r/mdphd • • May 01 '25

Joint Subreddit Statement: The Attack on U.S. Research Infrastructure

Thumbnail reddit.com
24 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • 22h ago

Genuinely how do undergrads get first authorships?

6 Upvotes

Undergrad at SLAC here. Research at an institution as small as mine moves at a snail's pace, and our PIs publishing student run research is a once-in-a-blue-moon event. I don't know if I'll have any pubs, period, by the time a graduate (in 3 years time) and I'm probably going to have to do a postbacc either way to be competitive.


r/mdphd • • 1d ago

How is this going to be done in four years?

16 Upvotes

3-4ish months into PhD and I feel like I have learned nothing and accomplished nothing. None of my experiments work, all of my cells die, etc. I feel as though I am putting in so much wasted effort. And the pace of everything would be fine except for the fact I have to produce something by the end of four years. If this is the pace that research moves at, how does anyone do anything -- let alone a whole PhD -- in four years? Even five years sounds too little at this point.

It is incredibly frustrating, and I am really afraid I will fail in this program. I can't bring myself to work more hours in the day, not that working more has led to anything useful anyway. Everything has its own learning curve, which would ordinarily be a challenge I welcome but I cannot overcome the stress of the immense time pressure MD/PhD students have.

I feel like I'm walking in a snowstorm, trying to make progress, but I'm walking against the wind and I can't seem to go forward.


r/mdphd • • 23h ago

clinical hours

2 Upvotes

how necessary are clinical hours? i’ve heard from different sources that MD/PhD admissions dont really care abt clinical jours and look down upon scribing for example. i guess my question is: how can i get clinical hours without a certificate? (i literally have NO time to get a certificate) and how many are considered competitive for md/phd?


r/mdphd • • 1d ago

What should I do next semester and app review as an MD applicant hoping to internally transfer

0 Upvotes

I would like to preface by saying that I am a current MD applicant with hopes of transferring internally into MD-PhD. I share the details below.

Options I’m considering for next semester:

Option 1: Hospice Volunteering and Part-Time EMT (I am nationally and state certified)
Option 2: Take A&P II and Hospice Volunteering
Option 3: Join a Cancer Immunotherapy Lab and Hospice Volunteering
Option 4: Take a Phlebotomy Course and A&P II and Hospice Volunteering
Option 5: Take a Sonography Course and A&P II and Hospice Volunteering

Currently, I have 3 MD IIs, no As currently and no top 20 MD IIs.

I plan to transfer internally into MD-PhD (deciding between molecular genetics and immunology, either way will focus on translational bench neuro-oncology research)

I recently sent the following updates to my current medical school application:
• ⁠LOR from my A&P I professor (told me it is stellar)
• ⁠LOR from my genetics professor (told me it is very strong)
• ⁠LOR from hospice supervisor (started and leading a program there)

My questions are:

  1. ⁠What should I do next semester?
  2. ⁠Anything else I can update schools with to increase my odds?
  3. ⁠Overall application review

My application:

GPA: 3.8
MS Neuroscience, BS Neuroscience and BA Public Health
MCAT: 515
Research: 4K hours, spans 4 labs, but 2K hours in a cancer lab with 1 co-author publication in a high impact peer reviewed journal
Clinical: 2K hours (volunteering, shadowing, scribing, and academic medicine clinical translation work). hospice volunteering
Non-Clinical: 1.5K hours (autism student class instructor + co-founder of org; 2nd degree black belt and instructor for a few years). Published health econ book author
Currently taking Genetics and A&P 1 as non degree student to further increase my academic readiness for medical school. (On track to get As in both, grades will be finalized in next few weeks).
TMDSAS Secondaries submitted: 8/14 - 8/17 (same day submission for all - pre written)
AMCAS Secondaries submitted: 9/3 to 9/7 (submitted same day to within 3-4 days of receiving - these were pre written); rest were submitted 9/9 to 9/13 (same week submission)
School list: All 14 TMDSAS schools + AMCAS (UCSF, Columbia, WUSTL, Yale, Cleveland Lerner, Mayo, WCMC, Feinberg, Sinai, CWRU, Einstein, OSU, BU, Rochester, Colorado, Tufts, Georgetown, Wake Forest, Vermont, Temple, Quinnipiac, Drexel, VTech, Albany)


r/mdphd • • 2d ago

can i justify a 516 MCAT retake?

