r/law • Competent Contributor • 14h ago • Mindblown 4 Regret 1

Legal News Austin man deported to Mexico is a US citizen, feds admit. They want the lawsuit dismissed.

https://www.statesman.com/news/article/austin-man-deported-mexico-us-citizen-lawsuit-22543114.php
17k Upvotes

423 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 14h ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (1)

3.0k

u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 14h ago • Bravo Mindblown Popcorn

What might go wrong if we allow ICE to deport American citizens without repercussions? Surely they wouldn't abuse that power...

91

u/Harmony_Bunny42 13h ago

According to Kavanaugh, such stops are merely "brief encounters" where citizens or lawful residents are quickly "free to go" after answering a few questions.

I guess he meant that for white people only.

43

u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 12h ago

Free to go... ...to Mexico

15

u/Odd_Vampire 11h ago

Or god knows what corrupt little Third World country they'll decide to send you.

28

u/Tier0001 10h ago

Nothing says "land of the free" quite like randomly being kidnapped and forced to "answer a few questions" by a militarized force.

24

u/XelaNiba 10h ago

And then to be detained, imprisoned, and deported because you couldn't produce your birth certificate during.....a traffic stop for excessive window tint. And you were just a passenger, riding along with coworkers on the way to work.

And your prison didn't accept the citizenship documents from your relatives who produced them to secure your release.

So much freedom!

7

u/IncredibleEdible321 8h ago

Except that people who clearly appear to be white don't ever suffer these kinds of indignities, let alone get kidnapped off the street, detained, and deported... unless, of course, they protest what ICE is doing or happen to get in their way. Then ICE just executes them in broad daylight.

1.4k

u/B-Z_B-S 14h ago

151

u/Vulpine_Gamer_194 13h ago

41

u/Boba_Brett 13h ago

31

u/Vulpine_Gamer_194 13h ago

A person of culture I see! Welcome fellow Tenno!

16

u/Boba_Brett 13h ago

Right back at ya! You miss Eris yet?

→ More replies (9)

13

u/mery_alv 12h ago

Im printing this for my next protest jajajajaj gold!

10

u/ItaJohnson 6h ago

Applies to cops too.

8

u/SuperSpecialAwesome- 11h ago

What's the original context for this pic?

55

u/B-Z_B-S 11h ago

17

u/Intoxic8edOne 9h ago

They're the same picture

180

u/P4us1ngD34th 14h ago

There needs to be accountability. The DOJ under Trump and his personal attorney have become a joke. The rule of law has been broken and beaten in favor of a wannabe mob boss and serial grifter and liar.

2

u/xteve 12h ago

Sarcasm: When you really really don't want to just say it, and you hope that at least somebody misunderstands your intentions.

4

u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 11h ago

I think this time I got away with it, even without the /s tag.

2

u/xteve 11h ago

"I got away with it." There's a high standard. Oh shit I'm being sarcastic now too. It's an epidemic of cheekiness. Anyhow, it's only a pet peeve; I also dislike local driving habits.

406

u/dallas121469 14h ago • Mindblown Bravo

But, but, but MAGAs said this would never happen. I’m confused. /s

173

u/BobbyJGatorFace 14h ago

Right? All you have to do is prove on the spot you’re an American citizen and they’ll totally believe you!

160

u/dallas121469 14h ago • Bravo

Good thing I always carry my DL, passport, birth certificate, SS card and sworn affidavit of my citizenship notarized and signed by 3 witnesses of good character. ICE needs to be defunded and dismantled. Ever wonder why Bush Jr. is so quiet nowadays? Because he formed this little army of brown shirts in the patriot act.

70

u/SimilarYard9840 13h ago

All they have to do is throw that shit away and say you didn’t have it. They’ll just lie in court with no repercussions if you’re lucky enough to even get to have due process. They’re even worse than the police.

20

u/Toadcola 10h ago

Have to get back alive from South America first, without documents, money, or your phone. Good luck!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/inredditorbit 12h ago

I’m doubting Shrub ever did anything while in office that wasn’t the brainchild of Dick Cheney.

6

u/Any-Expert6697 11h ago

Finally, someone else that uses shrub to describe Junior.

10

u/XelaNiba 9h ago

That's apparently not enough. You're gonna need to track down witnesses to your birth and get affidavits from them as well. And you'll need hospital records, baptismal records, and pediatrician records.

What's that? The small community hospital where your mom delivered you has been shut down for years and the records are unrecoverable? Too bad, off Congo with you.

4

u/dallas121469 9h ago

Not funny because the hospital I was born at is indeed shut down. 😡 lol

9

u/elonsghost 13h ago

Sounds sus

3

u/Toadcola 10h ago

I dunno, it’s not normal to carry that much documentation. Probably all forged.

