r/LessCredibleDefence • u/stopsquarks • 3h ago
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/PLArealtalk • Oct 14 '24
Posting standards for this community
The moderator team has observed a pattern of low effort posting of articles from outlets which are either known to be of poor quality, whose presence on the subreddit is not readily defended or justified by the original poster.
While this subreddit does call itself "less"credibledefense, that is not an open invitation to knowingly post low quality content, especially by people who frequent this subreddit and really should know better or who have been called out by moderators in the past.
News about geopolitics, semiconductors, space launch, among others, can all be argued to be relevant to defense, and these topics are not prohibited, however they should be preemptively justified by the original poster in the comments with an original submission statement that they've put some effort into. If you're wondering whether your post needs a submission statement, then err on the side of caution and write one up and explain why you think it is relevant, so at least everyone knows whether you agree with what you are contributing or not.
The same applies for poor quality articles about military matters -- some are simply outrageously bad or factually incorrect or designed for outrage and clicks. If you are posting it here knowingly, then please explain why, and whether you agree with it.
At this time, there will be no mandated requirement for submission statements nor will there be standardized deletion of posts simply if a moderator feels they are poor quality -- mostly because this community is somewhat coherent enough that bad quality articles can be addressed and corrected in the comments.
This is instead to ask contributors to exercise a bit of restraint as well as conscious effort in terms of what they are posting.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/Personal-Proposal-79 • 9h ago
Australia criticizes US Congressional Budget Office over AUKUS comments
asia.nikkei.comAustralian Defence Minister Richard Marles on Sunday criticized the United States Congressional Budget Office (CBO) over a report that said the AUKUS pact would decrease the number of attack submarines available to the U.S. Navy.
"They are wrong," Marles said, referring to the CBO, which said in the report this month that the sale of Virginia-class submarines to Australia could diminish the size of the navy's attack submarine force through to 2060.
AUKUS, Australia's largest-ever defense project, will put U.S.-commanded Virginia-class submarines in Australia from next year, involves selling several Virginia-class submarines to Australia from around 2030 and will have Britain and Australia build a new class of AUKUS nuclear-powered submarine.
Marles was not worried about the report "because AUKUS is very much happening" and "the production rate in the United States is absolutely increasing," he said in televised remarks.
In October, Marles said Australia remained on track to acquire its first nuclear-powered subs from the U.S. in the early 2030s.
The CBO did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside regular business hours.
Canberra has committed A$368 billion ($243 billion) over three decades to AUKUS, including billions of dollars in investment in British and US production bases.
Formed in 2021, AUKUS is part of efforts to counter China's growing influence in the Indo-Pacific. China has called the pact dangerous and warned it could spur a regional arms race.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/haggerton • 18h ago
Navy won’t rename carrier slated to honor Black war hero after considering switching it to Trump
edition.cnn.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/YouCantKeepJellyAway • 1d ago
Indian Air Force’s Rafale fleet down to 32, British aviation publication (Flight Global) says, backing Pakistan’s claim of downing four Rafale jets
dawn.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/MoodOutrageous6263 • 1d ago
It would appear that the SASC intends on protecting the DDG(X)
armed-services.senate.govOn page 75 of the 2027 NDAA, it states "Therefore, the committee believes that: (1) The Navy needs to continue work on the DDG(X) program so it will have options for replacing the early DDG-51s when their useful service lives have expired; (2) Work on the DDG(X) program needs to continue along roughly the same schedule as was envisioned last year; and (3) Design and construction of the BBG(X) should not supplant the important work that needs to continue on the DDG(X)."
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/Personal-Proposal-79 • 20h ago
British Commandos Defeat Team from Ukraine in Drone Competition in Germany
militarnyi.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/Spirited-Sir-3034 • 1d ago
Polish authorities say a Russian Kh-101 cruise missile crossed 50 km into Poland
interestingengineering.comThe reported incursion occurred during a large Russian missile and drone attack against Ukraine. Poland scrambled F-16 fighters, activated Patriot air-defense systems and coordinated with NATO surveillance assets.
Authorities also reported two other objects entering Polish airspace. The circumstances remain under investigation, including whether the incursions resulted from navigation errors, damage or deliberate route changes.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/rdh2dmd • 1d ago
South Korean anti-drone AESA radar to protect US refineries, stadiums
interestingengineering.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/tigeryi98 • 1d ago
Mysterious MQ-25 Stingray-Like Chinese Drone Emerges At Little-Known Flight Test Center
twz.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/Personal-Proposal-79 • 1d ago
New approaches will make air defence less expensive
economist.comDefending against a barrage of low-cost drones, missiles and glide bombs is possible—but it costs a fortune. In the first 100 hours after Operation Epic Fury began against Iran on February 28th 2026, America fired interceptors worth an estimated $1.7bn. But shooting down every $50,000 Shahed drone with a $5m Patriot interceptor missile is not economically sustainable. In Ukraine, meanwhile, such interceptors are in short supply as the country fends off Russian aerial attacks.
