r/mtgrules • • 37m ago

Landing Party/Riker/Beginning of combat question

3 Upvotes

Hi All, first post here, forgive breaches of etiquette!

I'm playing a [[Riker, First in the field]] deck with [[Landing Party]] on arena- Riker's ability triggers at the beginning of combat, I get 4 mana from Landing party, but the mana doesn't carry through to combat. It seems like it triggers at the end of main phase 2 then disperses. It's hard to use that mana as if it were main phase mana too - I cant reliably use it to cast creatures or activate [[aggrevated assault]] like I can with a fetch in main phase 2.

My understanding is that the beginning of combat would be part of the combat phase, and that mana wouldn't drain until the end of said phase (or at least until the end of declare attacks?)

Its not that I need to know how it works (assuming no bug anyway), but more that I don't have a framework of the rules that supports how this seems to function in-game


r/mtgrules • • 50m ago

End step Priority rules,

2 Upvotes

to preface i am beginner, i had this interaction on endstep where I activated brainstorm on opp's end step, saw thought scour in my draws and after putting two other cards back it immediately went into my turn instead of allowing me to cast the thought scour.

Is this how its actually supposed to be or could i have activated thought scour on the end step after resolving brainstorm?


r/mtgrules • • 1h ago

Edea, Possessed Sorceress & The Animus

2 Upvotes

Let’s say i control Edea, Possessed Sorceress and The Animus.

I exiled legendary creature A with a memory counter on it using The Animus.

At the beginning of combat during my turn, I gain control of enemy legendary creature B.

During my main phase 2, i use The Animus activated ability to make legendary creature B become a copy of legendary creature A until my next turn.

Does my opponent gets back control of creature B at the end of my turn ?

And if it happens, i suppose legendary creature B will still be a copy of creature A until my next turn.


r/mtgrules • • 6h ago

Question about zevlor and twinning staff

3 Upvotes

Im pretty sure it would only copy the spells that get made that target other players just once total. It wouldnt make copies for each individual copy that hit a seperate player. Im just asking to make sure im correct in thinking the trigger on zevlor is considered one instance of copying even with multiple players.


r/mtgrules • • 20m ago

Question concerning Aura and Ward

1 Upvotes

Hello there,

I was playing in Commander and one opponent played [[Replenish]] to get [[Parasitic Impetus]] back on board and attach it on [[Kiora, Sovereign of the Deep]]. He told me that he didn't had to pay the ward cost since he didn't targeted my Kiora, it was just the Replenish putting it on the board and the aura "attached" to my Kiora without targeting it.

Is this correct?

From my understanding, Aura with "Enchant creature" imply targeting, which then trigger Ward 3 from the creature being the target, thus my opponent needed to pay 3 or the Aura is countered.

For it's really just rules 303.4a on Auras needing target and 702.21a on Ward.

Am I missing something?


r/mtgrules • • 1h ago

Mobilize and "Opponents you attacked"

1 Upvotes

For example: [[Worf, Defiant Commander]] / [[The Beacon of Kahless]]

My play group was a little confused if these work with Mobilize and/or Mobilize-like effects.

Beacon reads differently from Worf, so they might even work differently, too? Would love clarification!


r/mtgrules • • 7h ago

Sword of Hearth and Home

3 Upvotes

If the creature this is attached to is White or Green. Can the ability to flicker target that creature? Is it the sword ability able to target? Or does the creature get it and can’t target itself.


r/mtgrules • • 1h ago

Duda Archnemesis

0 Upvotes

digamos que yo estoy jugando en formato "Gigante de dos cabezas", es decir, dos jugadores contra dos jugadores que comparten 30 vidas. cada uno controla su maná y criaturas, pero se juega en equipo compartiendo 30 vidas.

Cuando mi equipo ataca (yo y mi compañero), el equipo rival defiende con las criaturas que quiera de cada jugador.

¿Qué pasa si yo saco el encantamiento Archnemesis y encanto al oponente rival?

La carta dice "enchant opponent", pero el efecto se aplica al "when you attack enchanted player". ¿Aquí opponent y player significa lo mismo?