→ More replies (1)

78

u/xigdit 14h ago

MAGA were disappointed this didn't happen far more frequently

36

u/dallas121469 14h ago

They’re are Nazi wannabes

17

u/Dragon_wryter 13h ago

No no they can't be Nazis because they don't hate Jews! Literally everything else is exactly the same, but you can't call then Nazis because they disagree on exterminating that one specific group. The other groups are still OK to get rid of, just not that one.

12

u/Kaida33 13h ago

They are Christian Nationalists!!!

6

u/xteve 11h ago

Yes; but we absolve mainstream Christians when we blame the nationalists/evangelicals. Christians vote GOP in large numbers, driven by their distaste for reproductive freedom. Without the support of those whom we may call normal Christians, the freaks wouldn't have the MAGA platform.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ghost_finger 13h ago

If the person is brown are they really American though? - MAGA probably

2

u/mallogy 8h ago

It's been happening for decades. In the past, it tended to happen to people with disabilities who didn't understand what was going on. Now it's happening despite vehement protests by the victims.

1

u/fieryembers 53m ago

Yeah my mom told me that I was an idiot for voting for Harris, and that the US would never deport legal citizens. Then when I bring up the US deporting legal citizens “I don’t want to talk about politics, you know I don’t like talking about politics!” 🫩

72

u/KiscoKid1 13h ago

So does that mean we can deport Stephen Miller in a couple of years?

55

u/mixedresults12 13h ago

The real problem is how do we get him back to Mordor?

30

u/Numerous_Photograph9 13h ago • Helpful

Just give a small child a ring and send him. Miller will follow on his own

21

u/cooptheactor 13h ago

Now that's a little much, this is Stephen Miller we're talking about.

Just the child is enough, he won't care about some ring

6

u/CareApart504 11h ago

Any active volcano will do.

7

u/smellslike2016 12h ago

Just chuck him into the closest volcano.

3

u/readtheinstructions5 11h ago

I thought if we just throw a ring into the lava he would go after it screaming "MY PRECIOUS".

2

u/Gnardude 10h ago

Same way that they're taking the Hobbits to Isengard.

1

u/Dismal_Flounder_8351 12h ago

There is a convenient but secret drop off point for Mordor about 700 miles SE of Hawaii.

1

u/Forikorder 12h ago

true, we cant have him walk

1

u/KennethTremendous 12h ago

Tell him Baggins has his ring

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Electric_Antimony 13h ago

Send him to that Salvadorian gang torture prison and tell them all he's a snitch.

1

u/ScarInternational161 1h ago

I heard $5k a head is all it took, anyone got the venmo?

21

u/jankenpoo 13h ago

I predict he will “self-deport” himself in a few years to escape justice

10

u/JohnHazardWandering 13h ago

It won't work. We need to work on a solution involving garlic and wooden stakes. 

2

u/MRCHalifax 9h ago

So, fun fact: in the original Dracula novel, Dracula is not killed by a stake through the heart. A lawyer takes his head off with a kukri while a cowboy stabs him in the heart with a Bowie knife.

1

u/SutroViews 12h ago

Deport him directly into the custody of the International Criminal Court in the Hague.

1

u/friggintodd 12h ago

We just need to find out what his real name is and trick him into saying it backwards.

1

u/Deep_shot 3h ago

Can you even imagine what this country would be like if he had anywhere near the amount of power as a president and given control of the military? It would be the first American reich in the most literal sense possible.

43

u/Desperate_Set_7708 14h ago

Should be a summary judgment against the government.

27

u/-Nightopian- 14h ago

Against the individuals who authorized this.

11

u/wooops 13h ago

From the top to the bottom

26

u/epoch16245 14h ago

They seem like super reasonable people from all the videos I’ve seen. /s

28

u/Evadrepus 9h ago

You can't 'deport' a citizen, only an immigrant. Sending a citizen away like this is exile, not deportation.

24

u/maddrjeffe 9h ago

Kidnapping and false imprisonment

12

u/Financial-Week5787 9h ago

the constitution would agree, the supreme court agreed that ICE has no jurisdiction over US citizens

obviously with one opinion contrary called the kavanaugh stop where imprisonment is illegal but arresting someone and detaining them for the crime of looking foreign or brown is fine as long as its Just the right amount of harassment and not too detrimental

1

u/The_Bilo 9h ago

Whooooosh

6

u/DazzlingRutabega 11h ago

Yeah, right, and what could go wrong with doing mass deportations where they just round up people with a huge drag net indiscriminately.

6

u/delphinous 5h ago

it's really simple. they operate under a very simple premise: non americans don't have rights as americans. if they just assume everyone is a non-american then they have no duty to actually follow laws and can do whatever the hell they want. and since some people in power basically want to use them as a source of fear to exert control, they get political protection

and most of the time when they screw up and do act against americans, the americans in question aren't politically connected and it gets swept under the rug and hushed up, or blamed on some minority immigrant group

2

u/PantsLobbyist 13h ago

In their eyes it’s not a bug, it’s a feature.

