r/law
•
u/ggroverggiraffe
Competent Contributor
•
14h ago
•
4
1
Legal News Austin man deported to Mexico is a US citizen, feds admit. They want the lawsuit dismissed.
https://www.statesman.com/news/article/austin-man-deported-mexico-us-citizen-lawsuit-22543114.php
17k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 14h ago
All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3.0k
u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 14h ago •
What might go wrong if we allow ICE to deport American citizens without repercussions? Surely they wouldn't abuse that power...
287
u/ggroverggiraffe Competent Contributor 14h ago •
In case of paywall, break glass:
The federal government has acknowledged that an Austin man deported to Mexico following a Central Texas traffic stop in April is a U.S. citizen, reversing its earlier position as it seeks to dismiss a lawsuit accusing immigration agents of violating his constitutional rights.
Brian José Morales García, 25, was born in Denver and is a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico, federal attorneys said in a motion filed Friday in U.S. District Court in Austin. The acknowledgment comes nearly seven months after U.S. Border Patrol agents sent him to Mexico despite his repeated claims that he was American.
In the same filing, federal attorneys asked U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman to dismiss Morales García's lawsuit, arguing that federal immigration officers are protected from certain civil claims arising from their enforcement of immigration laws. The government maintains that Morales García voluntarily agreed to return to Mexico and disputes his allegations that agents pressured him into doing so.
The admission is a reversal of the government's previous position. In April, U.S. Customs and Border Protection told the American-Statesman that it had not arrested a U.S. citizen, saying records showed Morales García was in the country illegally.
Morales García returned to Texas on Aug. 30 after his attorneys provided additional documentation supporting his citizenship and reached an agreement with the Justice Department. His lawsuit, which seeks monetary damages and other relief, remains pending.
How an Austin man was deported after a traffic stop
Morales García was riding in a pickup truck with coworkers near Fredericksburg on April 3 when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper pulled over the vehicle for an alleged window tint violation.
Morales García, who speaks Spanish and was not carrying identification, told officers that he was born in Colorado and had a birth certificate and Social Security card at his Austin home, according to his lawsuit. Authorities contacted federal immigration agents, and Morales García was taken to the Gillespie County Jail before being transferred to Border Patrol custody.
Four days later, he was sent to Mexico.
The American-Statesman previously reviewed copies of Morales García's Colorado birth certificate, hospital documents and baptismal records and independently confirmed the existence of records supporting his birth in Denver.
His citizenship became a central dispute in the lawsuit he filed May 1 against federal immigration officials and state and local law enforcement officers.
Brian José Morales García (right) poses with his younger brother Miguel Ángel Morales García. Brian José Morales García (right) poses with his younger brother Miguel Ángel Morales García. Contributed by Brian Jose Morales Garcia/Contributed At a June hearing, Pitman declined to immediately order Morales García's return, citing conflicting birth records from the United States and Mexico. The judge instead directed both sides to gather additional evidence.
Morales García's attorneys subsequently obtained further documentation, including hospital records and witness statements, before the federal government agreed to permit his return in August.
Federal attorneys defend agents' actions
The government's latest filing provides a detailed account of how Border Patrol agents concluded Morales García was born in Mexico, even as federal attorneys now acknowledge his American citizenship.
According to the motion, Border Patrol Agent Robert Gil Jr. questioned Morales García at the Gillespie County Jail and checked a Mexican government identification database after Morales García said he did not have his birth certificate.
Gil found a Mexican registration record identifying Morales García as having been born in Zacatecas, Mexico. The agent said Morales García also told him he was born there after being warned that providing false information could result in criminal charges.
Based on that information, Gil concluded Morales García was in the United States illegally, according to the filing.
Federal attorneys contend that the agent explained Morales García's options, including appearing before an immigration judge or voluntarily returning to Mexico. They said Morales García chose to return and signed immigration forms confirming his decision.
Morales García has offered a different account.
In his lawsuit, he alleges agents repeatedly accused him of lying about his citizenship and threatened him with imprisonment. He said he eventually falsely claimed to have entered the country illegally because he feared prolonged detention and believed agreeing to leave was his only realistic option.
His attorneys also allege that family members and friends tried unsuccessfully to provide documents proving his citizenship while he was detained.
The federal government disputes those allegations, maintaining that Gil did not threaten Morales García or force him to sign the documents.
