r/law • Competent Contributor • 18h ago • Mindblown 1

Executive Branch (Trump) Trump Signs Executive Order Limiting Congress’s Access To ‘Executive Branch Departments And Agencies, Employees, Or Federal Contractors’ As Democrats' Plan Probes Into His Administration

https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/6235181-trump-executive-privilege-congress-investigations-order/
14k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 18h ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

6.9k

u/Asher_Tye 18h ago • Bravo Popcorn Heartwarming

Another EO that can be ignored.

3.2k

u/Complete-Tangelo1532 18h ago • Bravo

Correct

EOs are NOT legislation, but his dumb ass followers don't get that far lol

1.7k

u/Flannel_Panels 18h ago • Bravo

Especially EOs that directly conflict congressional balance of powers lmao

→ More replies (71)

124

u/Prometheus_303 17h ago • Bravo

(as an aside, don't forget these are the same people who, a little over a decade ago, claimed Obama was abusing his Presidential authority by issuing way too many EOs. Laws must come from the Legislative branch not the executive, they argued...

It might be worth noting as of 17 November, with just under 6 years as President, Trump has signed a total of 512 EOs (220 his first term and 292 this term). While Biden signed 162 and Obama signed 277, for a 439 total EOs in 12 years. Aka in 6 years, Trump has signed more EOs than his two democratic predecessors did in their 12 years in office.

In just the 2 years of this term, he has already signed more EOs than Obama did in 8 full years!!! And his first term came remarkably close to meeting Obama's two term total too...

But sure, Obama was the one trying to play king and issuing too many EOs...)

→ More replies (22)

52

u/Zepcleanerfan 17h ago

Remember when they seriously thought they were gonna repeal the fourteenth amendment with an executive order?

The president of the united states thought that. There are kids in middle school who understand why that doesn't work.

→ More replies (2)

89

u/mollila 17h ago

They are his Royal Decrees.

→ More replies (11)

127

u/mediocre_remnants 17h ago • Bravo Popcorn

He's not doing this for his followers, he's doing it to save his own ass. And it's not going to work. Even SCOTUS would agree that it's an invalid/illegal order.

→ More replies (45)

37

u/Which_Loss6887 17h ago • Bravo

Dump is the epitome of that annoying kid who stops everything and shrieks “Okay new rule! New rule!” and makes up some self-serving shit every time the game isn’t going his way

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (36)

140

u/hansn 17h ago

The key is this gives the executive branch cover to destroy records they were ordered to retain. They don't care if it's ruled illegal. The records will be gone.

51

u/Which_Loss6887 17h ago

Hopefully there will be at least one rat on the sinking ship who realizes they can build themselves a little raft out of those documents

→ More replies (7)

17

u/___pa___ 17h ago

I worry about this. However, it seems to me that if documents are being created, then they must be distributed. I suppose that is what they had to do to get things done. Government systems are not one for minimizing documentation. So anyone who got a copy of any of those documents can prove that documents were destroyed if they show the investigators a copy of a document that doesn’t exist the next level up. I also assume that documents have "owners" and if the documents are missing it is the owner's responsibility - and these people might not want to have to spend $100k defending themselves in court.

Anyone destroying a federal document must have committed a crime. I really doubt there is one single copy of these documents out there - hell NSA and CIA ridiculously-secret documents must have at least a couple of copies.

I know a white collar defense lawyer. He has been really slow with work. He's thinking that may change now since alot of people are going to be dragged into court. All those non-billionaires are not going to be happy paying $800 plus an hour just to help Trump stay out of trouble...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Luster-Purge 17h ago

Hey, this sounds familiar to something that happened in 1945.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/kombatunit 17h ago

Then a trip to Club Fed should be in order.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

166

u/Comrade-Conquistador 18h ago • Bravo

I don't think he knows or cares if EOs are legally binding.

198

u/Sufficient_Clock_203 18h ago

He thinks his fucking tweets are legally binding.

→ More replies (8)

36

u/Practical-Class6868 18h ago

Puffery. A business practice. Just say that it is legal and then let your opponent argue otherwise while you fuck off to the golf course.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/chickwifeypoo 18h ago

I'd say it's mostly that he don't know. He's so full of himself and got so many people around telling him what he says goes and without a doubt telling him he can put out one of those EO's and that it will mean he can do whatever he wants that he believes it.

→ More replies (1)

76

u/wp4nuv 18h ago edited 11h ago • Bravo

That's what governing by decree gets you. I know Congress will definitely ignore this one as it's unenforceable.
Edit: wow! An award. First time for everything.

About decrees, almost every President has some power to issue them. The joke is that Presidents who rule by decree rule over Banana Republics....

