r/mildlyinfuriating • • 3h ago

That's not milk Grabbed the eggnog instead of the milk

Post image

I went to make a bowl of cereal and didn’t realize I used eggnog instead of milk until 2 spoons in.

It’s a wild combo, but I guess it works.

Worst part is, this was literally the last of the cereal.

1.3k Upvotes

218 comments sorted by

532

u/donfan 3h ago

113

u/Skylantech 3h ago

Speed running it for sure

4

u/arnoldee002 2h ago

I’m already there. T1D if you’re wondering. Definitely not the same but it’s diabetes lol

5

u/Adventurous_Row3305 3h ago edited 3h ago

•

u/AccidentOk5240 2m ago

Haha funny jokes, but reminder that sugar consumption does not cause insulin resistance. If you’re insulin resistant, sugar consumption makes things worse, but it’s not the cause. 

64

u/ArasFlow 3h ago

Some bourbon will fix that

27

u/Skylantech 3h ago

Thought about adding some!

17

u/oddscenity 3h ago

What kind of cereal!? Cinnamon toast crunch, eggnog and bourbon sounds like a fucking dream 🤤

11

u/LongjumpingJaguar308 3h ago

Kinds looks like Capn Crunch?

9

u/oddscenity 3h ago

Might be my five year old child taste palate but Cap'n Crunch without the crunch berries is like Lucky Charms without the marshmallows.. that's just wheat baby

2

u/Xzanderth 3h ago

Pretty sure Krave

2

u/oddscenity 3h ago

Ugh cinnamon sugar churro krave is so fucking good

6

u/lilaccheesecake 3h ago • Popcorn

On a side note, accidently clicked your profile....

Sorry op for your waterslide rendezvous. Hope things got better lol, certainly this cereal was.

761

u/Accountant-According 3h ago • Bravo

229

u/SpeedBlitzX 3h ago

"Only 30 sweet Noggy days! Then the government takes it away again."

27

u/Accurate_Koala_4698 2h ago

No eggnog. In fact, no nog period

11

u/ancalime9 2h ago

Might want to ease up on the nog if it's stopped your period.

8

u/beam3475 2h ago

Simpsons did it

273

u/Elly_Higgenbottom 3h ago

Oh, please. Sounds delish! I thought it was mac n cheese.

54

u/ChachamaruInochi 3h ago

I did too, despite it being equally ridiculous to pour milk into a fully made bowl of mac & cheese.

8

u/ShinyShadowGligar 1h ago

I did this once by accident! I somehow accidentally bought a sweetened vanilla soy milk instead of unsweetened plain and used it to make Mac and cheese. 

•

u/ChachamaruInochi 30m ago

Did you try it? Just for science?

•

u/ShinyShadowGligar 24m ago

Yup, that's how I learned I made a major mistake. My toddler thought it was the best Mac and cheese ever though.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/PersonalityTough9349 1m ago

I’ve done same. The vanilla flavored not milk “milks” are easy to mistake for one another for some reason. They should change the packaging.

9

u/Ok-Addition1264 3h ago

Hell yeah.. a best mistake.

88

u/oddscenity 3h ago

This gave me so many ideas..

16

u/SmurfJooce 3h ago

Make pudding with nog. Banana cream worked well.

13

u/oddscenity 3h ago

Or like an eggnog cheesecake.. but with bourbon and cinnamon. With a gingerbread or cinnamon toast crunch crust.

7

u/junctiongardenergirl 3h ago

Or eggnog oatmeal. Or eggnog French toast. Or eggnog bread pudding.

3

u/CharmingAsparagus17 2h ago

I once was served bread pudding made with leftover stale cinnamon rolls and eggnog. I will never forget that

3

u/oddscenity 2h ago

Was it a good or bad experience? 🤔

2

u/AFrenchLondoner 1h ago

Forget the cheesecake, just give me the bourbon and cinnamon. In fact just get me a fireball

→ More replies (2)

2

u/chuffberry 2h ago

I saw someone on the internet make banana cream pudding this way. They also used biscoff cookies instead of nilla wafers.