5 Upvotes

i know with more study time i can do better. especially since i scored a 126 on b/b which was four points below my avg. im worried i wont be competitive for the programs im interested in with this score


r/mdphd • • 2d ago

How to improve interviews after rejections

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I am lucky enough to have received a good number of interviews, but it feels like my interviews have not been as well as I wanted which has resulted in at least 4 rejections and 1 waitlist from what I know. I have a few more schools I am waiting to hear back from post interview (2 of which I did at the very start of the season and have little confidence in looking back and looking at how I got rejected from the following 4) and a few left to interview at. The school that waitlisted me told me in voice that the interviewers all had good things to say about me and liked meeting me, but I doesn’t seem like it was enough to push me into the admit pool. I feel like I have been improving with each interview, such as becoming a lot more specific in my interviews about what type of research I want to pursue (neurodevelopmental and psych and imaging), how the school would help pursue that goal (been trying to get better at balancing the clinical vs research aspects), trying to be less convoluted in explaining my research (don’t think I’m doing a good job in explaining future steps/importance as well as I thought I was doing), and trying to improve the specifics of my why mdphd so that it ties more to my future goals, but it feels like it falls a bit flat towards a more cliche answer of why the joint-degree. Most of these invites were sent to me in September/October, so idk I’ll be seeing any more iis anymore, although I did send secondaries to like 30+ schools.

Do yall have any advice on how to improve moving forwards? For instance, what are these committees really looking for? I can’t tell if I’m not getting acceptances due to mismatch in research fit/funding or my interviews have been more awful/mediocre than I think they were (I definitely mess up at times) or both. In addition, the schools that waitlist you or won’t give you a decision tell you to keep in contact, and during interviews the interviewers have given me names of researchers that I might be interested in. Besides sending the occasional letter of update, does it really help staying in contact with the school, such as sending the student buddy messages; talking to the researchers the interviewers recommended/connected you to; and sending letters of interest/intent?


r/mdphd • • 3d ago

Any reason to not withdraw from schools following an A?

15 Upvotes

Hey all,

Very, very fortunate to have received an A last month to an MSTP. Since then, I have been receiving a few II's from other MSTPs that I (with near certainty) would not attend at this point, and would like to withdraw. I know that, for regular MD-only applicants, people may leverage these for aid or scholarships, but as I understand it that wouldn't be relevant to MSTP admissions.

Before I withdraw, I just wanted to check that it should be 100% okay to withdraw from these schools (and other schools I don't have IIs from, but also wouldn't attend). I'm not withdrawing from all my other schools of course, as some of these programs are also very strong in my particular field of study.

Best


r/mdphd • • 2d ago

can I apply for md-phd program with an undergrad in Chemical Engineering ? Would it lessen affect the chances in my application?

1 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • 2d ago

opinion needed

0 Upvotes

Chat is it taboo for me to ask my dad’s oncologist if I can shadow him🫦


r/mdphd • • 3d ago

Advice on applying MD/PhD after leaving a research position 🤪

6 Upvotes

Hi guys!

I'm planning to apply to MD/PhD programs in the upcoming cycle and would appreciate some advice, particularly from people who have experienced difficult situations with a PI.

I have several years of research experience, multiple publications and presentations, and a strong interest in pursuing a career as a physician-scientist in oncology with 2 first authors on the way(one from the lab I left and one from undergrad). I'm currently preparing for the MCAT and planning my next research opportunities.

Recently, I resigned from a full-time research position after reporting my PI for sexual harassment. I did an internship there then went to do a post baccalaureate for a little over a year and 2 months. I later raised concerns about retaliation and felt that the situation was not adequately addressed. I was also informed that there had been previous complaints involving the same PI for similar concerns.

Despite reporting my concerns through the appropriate channels (HR), I did not feel comfortable remaining in that environment (faced relation from him and was not protected after reporting). I eventually decided that leaving was the best decision for my well-being and future.

I'm now focusing on studying for the MCAT, finding another research opportunity, and potentially pursuing a research fellowship abroad. I’m taking my test in February and using this time to heal and study. After I take it I will look for a new lab.

I love research and still want to pursue an MD/PhD. I just don't want what happened in one lab to overshadow the work I've done or affect my future opportunities.

My biggest concern is how this might affect my MD/PhD applications. I contributed significantly to several research projects, but I'm uncomfortable discussing the circumstances surrounding my departure or relying on my former PI for a recommendation.

For anyone who has experienced something similar
How did you explain leaving a research position during interviews?
Did you disclose the harassment, or did you keep your explanation general?
Did not having a recommendation letter from your most recent PI raise concerns?
Did taking a few months away from research negatively affect your application?