13

u/phoarksity 17h ago

Congress will have to take it to court, repeatedly, as government agencies do not respond to Congressional subpoenas.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/PurpleToedUnicorn 18h ago

Thank God we have the DOJ to enforce the law once the EO is overturned. 

/s

21

u/Adventurous-Disk-291 18h ago

Enforcement is a real potential issue, but it's crazy EOs are being positioned as above the Constitution. I don't remember EOs even being on the public radar when I was young. At what point is it a violation of the oath of office to write EOs that explicitly contradict the plain text of the Constitution?

7

u/meowtiger 17h ago

At what point is it a violation of the oath of office to write EOs that explicitly contradict the plain text of the Constitution?

at least a year ago. the problem there is that the enforcement mechanism for a rogue executive branch is the legislative branch impeaching them, and...

→ More replies (3)

29

u/SearingPhoenix 18h ago edited 18h ago

Yeah... that's... That's not how co-equal branches of government with checks and balances work. I guess the dementia has vaporized his memory of fourth grade.

You can't just ignore a Congressional subpoena because your boss told you to.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/LostInRetransmission 18h ago

Yes , but, wanna bet the DOJ will respect those EO ?

Once the vote is done and you are seen in contempt of congress, the case is referred to a US attorney and grand jury. US attorney which are under the DOJ. Which would obey the EO.

See what I am hinting at ?

The other mechanism with the house/senate sergeant at arm , has it even been used in the late 20th or 21st century ? I don't think so.

We'll see but I think you have a lot to "clean up" in your government, after seeing how it was abused, and how check and balance were shit on by Republican.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ScottHK 18h ago

But will it be enough that he various staff and agencies don't comply with investigations?

→ More replies (8)

6

u/TheRealSparkleMotion 15h ago

Though it is nice of him to plant little red flags letting everyone know where the dirt is.

4

u/Geoffsgarage 17h ago

So when a subpoena is ignored, who is going to court to try to enforce? This DOJ won’t be.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/WildRabbitz 18h ago

He set the precedent, but his mouth-breathers will clutch their pearls if it happens and scream it's not fair.

3

u/Medium_Medium 17h ago

Until the Supreme Court squints at some European document from the 1400s just the right way and decides that this is legal... And then Congress lacks the balls the do anything about it.

3

u/KitKitsAreBest 17h ago

Well, shit. Game over then. Next he'll pass a little EO that just says "Trump Wins and is Emperor of Earth". That'l be end game for us all.

→ More replies (72)

1.5k

u/ARazorbacks 18h ago • Bravo

Pull all his funding. Literally turn the lights off at the White House and cancel all of ICE’s credit cards for putting gas in their cars. Shut the whole fucking thing down. 

And then subpoena Trump to testify before Congress why he’s limiting their oversight access to the Executive branch. 

837

u/Used-Feature-8611 17h ago • This Bravo Regret

You need ballsy democrats. And Jeffries and Schummer are not.

353

u/gonidoinwork 17h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

The only balls they have are AIPAC balls in their mouths.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/LOERMaster 15h ago

I can’t understand why after they were ineffective last time we’re going to put them right back in charge.

Schumer has all the intimidation of a strongly worded letter to someone’s underlings.

→ More replies (26)

32

u/cardmanimgur 17h ago

I'd love for him to testify before Congress for 4 hours because he would 100% fall asleep.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/tanrock2003 17h ago • Bravo

Nice idea, but the American political system is fundamentally broken.

There is little reason to believe that meaningful oversight, genuine accountability, or serious consequences will emerge without sustained public pressure.

I’ve been watching this unfold in disgust and horror from Canada since 2016, and Americans need to understand that voting alone is not enough. You need to exercise your constitutional rights, organize peaceful mass demonstrations, demand congressional oversight, support independent investigations, and use every lawful democratic mechanism available to hold public officials accountable.

Congress needs to fulfill its constitutional responsibilities. That means conducting substantive oversight hearings, issuing and lawfully enforcing subpoenas, investigating credible allegations of misconduct, and pursuing impeachment proceedings where the constitutional grounds are established.

I genuinely believe the next two years could cause catastrophic, potentially irreversible damage to American democratic institutions - if it’s not already too late.

Americans need to recognize the seriousness of the threat that authoritarian governance poses to their constitutional republic. Restoring accountability requires more than political promises. It requires independent investigations, enforceable ethical standards, judicial review of unlawful government action, and criminal proceedings where the evidence and applicable law justify prosecution.

Supreme Court justices are not above constitutional accountability. Where credible evidence supports allegations of impeachable misconduct, the House of Representatives should investigate and, where warranted, adopt articles of impeachment.