2

u/Woolybugger00 11h ago

Even better is just shooting the citizens they don’t like ….

2

u/Unable-Log-4870 10h ago

Lawsuits won’t stop abuses of power. It takes something more immediate.

2

u/rainshowers_5_peace 7h ago

Trumps end goal is to deport people he hates to the camps he's built in South Sudan and El Salvador. If he figures out how to strip people who born in the states of citizenship it's over.

1

u/texachusetts 12h ago

If he was a gun owner would still be ok with the 2nd amendment because the government took him away from his gun(s) and not the other way around. The founders and the law are very clear about this. I don’t make up the rules,

1

u/Dramatic_Charity_979 8h ago

Let's deport ICE to the arctic :P

1

u/DrNoxin 8h ago

They aren't getting the repercussions regardless. Taxpayers are.

1

u/nahcekimcm 5h ago

Bootlickers will say at least they weren’t at a concentration camp

1

u/updoot35 46m ago

Reposting articles and top comments, I see. Bot.

287

u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 14h ago • Bravo

In case of paywall, break glass:

The federal government has acknowledged that an Austin man deported to Mexico following a Central Texas traffic stop in April is a U.S. citizen, reversing its earlier position as it seeks to dismiss a lawsuit accusing immigration agents of violating his constitutional rights.

Brian José Morales García, 25, was born in Denver and is a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico, federal attorneys said in a motion filed Friday in U.S. District Court in Austin. The acknowledgment comes nearly seven months after U.S. Border Patrol agents sent him to Mexico despite his repeated claims that he was American.

In the same filing, federal attorneys asked U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman to dismiss Morales García's lawsuit, arguing that federal immigration officers are protected from certain civil claims arising from their enforcement of immigration laws. The government maintains that Morales García voluntarily agreed to return to Mexico and disputes his allegations that agents pressured him into doing so.

The admission is a reversal of the government's previous position. In April, U.S. Customs and Border Protection told the American-Statesman that it had not arrested a U.S. citizen, saying records showed Morales García was in the country illegally.

Morales García returned to Texas on Aug. 30 after his attorneys provided additional documentation supporting his citizenship and reached an agreement with the Justice Department. His lawsuit, which seeks monetary damages and other relief, remains pending.

How an Austin man was deported after a traffic stop

Morales García was riding in a pickup truck with coworkers near Fredericksburg on April 3 when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper pulled over the vehicle for an alleged window tint violation.

Morales García, who speaks Spanish and was not carrying identification, told officers that he was born in Colorado and had a birth certificate and Social Security card at his Austin home, according to his lawsuit. Authorities contacted federal immigration agents, and Morales García was taken to the Gillespie County Jail before being transferred to Border Patrol custody.

Four days later, he was sent to Mexico.

The American-Statesman previously reviewed copies of Morales García's Colorado birth certificate, hospital documents and baptismal records and independently confirmed the existence of records supporting his birth in Denver.

His citizenship became a central dispute in the lawsuit he filed May 1 against federal immigration officials and state and local law enforcement officers.

Brian José Morales García (right) poses with his younger brother Miguel Ángel Morales García. Brian José Morales García (right) poses with his younger brother Miguel Ángel Morales García. Contributed by Brian Jose Morales Garcia/Contributed At a June hearing, Pitman declined to immediately order Morales García's return, citing conflicting birth records from the United States and Mexico. The judge instead directed both sides to gather additional evidence.

Morales García's attorneys subsequently obtained further documentation, including hospital records and witness statements, before the federal government agreed to permit his return in August.

Federal attorneys defend agents' actions

The government's latest filing provides a detailed account of how Border Patrol agents concluded Morales García was born in Mexico, even as federal attorneys now acknowledge his American citizenship.

According to the motion, Border Patrol Agent Robert Gil Jr. questioned Morales García at the Gillespie County Jail and checked a Mexican government identification database after Morales García said he did not have his birth certificate.

Gil found a Mexican registration record identifying Morales García as having been born in Zacatecas, Mexico. The agent said Morales García also told him he was born there after being warned that providing false information could result in criminal charges.

Based on that information, Gil concluded Morales García was in the United States illegally, according to the filing.

Federal attorneys contend that the agent explained Morales García's options, including appearing before an immigration judge or voluntarily returning to Mexico. They said Morales García chose to return and signed immigration forms confirming his decision.

Morales García has offered a different account.

In his lawsuit, he alleges agents repeatedly accused him of lying about his citizenship and threatened him with imprisonment. He said he eventually falsely claimed to have entered the country illegally because he feared prolonged detention and believed agreeing to leave was his only realistic option.

His attorneys also allege that family members and friends tried unsuccessfully to provide documents proving his citizenship while he was detained.

The federal government disputes those allegations, maintaining that Gil did not threaten Morales García or force him to sign the documents.

