r/law • • 1d ago

Judicial Branch Justice Sotomayor signals support for Supreme Court term limits

https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/20/politics/sonia-sotomayor-supreme-court-term-limits?Date=20261120&Profile=cnn&utm_content=1795211363&utm_medium=social&utm_source=reddit_user
4.1k Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

56

u/cnn 1d ago

Justice Sonia Sotomayor told an audience in Philadelphia on Friday that she could support term limits for members of the Supreme Court, treading into a debate that may pick up steam when Democrats take control of Congress next year.

Sotomayor, the court’s senior liberal justice, noted that many other nations have managed to keep politics out of their judiciaries without lifetime appointments. After telling an audience that she wouldn’t offer an opinion on the idea, she then hinted that she was open to supporting the idea.

“As with everything else in life, I wouldn’t be unhappy with term limits,” Sotomayor said at an event hosted by the American Philosophical Society.

12

u/SuperSimpleSam 1d ago

many other nations have managed to keep politics out of their judiciaries without lifetime appointments

We haven't with lifetime appointments, so I don't see how it would hurt.

0

u/DoctorSelfosa 18h ago

I do find it somewhat hypocritical that she's been on the court 17 years and is saying this when she'll likely serve at least another 3-5 years

205

u/OldeManKenobi 1d ago

Look at that: a principled jurist.

60

u/Odd-Boysenberry-2260 1d ago

There are three of them on that panel.

-51

u/irrelevantusername24 1d ago

I think there are nine. Some of them just have lost their principles buried under the dirty money

30

u/Odd-Boysenberry-2260 1d ago

How can they both have them and lost them at the same time? Schroedingers principles?

-7

u/irrelevantusername24 1d ago

Unironically:

[They] keep[...] on forgetting

What [they] wrote down, the whole crowd goes so loud

https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/eminem/loseyourself.html

currency(n.)

1650s, "condition of flowing," a sense now rare or obsolete, from Latin currens, present participle of currere "to run" (from PIE root *kers- "to run"). The notion of "state or fact of flowing from person to person" led to the senses "continuity in public knowledge" (1722) and "that which is current as a medium of exchange, money" (1729).

https://www.etymonline.com/word/currency

Money is not speech. But also, the Internet - and the incomplete switch from the old means of transmission, to the new - has distorted all speech, irrespective of money.

It's like I explained in another recent comment talking about the similarities and also differences between Alex Karp (Palantir) and Donald Trump. They both go wherever the "winds" blow them. The difference is I think Karp is a bit more aware of his own bias, and that there are in fact a lot of people who believe very different things than he has typically been associated with. Trump on the other hand pays attention to Fox News and his sycophants. Trump, and Musk, are in a lot of ways the pre-eminent proof that social media, specifically the dead bird, rots your brain. I don't think they were always as stupid as they now are.

Karp, on the other hand, though I don't particularly think he is a good person, and there are a lot of things he is probably being less than upfront about, has made his career on organizing Internet data. Internet data is primarily financial and communicative. That's exactly what I am talking about. If anyone had the capability to find the difference between bias and reality, it would be someone like him. I don't think he has, because he goes where the wind blows, but my point is they both do follow what is "current" in the sense quoted above.

---

See also:

https://archive.is/M4rvy

Fuck John Roberts

---

See also: yes

More lyrics:

Surround your enemy with ways of escape

...

Don't be afraid, don't be the problem

Guilt and fear, the death of solution

What do you see? What's your pollution?

https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/bush/bloodriver.html

By which I mean you have to separate the person from the action, and only impose a punishment that fits the crime. Which for some of these people might be a tough pill to swallow.

-12

u/Simplesnore 1d ago

Haha. If the democrats had the majority on the court she would not have the same opinion. Get out of here with this BS comment

7

u/OldeManKenobi 20h ago

I invite you to plant your feet on planet earth.

-13

u/Mist_Rising 1d ago

Maybe you should wait until she isn't literally saying she doesn't have an opinion to blow her up?

She simply said she didn't disagree with something she literally has no control of and wouldn't impact her anyway.

13

u/OSI_Hunter_Gathers 18h ago

Expand the court to 27 justices and have cases randomly assigned. POTUS can only appoint 4 justices per term. Any resignations can only be filled with the appointment allocated. The court can still function with less than 27.

4

u/OSI_Hunter_Gathers 18h ago

Other justices not on the docket can submit briefs to be put on the record.

5

u/RobutNotRobot 1d ago

She supports the most difficult thing to reform the court because it would require a Constitutional amendment.

7

u/MddlingAges 23h ago

It's not in the Constitution at all, it's a custom. Go look it up.

Fundamentally, we can all agree that Americans shouldn't have royalty. Yes, Supreme Court Justices count as royalty, royalty have been voted into their titles over the centuries, and still are in many nations.

We've seen a level of corruption and unserious work in this Court that is alarming and requires correction. Making the President nearly a king after two centuries of contradicting precedent and practice is highly alarming and threatens our entire economy, as anyone can see - including the Court itself! The court gave Trump absolute power over independent agencies, upending centuries of precedent - except for the Fed, because that affects their bank account and their billionaire patrons. Trouble is, there's no legal basis for that carveout, they simple wanted a specific result and know that no one can contradict them.

So even they see the threat of their terrible agenda, and made a completely absurd carve-out contrary to actual law.

There needs to be term limits, but a rotating selection of justices would be better. We should put an end to the cozy corrupt system where the justices get the cases their patrons want, and they waive them in, in setups decided ahead of time, and the plaintiffs and justices have personal relationships but no one recuses themselves, ever.

This is fundamentally immoral and corrupt.

2

u/isthatreal 21h ago

We really only have to interpret “good behavior”

I’m thinking working past retirement age or x number of years is not good behavior because random arguments like diminished capacity, lack of accountability, yadda yadda

Or

Good behavior is serious ethical standards/lines that a few have them already crossed that is not good behavior. This seems more logical, but who knows…

Voila, good behavior interpreted and no more life terms

2

u/MddlingAges 20h ago

That’s too subjective and becomes a political witch hunt and constitutional crisis. It has to be law.

1

u/isthatreal 20h ago

Well, if the majority of SCOTUS could agree on an interpretation of the Constitution, then it is law. That’s their job. So pack the court with people willing to interpret good behavior. And it is subjective—everything is subjective when it comes to interpretation.

0

u/_jump_yossarian 1d ago

She should have taken the opportunity to retire when Biden was in office; 70+, diabetic, and a history of smoking. Didn't learn a thing from RBG.

-1

u/Depressed-Industry 12h ago

That's nice, but it isn't up to her.