The motion does not explain what specific evidence ultimately resolved the conflicting birth records or whether immigration authorities reviewed that evidence before allowing Morales García to return.
Government seeks dismissal despite citizenship acknowledgment
Federal attorneys argue that Morales García cannot pursue damages against individual immigration agents under a legal doctrine stemming from a 1971 Supreme Court decision known as Bivens, which allows certain lawsuits against federal officers for constitutional violations. The government contends that federal courts have declined to extend those protections to similar claims involving civil immigration enforcement.
Federal attorneys also argue that sovereign immunity prevents Morales García from pursuing his constitutional claims against the federal officials named in their official capacities because he has not established that the government waived its immunity from such lawsuits.
Separately, Gillespie County Chief Deputy Bryan Philips filed a motion Friday seeking dismissal of any claims against him. Philips argues that he was never named as a defendant in the lawsuit and that the complaint does not allege he personally participated in Morales García's detention.
Pitman has not ruled on either motion. Attorneys representing Morales García did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the government's filing.
Morales García's lawsuit seeks compensation for his detention, removal, lost wages and emotional distress.
986
u/geekmasterflash 14h ago
The federal government has now explicitly acknowledged that Morales García is a United States citizen, while simultaneously arguing that immigration enforcement immunity should shield it from liability for removing him from his own country.
Given the fact he is a documented citizen, just about every sitting judge and if necessary jury will have the same thought: why would a citizen volunteer for such a thing outside of undo coercion?
Coercion which they now admit begins with a false arrest and imprisonment which sets the stage for this "agreement."
186
u/sweatboxy 14h ago
If ICE with all its billions of dollars can’t tell who’s an American citizen, why should we let the federal government determine who has a legitimate right to vote?
182
u/fredandlunchbox 14h ago
I've read that ICE agents have to repay their full sign-on bonus if they fail to complete their contract for any reason, including termination without cause.
So if a new administration or a new congress were to fire them all, they'd be on the hook for $50k that I'm sure has been spent a long time ago.
Just food for thought.
86
u/mr_evilweed 14h ago
Oh... so like... exactly what liberals have been saying happens when you dont have due process and exactly what conservatives have been saying never happens?
77
u/doublethink_1984 14h ago
ICE agents do have some levels of immunity when enforcing immigration law.
Kidnapping, pressuring, and kicking a citizen out of the United States is not enforcing immigration law
182
u/blahblah19999 11h ago
So The US government can just deport a citizen with no repercussions. Someone tell me how the 2A crowd is OK with this.
79
u/B-Z_B-S 14h ago
23
u/elkab0ng 12h ago
“Okay, we fucked up and arrested someone for funsies and sent them to another country as a prisoner. But we get a do-over because we touched home base”
Basically our government is now Calvinball, but with guns.
21
u/Memitim 6h ago
Due process denied to one is due process denied to all. Republicans have violated it tens of thousands of times, kicking off the festivities with court order violations and easily discovered lies about the victims, and the crimes have gone on for over a year. If it survives this period intact, America will never live down this period of shame.
16
u/B-Glasses 9h ago
Many such fucking cases
15
u/ZanzerFineSuits 11h ago
Court should give him $10M out of the Trump Ballroom fund
40
u/notwhomyouthunk 14h ago
They just want to do a little ethnic cleansing. Mistakes happen. No need to make a federal case about it.
14
u/Pleasant_Character28 13h ago
Deport the fucks who did this
13
u/Sorry-Claim-2990 2h ago
If the government doesn't have to be responsible for its mistakes, why should I have to be responsible for my mistakes?
Why am I held to a higher standard than the government???
22
u/Green-Inkling 12h ago
Ha. Fuck no. You don't get to deport a citizen, admit you fucked up, then avoid consequences. It don't work like that.
23
u/janethefish 13h ago
This case should have clear evidence one way or the other. Either:
This is sounds reasonable, but how can he claim to be acting in his official capacity while deporting a US citizen or detaining one without any evidence? If they can do that, they can do anything in "official capacity" including torture, murder, theft, rape etc.
7
u/drunkshinobi 12h ago
This is why a year or so ago we were demanding due process for everyone. I haven't heard anything about it in months. Like we stopped caring. Just got used to it.
6
u/Zippier92 11h ago
It should come out of the paychecks of the people that actually deported him and the taxpayer should not be liable