Criminal accountability must be equally rigorous. Where investigations establish sufficient evidence of specific federal offences, prosecutors should independently determine whether charges are legally supportable if the Presidency changes in two years and the DOJ is reformed.

Charges involving conspiracy, obstruction of justice, public corruption, or violations of the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) must satisfy the statutory elements of each offence.

I’m talking about investigations with the seriousness, independence, and evidentiary discipline demonstrated by Italy’s Maxi Trials against organized crime - not political show trials, collective punishment, or predetermined convictions. A modern day Nuremberg.

That standard must apply to everyone, including powerful political figures such as Russell Vought, Steve Bannon, Peter Navarro, and individuals or organizations associated with Project 2025, if credible evidence establishes reasonable grounds for investigating specific unlawful conduct.

Enough empty promises, political theatre, and oversight without meaningful follow-through.

The American people have the right to peaceful assembly, lawful protest, petitioning their government, demanding transparency, and seeking remedies through the courts.

Accountability is not revenge. It is the impartial application of the Constitution and the law regardless of political affiliation, wealth, influence, or public office.

A constitutional republic cannot survive if its institutions refuse to enforce the constitutional limits on governmental power.

Defending democracy means demanding accountability while protecting the very legal principles that make democracy possible.

7

u/ScannerBrightly 14h ago

A constitutional republic cannot survive if its institutions refuse to enforce the constitutional limits on governmental power.

This is how our Democracy will die.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Valuable-Speaker-312 18h ago

And he will counter with "executive privilege" to ignore the subpoena.

31

u/ARazorbacks 17h ago

I agree that’s what he would do. At that point he can fund the Executive branch from his bank account or solicit donations from supporters. 

If he can wield executive privilege like a weapon then Congress can wield funding like a weapon. 

We won’t get any of this because we don’t have anyone in power capable of doing what it takes to bring someone like Donald Trump to heel, but it sure would be nice. 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Cardsfan1 16h ago

Chuck and Hakeem will write strongly worded letters instead. That’ll show him.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

519

u/Zulmoka531 18h ago

I think even the corrupt SCOTUS would have a hard time acknowledging the sheer bullshit of this EO.

It literally cannot be upheld.

234

u/ControlAgent13 18h ago

It's not designed to be upheld, just to slow things down. Scotus will "slow roll" this requiring it go thru lower courts first then take a year to rule on it.
That's exactly what Scotus did in Trump's first term when Trump claimed "executive privledge" and ordered Congressional subpoenas ignored.

30

u/Additional_Exam_9884 17h ago

At this point it seems Dems should be ignoring even SCOTUS slow rolling things if it can force a decision. Make them the bad guys by forcing them to pick a side before this administration gets out of office. I have no idea how to do that but it seems they should be fighting fire with fire.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/spazzcat 17h ago

It won’t slow anything down . Congress will simply ignore it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

30

u/RosyPalm 17h ago

Yes, but that won't stop any and every executive branch department from claiming that because it might be upheld they have no choice but ignoring Congress until the issue is decided by the Supremes.

Oversight isn't going to happen with cooperation. It's going to need whistleblowers, leaks, and people realizing that they're being setup to take the eventual fall for the guys urging them not to cooperate.

21

u/ObligationMurky8716 18h ago

"We'll allow it for now, then revisit it after he's gone."

3

u/hunter_531 17h ago

I'd like to agree, but to me this is less egregious than the birthright citizenship EO, and they still voted 6-3 on that

→ More replies (5)

406

u/dballing 16h ago

At some point, someone will explain to him that he can’t unilaterally limit another co-equal branch’s constitutional authority right?

181

u/Bongressman 16h ago

I wonder how he would react if someone told him that Congress is actually the most powerful branch within the US system. The only reason he is allowed to get away with any of this shit is because GOP congressmen and women are so fucking weak kneed.

22

u/smiama36 15h ago

Not weak kneed. Republicans could have gotten rid of Trump several times over the years. They didn’t want to. They have worked for this for years- their hands on the levers of power and control. They have protected, defended, supported or stay silent for a decade because he gave them exactly what they wanted.

→ More replies (11)

26

u/OGMoonshiner 15h ago

"They are not the most powerful branch. Are you a stupid person? They are a branch. Branches like on a great tree. A powerful tree. Very powerful. You ever see a big oak tree? Tremendous branches. Huge branches. Some branches are so strong you could hang a lot of weight on them. Probably more weight than some members of Congress can handle. And believe me, some of those members are carrying a lot of weight. Unlike me. Perfect health they said."

Probably something like that.