The motion does not explain what specific evidence ultimately resolved the conflicting birth records or whether immigration authorities reviewed that evidence before allowing Morales García to return.

Government seeks dismissal despite citizenship acknowledgment

Federal attorneys argue that Morales García cannot pursue damages against individual immigration agents under a legal doctrine stemming from a 1971 Supreme Court decision known as Bivens, which allows certain lawsuits against federal officers for constitutional violations. The government contends that federal courts have declined to extend those protections to similar claims involving civil immigration enforcement.

Federal attorneys also argue that sovereign immunity prevents Morales García from pursuing his constitutional claims against the federal officials named in their official capacities because he has not established that the government waived its immunity from such lawsuits.

Separately, Gillespie County Chief Deputy Bryan Philips filed a motion Friday seeking dismissal of any claims against him. Philips argues that he was never named as a defendant in the lawsuit and that the complaint does not allege he personally participated in Morales García's detention.

Pitman has not ruled on either motion. Attorneys representing Morales García did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the government's filing.

Morales García's lawsuit seeks compensation for his detention, removal, lost wages and emotional distress.

164

u/Snakes_AnonyMouse 13h ago

Just to get this right, when presented with "conflicting birth records from the United States and Mexico" the judge decided the correct thing was to continue the illegal "deportment"? What happened to innocent until proven guilty? This sounds an awful lot like guilty until you can disprove every piece of bullshit we made up".

Every part of this is fucked, but to me ignoring this fundamental element of constitutional protection is absolutely wild and beyond the pale. He should have had an emergency injunction to return Brian to the Untied States until such time that the government could actually prove their case

67

u/nhavar 13h ago

Immigration judges work for the executive branch and follow whatever guidance the current admin provides versus judicial branch judges who are overseeing the lawsuit. Two different groups with differing agendas.

20

u/NeitherEntry6125 12h ago

Immigration judges are also nazi's

2

u/maroon_sky 5h ago

Not only that. In the last two years the DOJ replaced most of the old judges who knew the law better than the new appointees who in the most of the cases don't have much immigration law experience (just check any DOJ press releases about the new judges, for example). The latter care only about the numbers.

3

u/IzarkKiaTarj 9h ago

What the fuck? How did we end up deciding that some judges shouldn't be in the judicial branch?

7

u/WishAbedWasBatman 5h ago

For the same reason it was decided long ago that immigration violations are civil offenses and not criminal, that way they don't have to be guaranteed an attorney: because they want to violate people's rights and keep the system rigged against certain groups of people.

3

u/Engorgedtoenail 5h ago edited 5h ago

The short overly simplified version is that the constitution defines the judicial branch in Article III. Lays out the federal courts, appoint process, and whatnot. The Supremes, circuit and district courts are all Article III judges.

Then there are Article I judges. These are authorized by congress, but mostly run by the executive branch and don’t have a uniform rules and process on appointments and powers. Generally they are more specialized courts like bankruptcy, tax, territorial courts and immigration courts. These “judges” don’t have the same lifetime tenure, salary, and other protections article III judges get. Article III courts are always worried about resources and are generally happy to not be bogged down by all of the thousands and thousands of cases article I courts deal with. And article I courts are fairly limited in scope. A bankruptcy judge is only supposed to deal with issues of law necessary for the bankruptcy matter.

It makes some sense. Article I courts deal with specialized matters. Taxes and bankruptcy are complicated, makes sense to have a court that just lives and breathe it. Same with military courts, it’s literally its own legal system that the average lawyer never touches. But the Executive branch ends up having way more power and influence over these courts which leads to problems. Immigration court is particularly bad.

On paper there is supposed to be an appeals process where article III courts can review the article I courts, so they should be the final say

Disclaimer, there have been some recent Supreme Court cases that have upset a lot of long established administrative law and I have not bothered to keep up with it. I think everything above should still be right lacks a lot of detail and nuance

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nhavar 3h ago

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act in 1952 Congress created a new role inside the executive branch which was meant to oversee immigration and deportation cases. At the time they were called "special inquiry officers". Later the DOJ decided that when deportation was contested they needed a separate prosecutor role. By the 70's they took that a step further and changed the "special inquiry officer" to use the title of "immigration judge" to reflect their "adjudication" of the cases, given that there could be both a prosecution and a defense. Even though many of the normal criminal court proceedings and rigor aren't there because this is a civil matter (i.e. like a ordinance violation or a parking ticket, not theft or murder). Thus no right to speedy trial or trial by jury of peers or any of those things really. Just the DOJ deciding who goes and who stays based on their own criteria and the whim of the administration in power at the time. Usually it doesn't change on a dime, but you know Trump and maximizing chaos for the likes and the clicks and the meme coins and all.

39

u/TheRealStepBot 12h ago

No judge was involved here. Just employees of the executive branch acting without due process or judicial oversight.