2

u/oddscenity 2h ago

Why always banana cream? Couldn't it be some other type of pudding? I dont love bananas

3

u/beesarefuckingdying 2h ago

I'm sure it could be whatever you want it to be

→ More replies (1)

9

u/SquirrelyBoy 2h ago

Try golden grahams with chocolate milk

3

u/oddscenity 2h ago

Fruity pebbles with vanilla bean ice cream

6

u/Feelfree2sendnoods 2h ago

I thought this was macaroni for a sec, and honestly kind of intrigued me

2

u/pre_pun 2h ago

I'm going to try it, but with egg nog ice cream.

2

u/oddscenity 2h ago

Egg nog ice cream and macaroni!?

•

u/Kain_713 0m ago

Last Christmas I accidentally grabbed the eggnog instead of heavy cream when making home made Mac and cheese. It was too late to correct it so I just rolled with it. It definitely added something to the sauce, I really liked it.

37

u/Successful_Face3408 3h ago

Future prank, unless they're allergic to eggnog

17

u/SquireShanksalot 3h ago

I wonder what the best kind of cereal would be for eggnog

31

u/Malfunction1972 2h ago

I'd bet that cinnamon toast crunch would be awesome

8

u/versusrev 2h ago

Clearly a connoisseur of the herb

5

u/SeniorDiscount 1h ago

Fuck!!!! Eggnog ice cream with crushed up CTC on top! Maybe add some raw sugar on top, hit it with a kitchen torch to make a warm crust like on a creme brulee.

1

u/Malfunction1972 1h ago

You good sir are onto something. I'm going to have to try this.

3

u/creatyvechaos 1h ago

Make sure you get some mini dehydrated marshmallows as well

2

u/impossible_burrito 2h ago

Captain crunch already has that sort of eggnog taste

•

u/Complete_Entry 50m ago

captain crunch is a good one, golden grahams is terrible.

14

u/NoxKyoki 3h ago • Heartwarming

I am in need of that nog.

Personally, I see this as a win. Depending on the cereal, of course.

12

u/MrZephy 3h ago

Put strainer over bowl

Pour egg nog into glass from bowl

Fill bowl with milk

3

u/SeniorDiscount 1h ago

Oooo!!! Cereal flavoured egg nog! I’d have a swig. I love cereal milk, especially Cap’n Crunch and Frosted Flakes.

29

u/24megabits 3h ago

I'm glad you aren't like that one guy who was mad that stores were selling egg nog before November.

16

u/SammyGeorge 3h ago

Omg I wish they would sell egg nog in stores before November where I live. They don't start selling it until the 1st December and they stop on the 25th. 25 days a year is not enough egg nog

(Yes, I know I could make it at home but I'm not that skilled lol)

13

u/AMLIDH2 3h ago

Im happy af I get a half gallon from Walmart like every other day, love the stuff. They sell Southern Comfort egg now, its alcohol free, just good old fashioned spiced egg nog an man is it good. My blood gets real thick an sweet this time of year, real thick. And them boom Jan 1 an shits all gone. Im gonna stock up this year before they stop selling it. Anybody know if u can freeze egg nog without ruining it?

5

u/Magic-mick333 3h ago

Costco eggnog is 7x better than Walmart eggnog no joke

2

u/edked 2h ago

Yeah, I can remember some people I knew freezing egg nog and it turning out fine.

1

u/trey_wolfe 1h ago

Yep, it holds up pretty well to freezing. Also amazing put through an ice cream machine.

2

u/NoFuqGiven 2h ago

But they've sell it year round!!!

10

u/CrimpAndGritz 3h ago

Infuriating or ingenious?

9

u/NearPeerAdversary 3h ago

I would call that an unexpected win.

7

u/TreeHedger 2h ago

I didn’t see the words “by accident” in the post.