En este caso como aplica está carta? funciona o no funciona? Yo tengo 2 oponentes (2 players), o tengo 1 oponente que son 2 players? El efecto se aplica al atacar al equipo rival, o no funciona porque no estoy atacando a un jugador si no a un equipo?


r/mtgrules • • 3h ago

Zaxara and alternative casting costs

1 Upvotes

Does Zaxara still make a hydra if you cast a spell for an alternative cost with an x in it? For example casting Nature’s Rhythm for its Harmonize cost?


r/mtgrules • • 10h ago

Questions about cursed mirror

3 Upvotes

What happens when [[cursed mirror]] copy cards like [[angel of serenity]] and [[angel of condemnation]]and dont leave the battlefield?

They have an ability that triggers when they leave the battlefield and cursed mirror stops being the copy end of turn but it never leaves the battlefield.


r/mtgrules • • 11h ago

Graaz + Kenrith's Transformation interaction

1 Upvotes

If I enchant [[Graaz, Unstoppable Juggernaut]] with [[Kenrith's Transformation]], Graaz becomes a 3/3 Elk and loses all abilities.

Are my other creatures still 5/3 Juggernauts?

My understanding is that this might work because of the layer system: Graaz's type-changing effect applies in Layer 4, while Kenrith's Transformation removes abilities in Layer 6, and its power/toughness-setting effect applies in Layer 7b.

Is this correct, or does removing Graaz's ability stop the entire effect from applying?


r/mtgrules • • 12h ago

Protection, triggers, and color changing

0 Upvotes

If the color of a permanent changes after its trigger is put onto the stack targeting a creature with protection from the color it changes into, does the triggered ability fizzle.

Ex. I have a creature equipped with [[Sword of Feast and Famine]], my opponent tries to return it to my hand with [[Aether Channeler]], in response to the trigger I change the color of Aether Channeler to black using [[Sway of Illusion]]. Does my creature still get bounced?


r/mtgrules • • 16h ago

Uugguu and Mirror of the Forebears

1 Upvotes

[[Uugguu, the Omniplasm]]

[[Mirror of the Forebears]]

Do I get two token Mirrors that I can activate to make even more Mirrors?


r/mtgrules • • 17h ago

Kaalia, windcraig siege and Rune Scarred demon

0 Upvotes

If I double Kaalias trigger with windcraig and put out rune scarred. Can the tutored card be put out with Kaalias ability


r/mtgrules • • 18h ago

Training grounds and XX mana costs

0 Upvotes

Let's say I have a training grounds on the field and a Gogo, Master of Mimicry. I was told that training grounds could only reduce 1 of the 2 x's and that i can't split the mana reduction to -1 to both X's. So if I say wanted to copy 2 times, training grounds would attempt to reduce x to 1, and I'd have to pay the full other x value for 3 mana spent total. Or if I wanted to copy it 3 times, it ends up being 4 mana spent total. (3-2) + 3.

Is this correct and can I get sources explaining this? I'm having trouble groking what actually happens.


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Clarification on Mimeoplasm, Revered One and Blink Effects

0 Upvotes

Looking to make a silly deck with [[Mimeoplasm, Revered One]]. Its activated ability makes it a copy of a creature "exiled with it"; if Mimeoplasm gets removed and I cast it again, can it still become a copy of the cards it exiled before it was removed? I always get confused about this rule ...


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Brace for Impact and Hardened Scales

0 Upvotes

What kind of effect is [[Brace for Impact]]?

Instant. "Prevent all damage that would be dealt to target multicolored creature this turn. For each 1 damage prevented this way, put a +1/+1 counter on that creature."

I want to say it's a delayed, triggered ability (a rare exception that doesn't use "When, Whenever, or At") that will place +1/+1 counters individually?

But I could be wrong on all of that.

Ultimately I'm curious if [[Hardened Scales]] will double each +1/+1 counter in this case.


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

The Master, Transcendent reanimates Lord of Extinction

0 Upvotes

I mill [[Lord of Extinction]]. If my opponent taps his [[The Master, Transcendent]], what is LoE’s power and toughness? Can you ELI5? Thanks.