I'd really appreciate any advice. Regardless of what happens I will continue to warn other women and I had some great female and male witnesses who were postdocs. They now have spread the news of what a creep he is with their past PI’s.


r/mdphd • • 4d ago

Lots of people confuse a “nice” or “cold” interviewer with their own performance

29 Upvotes

some people will naturally push back on what you say and others r naturally very inviting and bubbly people. as long as you did your best to convey your candidacy your interviewers reactions or personality does not really say anything about what ur results will look like. Also, my understanding is the individual faculty meetings hold very little weight and at least for me, most of my faculty talked about the school and their work more than they asked me questions. most of the meat is committee interview. good luck to all!


r/mdphd • • 5d ago

Is it a good idea to try for an MD-PhD as a non-trad career changer applicant?

7 Upvotes

I'm 27 right now. I was a foreign undergrad student with a Bachelor of Engineering in Computer Science with 3.85 GPA (after US equivalency). Due to persecution in my country, I decided to leave and immigrate to the US. I was never interested in the software field, but my family was controlling my educational decisions at the moment so I didn't have a choice. Upon coming here, I finished my MS in Bioinformatics (3.96 GPA), and started working as a Research Data Scientist at a medical school in Boston (I led 4 projects focusing on systems biology and precision molecular medicine for Alzheimer's Disease, and supported 4 in radiology) while I worked on my immigration case, which I finished in early 2026. After that, I've had more time to think about my career and I really want to pursue my original interest in physician-scientist path, so I'm planning to start a pre-med post-bacc soon and apply to MD-PhD programs probably in 2028. I think I'll have over 13000 official hours of research since 2020 (2 first and 3 second author publications, 2-3 poster presentations), 300 hours of volunteering at a safety net hospital in my area, and around 100 hours of shadowing if everything goes according to my plans. I'm not sure if volunteering and shadowing will count as clinical experiences, but I'll also try to get some clinical experience if possible.

I was wondering if it's worth it to try for an MD-PhD with that kind of background. I mostly see applicants with science backgrounds, and I did have 1.5 years of science in my undergrad. I feel like my foreign bachelor might be the biggest barrier. So far, I only have graduate level courses in the US from my masters and extra coursework in Pharmacology and Public Health from my work (non-degree tuition remission, 4.0 GPA).

I'm not a genius and I know how much I don't know yet, and I worry that I might waste my time and money trying to compete against super geniuses that start preparing for med school in high school. I just love learning and I can be pretty good at it sometimes.

If anyone has any advice on what I could try to do in the next couple of years, I'd really appreciate it.

P.S.: I won't apply as an international applicant, but as a domestic applicant. I'm also open to just MD since that also provides research opportunities. I don't think I can make a decision about my PhD research without clinical/medical training of some kind, which is why I don't think I am interested in just a PhD.


r/mdphd • • 5d ago

Not feeling good about interviews

4 Upvotes

Anyone have interviews they felt bad on and then got an A? I thought I had a good interview, but ended up with a waitlist, and now I'm worried my other interviews also did not go great and I'll get rejected because my GPA and MCAT are below the school averages


r/mdphd • • 5d ago

rescheduling interviews

2 Upvotes

I'm super grateful to have received a handful of interviews, but unfortunately a few of them overlap. Is it worth it to try to reschedule or do I just need to withdraw. They are on each respective program's final day, so I could ask them to move it up but I'm guessing those are mostly full. Also, should I try to reschedule the lower ranked program (mid tier MSTP) which I could have a better chance of getting accepted to, or the higher ranked program (T20ish) but I might not have a great chance of acceptance?


r/mdphd • • 5d ago

Does your feelings after interviews predict results?

0 Upvotes

Hi all, I’ve heard from the MD only side that how you feel after an interview doesn’t reliably predict the outcome. But we are all scientists, so I was wondering if there’s some kind of consistency or a way to predict? Pas applicants, what was your experience?


r/mdphd • • 6d ago

Early Secondaries, Late T20 IIs?

4 Upvotes

Hey all, wondering if any previous cycle applicants can weigh in on receiving late IIs from these schools even after early secondary submission (Early July/within 2 weeks). Fortunate to have some other IIs just wondering if it's still possible to hear back in Dec/Jan and where at. Cheers.


r/mdphd • • 6d ago

Seeking a mentor

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone!
I’m new here and was looking for someone who has done/is doing all of this who’d be willing to help answer some of my random questions as they come up throughout my journey. I know Reddit is a place where you can shoot out a question and get a lot of responses, but that’s not really my forte (I’m probably going to be asking dumb questions and would be happy to avoid any serious grilling).
I’m currently a senior studying Chemistry and Economics at Indiana University. I’ve got a lot going on and am still figuring out all the nitty-gritty details of the application process. Whenever I’ve had the chance to learn more about it, I keep realizing just how much there is that I don’t know.
I’m not looking for someone to hold my hand or babysit me through this journey. I’d mostly just appreciate having someone in my corner who I could reach out to once in a while with questions. To clarify, I’m not asking for someone to coach me or guide me every step of the way. I’m just hoping to connect with someone who’s been in my shoes before and is willing to share their perspective.
Thank you for reading!


r/mdphd • • 6d ago

update letters, too late?