13

u/Vegan-juice-girl 2h ago

I am not american so I am kind of confused. I thought eggnog was an alcoholic beverage that you drink in the holiday season. Is this milk flavoured with eggnog or is it really the eggnog but in a gallon form? If it is the latter, is it normal to buy an alcoholic beverage in this format?

11

u/Emergency-Try2235 1h ago

Hey! American here. We sell pre-made eggnog in our grocery stored with some additional preservatives/stabilizers to keep it shelf stable a little longer. It does not contain alcohol. That is more of a choose your own adventure when you get home.

9

u/flabort 1h ago

Basically North American Eggnog is sold as a Virgin version of the drink, a blend of milk and egg and nutmeg and other spices and copious sugar that can be drank on its own by children and adults, or treated as a mixer and have rum added; before alcohol is added, it typically needs refrigeration. But once rum is added, though I haven't seen this happen in person, I am told it's typically left out for a few days while people take drinks out of it over that time. This can be seen in the movie National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation, where a punch bowl of rum-spiked eggnog is in the hallway and the family uses moose-shaped mugs to dip in the bowl and scoop out eggnog to drink.

But while it's in a 1L carton, which is shaped identically to a 1L milk carton just labelled different, it is non-alcoholic on this side of the pond. Just one of many drinks that is non-alcoholic by default as a result of Prohibition. See also: Apple Cider vs Hard Apple Cider.

•

u/TheLoneCenturion95 27m ago

Today I learnt there is rum in eggnog and now I need to try it, I'd always just assumed it was some horrific calorie dense sugary nightmare but now I know it's a horrific calorie dense sugary nightmare that you put rum in I'm all up for it. What kind do they put in it though? Navy, dark, spiced?

•

u/Complete_Entry 50m ago

leaving a bowl of eggs and milk sitting out sounds incredibly foolish. I've had it from a punchbowl, but it was a chilled punchbowl with ice under it.

•

u/Tjaresh 32m ago

Follow up question: 1/2 Gallon is about 1.9L. How much do you drink of this? In Germany it's served in very small glasses (0.7 oz). This is enough for a decade. 

3

u/Suspicious_Dingo_426 1h ago

The alcohol is optional, and is usually added just before serving.

•

u/Complete_Entry 51m ago

the cocktail calls for alcohol, the costco one premixed is essentially rocket fuel.

6

u/PlatypusEgo 3h ago

Add a half pint of rum.

You just invented my new favorite cereal

5

u/DenverBowie 3h ago

Seems like a lot of rum at breakfast, but they say it’s the most important drink of the day….

5

u/-_G0AT_- 2h ago

Where is the problem?

3

u/SalvationArbys 3h ago

Seems like a revolutionary idea

3

u/GinchAnon 3h ago

I mean, that sounds like a pretty potentially awesome mistake....

3

u/snafe_ 2h ago

I've never tried it, always through it was an alcoholic drink. Not a thing in Ireland though. Might make some closer to Xmas.

3

u/AlternativeFilm8886 2h ago

Looks like one of those things Bob Ross would call a "happy accident"

3

u/revdon 2h ago

It could be worse. You didn't make Mac 'n' Cheese with it.

3

u/artrald-7083 2h ago

I accidentally poured coffee rather than milk on my cereal one morning.

I added milk. It was actually surprisingly good.

2

u/Doctor429 3h ago

Ok, now I want to give it a try

2

u/xboxchick311 3h ago

You know, I don't hate this.

2

u/Altruistic-Report-30 3h ago

Idk, Cap’n Crunch with sugar cookie eggnog…I think it sounds like it would be good.

1

u/Xzanderth 3h ago

Pretty sure it's Krave, weird combination for sure but probably edible

2

u/maraney 3h ago

Accidentally delicious!

2

u/emilie1031 3h ago

I mistakenly added Eagle Brand to my mashed potatoes instead of regular canned milk

2

u/Beautiful-Total-3172 3h ago

This a trick, that gotta hit. Nog'n Crunch. I'm on to your cyop op.