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Lwaxana Troi and doubling non-creature triggers

0 Upvotes

Let's say I'm playing a [[Bello, Bard of the Brambles]] deck, and I've previously played [[Lwaxana Troi]]. I play and [[Aether Flash]], then I activate Lwaxana's ability targeting the Aether Flash. I get my double card draw trigger on my turn, then I pass the turn. On my opponent's turn, when they play a creature, does Aether Flash deal 2 or 4 damage to it?


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Timing restrictions

0 Upvotes

I just cast [[Guff rewrites history]]. An opponent flipped a counterspell and didn’t cast it. Nearly a full turn rotation later, he attempts to cast it for free from exile. Is he allowed to do that?


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Mulligan rules and how you play with them? Am I asking too much?

0 Upvotes

So I hit up my friend to set up mulligan rules. I asked 4 times if we could just follow the rules if the game. Each time he says “it’s situational” “I don’t care about winning I just wanna have fun”.

We have been playing for 20 years on and off.
(Btw this is the guy that drew 7, didn’t like it, drew 7, didn’t like it, drew 7, didn’t like it, changed deck and drew a new 7, than won the game)

I just hate that he wants everyone to have separate rules based off of who they are and what deck it is.
Am I asking too much?

We messaged for an hour and he would NEVER pick a rule. He wants them flexible.

ME
I guess I just want to know what rule we’re playing by lol. It doesn’t have to be a big deal. I’m just trying to figure out the rules so we’re all playing the same game. Are we mulliganing until we get 2 lands, 3 lands, or what? It’s not a tournament, but we should still have some kind of rules in a competitive card game lol.

It doesn’t have to be what I want. I just voted for the normal mulligan rules. I’m fine with whatever everyone agrees on.

HIM

We can talk about it later man its situational I just don't like seeing ppl sit there with one land is all weather its me or others but like I said its all situational depending on decks and who is playing lol either way i don't care what rule is decided Bic im not worried if I win or loose just trying to play its just harder to do that with one land and I also don't want to win beating on ppl with one land but its all situational and preferences but we can establish rules b4 games depending on whoever is around I just don't wanna force mull rules on strangers I wanna see what they bring to the table but ppl also need to know when its appropriate i guess but first mull is always free I don't care what anyone says


r/mtgrules • • 2d ago

Can I transform a copy of a card?

2 Upvotes

I have [[Gwyndala, the Progeny]] out. I cast [[Dowsing Dagger]], then use Gwyndala's ability to turn her equipped [[Neuroflux Heirloom]] into a copy of Dowsing Dagger. If I connect, does the temporary dagger transform? What happens here in general?


r/mtgrules • • 1d ago

Understanding Copy and Multiplicity

0 Upvotes

I just bought the “We Are The Borg” deck and am trying to understand how the ability of “Hugh, First of Many” works in the sense that if I had “Conquest Mission” on the battlefield and casted a theoretical artifact creature that has a static ability of “Whenever you generate one token or more, create twice as many.” and Replicated it 3 times; Would they first off, enter the battle or manifest? And if they do enter the battlefield, do they enter simultaneously or one at a time? And if they do enter one at a time, do they stack the effect of Conquest Mission in a multiplicative sense? (i.e. 1st original creature procs 1 Borg Token, then the 1st copy procs 2 Borg Tokens, then the 2nd copy procs 8 Borg Tokens, then the 3rd copy procs 16 Borg Tokens | Sorry if my math is wrong |) Or is my understanding of copy wrong? Sorry for the essay, any clarification would be much appreciated!


r/mtgrules • • 2d ago

Skipping Trigger

0 Upvotes

Howdy y'all.

Just wondering about [[G'raha Tia, Scion Reborn]]. Because it's a May trigger, can you skip resolving it on your first noncreature cast to use it on the second cast? So can you cast a one drop artifact, refuse to pay the life then cast a 3 drop artifact and pay the life to get the effect? I'm unsure if the Once per turn is on the ability activation or resolution.