But in 2027 the economics of air defence will become less grievous. Cheaper systems will enter production or service. Others will be made in greater numbers, bringing down costs.
Accelerating test-and-redesign cycles is one way to save money. Latvia has let Frankenburg Technologies, an Estonian interceptor startup, conduct around 100 test launches a year at its Adazi military range. That helped Frankenburg get its Mark 1 counter-drone missile “from PowerPoint to the demonstration of a guided catastrophic hit” in just 13 months, says Kusti Salm, the firm’s boss. At ranges elsewhere in Europe, one or two tests a year can be the norm. Increased production should bring the Mark 1’s price below $30,000 by the end of 2027. Comparable interceptors can cost $250,000, or double that in wartime.
Ukraine has taken rapid iteration even further, using feedback from the front. Take the Sting, a quadcopter interceptor introduced in 2025. It has been destroying roughly 2,500 Shahed and Geran drones a month, with a success rate higher than 90%, says an executive at Wild Hornets, its manufacturer. The Sting sells for about $2,000, with some configurations costing half that. In-house production of many parts helps, as does scale: more than 10,000 are built a month. A faster variant, the Sting 2, will be in mass production by 2027.
Then there is cheaper propulsion. Instead of a gas turbine, the Kestrel, a new interceptor from Greenjets, a British startup, uses ducted electric fans with fewer moving parts. Built to kill Russia’s fastest Geran drones, it can exceed 600kph. Anmol Manohar, the firm’s boss, calls it “jet performance at electric costs”. A Kestrel costs less than $50,000, compared with $125,000 for a similarly capable Coyote Block 2C, a jet-powered interceptor made by America’s RTX. Greenjets has been turning out 1,500 Kestrels a month. Mr Manohar expects to quadruple output by early 2027, knocking a third off the cost.
Cheaper still is gunfire, made increasingly viable by advances in robotics. In July, Allen Control Systems, an Austin-based startup, began shipping Bullfrog, a robotic machinegun mount that uses cameras and a laser rangefinder—at a tenth of the cost of radar—to aim at drones. The firm expects to ship more than 2,000 units in 2027, including to Ukraine.
Weapons that fire bursts of energy, not bullets, are also becoming practical, at least against drones. In 2027 a British navy destroyer will get DragonFire, a laser gun. Each shot costs about $13. But it is no use against cruise and ballistic missiles, where something like a Patriot is still needed.
Lockheed Martin, maker of the Patriot system, is developing a cheaper form of its interceptor. The aim is to deliver 90% of the capability at half the price. Fire Point, a Ukrainian startup, is working on an even cheaper option, at less than $1.2m apiece. It aims to test-fire it in mid-2027.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/Garbage_Plastic • 1d ago
GSDF identifies cause of fatal tank explosion in April
japantimes.co.jpA fatal tank explosion that occurred during a live-fire drill..in April..
..caused by a fragment of a silicone rubber band..left in the chamber at a high temperature after the previous round was fired and came into contact with the next round, triggering an explosion.
The band fragment also prevented the breech mechanism..from functioning properly.
The incident involved a state-of-the-art Type 10 tank..killing the..tank commander, the..gunner and a..safety officer..The driver sustained serious injuries.
..a similar incident..occurred during training..in 2018. Since that incident did not result in an explosion or casualties, the information was not shared within the organization.
It has stopped using the anti-tank shells in the Type 10 and Type 90 tanks since the April incident..The GSDF said it will develop more durable projectiles as a preventive measure.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/warfaceisthebest • 1d ago
How good is bofors 40mm mk4, as a gun ciws?
Asking this because RN use bofors 40mm mk4 instead of phalanx, and maybe will use it more for the future.
So how good is it, comapre to traditional gun based CIWS, like phalanx, goalkeeper, Korean and Chinese ciws, or millennium gun? I know it is not a dedicated ciws, but certainly RN wll have to use them as ciws, at least on Type 31 and possible future ships.
As far as I know, ciws will need to fight sea skimming missiles (both stealth ones like nsm, and super sonic ones like YJ-83), drones, and occasionally fast attack crafts and surface drones. How good is bofors mk4 against those targets? And how good is it compare to other ciws? Why RN picked it over Phalanx or other ciws?
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/Advanced-Ice2095 • 2d ago
Are “pocket sized” CATOBAR carriers like the French Charles de Gaulle (42,500t) useful for US/China as a complement to supercarriers? They are already building LHA/LHD in the 45,000t to 50,000t+ range
The contemporary French Charles de Gaulle displaces approximately 42,500 tons and operates conventional carrier aircraft using 2 catapults and arresting gear (CATOBAR). The Cold War period also had CATOBARs like the French Clemenceau-class and UK’s Audacious-class in the 32,000-37,000t range. To accomodate contemporary carrier based aircraft, ~42,000t may be the bare minimum size required to operate the same aircraft types as 100,000t+ supercarriers.