31

u/Fischer72 11h ago

You are correct. Immigration "judges" are not Article 3 judges. They are Administrative Adjudicators who work under the Executive branch. Trump has also purged them of all independent members and replaced them with rubberstamp cronies.

14

u/blbd 7h ago

Immigration "judges" are part of the executive branch and don't have appropriate tenure protections or legal qualifications of any meaningful level. Thus making them every bit as corrupt and/or biased as whomever is running the executive branch at any given point.

So they should not actually be allowed to judge any cases of anything at all in the first place. Thanks to the morons in SCROTUS they are allowed to do this despite the fact that the plain language reading of the Constitution would imply exactly the opposite approach to things would be correct. 

→ More replies (1)

50

u/ori68 14h ago

Kind of seems like ICE and the police department should be sued

32

u/ZombieZookeeper 13h ago

So basically Robert Gil Jr saw brown skin and immediately thought "illegal".

Next we need to identify the DOJ lawyers making arguments so we know who needs to be disbarred.

31

u/SoCallMeDeaconBlues1 14h ago

I hope he doesn't drop the case- or take settlement. Sure seems to me that they could've at least LOOKED, and it doesn't sound like they did.

1

u/Any_Show_5160 9h ago

He will take a settlement, the city, state or federal government will pay handsomely to sweep this under the rug, it makes it harder for the next person suing the government if no precedent has been set.

26

u/TheRealStepBot 12h ago

The very premise of their argument is ridiculous on its face. The detention of a us person citizen or not is coercive. What other forms of coercion they deny beyond that is entire immaterial.

“We didn’t literally torture him” good on ya, but why is he in jail without lawyer to begin with. Calling it immigration detention doesn’t suddenly make it different from any other arrest. That they then didn’t bring charges or accuse him of a crime aught to be reason enough for action against them to begin with.

Just not following the law does not remove the burden of the government to ensure that process has been followed and his rights are being protected.

1

u/Kruphix_Horizon 4h ago

I think they're trying to establish immigration detention as a loophole to unlawfully imprison citizens.

1

u/TheRealStepBot 4h ago

Oh that’s very much the play. Having detention that’s not detention is the point here.

My point is that the emperor is clearly naked. It’s an abandonment of the principles of the rule of law. It’s entirely extra judicial.

They are largely counting on the combination of this stuff being boring to the average person and thus they can’t tell this sham from the real thing, and secondly the rabid nativism of maga supporters

23

u/hhmCameron 13h ago • Bravo
  • We don't need no water
  • Let the (trump loving bastards) burn
  • burn (trump loving bastards) burn

3

u/NeitherEntry6125 12h ago

I'm pretty sure they'd put the you know what in the you know where

3

u/hhmCameron 12h ago

There it is tyvm

1

u/DeepD4yourwife 13h ago

Classic

3

u/hhmCameron 12h ago

I wonder where the bloodhound gang would be on this...

1

u/DeepD4yourwife 12h ago

Your comment deserves this

2

u/hhmCameron 12h ago

Deserves what?

No pic did have

2

u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 12h ago

Imagine a fierce beer coaster.

11

u/ViolettaQueso 14h ago

Thank you.

6

u/Sojouner_King 8h ago

I got banned from r/immigration for saying that this is what happened. The MOD was sure I was wrong and was spreading misinformation. The bootlicker MOD insisted ICE follows all procedures and laws and to say otherwise was spreading misinformation. But anyone with a brain that had been paying attention knew ICE violated his rights and maliciously refused to check his citizenship.

3

u/inredditorbit 12h ago

It’s particularly surprising given that Judge Pitman is an Obama appointee, pretty progressive in his rulings (that conservative appellate judges love to overturn) and is one of only 4 openly gay judges in that position in the country, along with 3 women. You’d think he’d be able to spot discrimination and a rush to judgment.

→ More replies (50)

986

u/geekmasterflash 14h ago

In the same filing, federal attorneys asked U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman to dismiss Morales García's lawsuit, arguing that federal immigration officers are protected from certain civil claims arising from their enforcement of immigration laws. The government maintains that Morales García voluntarily agreed to return to Mexico and disputes his allegations that agents pressured him into doing so.

The federal government has now explicitly acknowledged that Morales García is a United States citizen, while simultaneously arguing that immigration enforcement immunity should shield it from liability for removing him from his own country.

Given the fact he is a documented citizen, just about every sitting judge and if necessary jury will have the same thought: why would a citizen volunteer for such a thing outside of undo coercion?

Coercion which they now admit begins with a false arrest and imprisonment which sets the stage for this "agreement."

642

u/Kahzgul 14h ago • Bravo

A US citizen isn’t “returning” to Mexico. They’re being exiled there.

274

u/Pokerhobo 13h ago

It was human trafficking.

148

u/Effective-Cress-3805 13h ago

Isn't this known as kidnapping?

45

u/RUOFFURTROLLEH 11h ago

Isn't all of this moot?

