r/law • Competent Contributor • 18h ago • Mindblown 1

Executive Branch (Trump) Trump Signs Executive Order Limiting Congress’s Access To ‘Executive Branch Departments And Agencies, Employees, Or Federal Contractors’ As Democrats' Plan Probes Into His Administration

https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/6235181-trump-executive-privilege-congress-investigations-order/
14k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

407

u/dballing 17h ago

At some point, someone will explain to him that he can’t unilaterally limit another co-equal branch’s constitutional authority right?

181

u/Bongressman 16h ago

I wonder how he would react if someone told him that Congress is actually the most powerful branch within the US system. The only reason he is allowed to get away with any of this shit is because GOP congressmen and women are so fucking weak kneed.

22

u/smiama36 15h ago

Not weak kneed. Republicans could have gotten rid of Trump several times over the years. They didn’t want to. They have worked for this for years- their hands on the levers of power and control. They have protected, defended, supported or stay silent for a decade because he gave them exactly what they wanted.

5

u/bluescrubbie 15h ago

While simultaneously eroding trust in government, which they also wanted.

4

u/bagheera369 14h ago

Yep...this is a multi-pronged attack.

Federalist society getting a supermajority in the SC, and willingly concentrating power in the executive.

GOP congress abandoning any and all responsibility for holding anything in check, and willingly concentrating power in the executive.

State Governors and legislatures kneeling directly to the national executive, normalizing the behavior of everyone involved, so that American society begins to perceive it as normal.

Meanwhile, they have unilaterally destroyed every independent agency that monitors or provides a check on what's going on.
They've threatened anyone and everyone that doesn't agree with them, and created an anonymous private army, that moves through the country on an unlimited budget, and does whatever it wants.

Our press had long-abandoned it's duty to actually call balls and strikes properly, and they were used to normalize all this as well, and now that most of our press is directly owned by billionaire fascists, what few members were pushing for accountability, are mostly gone.

The fun part, is they told everyone exactly what they were going to do, this whole time...inviting Orban, Bukele, and Milei to conservative conferences, funneling money to terror and supremecy groups in the US....letting Musk literally steal every last ounce of private data from US systems, and feed it all to likely Russia and Israel, all of them getting obscenely rich while doing this.....fuck, even going back so far as the Patriot Act, to push the snowball that had been being built for years, down the hill, showing you that Dems are absolutely complicit in getting us to this point, and mostly not doing shit about stopping it.

It's all been right there, out in the open, or just below the surface, because who needs to hide shit, when you own all the levers of power, and you've spent the past 70+ years working to make the citizenry less intelligent, more desperate, and therefore completely susceptible to propaganda at every level.

The US is laying cold on the concrete, being looted for parts, and the recent "blue wave" was most likely just a twitch of the rigor-mortised nervous system, or at most a death shudder, as Jeffries and Schumer help Trump, AIPAC, and the Billionaires put every roadblock possible up, between us and the ambulance.

As Carlin once said...."It's called the American Dream, cause you gotta be asleep to believe it."

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

26

u/OGMoonshiner 15h ago

"They are not the most powerful branch. Are you a stupid person? They are a branch. Branches like on a great tree. A powerful tree. Very powerful. You ever see a big oak tree? Tremendous branches. Huge branches. Some branches are so strong you could hang a lot of weight on them. Probably more weight than some members of Congress can handle. And believe me, some of those members are carrying a lot of weight. Unlike me. Perfect health they said."

Probably something like that.

20

u/mrpres1dent 15h ago

You forgot the "Excuse me. Who are you with? What news outlet? CNN? You are fake news. You're a sick person. Really sick."

11

u/sam56778 14h ago

You forgot “you’re a nasty person.”

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Ascal15 15h ago

Uncanny

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Top_Equivalent_2313 16h ago

Impotent is a better word

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ReddiWhippp 15h ago

Complicit

→ More replies (17)

52

u/robinsw26 17h ago

But a co-equal branch can shut off the flow of money until it gets the answers it wants.

20

u/Bob_Obloooog 16h ago

Wait until those scumbags SCOTUS say he can.

21

u/TheStolenPotatoes 16h ago

That's fine. Just pass the SCOTUS ethics bill that's been proposed and neuter those corrupt pieces of shit.

4

u/praetorian1979 16h ago

Then they'll just declare that law unconstitutional. Might have to start ignoring the supremes until changes can be made for the greater good of the country.

5

u/TheStolenPotatoes 15h ago

Should be expanded to the number of seats on the bench equaling the number of federal circuit courts. This MAGA controlled Supreme Court has done more damage to its credibility than just about any previous Supreme Court in the country's history. The ethics proposals are the bare minimum of what's needed to get that institution back under control. The legislative branch was always meant to be the strongest branch of government. They need to bring that court to heel or it's going to get even worse, especially with all those Heritage Foundation stooges sitting on it now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Thin_Chain_208 16h ago

I hope they do this. With Jeffries in charge I have my doubts.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/spiralenator 16h ago

Also, co-equality is made up. There is nowhere in the constitution or any law passed by congress that says the branches are co-equal. I think its quite clear that congress was vested with the greatest authority, as it is the only branch capable of altering the constitution, as well as passing laws that the other branches must follow.

15

u/DanieltheGameGod 16h ago edited 16h ago

Anyone who looks at the structure of the government or the writings of the founders would realize Congress is by far intended to be the strongest branch, hence part of the reasoning for splitting it in two. The judiciary barely had any powers before it gave itself the power of judicial review.

I swear somehow people get separate but equal from Jim Crow and somehow misremember it as three separate but equal branches of government or something. Balance of powers/checks and balances ≠ three co equal branches.

Edit: Federalist 51:

But it is not possible to give to each department an equal power of self defence. In republican government the legislative authority, necessarily, predominates. The remedy for this inconveniency is, to divide the legislature into different branches; and to render them by different modes of election, and different principles of action, as little connected with each other, as the nature of their common functions, and their common dependence on the society, will admit.

11

u/spiralenator 16h ago • Bravo

In full agreement! Congress confirms or dismisses nominees for SCOTUS. Congress determines how many justices to seat. Congress determines what "on good behavior" means, and what grounds SCOTUS can be removed. Same for the president, and for any other member of the government subject to impeachment. SCOTUS can interpret the constitution, but only congress can change it. SCOTUS can rule that a law passed by congress is in conflict with how they interpret the constitution, but congress again, can change the language of the law, or the language of the constitution. No other branch has any power over congress, but congress has power over every other branch. It's clear as day and I can't help but think the co-equal talking point is manufactured to muddle the structure of power in this country so that criminals and their enablers the executive and legislative branches can usurp power over congress. And congress IS the people. The people have always been the ultimate authority, and the people are represented through congress, not the executive.

/rant

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/lancer-fiefdom 16h ago

The Supreme Court will in 14 months through a one time exception in a short docket secret decision

5

u/serpentear 16h ago

Oh it’s already been explained to him and I promise you it’s not being explained to him anymore.

17

u/sourcreamus 16h ago

Co equal is Nixonian propaganda. Congress is the most powerful

→ More replies (15)

8

u/Puck68 16h ago

And who’s going to stop him? That’s the problem.

10

u/SuperGandalff 17h ago

With Miller in charge? Good luck with that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (56)