Plans for an underground rail network in Manchester, inspired by European systems in Frankfurt, Munich and Milan, are being developed by transport officials.
At present, five city centres in the UK have some element of underground metro: London, Glasgow, Liverpool, Newcastle upon Tyne and Sunderland.
The multibillion-pound plan for the city would transform Manchester Piccadilly station into the “King’s Cross of the north”. The modernisation of the station, which already handles more than 30 million journeys a year, is a key priority for the region, according to senior leaders at No 10 North.
Transport bosses in Manchester describe the city’s tram system, which covers 64 miles with 99 stops across eight lines, as “creaking”. Known as Metrolink, it carried more than 200,000 passengers on April 19 this year, the Sunday of the Manchester marathon, believed to be a record.
Internal estimates made by Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) show parts of the tram system running out of capacity by 2050, despite a new fleet of longer trams that are due to be brought in by 2030. TfGM’s engineers now intend to learn from Frankfurt and Milan to solve Manchester’s capacity problem.
“We’ve seen significant population growth in the city centre in recent years,” said Bev Craig, the Greater Manchester mayor. “The reality is we’re the fastest-growing city region — and we need infrastructure that keeps up.”
Within Manchester city council’s boundaries, the population has grown from 540,000 in 2015 to 645,000 last year, an increase of 20 per cent. Three million people live in the wider city region.
Craig said: “It’s about getting the connectivity to move from Piccadilly to Aviva Studios [the arts centre], or travelling from the football clubs to Spinningfields [the business district].
“In any one weekend, you could have a game at Old Trafford, another at Etihad stadium, 22,000 attending a music event at Co-op Live, 18,000 in the AO Arena, and a business conference at Manchester Central. The region will need a mass transit scheme to get people where you need them to be.”
Manchester’s three options
The new underground plans, briefed to The Sunday Times, show three options being considered, which could work together as one network.
The first is a standalone metro line tunnelled at a cost of “tens of billions of pounds”, according to one TfGM official. The new route would connect Manchester Metropolitan University and the University of Manchester in the south to the suburbs to the north, going through Piccadilly station in the city centre.
The second option is a “relief” line dug under the city’s current tram route from Altrincham to Bury. Possible stops for underground platforms include Trafford Bar, Deansgate Castlefield — next to where No 10 North will move next year — Piccadilly Gardens and Piccadilly railway station, and up towards the Queens Road depot.
This would effectively create “two pipes” through the city centre rather than one, significantly increasing capacity. Engineers are looking to Munich’s S-Bahn for inspiration. The German city is building a 7km (4.3-mile) tunnel through the city for its suburban trains, which will have three underground stations.
A third plan for the network is a National Rail relief route travelling northwest from Bolton and Wigan towards Manchester airport, cutting diagonally underground through the city centre with possible stops at Salford Crescent, Salford Central, St Peter’s Square and Piccadilly. A similar line has been built in Milan; called the Passante, it connects existing suburban train routes.
Manchester city centre sits on reddish, often pebbly sandstone, as well as mudstone and siltstone. One engineer, familiar with the plans, said: “Sandstone is a hard rock, the sort of stuff tunnellers dream of. Compare that to cities built on clay, where you have to fill in a lot of fissures when tunnelling or you end up with sinking buildings, as seen in Frankfurt.”
The Department for Transport is being briefed on the proposals by TfGM. The next stage would be a business case showing the value of such an investment.
Burnham, when he was mayor, argued that an underground station at Piccadilly would “pay for itself over time”, coining the phrase “the King’s Cross of the north of England”. He set a target for costings on the plans by 2030, before leaving for his successful tilt as MP of nearby Makerfield.
TfGM has undertaken a review of ten similar cities in Europe based on factors such as overall population, population density and size of the city region.
In Greater Manchester, there are only about twenty trips per capita per year on trams and trains within the city region. The lowest-performing similar city, Stuttgart, had 80 trips per capita per year — four times the amount.
An initial feasibility assessment found only one set of tunnels — the Guardian Underground Telephone Exchange complex, a Cold War communications bunker — beneath the city centre. It was built in the 1950s to keep telephone links running in the event of a nuclear attack. The main complex sits about 110ft beneath Chinatown.
Engineers say this relatively clear ground means there are few “alignment” and “threading” problems underneath Manchester when compared to London.
Most of London’s Tube tunnels were bored through clay. Parts of the District and Circle lines are 16ft to 20ft deep; deeper routes such as the Northern and Bakerloo lines reach a depth of about 80ft. The deepest station is Hampstead on the Northern Line at 192ft.
Station tunnel caverns containing platforms in London are often round and created using sprayed concrete linings for ground support of the soft London clay. In Manchester, station tunnel caverns can be created using the natural strength of the Sherwood Sandstone and minimal ground support, meaning they can be more box-like, which is easier to engineer.
Copenhagen racked up 110 trips, Milan 120 and Munich, the highest performer, stood at 250.
Two rivers, the Irwell in the north and the Medlock to the south,, will determine how deep the underground tunnels and stations will need to be.
An initial feasibility assessment found only one set of tunnels — the Guardian Underground Telephone Exchange complex, a Cold War communications bunker — beneath the city centre. It was built in the 1950s to keep telephone links running in the event of a nuclear attack. The main complex sits about 110ft beneath Chinatown.
Engineers say this relatively clear ground means there are few “alignment” and “threading” problems underneath Manchester when compared to London.
Most of London’s Tube tunnels were bored through clay. Parts of the District and Circle lines are 16ft to 20ft deep; deeper routes such as the Northern and Bakerloo lines reach a depth of about 80ft. The deepest station is Hampstead on the Northern Line at 192ft.
Station tunnel caverns containing platforms in London are often round and created using sprayed concrete linings for ground support of the soft London clay. In Manchester, station tunnel caverns can be created using the natural strength of the Sherwood Sandstone and minimal ground support, meaning they can be more box-like, which is easier to engineer.
An underground station at Manchester Piccadilly would need to be roughly 100ft deep. “Ideally you want to be as close to the surface as possible,” said the engineer, as this would make it quicker to reach for passengers and cheaper to build.
Manchester is lobbying the DfT and No 10 North for a new four-platform underground station at Piccadilly to serve Northern Powerhouse Rail (NPR). This would mean that trains could arrive from Liverpool via Warrington and Manchester airport, stop at Piccadilly and then continue on towards Yorkshire: a “through station”, in the jargon.
Craig argues that building underground would also free up prime real estate around the station: enough space to build 40,000 new homes and a million square feet of office space. The NPR plan would also prepare Piccadilly station for a future underground network.
“The case for an underground station at Piccadilly is very clear, and one we’ve been making for a generation now,” Craig said. “It would also open the door to a wider underground transport system. For me, this is the only option that’s fit for a world-class city region like ours.”
Vernon Everitt, transport commissioner for Greater Manchester, said: “Greater Manchester is growing fast, with a rising population, new homes and jobs — and an event calendar to rival anywhere in the world. That means demand for public transport is only going to grow. If we don’t think big and act boldly, we risk holding ourselves back.”
The DfT said: “Everyone across the country should have access to good public transport, which is why we are working closely with Greater Manchester to improve connectivity across the north.
“As part of this, we’re exploring options and evidence for improvements to Manchester Piccadilly, including an underground station, for Northern Powerhouse Rail.”