We might get the courts to allow Garcia to return back to the US...

But there is no accountability since Trump is going to pardon LITERALLY EVERYONE connected to him.

36

u/geekmasterflash 11h ago

Fun fact about pardons:

You can't invoke the 5th when called to testify about it. Pardoning everyone actually puts Trump and the administration into a corner where all of the bullshit gets recorded down to the last detail.

19

u/RUOFFURTROLLEH 11h ago

Errrr... have we been following different Administrations?

Trump doesn't follow the law or rules and even when forced by courts they still refuse.

So I mean, Trump will pardon them and they will continue to refuse subpeonas.

I would love what you are saying to come true but that stills requires them to actually say that bullshit which we already know they won't do.

It literally needs to be punishment or its 100% fair game for them to continue.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/geekmasterflash 14h ago

A) That is a quote, not me saying that.

B) He's a dual citizen, so it would be okay to say he's returning both in the case of going to Mexico and also in coming back.

81

u/Kahzgul 14h ago • Bravo

I know. I’m responding to the quote. It’s an insane argument. Also, America doesn’t care about dual citizenship. If you’re a citizen, you’re a citizen, and forcing you out of the country is technically exile.

33

u/LOSSLESS_FLAC 12h ago

I'm a dual citizen both US and Mexico (parents) and I don't 'Return' to Mexico. I go to Mexico. I do not live in Mexico. I don't work in Mexico. What do I 'return' to are to my fav taquerias and coffee shops.

14

u/Worried-Rough-338 12h ago

You can be a dual citizen of a country without ever having been there. “Return” implies going back to a place you’ve been before, which isn’t automatically the case in a case of dual citizenship.

1

u/morpheousmorty 44m ago

I'd have to say exile is also accurate because good luck getting back in with a deportation in your record. It happens but so does returning after exile.

61

u/IchooseYourName 13h ago

"...return to Mexico."

Using return is a choice, considering he was born in the U.S.

19

u/inredditorbit 12h ago

Correct, seeing as Mexico is not his country of origin. He drew his first breath in Denver.

87

u/Unbr3akableSwrd 14h ago

I mean, with all the news and stories about ICE deporting people to El Salvador or other countries to which they have no relation with, seems like, facing the unknown or Mexico, it’s no surprise they choose to go to Mexico and figured things out once there.

38

u/geekmasterflash 14h ago

Yes, I can hardly blame Morales for that and I look forward to his explaining how that was used to coerce his "agreement."

6

u/Mute2120 10h ago

And deporting here doesn't describe what's happening. They are getting sent to foreign prison/labor camps for life without trial. That's a lot of the coercion, you leave on your own or you're life is basically over.

21

u/Schuben 12h ago

Undue* coercion. As in not-due to them. Undo coercion is what I gaslit Clippy with in the early 2000s.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Previous_Beautiful27 12h ago

“Arising from their enforcement of immigration laws” what immigration laws were being enforced here? Sending a US citizen to Mexico is enforcing what law exactly? This is clown shit

11

u/xigdit 11h ago

Got it. DOJ says this guy is entitled to jack squat for being kidnapped, falsely imprisoned, and wrongly deported, but also tried to assert Trump was entitled to $1.776 billion and lifelong indemnity because of the horrific offense that the IRS leaked his tax return, which happened while he, Trump, was president!

The oligarchy can't get much starker than this.

3

u/boringhistoryfan 11h ago

Put simply: We are allowed to rendition US citizens and not be accountable because we put the letters ICE on our vests.

2

u/Kerbart 8h ago

One can argue that he arrived in Mexico under false pretenses about his Mexican citizenship.

That makes him, in the eyes if ICE, a law breaker of the worst kind. Surely we can now revoke his citizenship as he committed a crime!

/s because reddit is full of idiots

1

u/ArtsyApoidean 6h ago

Since when does immigration enforcement get to be above the law? I don't recall that part of the Constitution.

Is this based on the precedent from Trump v United States regarding general far-reaching executive immunity, or is this a Bush-era thing? Or are they just fabricating it wholecloth?

186

u/sweatboxy 14h ago

If ICE with all its billions of dollars can’t tell who’s an American citizen, why should we let the federal government determine who has a legitimate right to vote?

41

u/lunartree 14h ago

That's exactly why the federal government DOESN'T control who has the right to vote.

16

u/NotWorthSurveilling 13h ago

They might be talking about the so called SAVE America Act.

5

u/QuintinStone 7h ago

A fact which the GOP is trying to change.

12

u/Kahzgul 14h ago

I mean… states run their own elections, not the feds.

2

u/capincus 1h ago

They're incredibly obviously referring to the current federal administration's attempts to take over control of election administration/voter roles.

3

u/Revolutionary_Bee251 12h ago

They could if that was truly their intention, with honest mistakes being quickly addressed with a sincere apology and mild reparations as appropriate.