→ More replies (14)

7

u/Top_Equivalent_2313 15h ago

Impotent is a better word

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ReddiWhippp 15h ago

Complicit

→ More replies (17)

52

u/robinsw26 16h ago

But a co-equal branch can shut off the flow of money until it gets the answers it wants.

20

u/Bob_Obloooog 16h ago

Wait until those scumbags SCOTUS say he can.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (18)

8

u/lancer-fiefdom 16h ago

The Supreme Court will in 14 months through a one time exception in a short docket secret decision

17

u/sourcreamus 16h ago

Co equal is Nixonian propaganda. Congress is the most powerful

→ More replies (15)

5

u/serpentear 16h ago

Oh it’s already been explained to him and I promise you it’s not being explained to him anymore.

8

u/Puck68 16h ago

And who’s going to stop him? That’s the problem.

10

u/SuperGandalff 16h ago

With Miller in charge? Good luck with that.

7

u/mhsuffhrdd 16h ago

The "plenary authority" guy?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Franciscojerte 16h ago

You’re giving trump too much credit. He’s unaware of how the govt works. He’s signing this cause miller told him.

3

u/RhoOfFeh 16h ago

I guarantee you people have tried and gave up in frustration.

→ More replies (54)

139

u/ICLazeru 17h ago

Not how that works. EOs have to be based in a constitutional or statutory authority, and I guarantee there's none of those saying the executive branch can simply ignore a congressional investigation.

26

u/JKlerk 17h ago

This is SOP for Trump and his cronies. Use the legal system to delay until the next election.

25

u/jpmeyer12751 17h ago

“There’s none of those saying the executive branch can simply ignore …”

To which John Roberts replies, “Hold my beer”.

16

u/Element174 17h ago

I mean, John Roberts is the most likely Republican seated to follow the Constitution over what Trump wants, as he sided with Democrats more than any other GoP SCOTUS Judge. Alito and Thomas would be far more logical choices of, "I wipe my ass with The Constitution for Orange Diddler Daddy."

→ More replies (4)

9

u/TaquitoBanana 15h ago

It gets better than that.

Roosevelt and Taft both attempted to place a similar gag on federal employees, to stop them from testifying or whistleblowing to Congress.

In response, the Lloyd-LaFollette Act was passed which was the first real codification of our modern Whistleblower Protections.

And driving from that you have this gem:

5 U.S. Code § 7211 - Employees’ right to petition Congress

The right of employees, individually or collectively, to petition Congress or a Member of Congress, or to furnish information to either House of Congress, or to a committee or Member thereof, may not be interfered with or denied.

And there is well eztablished case law, including the Supreme Court analysis that explicitly identifies the intent of the law, and eatablishes that it is valid.

It's just more bullshit that will get destroyed by the courts.

10

u/Capt-Crap1corn 17h ago

Stephen Miller working overtime I see

→ More replies (1)

7

u/kevinlc1971 17h ago

With the current SCOTUS, not a bet I’m making on Kalshi.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

91

u/JayVoorheez 18h ago

The most transparent(ly corrupt) administration ever!

139

u/Vyntarus 17h ago

"Most transparent administration" everyone.

Most transparently corrupt, sure. It's easy to see right through them.

If the Democrats don't punish all these crimes hard, we will be dealing with something worse than MAGA in a few years.

12

u/thisbeardistaken 17h ago

Soooooo transparent. Bigly transparent.

→ More replies (4)

177

u/Pitiful_Conflict7031 18h ago

I mean, if laws can change depending oh who they serve do they matter? I think not.

142

u/Relevant_Winter_7098 18h ago

Thankfully, EOs aren't laws. Everyone who follows that EO instead of responding to subpoenas will be committing a crime

38

u/Quakes-JD 18h ago

While true, the DOJ will not charge anyone as long as they are doing what DJT tells them to do.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/ahhhbiscuits 18h ago

But who's going to enforce it?

→ More replies (3)

12

u/AdministrativeTrain 18h ago

Trump's employee base aren't the smartest bunch

→ More replies (2)

57

u/zoinkability 18h ago

“The most transparent administration in history!”

25

u/KyOatey 18h ago

Transparently criminal, that is.

54

u/Darktofu25 18h ago edited 17h ago

That’s not Constitutional. You can’t tell a co-equal branch of government that they can’t perform their oversight duties. Another Trump fail.

9

u/OysterPickleSandwich 16h ago

Anyone who wrote it is also violating their oath to the to protect and defend the Constitution. 

→ More replies (1)

45

u/GrannyFlash7373 15h ago

These documents are a paper trail of his criminal attempts ot obstruct the law.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/Live-Collection3018 15h ago

Sounds like cause for impeachment to me.

