r/macarons • • 15h ago

Second attempt at French macarons and they're puffing up, cracking, and have no feet

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

So I've tried making French macarons twice now and I'm trying to figure out what I'm doing wrong lol.

My first batch was purple. I wasn't super strict with measuring and used cups instead of weighing everything. I still followed the recipe carefully, watched videos to check the consistency, and thought I was doing everything right. They cracked and had basically no feet, but the inside was actually pretty decent. They were a little crunchy outside and soft inside, and honestly tasted really good.

So for my second batch (green), I decided to be much more precise. I weighed absolutely everything down to the gram, watched even more videos about the meringue and folding, and made sure the shells were dry to the touch before baking.

And somehow they turned out worse??

They puffed up quite a bit, cracked again, and still had almost no feet. But the biggest difference was the inside. There's now a HUGE air pocket underneath the top shell, with just a thin layer of cookie at the bottom. When you bite into them, the top basically shatters.

Looking at pictures of other people's macarons on here, I'm also realizing mine seem to puff up a lot more than normal.

I baked them at 300°F on silicone macaron mats. The first tray baked for around 15 minutes and the second for about 17. The longer baked ones came off the mat more easily, but were crunchier.

One thing I noticed is that my green batter was a bit thicker than my purple batter, and the piping swirls took longer to disappear. So I'm wondering if I didn't fold it quite enough?

I've also ordered an oven thermometer because I'm starting to suspect my oven might be running hotter than it says.

Has anyone had macarons that puff up way too much, crack, have huge hollow centres, and barely develop feet? What ended up fixing it for you?

I'm determined to figure these things out, but I'm running out of ideas lol.