2 Upvotes

Is it it too late to send update letters at this point in the cycle like if I get update letters in by December 1st should I send them or is it like, at this point it's not worth it to try to get more II via these update letters.


r/mdphd • • 7d ago

B.Pharm 7th Semester Student from India – How can I strengthen my profile for fully funded US Pharmaceutical Sciences PhD admissions (Fall 2028, CGPA ~3.1/4.0)?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/mdphd • • 9d ago

Struggling with mental health as an aspiring MD-PhD student. Will needing accommodations hurt my future?

25 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm currently a sophomore at a research university majoring in neuroscience, and my long-term dream is to pursue an MD-PhD and become a physician-scientist.

I've always been academically ambitious and deeply passionate about neuroscience research. I've been working in a research lab, trying to develop an independent project, and balancing a demanding premed course load.

Unfortunately, I've been struggling significantly with my mental health. I have a history of anxiety, depression, and OCD, and recently my symptoms have become much harder to manage. I've been experiencing severe anxiety, exhaustion, difficulty concentrating, and trouble keeping up with studying.

My psychiatrist is considering recommending formal testing accommodations, and I'm also thinking about contacting my university's student support office to request postponements for some upcoming exams.

I recently opened up to my research mentor about what I've been experiencing, and while I hope they'll be understanding, I feel incredibly ashamed. Part of me feels like needing accommodations means I'm not intelligent, resilient, or capable enough to pursue such a demanding career.

I'm terrified that my mental health difficulties will negatively affect my grades, research opportunities, recommendation letters, or eventual MD-PhD applications.

I know intellectually that mental illness doesn't make someone less capable, but it's difficult to extend that understanding to myself.

I wanted to ask:

  • Has anyone here received testing accommodations or academic extensions during undergrad and successfully gotten into medical school or an MD-PhD program?
  • Did your mental health struggles affect your relationship with research mentors or recommendation letters?
  • Have any of you experienced a particularly difficult semester academically because of mental health challenges and still gone on to succeed?
  • How did you overcome the feeling that needing help meant you weren't cut out for medicine?

I genuinely love neuroscience and still want to pursue this career. I'm just scared that I'm falling behind and ruining my future.

I'd really appreciate hearing about anyone's experiences. Thank you.


r/mdphd • • 9d ago

What's the deal with CA program ii invites?

12 Upvotes

Does anyone have insight regarding the ii's going out for the MD/PhD programs in California? Cycletrack historical data seems to suggest UCSF, UCSD, UCLA, UCI, and USC are behind on invites at this point? Particularly curious because my app is strongly skewed toward these west coast schools! Ah!


r/mdphd • • 9d ago

Update Letter Advice

5 Upvotes

I have received 2 IIs from T15 schools as an international applicant (not Canadian). I am very grateful for these interviews, but I'm also a bit worried that these come from very strong and reputable MSTPs and that they might have low post-interview acceptance rates. I did not notice any strong red flags during my interviews, and I connected well with one faculty member from each school! I also have 4 rejections from T10 schools, and radio silence from the remaining 12.

My first question is, once you get an interview from an MD/PhD program as an international applicant, are you chances comparable with the ones of a U.S. citizen? In other words, does this mean the school has enough funding to take you in and would not reject you because of that?

Would you recommend sending update letters to the remaining schools and/or the schools that I interviewed with, and are 2 IIs still a good shot? I do not have any new publications, but I attended a research conference and have new clinical and leadership positions. I mentioned all these as my 'plan for the gap year' in my secondaries, but now that they came true, do I need to update the schools on that? I apologize if I sound neurotic. I am trying to plan for the rest of my gap year, and that largely depends on whether I get in this cycle. I am grateful and open to any feedback/suggestions. Thanks! :)


r/mdphd • • 8d ago

Do you guys feel good after your interviews?

2 Upvotes

I always feel extremely mid. Definitely answers I feel confident in but tons I feel were either mid or hand wavy or where I should’ve used a stronger anecdote. Idk out of my hands now but was hoping others felt similar haha