8

u/Zaiakusin 14h ago

Wheres the "days since last impeachable thing" counter? Needs to reset it again

78

u/janzeera 18h ago

How does the authority of the U.S. Congress—and by extension state legislatures—to monitor, investigate, and supervise the executive branch, federal agencies, and government programs as part of the constitutional system of checks and balances work?

90

u/doublethink_1984 18h ago

By ignoring this illegal EO.

If it's ruled legal that sucks but that means a Democrat preaident in 28 can essentially do whatever they want to hold this admin accountable

7

u/Old-Engineer854 17h ago

No, no, no...the Supreme Court clearly meant "not like that" in their ruling, for future Presidents. /s

Seriously, though, why is there so much stonewalling and protest before any investigation is even potentially happening?  They should know telling people "dont look at the [man, deal, receipts, etc.] behind the curtain" didn't work in the movies, and works even less in real life.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Not_Sure__Camacho 18h ago

Only when Congress does their duty and does it without caring if it "looks political".  The problem is that a lot of people in Congress are as corrupt as the president.  

21

u/caniaccanuck11 18h ago

It largely depends on an independent justice department that will uphold contempt charges from Congress. Lots of high level people are likely going to ignore congressional subpoenas and the DOJ is going to ignore any requests from Congress to charge them.

9

u/jameson71 18h ago

Was probably a bad idea to put the justice department under the executive then if the authority of congress depends on it.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/r4b1d0tt3r 18h ago

Even if/with the judiciary countermands the order it's an extra layer of litigation and stalling to get through.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ttw81 18h ago

the sc already made trump above the law when they gave absolute immunity.

4

u/Urabraska- 18h ago edited 18h ago

Well first. They launch the investigations. If the DoJ continues to stone wall. Impeach Blanche. Congress can do this. Once impeached. Get an actual leader in charge that will make sure the DoJ does its job. Then the EO can be entirely ignored as it's 100% illegal on a constitutional level as part of congresses job is oversight on the executive.

Even if a temp head takes Blacnhes place and attempts to do the same. Congress already showed they will impeach the head of the DoJ. So that replacement might think twice before doing what Trump tells them. While doing this. They gotta nail Blanche to the wall if it gets this far. Like. Actually ship him to prison on violating the law. They can't just let him go and think everything is fine. Its at a point that if nobody is held accountable. Nobody ever will and the system is dead. The day of partisan hand shaking is over as Trump turned the GoP into a party that is seeking to destroy the law.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Syberz 18h ago

From what I've seen, it doesn't.

→ More replies (1)

68

u/Icy-Feeling-528 18h ago

The mere fact that an executive would issue this type of order is grounds for impeachment or removal, and perhaps treasonous.

15

u/Winter_Whole2080 18h ago

Absolutely. Acting as if the Legislative branch isn’t co-equal.

8

u/Oregon-Pilot 17h ago

We all understand this and see it for what it is clear as day.

His supporters are too stupid to understand anything.

32

u/Bleezy79 15h ago

He thinks he can make himself a king through EOs and I cannot wait to watch this fat pedo squirm.

29

u/AyeMatey 13h ago

This will be legally ineffectual, but politically what does it say? “I do not want Congress to exercise its oversight responsibility.” And why?

Why would he want his behavior to remain unexamined?

Can anyone guess why?

28

u/Blacksad9999 14h ago • Heartwarming

Neato.

That will take like a day to get thrown out of court. lol

One branch of government doesn't get to dictate to another branch how they can operate under the law and constitution.

11

u/Molbiodude 14h ago

He's mistaking the 119th Congress openly abdicating their authority with him being able to do whatever he wants without Congress. He'll find out soon enough.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DuntadaMan 13h ago

The problem I have is that I suspect a great deal of our government will treat it like it has some kind of legal standing until then. Like that policy of not investigating a sitting president from the DOJ that has no standing but was still followed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

27

u/ButterscotchTop194 18h ago

That's a very fascist thing to do

27

u/The_True_Gaffe 14h ago edited 9h ago

Except it has no actual value, congress by default has the power to vote any choice made by trump, even his executive orders aren’t even real bills or laws, congress can flat out revoke them the second they feel like it making any order he puts out effectively useless.

Edited - Spelling

403

u/Stereo_Jungle_Child 18h ago • Regret

So what happens when Congress subpoenas people to testify in investigations into Trump's crimes, Trump says they don't have to (or can't) testify, the DOJ refuses to arrest or prosecute them for refusing, and then they also refuse to provide documents and records that Congress wants for its investigation?

Nothing happens, that's what.

