits to free speech. I might not like that idea, and there are clearly situations where that doesn't hold (like in the place where many people lack the fundamental understanding that is they can only enforce that on platforms which are controlled by the government), but it does seem sensible to an extent. Let's go with the idea of maintaining an "internally consistent worldview". They do not have an internally consistent worldview, because they argue for that and then turn around and hinder, or harass by means of filing lawsuits or even simply making public announcements, criticizing very milquetoast individuals and shows like Jimmy fucking Kimmel. Which is made all the more absurd when the Internet exists.

The other part of this where the problem becomes one of existentiality, is the dereliction of their actual duty. Rather than policing the content, what they are supposed to be doing, is regulating the infrastructure on which that content is broadcast. And there are numerous "lines" of transmission - wired and wireless, and all the many ways that can happen. It could be reasonably argued the Department of Energy should subsume them, because they have crossed from useless (where they were in the 90s) to actively harmful and a legitimate threat to national security. The Department of Energy, on the other hand, does make sense, because the Internet providers and the electric companies should have always been one.

We are reaching a point at which the battle of existence is between "the market" and the market. Only one can survive.

9

u/AbaloneDifferent5282 1d ago

I think at this point it’s safe to assume that Trump and his goons mislead a lot of people about a lot of things. And they’re still doing it.

5

u/SoCallMeDeaconBlues1 1d ago • Bravo

He "says" he has documents?

FFS, don't just "SAY" it. Show us the money.

This is like all these other people through the years (from various countries and places) claiming they had proof of Donny doing the nasty with minors. SHOW US, don't just tell us about it.

Quit fucking around. SHOW US THE MONEY. I don't want to hear any more hear-say. Show me the proof or shut the fuck up. Otherwise, it's just water cooler banter.

1

u/Major_Honey_4461 1d ago

What they don't lie about they hide in disappearing apps.