Today, both the US and China already build large amphibious assault ships (LHA/LHD) in the 40,000–50,000+ ton range.
How much additional engineering complexity and cost would be involved in developing a CATOBAR carrier of comparable displacement, featuring an angled flight deck and one or two catapults?
Such a design could potentially operate some of the same fixed-wing aircraft as larger fleet carriers, allowing greater flexibility in aircraft deployment, maintenance, and operational planning. Imagine a fleet where pocket carriers and supercarriers can trade airwing squadrons.
Would a fleet combining pocket CATOBAR carriers with supercarriers offer meaningful advantages in terms of procurement cost, operational flexibility, and fleet availability?
Or would the limitations in sortie generation, aviation fuel and ammunition storage, aircraft capacity, and survivability outweigh those benefits? Do all missions really need supercarrier sized sortie generation?
It would be particularly interesting to discuss whether the economics and operational advantages of smaller CATOBAR carriers (pocket carriers) justify their development, given that both navies already possess the industrial capacity to build similarly sized amphibious assault ships.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/rdh2dmd • 2d ago
S.Korea launches advanced 3,600-ton frigate equipped with homegrown radar
koreatimes.co.krr/LessCredibleDefence • u/StealthCuttlefish • 2d ago
India to let Japan use firing ranges for missile tests
archive.isr/LessCredibleDefence • u/PrettyCold9669 • 2d ago
US Navy fired expired weapons during the Iran war which navy secretary compared to eating stale bread
businessinsider.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/Personal-Proposal-79 • 2d ago
US warned supplying nuclear-powered submarines to Australia would diminish its own fleet for ‘many years’
theguardian.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/rdh2dmd • 2d ago
NEO Battery partners with Korean drone maker for development and joint entry into Canadian Market
canadianmanufacturing.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/1Card_x • 3d ago
Trump Says US Does Not Support Taiwan Independence in Meeting With Xi Jinping, Chinese State Media Reports
ibtimes.co.ukThe remarks reflect Washington's longstanding position, while Xi urged the US to avoid disrupting ties over the disputed island.
President Donald Trump told Chinese President Xi Jinping that the United States does not support Taiwan independence, according to Chinese state media, as Beijing warned that the disputed island could disrupt relations between the two powers.
The remarks came during talks in Shenzhen on Thursday, 19 November, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. It was the leaders' third meeting this year.
China's official Xinhua news agency attributed the statement to Trump, reporting that he said Washington does not support "Taiwan Independence". The account did not provide a longer quotation or explain whether the two leaders had reached any new understanding on the issue.
Xi told Trump that Washington should do the "right thing" on Taiwan and avoid major disruptions to US-China relations, according to Xinhua.
The warning stood out in an otherwise upbeat Chinese account of the meeting, which described ties between the countries as broadly stable and improving.
Taiwan is a self-governing democracy that Beijing claims as its territory. China's government has not ruled out using force to bring the island under its control, while Taiwan's government maintains that its future must be decided by its people.
r/LessCredibleDefence • u/reelect_brandon_john • 2d ago
The Pentagon Urgently Needs More Patriot Missiles. It’s Running Into a Rayon Problem.
wsj.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/Personal-Proposal-79 • 2d ago
France and Sweden hold first joint nuclear-deterrence exercise
defensenews.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/StealthCuttlefish • 2d ago
Toti pushes new foreign-built shipyard in the US to focus on frigates, large surface combatants
breakingdefense.comr/LessCredibleDefence • u/Spirited-Sir-3034 • 3d ago
US Marines set world’s longest low-power troposcatter communications link at 187 milesA military communications system that fits inside airline-checkable cases has now established a 187-mile link.Read Next: Raytheon brings two US firms on board to shore up Tomahawk missile suppliesByAamir Kholl
interestingengineering.comDuring Exercise Tropo Thunder in Hawaii, U.S. Marines used Comtech’s portable COMET MPR system to connect Oahu with Hawaii’s Big Island across 187 miles.
According to Comtech, the link averaged approximately 10 Mbps, maintained 100% availability during the demonstration and recorded around 6 ms round-trip latency. The equipment can be transported in airline-checkable cases, deployed in about 30 minutes and operated using less than 350 watts of total power.
Troposcatter systems transmit signals beyond the radio horizon by scattering microwave energy through the lower atmosphere. This could provide expeditionary units with a terrestrial backup when satellite or fiber connections are unavailable.
The company did not disclose the exact transmission power. What other civilian or emergency-response applications could benefit from a portable long-distance system like this?