Headnote: This post is written to share some insights and propose resolution to the causality paradox in the time travel stories with a self consistent timeline where you cannot change anything or create a parallel universe. The proper resolution inevitably involves the consideration of a higher power as we call it "fate".
In order to understand the causality loop, we must consider these two principles:
First: When we think about a causal loop, we usually represent it like two curved arrows drawn in the opposite directions between point A and point B on a paper. But in the actual, this dynamic of causality does not objectively depend on a single frame, instead we switch over between distinct and subjective perspectives.
To illustrate this, we draw an arrow from point A to point B on the front side of the paper. Then we turn it over and draw a second arrow in the opposite direction, from B to A, on the back of the paper. Now in this visual, there is objectively no loop between A and B; because the two aspects of the loop are standing on the two discrete sides of the paper rather than on a single frame.
So when reasoning about the loop of causality, we must take into account that the opposing aspects of causality occur subjectively only from the perspective of the given cause. For example, the Others treat John like he was special in the present time, because they've been told in the past that he was going to be their leader. But this sense of causality only exists subjectively from the perspective of the Others, it is not an ultimate, objective sense of causality.
Then, when John carries this information with him to the past and tells Richard that he was gonna be their leader, now we perceive causality from John's relative perspective. And this subjective frame of causality of John is distinct from the subjective frame of the Others/Richard (like how two sides of the paper are distinct). Eventually; the sense of causality is relative and subjective, which brings us to the second principle:
Second: Causes are ostensible; the purposeful results coming out of them are intended by fate:
- When Sawyer brings the rope inside the well to the past during a time flash, it guides the ancient people to discover the pocket of energy beneath that sector and build the frozen wheel. Because of the discovery and turning of the wheel, the Ancient Incident happens which results in the building of the cork system in the heart of the island. The frozen wheel becomes crucial for the future events as well, by Dharma people finding it first then Ben turning it in 2004. That also plays into the critical events of time travel and the significant purposes of destiny coming along with it.
Now all the benefical threads coming out of Sawyer's individual action are weaved by fate. The relation of causality between Sawyer's act and its meaningful results is only apparent. We can imagine a causal relation by thinking:
"Sawyer brings the rope to the past -- ancient people build the frozen wheel -- later Ben turns the wheel -- it causes Sawyer travel to the past in the first place".
But the sense of paradoxical loop in this thought has no genuine value: while Sawyer is an apparent intervening cause, the effect and the power of the cause is carried by destiny.
In Conclusion; the comprehensive knowledge of destiny establishes an all-purpose situation that provides meaningful results for each and all of the people.
The Compass
As an additional matter (pun intended), the physical matter of objects coming out of nowhere is another issue with the time travel loops. Because the first law of thermodynamics says: "the total amount of energy in a closed system remains fixed, energy cannot be created or destroyed". So the question becomes then; "In the closed system of our universe (or the island), how is the compass created and destroyed? Where did its matter come from?"
The ultimate solution to this problem is connecting the mystical energy of the island (and the ones in the world) to an eternal, metaphysical source existing in the background of our physical universe. This spiritual view is explicitly supported by the show's lore; by the light being related to life (existence), death (entropy) and rebirth (cycles) in the universe.
So the compass is created (and destroyed) by the energy of the island that is spiritually connected to a high metaphysical source that also created the universe and everything in the first place. This is also how the monster is able to replicate the physical dead bodies on the island when he takes on their form..
Thank you for reading!