429

u/Relevant_Winter_7098 18h ago • This Bravo

Congress can and should send the Seargent at Arms to go arrest them and compel their appearance.

141

u/Numeno230n 18h ago edited 15h ago

It has become abundantly clear that Congress requires its own enforcement agency that is independent from the DOJ and executive. Who is going to arrest the AG when he commits blatant crimes?

EDIT: People keep saying Capitol police. The capitol police are never in a million years actually put cuffs on a congressperson, an attorney general, supreme court justice, etc. I'm not talking cops putting up barriers and carrying mace. I'm talking federal agents with investigative powers, a team of prosecutors, on the ground agents who can make arrests and, when necessary, carry out independent investigations of the DOJ itself. When Congress tells a billionaire to appear before them, he should be there or else risk being in a jail cell. When a DHS head like Noem commits countless crimes, an arrest warrant should come straight from congress. Not the ridiculous "invitation to lie to Congress" that is a Congressional subpoena these days.

→ More replies (24)

21

u/madmax177 18h ago

Agreed, we need some action.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (47)

33

u/Sea_Mind3678 18h ago

Ask Gym Jordan. He’s been ignoring a subpoena for years and nobody has done shit about it.

56

u/Lower-Engineering365 18h ago

I understand your anger, but this comment seems rooted in politics and not the actual law. SoL on contempt of congress is 5 years. Anyone who ignores congress in the next 2 years can and will be prosecuted in 2029. I would not be surprised if they get plenty of cooperation as a result (or pleading the 5th).

Now, the real issue is presidential pardons.

→ More replies (24)

19

u/Lisan-al-Gaib-65 18h ago

Impeachment and removal. The only similar situation I can think of is after the civil war and the impeachment of Johnson.

9

u/Concerned_EducaterCA 18h ago • Bravo

Good luck getting 67 senators to convict and remove

Out system is impotent in dealing with this kind of threat

→ More replies (6)

6

u/SomeRandomRealtor 18h ago

Then it becomes a SC case and Trump buys 4-6 months of non-compliance at least while people have a stupid argument over whether the executive branch has the power to limit the authority of other branches

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Educatedrednekk 18h ago

Congress would have to pass a law giving state AGs the right to prosecute. Which won't happen over his veto.

Trump can pardon for Federal crimes, but not civil liabilities. If we get a trifecta in 2028, Congress could amend the Federal Tort Claims Act to make executive officials personally liable for any illegal deeds. Just let all their victims sue. ICE agents, State Dept, "War" department, etc.

3

u/Mobile_Incident_5731 18h ago

The Constitutional solution is impeachment.

→ More replies (33)

25

u/Flokitoo 17h ago • Mindblown

It pains me how people still don't understand the true insidious nature of Roberts' decision in US v Trump. Roberts made very clear that the only repercussions for violating the law is impeachment. So practically, Trump can do anything he wants.

3

u/YouWereBrained 17h ago

Exactly. Until the concept and implementation of a new process, impeachment AND CONVICTION won’t ever happen.

24

u/jisa 17h ago

This seems like an impeachable offense in and of itself...

21

u/Pacifix18 18h ago

Add it to the list of impeachable offenses.

21

u/JustinKase_Too 10h ago

Most transparent administration ever... transparently corrupt that is.

41

u/3-Ballin 12h ago

Norms are over. Put it in writing. This is easy. " No judge can accept gifts"

8

u/IsaacNewtongue 9h ago

It's already written into law that no president may accept gifts. And yet, he's got that lovely jet from Qatar

7

u/3-Ballin 12h ago

No representative, no senator, no fucking judge

3

u/Ba_Dum_Ba_Dum 12h ago

Yes!!! Put everything in writing! Ffs. 🤦‍♂️

→ More replies (1)

20

u/elkab0ng 17h ago

In related news, I have signed an executive order that my wife is not allowed to question my spending on motorcycles, the IRS must accept my “just because” explanation on those ‘entertainment’ expenses, and the speed limits do not apply to me if I am wearing socks.

Thank you for your attention in this matter!

20

u/novonshitsinpantz 14h ago

Totally the act of a guy with nothing to hide...

20

u/Naive-Interview6035 6h ago

Bro is like, “use this one simple trick to skirt the Constitution…”

He probably things I can write an EO like, “Congress can’t impeach the President.”

Fucking idiot.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Competitive_Ad291 12h ago

I’ll take things that are illegal for $800 please Alex

12

u/audiofankk 11h ago

I think you mean $800 billion...

19

u/dBlock845 14h ago

I'm sure Rep Garcia is shaking in his boots... ooh so scary, Trump signed a meaningless piece of paper as an effort to try and stall in the courts!

