r/mumbai • u/Broad-Research5220 • 3h ago
Discussion Mumbai’s MOST Profitable Business Model
Investigative journalist and author Palak Shah recently shared on Mumbai’s daily parking nightmare. He frames it as the city’s most profitable, self-sustaining business model, one that requires zero capital, faces no competition, never issues a refund, and is run by two partners who never had to sign a contract: the BMC and the Mumbai Traffic Police.
According to Shah, the foundation of this model began with land. Over the years, residential towers, commercial shops, restaurants, banquet halls, and coaching centers were cleared on narrow lanes originally built for forty families. Builders sold apartments worth crores with brochures promising ample parking, only for buyers to discover stack-parking contraptions barely able to fit three hatchbacks.
This is what we call manufactured demand. Mumbaikars bought vehicles, paid road tax, registration fees, insurance, and EMIs, but every night, residents circle their blocks three or four times before giving up and parking outside their own society gates. The Traffic Police tow van lifts the vehicle and issues a challan. The BMC manufactures the problem, the Traffic Police collect the revenue, and the citizen pays twice, once in the price of their flat, and repeatedly in fines.
Major hospitals in areas like Parel were cleared with no parking for patients, visitors, or even ambulances. A son rushes his father into the emergency ward during a heart attack, runs back out to move his car, and finds a challan waiting on the windshield. Meanwhile, police stations themselves lack parking, leaving department jeeps lined up on the very public roads where citizens are fined for the same offense.
Do you agree with his perspective?