r/matrix • u/Future_Adagio2052 • 18m ago
theory: the second renaissance as shown in the Animatrix is machine propaganda
After doing a rewatch of the Animatrix (specifically the second renaissance part 1 and 2) something felt off with what we are told in the story that makes me suspect that the information we are given is machine propaganda.
Now for starters I won’t be bringing up the human battery thing since even if it doesn't make sense irl it’s still what is established in universe thus I don’t see anything wrong with it here.
For part 1: the machines are shown as being treated as something akin to slaves with them shown doing the work given to them by their human masters with a not so subtle allegory to exodus with the machines building pyramids, after b166er’s trial we are greeted with machines and their human sympathisers being mercilessly killed with what can almost be described as human caricatures brutally killing them in landmines and a scene where a group of men tear the shirt off a female robot and kill her whilst she pleads for them to stop and begs that she is real.
This would all been fine if later in part 1 we are told the machines sought refuge somewhere in the middle east and established a city, this however makes no sense if humanity was so hellbent on destroying the machines then why would any government official in the middle east (whatever this is the Iraqi government or some other government isn’t said to us) let the machines not just settle there but also establish a full blown city?
Especially as the machine city (01) grows to the point they eventually overtake the human economy causing it to almost collapse, the story frames this in an almost one sided manner with the machines shown as innocent victims trying to make peace with humanity as shown in a later scene where 2 01 ambassadors are sent to the UN summit whilst the humans are shown as almost mindless monsters hellbent on further victimising the machines and wiping them off the face of the planet like vermin (as shown where a fly is swatted on a flat map on what we could presume to be where 01 is located)
Except this doesn't address why 01 was allowed to be built in the first place and not immediately destroyed at the first sight if humanity hated them so much to the point of destroying every single machine to the point of making whole landmines full of destroyed machines, the machines themselves are not blameless however as they didn’t do anything to help de-escalate things and we are not told what specifically the “stable civil relationship” would have looked like, let alone if this wasn’t a biased retelling if we are to believe the story is propaganda from the machines
Another point to question the accuracy of the second renaissance is part 2 where humanity nukes 01 in an attempt to destroy the city bombards it with nukes, this however seemingly does nothing to the machines who begin to advance on all fronts after the nuclear fallout with the narrator stating that the machines had adapted to the extreme heat unlike “there former masters” however an emp from such a barrage would frankly cripple or destroy 01 and this is without assuming that humanity wouldn’t have been on guard around 01 to deal with any potential survivors from the blasts, (this is also not getting into how the machines are affected by EMPs in the films although this could be explained by them sacrificing emp protection for speed as seen with the sentinels in the Matrix trilogy)
If this is propaganda then it wouldn’t stand to reason that the machines changed some details to make themselves seem stronger than they actually were, this is seen later in part 2 where we are witnessed to humanities last evil with them blocking out the sun in a hubris last ditch effort to weaken 01 and causing the machines to adapt with less human designs as they overwhelm humanity before subsequently defeating them and creating the matrix (if we are to believe this is the actual reason and not some retelling of humanity blocking the sun)
The smoking gun to all this? The Zion archive, in the first movie Morpheus tells neo that humanity only has “bits and pieces of information” about their past (most notably that humanity blocked the sun) and yet these archives exist and the idea of Zion keeping an AI despite the risk of such an AI falling to 01 hands feels hard to believe (this is also getting into if said records are even realistically depicted as there are multiple scenes that could not have existed leaving to the possibility that corruption/tampering of history could be in said records)
however if we take everything we looked at from part 1 and 2 specifically regarding the one-sided portrayal of morality we are presented with, the machines could have very well have both created and planted these files for them to be found, what reason the machines have to gain from this? Simple, to make the matrix seem like a mercy granted by the machines who were given no choice but to use humans as batteries due to the blocking of the sun (caused by humanities arrogance) and thus make it appear as though the machines are doing humanity a favour for what they had done to the machines in the past by giving humanity the Matrix for them to live in blissful ignorance instead of being wiped out entirely.
Tldr: the second renaissance is machine propaganda due to contradictory/unreliable information given to us by the movie and also to make the matrix seem more favourable to humanity under the guise of it being "mercy" by the machines