2

u/fusionmobile 3h ago

EAT THE HELL OUT OF THAT.

2

u/skiesoverblackvenice 3h ago

with krave (i’m assuming) too?? damn good night

now i’m craving cereal

2

u/fatDaddy21 3h ago

Bowl full of eggnog with some broken up oreos in it is the Breakfast of Champions, friend

2

u/gilt3t 3h ago

How i would've reacted before slamming 30u of insulin and crushing this bowl of heaven

2

u/NoFuqGiven 2h ago

Could be worse! Atleast it ain't skim milk

2

u/sezdawg7 2h ago

Hey man, I've had captain crunch with half n half before. If it works it works.

2

u/LegoNoah123 2h ago

Ok but that cereal is going to taste divine

2

u/SnoringEagle 2h ago

Tis the season to put vanilla custard in my coffee

3

u/Labmit 3h ago

May I ask what is Eggnog? Different country and Christmas culture and all.

8

u/Some_Conference2091 3h ago

Eggnog, historically also known as milk punch or egg milk punch, is a rich, chilled, sweetened, creamy dairy-based beverage traditionally made with milk or cream, sugar, whipped eggs and, in some contexts, distilled spirits such as brandy, rum or bourbon Source: Wikipedia 

It's very good, try it if you have the chance.  

8

u/FitPossession8762 2h ago

Its definitely an acquired taste, I'm surprised how many people I've met that act like it's the foulest drink on the planet.  I personally LOVE egg nog and have to remind myself not to drink too much because i already have diabetes

4

u/Stormfeathery BLUE 1h ago

I should really get more lactaid and try some eggnog again this year. Lack of egg nog is one of the tragedies of lactose intolerance

4

u/TheRoyalBrook 1h ago

Try the guardian brand online, cheaper than lactaid brand, same effectiveness imo. 360 of them for 30 bucks.

2

u/FitPossession8762 1h ago

I'm partial to the non alcoholic southern comfort brand

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Suspicious_Dingo_426 1h ago

I like egg nog, but a spice some manufacturers use gives theirs a chemical or medicinal aftertaste that's off-putting to me.

1

u/PineappleFit317 1h ago

I like nog and don’t like nog. If I drink it, I’m like “this is good”, but then get to a point where I’m like “ugh”. Though I’d bet egg nog would absolutely slap if it subbed for milk for some Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Corn Pops, or Frosted Flakes, maybe even Mini-Wheats.

1

u/echovyn The emoji scissors ✂️ wouldn’t close in real life 1h ago

As an autistic person, it is definitly one of the foulest drinks in existance. Not because of it's taste, that's wonderful. It's because it is so damn thick it throws off the texture

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Hairy-Fart_8808 1h ago

Acquired? First sip i loved that shit, have yet to try with alcohol though

→ More replies (2)

1

u/NiceTrySuckaz 1h ago

Yep, an acquired taste is exactly right. The flavor is strong and unique and I hated it the first time I tried it. But if you know what you're in for when you start sipping it grows on you.

1

u/tofuyakisoba 1h ago

I love the taste of egg nog but it's too thick for me, I add a bunch of milk to it. Also some brands of egg nog taste really weird so that might contribute to some people's dislike. I used to work at Starbucks and their eggnog tasted like bubblegum and nutmeg to me for some reason.

1

u/Remarkable_Rough_649 1h ago

It just tastes like an even richer non-frozen vanilla milkshake to me

•

u/Complete_Entry 53m ago

I mean ingredients wise it's an unchilled milkshake. Hell on calories though.

1

u/CassianCasius 1h ago

Yeah it can totally depend on the brand too. I don't like most egg nogs but a local dairy farm near me makes an amazing egg nog it's so good 

1

u/DidItForTheKnookie 2h ago

It's basically like really thick milk, with the most heavenly flavor.

