What is SMART?
S.M.A.R.T. (Self-Monitoring, Analysis and Reporting Technology) stats track internal sensors and error logs on a hard disk drive (HDD/SSD) to warn of mechanical wear or impending failure
I used to have a hobby of salvaging old HDDs/SSDs from old PCs.. these dried up to much competition and laws changed due to Lithium fires .
Now I have to buy HDDs/SSDs on Amazon, eBay..
When you salvage (rebirth) HDD/SSD you learn how to identify the duds and fix them.
I just bought a brand new HDD from Amazon ..some analysis details were removed .. I don’t want to be sued. It is a dud. You can see in the partial CrystalMark report.
That is the 3rd HDD I bought in the last 18 months that was used and faulty.
Signs of faulty HDD/SSD a dud
- Your PC boot will slow down .. as PC tries to connect to device and may run slowly
- On Mac .. Mac will ignore it
- Both on a PC and Mac a dud will not be visible.
In PC case ..since you no longer need to eject before unplugging .. unplugging then plugging a dud will cause Windows interrupts in most cases the dud will become visible and can be formatted or fixed.
Same for the Windows Apps … Windows Disk Management App will not see a dud at start up but may after you start the App and then plugin the dud.
On Mac please do not plug/unplug devices without an eject which can further damage the device. You can’t eject a device on a Mac you can’t see..Please minimise unplugging it or even better shut down a Mac then unplug the dud. I must admit I often don’t follow my own advice .
On a PC there is an app called CrystalMark (you see its sample printout) . It uses low level coding and will detect all the drives,duds , APFS volumes even if these are not visible to Windows.
Not sure about journaled(HFS+) HDDs/SSDs ..I stopped using these since High Sierra
https://crystalmark.info/en/software/crystaldiskinfo/
Mac equivalent is smartctl which runs in the terminal only for SMART verified devices and needs device address (diskxxx) which does not exist if Mac can’t see the device.
So what does the CrystalMark report say about the brand new HDD?
- It is not new
- It has a high error rate
- Somebody tried to reset SMART stats and made mess of it
- It was intentional, not manufacturing fault it is a fraud
This is a typical profile for a dud.
I have 3 x PCs that run data farm of my HDDs/SSD
CrystalMark is a magic App .. with a few clicks it reports the status of all attached devices .
For any new HDD/SSD on PCs I run
- CrystalMark
- AJA benchmarks
AJA benchmarks it identifies configuring issues like wrong cable.. Which is now a very common mistake ..Many SSDs that are sold with USB_C charge cables.
On PC I can decide to repair the dud. PCs can repair devices( chkdsk ….) .
On Mac there are no Apps/Commands to repair devices .. First Aid..FSCK repair file systems not drives.
The latest dud was repaired by a PC and it can be used . But it is full of errors . Any HDD/SSD that fails tends to fail again.. and again. I am getting a refund for the dud.
What happens if you don’t have a PC, only a Mac?
I have 3 x Macs
M1 Mini has USB4 and 2x USB3.2 gen 2 SSDs one is Samsung T7
2013 iMac has Samsung T7 ... 2010 Mini I just look at (LOL)
Even with full PC testing that I have done..In the Mac case HDD/SSD Quality matters .. nothing is good enough for my Macs.
Macos lies.. If you look at DU you will see some devices are SMART verified .. it just means that these stats can be read by an app like SMARTCTL.
If you run exFat SSD/HDD on Mac .. it is not SMART verified .. you switch the device to PC then all SMART data is there .. no gaps …
Mac or rather HDD/SSD drivers collect SMART data all the time.
When you plug in a dud into PCs goes into a coma.. When you plug in a dud into a Mac it instantly ignores it by reading SMART stats and using trigger values to declare dud a dud. There are many false flags.
PC will attempt to read a dud.. That is why often HDD/SSD works on a PC not on a Mac.
Without a PC there is very little that can be done on a Mac.. returning or getting a new drive are the only options.
You can diagnose or repair devices you can’t see. Even erasing on a Mac is just writing a new file system.
Not a Quick format on PCs takes ages and checks every sector and marks faulty as not to be used. Making the device itself usable.
Mac erases(formats) in seconds ..it's equal to PC quick format. It does not check anything.
That is why I use exFat for all of my archives.. APFS is more secure to write a sector (Cluster).. But when APFS volume fails .. there is no way to repair it .. you may use DiskDrill to dig for some files..
APFS is safer at record/file and it is totally useless in volume recovery or repair.
With exFat and a PC I may lose some files but not a volume. This is covered by backups and a binary comparison App that I run . Nothing is lost .. all is recoverable.
If you choose to use exFat on your Mac, use PC to format it.
Mac uses a very small sector (Cluster) size of 4K ,making exFat slow. exFat formatted on PC will run as fast and even faster than APFS.
My work files … are on APFS and all the long term archives are exFat.
Why is there so much HDD/SSD duds fraud?
It is called AI price shock RAM , SSD prices went through the roof HDDs not as much.
My Samsung T7 that cost me AUD $70 is now AUD $369. The USB4 SSD that cost me $90 now is worth a second hand car.
HDDs prices doubled..
They just screwed us by diverting RAM and SSD manufacturing away from retail to a more profitable AI and creating AS - Artificial Shortages (LOL).
There are huge profits to be made.
It is madness. My HDD/SSD (22 of them) data farm replacement cost is more than Macs and/or Mini PCs that use them.
For mac only users I suggest you
- Avoid the cheapest HDD/SSD
- Buy from the physical stores with a good return policy
- Get a Mini PC or friend which has one and check all of your HDDs/SSDs