Modifying a comment I made in another post because I want to hear peoples opinions on it. It was in response to the opening scene and the logic of Sam's vibranium suit. Here's the modified text:
I'm starting to feel like the 'vibranium suit' really undermines this story. You have two mystic metals in this story, and the difference in power between them is the driving force of the conflict. But do we actually ever see that difference? Of course not. I imagine any attempt at doing so got cut. Development for this movie seemed like a bit of a mess.
They had an opportunity here to show how impressive Sam's vibranium suit is, but that would make him look too strong and undermine the message of the movie, so instead they just say the vibranium suit is really cool and give it some purple energy on the wings.
In the final fight, we get to see some of his suit's vibranium attributes manifest, though only through the wings and his ability to not die from hulk punches. But the opening scene fails to introduce a crucial piece of setup: hype.
Imagine if this landing had a harder impact. Imagine if the vibranium acted like it does in other movies. He hits the ground and a piercing hum starts to travel up his legs and through his wings, as they charge up and release a shockwave of force signaling his arrival.
It sets up the suit, let's sam have a big entrance, and gives us two very cool and IMO crucial additions to this movie:
- Sam gets to aura farm with more than just hand to hand and speed
- We introduce a means by which to differentiate
Vibranium and adamantium. I'll explain in a moment.
They could have had Sam's wings generate gale force winds just by absorbing blows. Bro could have a shockwave aura through every major fight scene while still having normal human strength. Plus, a vibranium windstorm would give Sam's Cap a unique, on theme, visually interesting power to get excited about.
And then, since we would have spent this movie showing off how well vibranium manipulates energy, even if it was just in a couple small moments, you become able to introduce the adamantium at the end as a hard counter. Someone gets an adamantium weapon or armor or something. Hell maybe the leader traps Ross in an adamantium mask, making his rage even more blind. Cap goes to hit it with a huge charge of vibranium energy and it just eats the blow. No big reverb, no nothing. Unstoppable force meets immovable object.
IMO there are a lot of weird decisions in this movie, but in general it just feels like too many stories being told at once. Sam needs a means to retake focus other than Isaiah. Making his suit interesting yet obsolete would tie his internal conflict to the resource conflict much more neatly.