Side note for Americans who drink alcohol, try it this year with Kahlua. Mixed about 2 parts egg nog, 1 part Kahlua. Thank me later, it's the nectar of the gods.

1

u/Scittles10-96 1h ago

It tastes like melted ice cream, raw eggs and booze mixed together to me. I imagine there’s some delicious homogenous flavor others get, but for me for some reason I just taste everything separately in any egg nog I’ve ever drank in my life.

4

u/Not_ur_gilf 3h ago

Imagine if you cut melted cinnamon ice cream with a splash of milk so it’s drinkable. That’s what it tastes like (full truth- it’s an uncooked custard made with heavy cream, sugar, and eggs, usually in that order.)

•

u/Complete_Entry 52m ago

they make egg nog ice cream, it's okay but it sat in the freezer a while. The pumpkin pie one vanished without my intervention, house likes pumpkin pie.

1

u/Yoitman 3h ago

‘Tis noggy egg.

A Slightly sweet creamy drink, fairly sugary.

1

u/funktion666 1h ago

You have to just try it sometime if you visit. It’s sweet vanilla Xmas dairy drink. With alcohol usually.

Don’t ask any more questions, otherwise it gets gross sounding lol. I can’t think about it at all. Just gotta enjoy the flavor. It is really yummy!

•

u/yellowspaces 48m ago

It’s essentially a very thin custard.

1

u/Middle-Bill3873 2h ago

Google is amazing

1

u/sorry-i-was-reading 3h ago

TWO spoons in? 🤨 😂

1

u/Mostly_Nohohon 3h ago

I was wondering if maybe you were on to something good with that combo. I've never even tried eggnog for some reason but sugar cookie eggnog sounds pretty tasty

1

u/ElectricRune 3h ago

You just gave me an idea...

1

u/Evening_Boot_2281 3h ago

from 1 to 10 how would you rate it?

1

u/CpuJunky I mean, c'mon 3h ago

Now... what kind of cereal?

1

u/ZealousidealCheck612 3h ago

I thought you made mac and cheese with sugar cookie eggnog 😅

1

u/Solid-Birthday-9533 3h ago

Well add some liquor and have a delightful day.

1

u/clubmedschool 3h ago

My teeth hurt

1

u/MissNoTrax GREEN 3h ago

Eggnog makes good french toast...

1

u/hardlythriving 3h ago

Is this Krave? I loooove that cereal

1

u/AntibodyEnjoyer 3h ago

Sorry you can’t read, OP

1

u/xikbdexhi6 3h ago

How did it taste? I know I shouldn't assume you ate it.

How did it taste?

1

u/ConsistentPound3079 3h ago

It's okay, I brushed my teeth with Voltaren, who the fuck leaves a tube of that in the toothpaste holder.

1

u/Spirited_Marzipan_24 3h ago

How was it rate it out of 10

1

u/Legitimate-Log-6542 3h ago

I’m kind of thinking this is an upgrade

1

u/Ibanezrg71982 3h ago

With is that, Capn' Crunch?

1

u/Xzanderth 3h ago

Looks like Krave

1

u/blue_matches_my_eyes 3h ago

God I loved Krave, miss the double chocolate one they used to have

1

u/Illustrious_Talk9656 3h ago

Did it taste good?

1

u/hillsb1 3h ago

I'll bet that tasted amazing, though

1

u/1outofbillions 3h ago

How did it taste? I'm curious lol

1

u/Prestigious-Door-311 3h ago

So, is eggnog just flavoured (yes, I used the 'British' spelling) milk?

1

u/Budget-Cantaloupe725 3h ago

It’s not that it’s egg nog, it’s that it’s SUGAR COOKIE egg nog.

1

u/the_orange_alligator ORANGE 3h ago

So how was the taste

1

u/Wolfy_Packy 3h ago

thanks for reminding me, i gotta get some eggnog

1

u/Dragontastic22 3h ago

From a peek, this looked like mac & cheese instead of cereal. It could've been worse. 