Accurate databased immigration enforcement is, shockingly, not their goal.

182

u/fredandlunchbox 14h ago

I've read that ICE agents have to repay their full sign-on bonus if they fail to complete their contract for any reason, including termination without cause.

So if a new administration or a new congress were to fire them all, they'd be on the hook for $50k that I'm sure has been spent a long time ago.

Just food for thought.

90

u/Schmenza 14h ago

Used truck market about to get real spicy

35

u/hipyounggunslinger67 13h ago

So predictable. You know how people figure out where an ICE surge is happening ahead of time? Tinder, suddenly there will be an influx of a bunch of men of a certain stereotype in the area. They also all book at a particular hotel chain to bank reward points.

2

u/balding_git 5h ago

tinder? or grindr?

15

u/x5163x 14h ago

Junior enlisted military have already been doing this.

27

u/Revolutionary_Bee251 12h ago

Two things -

  • ICE agents have yet to receive the $50k bonus they were promised
  • Homeland still has access to billions of untapped dollars for the rest of Trump's presidency unless Congress rescinds it

Feel free to correct me if you have evidence to the contrary

20

u/skawn 12h ago

Supposedly, it's 10k paid yearly, for five years.

Source: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2025/10/18/florida-ice-job-police-hiring

2

u/fredandlunchbox 10h ago

This is also what I’ve read, and there may have been a lump sum at some point as well?

1

u/Revolutionary_Bee251 5h ago

Great source, thanks for sharing. The last bit is something I think we're all wondering.

"“I think it’ll be interesting to go back and look at this 10 years from now and see who took these jobs, what happens to their careers long term and where they end up,” Burch said of the ICE recruitment."

86

u/mr_evilweed 14h ago

Oh... so like... exactly what liberals have been saying happens when you dont have due process and exactly what conservatives have been saying never happens?

12

u/Worried-Rough-338 12h ago

I suppose he should be grateful he was deported to Mexico and not the Democratic Republic of Congo.

→ More replies (3)

77

u/doublethink_1984 14h ago

ICE agents do have some levels of immunity when enforcing immigration law.

Kidnapping, pressuring, and kicking a citizen out of the United States is not enforcing immigration law

9

u/Initial_Attitude_851 12h ago

Immunity is the problem across the entirety of the public sector. Public sector jobs are the participation trophies of the workforce.

182

u/blahblah19999 11h ago

So The US government can just deport a citizen with no repercussions. Someone tell me how the 2A crowd is OK with this.

86

u/EvilDanno 11h ago • Bravo

There is no single group of people more cowardly than the 2A crowd. All a bunch of feckless larping posers.

35

u/wotantx 11h ago

r/liberalgunowners exists, but we're hardly the majority.

13

u/Major_Regret2905 9h ago

Liberals with guns are like conservatives with abortions: you have em you just don't talk about em

→ More replies (1)

6

u/EvilDanno 10h ago

No argument there. I shouldn't paint you all with the same brush. As a Canadian gun owner, it's hard to see you guys have a legitimate right to own proper firearms and have a significant portion of those fortunate folks not ever intend to exercise that right. Far easier to drink the Kool-Aid, suck orange dick and blame Black people, immigrants and the 3 trans people who want to play sports I guess.

2

u/slab_schitty 9h ago

Don’t underestimate us and how well armed we are lol. All my lib friends are armed to the hilt.

I lost all my firearms in a fishing accident a while back.

1

u/Aviacks 2h ago

I'm struggling to understanding how liberal pro 2A are supported in this forum while we're also calling anyone pro 2A a coward for not killing federal agents? You're just as cowardly as pro 2A MAGA by the standards the comments have set here

14

u/GoAheadIfYourAble 10h ago

It’s not “larping” when many of them are openly white nationalists, they straight up don’t think every citizen has the same rights as them. Unpatriotic losers

57

u/MadRaymer 10h ago • Bravo

The 2A crowd insisted they needed weapons to stop a tyrannical government, but now that the tyrannical government has arrived they can't use their weapons because their hands are occupied with jerking it to that tyrannical government since it oppresses people they don't like.

3

u/WinterTourist25 10h ago

Hey, two of 'em already stepped up.

→ More replies (14)

16

u/Jonqbanana 7h ago

It is amazing to me the buffoonery in these comments. You are absolutely correct. The 2a crowd has been absolutely silent. They will say children dying from gun violence is a necessary evil to protect their right to defend themselves from a tyrannical government but when a tyrannical government comes along they are fine with it because it’s truly exactly what they want.

10

u/Igggg 8h ago

Not every UA citizen! Just the ones that fail a Kavanaugh stop.

13

u/Gwendolyn-NB 11h ago

Something something something skin color something something heritage something something

10

u/Itscatpicstime 7h ago

Easy, he’s brown

13

u/Haradion_01 10h ago

The 2A crowd was always on the side of authoritarian government, so long as it only oppressed the people they thought were lesser. 

