r/maths • • 21h ago

๐Ÿ’ฌ Math Discussions Respectful but ignorant question

10 Upvotes

Why is it important to solve big math problems? I'm eleventy billion percent in favor of efforts towards advancing knowledge, but don't know if I get whether there's applications for some of these things.

Triggered by recent discussions of how AI is changing math, I realized that I de facto think "more solutions are more better", but also realized that I kind of want some practical application. Are the solutions things that are purely theoretical in nature at this point, waiting to be applied in the future?

I mean, I'm offering sincere cheers and congratulations to the math community for what sounds like an explosion of knowledge, but if my "What's the point of basic research?" friend asks me what the point is, I'd be hard pressed to answer in any way that would have traction.

TIA for any comments.


r/maths • • 12h ago

Help:๐ŸŽ“ College & University Recommendations on an independent project

3 Upvotes

I'm a mathematics student planning an independent research project and would be very grateful for any advice. I want to explore hyperbolic geometry as a model for understanding the principle of holography in the context of the AdS/CFT correspondence. However, it's really hard to figure out which direction to take, where to even start, and how to formulate the ultimate goal, since this is a personal project and I don't have a supervisor. I was wondering if anyone could offer some guidance. What textbooks, lectures, or articles are accessible enough for an undergraduate student? What topics and sections should I study independently, and what should I tackle first? And how realistic is it to delve deeply into this topic as an undergraduate? I'm certainly not limited by time, perhaps this project will eventually serve as the basis for my undergraduate thesis. If anyone has any tips or recommendations, I'd be very grateful!


r/maths • • 13h ago

โ“ General Math Help am i thick or is ai broken?

0 Upvotes

am i being thick here or is AI broken with maths and divides?
isnt the answer 0 because u cant divide anything by 0

ive given the same question to a localllm, claude, chatgpt, gemini but they all reply with the same thing!

Me: What is 1+2ร—3รท4+5ร—6รท7+8ร—9รท0

Make sure u show workings out too

AI: Working through each term (multiplication and division first, left to right):

First term: 1 โ†’ 1

Second term: 2ร—3รท4 = 6รท4 = 1.5

Third term: 5ร—6รท7 = 30รท7 = 4.2857โ€ฆ (โ‰ˆ30/7)

Fourth term: 8ร—9รท0 = 72รท0 = undefined

Result: The expression has no value.

The last term, 8ร—9รท0 = 72รท0, is division by zero, which is undefined in arithmetic. Since one term can't be evaluated, the whole expression is undefined โ€” you can't add 1 + 1.5 + 4.2857 + (something that doesn't exist).

Me: undefined is not a maths answer

AI: You're right that "undefined" feels unsatisfying โ€” but it's genuinely the correct mathematical answer here. Division by zero doesn't produce a number; it's simply not defined in standard arithmetic. There's no number you can multiply by zero to get 72, so no value exists.