1

u/Lopmon_ 3h ago

I was scrolling past this and thought that was a bowl of mac and cheese 😭

1

u/BajaBlastingRopes 3h ago

Blue lid is 2% milk. THERE IS A SYSTEM. THIS IS HOW SOCIETY BREAKS DOWN

1

u/This-is-FUBAR82 3h ago

Could have been worse, could have used the egg nog to make Kraft Mac and cheese. (That's what I thought it was when I first saw the picture.)

1

u/the_cats_pajamas12 3h ago

So... my question is... where does one purchase sugar cookie egg nog?

1

u/fluffypotato 3h ago

Eeeeeeww

1

u/cormbeefhashtag 2h ago

I’d try this.

1

u/werewolf-luvr 2h ago

Thats a direct upgrade

1

u/Smokeythemagickamodo 2h ago

This sounds awesome

1

u/fudgechemist 2h ago

A happy accident

1

u/Too_Relaxed_To_Care 2h ago

Everyone saying sweet cereals but eggnog is already really sweet, something like Raisin Bran would probably be better.

1

u/Step-exile 2h ago

Can someone explain for non americann what is the thing he used instead milk?

1

u/tardiscoder 2h ago

For a second I thought OP made mac and cheese with eggnog. The horror.

1

u/No_Tension420 🫥 2h ago

You didn’t notice the $5.99 cost?

1

u/TheAlmightyBirdQueen 2h ago

Boss I thought that was mac n cheese

1

u/Stephen_Is_handsome Stephen Harris 2h ago

What is egg nog I all ways see it on films like home alone but never seen it in real life

1

u/Solrex 2h ago

Yum!

1

u/tiptoe_only 2h ago

I personally would not be upset

1

u/Thebigbambino87 2h ago

. . . anyone else prefer eggnog as cold as possible?

1

u/Sorry-Climate-7982 1h ago

Well, did you eat it anyway, and if so, how was it?

1

u/Moonlit_Cinders 1h ago

Actually sounds lowkey tasty. Sugary af tho. Maybe just a once a year snack, perhaps after partaking in a veeeery good brownie...

1

u/Eclipsed_Shadow 1h ago

I thought I was looking at a bowl of tater tots for a sec

1

u/Dank_geek710 1h ago

Rate it out of 10

1

u/Affectionate_Leek127 1h ago

Merry Christmas

1

u/ASadLesbian- 1h ago

oh i would be DEMOLISHING THAT
i love egg nog

1

u/Franican 1h ago

If I thought of this 10 years ago there wouldn't be enough Ozempic in the world to keep me under 1,000 lbs.

1

u/FluffyFry4000 1h ago

oh shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiid

I wanna try that now

1

u/SupremePopTart 1h ago

This isn't mildly infuriating. It's mildly delicious.

1

u/brickiex2 1h ago

6 outta 10 ....would try though

what cereal is that?

1

u/Chunkycheesesteak 1h ago

Use a spaghetti strainer with another bowl underneath, dunk that and start over.edit nvm I seen this post was 2hrs ago

1

u/BuggleTrucken 1h ago

I would slurp that down like the fountain of youth.

•

u/Complete_Entry 56m ago

egg nog in cereal is fine, but have you noticed most of it is stepped on this year? Yours is sugar cookie, mine was spice, haven't seen plain yet.

•

u/ElderberryUpper7594 55m ago

Was it good? This seems like a mix up you can forgive yourself for.

•

u/DeeplyFlawed 54m ago

Egg nog is nasty. I’m sorry.

•

u/Scrimshawsedation 8m ago

I am a glutton when it comes to nog... How are you stomaching that sugar cookie mess they called eggnog? I just got one yesterday thinking I'd try something new and I wish I hadn't.

•

u/trisanachandler 2m ago

If that had been macaroni, it would have been far worse.

•

u/RevolutionTiny7138 2m ago

You guys still eat cereal?

1

u/juliamarielovestrees 3h ago

This is not infuriating at all.