3

u/Equivalent_Ad9414 11h ago

It has happened before, and will keep happening.

3

u/WinterTourist25 10h ago

Two of 'em already stepped up.

2

u/AdOnly5876 11h ago

Its actually quite common, look up operation Wetback.

6

u/DarthBrooks69420 8h ago

Many of them aren't,  ehy do you think that the Texas counties bordering Mexico that used to be very red turned solid blue this election?

5

u/Ruleoflawz 7h ago

The border counties look historically bluer than other non-metro regions of texas.

5

u/Puzzleheaded_Fold466 4h ago

Gas got too expensive for all the freedom trucks.

9

u/Zenin 7h ago

Yes, they did. When the 2.0 regime stopped gaslight and just marched out the Fourth Reich loud and proud, America not just Texas border counties finally woke up and threw out the bums.

But please, don't let me interrupt your racist coping.

3

u/Jalapenoplanter 7h ago

0 evidence that most gun owners are against this

→ More replies (13)

23

u/elkab0ng 12h ago

“Okay, we fucked up and arrested someone for funsies and sent them to another country as a prisoner. But we get a do-over because we touched home base”

Basically our government is now Calvinball, but with guns.

21

u/Memitim 6h ago

Due process denied to one is due process denied to all. Republicans have violated it tens of thousands of times, kicking off the festivities with court order violations and easily discovered lies about the victims, and the crimes have gone on for over a year. If it survives this period intact, America will never live down this period of shame.

16

u/B-Glasses 9h ago

Many such fucking cases

15

u/ZanzerFineSuits 11h ago

Court should give him $10M out of the Trump Ballroom fund

40

u/notwhomyouthunk 14h ago

They just want to do a little ethnic cleansing. Mistakes happen. No need to make a federal case about it.

14

u/Pleasant_Character28 13h ago

Deport the fucks who did this

13

u/Sorry-Claim-2990 2h ago

If the government doesn't have to be responsible for its mistakes, why should I have to be responsible for my mistakes?

Why am I held to a higher standard than the government???

2

u/McDuchess 1h ago

They do. They’ll send don’t want to.

Not thing we know, the crazy old man will sign an EO declaring they hold no responsibility.

And some idiots will think that an illegal EO is somehow valid.

22

u/Green-Inkling 12h ago

Ha. Fuck no. You don't get to deport a citizen, admit you fucked up, then avoid consequences. It don't work like that.

8

u/unicornsandrainbowst 11h ago

It does and totally works like that (unfortunately). In the absolute best case, the man will get a couple millions from taxpayers money, and thats it.  

2

u/kerbalsdownunder 10h ago

This happened a lot during Operation Wetback

2

u/pantry-pisser 9h ago

Bro that was over 70 years ago

3

u/kerbalsdownunder 8h ago

And you don't think certain courts today wouldn't use that as justification for current actions?

→ More replies (1)

23

u/janethefish 13h ago

This case should have clear evidence one way or the other. Either:

  1. they have video of him agreeing to return without pressure.
  2. Video shows him agreeing to return under pressure.
  3. The government does not record video because they have a deliberate de facto policy of deporting and detaining citizens and want agents to create false records.

Federal attorneys also argue that sovereign immunity prevents Morales García from pursuing his constitutional claims against the federal officials named in their official capacities because he has not established that the government waived its immunity from such lawsuits.

This is sounds reasonable, but how can he claim to be acting in his official capacity while deporting a US citizen or detaining one without any evidence? If they can do that, they can do anything in "official capacity" including torture, murder, theft, rape etc.

15

u/L2Sing 13h ago

And the first amendment specifically allows citizens to petition their government for redress, which should make the immunity claim, which is not in the Constitution, moot, no?

3

u/PopBulky7023 11h ago

It's very easy for a dishonest court to define petition as "ask".

7

u/rygelicus 12h ago

Qualified immunity is not intended to protect from abusive malicious actions by government officials. It is intended only to protect from actions in line with the proper execution of their duties according to the law. If it is found the agents did not follow the law correctly that 'should' be the end of their qualified immunity in this event. Unfortunately it gets applied broadly to 'anything the agent does' unless you can forcibly get through those protections.

3

u/cloudcottage 12h ago

Having video of him agreeing doesn't mean he's returning without pressure. If you spent the prior few hours arguing with them that he's an American citizen, or days because of judge also decided to deport him, trying to be polite on a video so you don't get sent somewhere worse or get abused by the detention officers does not mean that you're set without coercion. I don't think it's possible to be sent somewhere without coercion once in ICE custody.

7

u/drunkshinobi 12h ago

This is why a year or so ago we were demanding due process for everyone. I haven't heard anything about it in months. Like we stopped caring. Just got used to it.

6

u/Zippier92 11h ago

It should come out of the paychecks of the people that actually deported him and the taxpayer should not be liable