→ More replies (3)

18

u/_jump_yossarian 16h ago

I seem to remember trump and Fox News attacking Pres Obama and Biden for their use of executive orders. Obama had a grand total of 277 EOs in 8 years. trump is over 500 in <6, with 292 so far in his second term. Not a peep from Fox about trump’s abuse of powers.

16

u/SCWickedHam 18h ago

Next, the Supreme Court can’t interpret the constitution.

9

u/farrowsharrows 18h ago

It doesn't seem to be able to.

16

u/Protiguous 14h ago

Lol, nope.

Chump, that's not an authority granted to the executive branch by the Constitution or Congress.

You traitors really don't see the irony of complaining about being investigated for corruption, do you?

15

u/walksonfourfeet 18h ago

President signs executive order limiting powers of other branches of government. Yeah, that’s totally cool, so much democracy

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ThePensiveE 17h ago

We're about to see a full on Executive branch meltdown over all the oversight.

There's nothing Republicans hate more than being held accountable to the citizens.

14

u/StartlingCat 17h ago

The executive branch is the goddamn mafia.

14

u/JoyousMadhat 16h ago • Popcorn

Any action to restrict is another confession of a crime and misconduct

→ More replies (1)

13

u/NameLips 16h ago

Trump has claimed total, kinglike authority over the executive branch. This is the Unitary Executive theory, and the supreme court is loaded with Trump nominees who support this idea.

The problem is, for the last 100 years Congress has been establishing "independent agencies" like the Federal Election Commission and dozens of others, to run essential government functions. They have to be put somewhere in the federal government, so they were put under the Executive umbrella, but were created by law to be independent and outside the direct control of the President.

Trump has claimed that Congress cannot limit his executive control in that way. They cannot declare part of the executive branch beyond his control, so those parts of the law are simply unconstitutional and do not bind or restrict him.

Scotus has backed him up on this, essentially saying if Congress doesn't like Trump breaking the law, their only recourse is to impeach and remove him. The threat of impeachment is the ONLY check on Trump's powers. He obeys laws only as a courtesy, they can do absolutely nothing if he breaks them, or orders anybody else to break them. He can pardon anybody who follows his orders and defies the law. King until removed, with no consequences for his blatant corruption and lawbreaking before, during, or after.

13

u/OffToRaces 15h ago

Good luck with that. When is the WH Counsel going to be brought up on charges??

14

u/Fast_Feeling_8917 15h ago

And Bar complaints.

12

u/rahvan 17h ago

The paper used for this executive order is prime material for the Congress toilets. Because that’s how worthless this executive order is, that literally anyone can wipe their asses with it

23

u/YesterShill 17h ago

EOs do not supersede the Constitution or laws.

11

u/intronert 18h ago

It’s all about the coverup.

11

u/1970s_MonkeyKing 17h ago

/Congress laughing in Constitution

→ More replies (1)

11

u/PDXGuy33333 15h ago

The ultimate lesson here is going to be "Thou shalt not anger those who fund your existence."

20

u/CommonConundrum51 12h ago

Reinforcing the position that they have nothing to hide.

10

u/copperblood 18h ago

Temu Mao speaks 🤣🤡

10

u/jim45804 18h ago

Ah yes, something a dictator would do.

10

u/ShareGlittering1502 18h ago

Trump: “I’m on base. You can’t touch me.”

10

u/GrannyFlash7373 15h ago

LAME attempt to try and stop the criminal investigations into his Regime's nefarious activities. However, it isn't worth the paper it is written on.

10

u/DiverBackground6038 5h ago

3 EQUAL branches of government, the President has no authority over congress

9

u/0_IceQueen_0 18h ago

Is this the bureaucratic version of shredding documents before a raid? 😂

An executive order doesn't override congressional subpoena power. All this really does is guarantee two years of court battles to run out the clock.

9

u/canwehavepotatojokes 17h ago

He keeps trying to do King shit.

9

u/letdogsvote 17h ago

For a group that claims to own Patriotism, the MAGAs sure do want a king.

9

u/burnmenowz 16h ago

Unconstitutional

16

u/buntopolis 17h ago

We need a constitutional amendment to get rid of unitary executive theory - this administration has turned the country into a sick joke. Aided and abetted by a Supreme Court who apparently think the people rebelling against a King would set up their own.

8

u/NoPhone4571 18h ago

Absolutely meaningless to the Legislative Branch.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/gerblnutz 18h ago

Good thing the constitution says otherwise

8

u/SoCallMeDeaconBlues1 18h ago

For now, Congress has abdicated the power of the purse.

Maybe it's time for that to change.

