r/law • • 1d ago

Executive Branch (Trump) Trump’s Judge Pick Visibly Unravels Over Third-Term Question, But Dem Corners Him and Refuses to Let Him Off the Hook

https://atlantablackstar.com/2026/11/20/trumps-judge-pick-visibly-unravels-over-third-term-question/
1.9k Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

467

u/ExpertRaccoon 1d ago • Bravo

They need to start asking this same question but frame it if Obama is allowed to run for a third term.

166

u/AMetalWolfHowls 1d ago

lol, would love to see that and then ask if it still applies to this chump

153

u/Licky_Anus 1d ago

He’ll say it only applies to him cause the 2020 election was stolen from him. If the SCOTUS somehow twists themselves in knots to allow him to run for a third term, Obama definitely should run against him. It would be poetic justice for him to end his career by losing to the man he’s most jealous of.

165

u/TheGrandExquisitor 1d ago • Bravo

If SCOTUS allows Trump a third term, we should raze the Supreme Court to the ground in righteous anger. 

50

u/weedexpat 1d ago

Why wait for that?

57

u/TheGrandExquisitor 1d ago

Fair point. They already legalized crime for rich dudes...

30

u/Bookee2Shoes 1d ago

They really have, and not just for POTUS. It’s unbelievable.

27

u/AMetalWolfHowls 1d ago

Remember, if the only punishment is a fine and not jail time, it’s only a crime if you’re poor.

2

u/Rayloco 7h ago

Same for corporations! Why should they have the same Rights as Citizens but not the same Responsibilities? Start throwing top officers, Board members, and top stockholders in prison for lawbreaking and you will see corporate responsibility take on a whole new meaning!

3

u/Xytak 21h ago

Checks bank account balance

Actually guys I’m down to $10. I’m gonna have to stay sit this one out

1

u/Rayloco 7h ago

The Supreme Court needs to be razed to the ground before that and restarted from the ground up.

10

u/831loc 1d ago

Obama had a 3rd term stolen from him by that nasty constitution.

Because of that he should be able to run again.

4

u/Licky_Anus 1d ago

Agreed!

9

u/Rioting_Derp 23h ago

Personally I hope deeply that if he tries to run a third term, Obama flat out refuses to run and quotes the Constitution as the reason why. While it would seem poetic, having Obama run would only legitimize their own law breaking, for which we really need to have a reckoning as a country. It saddens me that when MAGA is done, and this putrid orange stain on American history is removed, there won't be consequences. Instead, we will get told that we should reach across the aisle again, be civil, be refined and peaceful and focused on the future. To hell with that, I want justice. I want justice under the law against those that have broken them.

6

u/caniaccanuck11 1d ago

They’d go for the argument about consecutive terms. Obama served two in a row and is ineligible. Trump didn’t therefore he is. Or some such BS.

25

u/Licky_Anus 1d ago

Too bad for them there’s no qualifier in the 22nd about consecutive v non-consecutive. Bannon has also floated the idea of him running as VP and having the Presidential candidate step down after inauguration. Thankfully, that’s a violation of the 12th Amendment, which says no person shall be elected VP who is ineligible to be Prez.

Of course, the problem is that the conservative majority on the SCOTUS are originalists, so they’ll probably try to say that the 22nd amendment was written after FDR was elected, so it only applied to him…even though he’d been dead for 2 years when it was proposed and 6 once it was ratified by the required number of states. That’s obviously bullshit, but this court has quoted Salem Witch Trial judges trying to justify the Dobbs decision, created Presidential immunity for official acts, among other batshit decisions that overturned years of precedent, so all bets are off. I’m sure Alito and Thomas would say he can run again, at the very least.

I hope it’s obvious that I’m being a little facetious predicting what originalists will say, but I can totally imagine them coming up with some sort of crazy justification.

16

u/Leumas_ 1d ago

I don’t think you’re being facetious at all. There is literally no intellectual, moral, or legal bottom to what Republicans will do to stay in power long enough to drain every last dime and resource out of the US and the world.

0

u/Jock-Tamson 1d ago

The argument they make is that the 22nd Amendment says he is ineligible to be elected President not to be appointed President so he can run as VP.

You see it get floated on here regularly.

4

u/Licky_Anus 1d ago

But the 12th Amendment makes that argument moot.

3

u/Jock-Tamson 20h ago

No, you see because the 22nd doesn’t make him ineligible to be President it just makes me ineligible to be elected so the 12th doesn’t apply.

Look I am not making this argument, it’s obvious bullshite.

Let’s be very clear about this. This is a disingenuous bullshite argument of the sort that renders the law meaningless. People advancing it are authoritarians who want just that, partisans seeking a rationalization to smash down the voice telling them that, and damned fools.

I am telling you what I see repeated by the same ecosystem that kept talking about alternative electors in 2020.

It’s the rationale they would argue.

16

u/0202_tihssitidder 1d ago

Bill Clinton.

Why does everyone leave out Bill? He and Trump are the same age.

5

u/mduell 1d ago

Way too right for the current party: immigration, 2SLGBTQIA+, etc.

10

u/AyeMatey 1d ago

We are fantasizing that asking if the 18th amendment would apply to Obama would make for good theater. But a well-prepared maga person will anticipate this line of questioning and might say “Sure! He could run”

And then what have accomplished? We are muddying the water, and legitimizing the discussion of nullification of the 18th amendment. Which is not a win!

Obama wouldn’t agree to run again. But Trump would. And by agreeing to discuss it, we have shifted the Overton window.

We don’t need more tricky ways to get to “gotcha”.

We already have the candidate disqualifying himself by saying “I don’t know”. Ok. End of conversation. You are disqualified.

We do not need to keep talking to, or about, these iceholes! After they disqualify themselves , declare victory and MOVE ON. Stop the conversation. “No further questions.”

4

u/fazlez1 20h ago

We do not need to keep talking to, or about, these iceholes!

Fargin corksuckers!!

6

u/MisterTruth 1d ago

"Well he had consecutive terms so that disqualifies him" igoring that Trump 2028 would be a consecutive term.

2

u/SanityPlanet 17h ago

Their argument is that you can’t have more than 2 consecutive terms, so Trump’s corpse would be unable to run in 2032. Of course, should he happen to survive that long, they will find another reason to argue he can run again.

0

u/naijaboiler 18h ago

i hate this line. it legitimizes wrong. no.

2

u/ExpertRaccoon 18h ago

Twas sarcasm my dear friend

95

u/RustedRelics 1d ago

Those are disqualifying answers. Period. Sad to watch those exchanges. Guy should be ashamed of himself.

51

u/geekmasterflash 1d ago

I like how if we grant the idiots their idiocy and for the sake of argument accept that 2020 was "stolen" they still can't give a better reason for why a third term is justified other than hurt feelings.

24

u/SnoopingStuff 1d ago

No judge picks , sorry Merrick Garland rules apply

3

u/Senedoris 22h ago

That will work once Democrats in the Senate have been sworn in. I don't exactly think Republicans will block nominations based on the logic of themselves blocking Garland.

24

u/rellsell 1d ago

What a dummy. All he had to do was stick to the game plan SCOTUS used when asked about abortion. Just lie…

6

u/SpicySweetHotPot 1d ago

If it’s a question that Dumpy will get upset about the defer, delay, or lie. Truth has no place in this administration.