8

u/guttanzer 17h ago

So, nothing.

Congress has a legislative interest in everything that happens in the executive branch.

8

u/southflhitnrun 17h ago

Nothing he does as an official act of his Presidency is a crime, based on a simple interpretation of that SCOTUS decision.

Everytime they want to do something they think it illegal, they have him issue an EO.

It really is that simple. And, the underlings believe they are shielded from prosecution because they are just "following the EO."

8

u/atreeismissing 16h ago

Can news orgs start putting the word "nonsense" in front all Trump EOs. This is clearly illegal, and will be overturned once it works it's way through the courts, but it's obviously nonsense and done to give him cover to delay handing Dems govt documents, which by the Constitution they have an oversight right to view.

8

u/AtuinTurtle 14h ago

Part of this is that he’s threatening to fire anyone that cooperates with the probes. Is that extortion?

14

u/ScarInternational161 16h ago

I have a very real question.

Is the law going to be able to withstand the challenges this administration has presented, without direct interaction from some form of police/military style of force to prompt them to comply?

Stripping it down to bare bones? Is there even a way to force the executive branch to comply with court, constitutional, federal law, or even scotus decisions?

9

u/DeathKillsLove 16h ago

Yes.
Take away the money.
Fine the "R"s for failure to comply with Congress power to COMPEL testimony

9

u/talino2321 16h ago

Yes, don't fund them. The power of the purse is Congress's only real hold over the executive branch. Oh sure Congress can withhold approving the 🍊💩 appointments. But ultimately it comes down to the money

8

u/bobnla14 15h ago

Um, The Trump administration reallocated funds that were already earmarked for various programs and moved them to other projects. Doge flat out and pounded funds that had already been allocated for various projects. This is in direct violation of the power of the person, yet nobody did anything at the Congressional level. Several of the organizations did get their money after filing lawsuits and enough time went by that they realized that they weren't getting the savings out of Doge that they thought they would

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/PreparationKey2843 18h ago

Why would he do that? Does he have something criminal to hide? (Rhetorical questions)

7

u/wooops 18h ago

That's not how any of this works

7

u/RustedRelics 18h ago

Doesn’t work that way, Donny. But, of course, they know that and do it simply to cause disruption and force lawsuits. Traitors — every one of them.

7

u/Admirable_Nothing competent contributor 18h ago

The Coverup begins

7

u/Rough_Common6857 16h ago

Totally not hiding anything 🙄

6

u/dryheat122 18h ago

Tyrant who thinks he's king tries to neuter a co-equal branch by signing a decree.

Dems should request a hearing on the shadow docket. This more of an "emergency" than anything the admin has requested that for.

6

u/Depressed-Industry 17h ago

Th new Congress should zero out OMB.

6

u/bd2999 16h ago

Seems meaningless to do this. You cannot declare yourself resistant to a branch that provides oversight. The whole point of this is to trigger a lawsuit to cause delays. As this is horribly unconstitutional.

5

u/LotsofSports 18h ago

EO is a big zero.

5

u/CFCYYZ 18h ago

"You can fool all the people some of the time and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time."

- A. Lincoln (attrib)

4

u/Separate-String5205 17h ago

Wow. I never knew Bob Marley was quoting Lincoln . Awesome

→ More replies (1)

5

u/stlnation500 16h ago

New Congress: “Aww that’s cute.”

*Proceeds to Ignore Executive Order

→ More replies (6)

5

u/pilsnerd11 15h ago

Cute, might slow things briefly until a judge says “no”.

5

u/whereismymind86 7h ago

Yeah...that's not a thing he can do, this eo can and will simply be ignored.

4

u/ZorroMcChucknorris 18h ago

This mother fucker.

4

u/What_a_fat_one 17h ago

hahahaha that's not the way that works mother fucker

4

u/Hesitation-Marx 16h ago

Whew, that’s impressively corrupt.

6

u/mothyyy 7h ago

There's this thing called the Judicial Branch which will say "yeah no, you can't do that."

4

u/Treblehawk 4h ago

Are you sure? Some of the things they should have said no to they have not said no to...

3

u/Ok_Face8380 17h ago

Right and he can’t start wars without Congress’s approval.

We all see how that is working out.

3

u/mediaogre 17h ago

The kompromat is strong with this one.

3

u/HeadApplication2941 7h ago

Is this a cover up ?

5

u/dsj79 17h ago

Which means absolutely nothing
It’s a means to get to the Supreme Court
6-3 would be my guess

7

u/Florac 16h ago

It’s a means to get to the Supreme Court

Which allows Trumo to delay investigators by a year or so.

2

u/Slippery-ape 17h ago

Lol good luck