r/musicians • • Jul 10 '25

Introducing /r/musicians Community Rules (finally!)

73 Upvotes

Hey r/musicians community,

We’ve heard your overwhelming requests for clearer guidelines to keep this subreddit a vibrant, collaborative, and respectful space. It’s long overdue (sorry!), but we’re excited to introduce the official rules for r/musicians! These rules are designed to foster creativity, connection, and respect while addressing key concerns like banning AI-generated content.

r/musicians Rules

  1. Encourage Collaboration This is a space to connect and create together. Share ideas, seek bandmates, or propose projects. Be open, inclusive, and supportive in all collaboration efforts.
  2. Respect All Members Treat everyone with kindness. No harassment, bullying, or discrimination. Keep feedback constructive and positive.
  3. No Sales or Self-Promotion We’re a community, not a marketplace. Don’t post to sell products, promote services, or advertise your music, events, or channels. Focus on sharing knowledge and experiences.
  4. No AI-Generated Music AI-generated music is not allowed. This subreddit is for human-created music. Please share AI music in r/AI_Music or other relevant communities. This extends to repeated discussions of AI generated music.
  5. Stay On-Topic Posts should focus on musicianship, collaboration, or music creation. Off-topic posts, like unrelated memes or spam, will be removed.
  6. Follow Reddit’s Content Policy All content must comply with Reddit’s site-wide rules, including no illegal content, doxxing, or spamming.
  7. Report Violations See something that breaks the rules? Report it to the mods. Don’t engage in arguments - let us handle it.

These rules are just a starting point, and we’re open to your thoughts. Please give us your feedback as well - we want there to be some clear rules but at the same time not go overboard - the up/down vote system in a big way is what shapes a community by the best posts going to the top, not by going overboard with rules.

In short, be nice to each other, and no AI generated content.


r/musicians • • 8h ago

Being forced to have an extra unwanted band member each gig

143 Upvotes

So I play in a big salsa band and every time we gig we end up having someone we didn't invite to try and join in on the band on stage and it's a constant curse that I'm sure I'm not alone with experiencing.

We are a big salsa band of 8-10 people and I'm not sure what it is about us but every time we play it seems everyone wants to join in. During our first gig some dude with a tambourine jumped up on the stage mid-set with us and started to play the damned thing off-sync to the rest of the band. After a few songs the singers kicked him out.

We had a big show in a huge venue at the beginning of last year and I was at dinner with some female friends and they asked me about my band and the upcoming show. One of the girls start overtaking the conversation how she has opera singing experience and that she can join our band as a singer (?) - she wasn't even kindly asking, but pretty much pressuring me to take her in. I asked her if she has any experience with Salsa music, she says not. I asked her if she even knows Spanish try to and make the point that she just isn't a good fit - she obviously says no - then the other girls at the dinner table try and convince me that she can learn Spanish phonetically and that it would be stupid of me not to let her into the band to play at that show. I felt like I was in a black mirror episode and that this was perhaps the most absurd shit I've ever experienced. Mind you - this is 2 weeks before the big show. I made it perfectly fucking clear to her and everyone at the table - at the cost of looking like an absolute asshole that she wasn't a good fit, that I couldn't make an executive decision of who can and can't join the band and that if she ever learns Spanish or Latin music we might consider taking her in.

2 days before the show I get the call from this bitch asking for details of the show. I told her she wasn't invited (this was a private company event) and I haven't talked to her or her friends since then.

4 months later we're playing at a Salsa dance club and we have a repeat of the 1st incident, except this time this dude borrows the percussionists cowbell and start playing the freakin' cowbell off-beat during sound check on stage behind the drummer. Before we went on stage our congero had a very serious and less friendly talk to the guy where he basically said he would make sure he gets thrown out of the venue if he tries pulling that shit during the show. The dude really thought he could just join the band on stage with his cowbell. Incredible

2 months later we're playing at medium-sized festival and the freakin' festival announcers after presenting us goes to the side still on the stage and starts singing with us off-key.
She keeps screaming at the audience and tries to hype the audience up between the verses and doesn't even know the name of the band and keeps shouting the wrong name of the band to the audience mid-show. I spent a shit ton of time and effort to record the audio and video of that show and now I have this complete fucking b#!% ruining the entire performance and forever recorded on it too. The lead singers told her to shut the fuck up mid-song after the 2nd song. She got the gist and got off stage.

This was the absolute worst example of getting the unwanted +1 band member that we have ever experienced and it has become a constant joke but also a glooming curse that keeps repeating itself over and over again.

Surely we aren't the only ones experiencing this and I'd be glad to hear your similar stories or reaction to this.

Have a nice day.


r/musicians • • 16h ago

What success means to me at 50

106 Upvotes

When I was in my early 20's and playing regular shows I had to make a choice between being a good mom and living the rockstar life. My husband at the time was insanely jealous that I was in a band and playing in front of hundreds of people and he wasn't supportive at all and he made it impossible for me to live my dream.

After dropping that loser, I played here and there but nothing seriously for decades.

A few years ago I decided to try playing with bands again and even though none of them have made it to the stage, I realized that my writing skills had improved drastically so I started recording my riffs and put them on YT to save for later in case I wanted to use them for full songs.

In these videos, the lighting is bad, it looks like I just got home from the gym because I did, my hair is out there and I'm not playing perfectly by any stretch of the imagination, and sometimes you only see my hands and the guitar.

It's not as though I've gone viral or anything like that, I have less than 150 followers and some of my videos only get a handful of likes, and that's okay.

What astonishes me though are the comments, like, "I'm happy I'm on the planet at the same time as you homie" and "this is really inspiring me".

I used to think that success in music was getting a record deal and getting paid to play in front of a big crowd, and for sure, that is awesome too, but these sincere comments from strangers make me realize what a gift it is to be able to write music and that success comes when a connection is made.


r/musicians • • 2h ago

Best high fidelity ear plugs?

3 Upvotes

Hey guys! Looking for some to use during sound baths. Google says Alpine, Etymotic, or Loops. What do you think? Thanks!!


r/musicians • • 33m ago

UK Reggae musicians wanted

1 Upvotes

Hello fellow reggae musicians,

My bass player and I (I’m a drummer) are looking for keyboard players and guitarists to rehearse and play with.

We play everything from rocksteady and roots, to rub a dub and dancehall

You don’t need to be a virtuoso, we just need you to have a good sense of timing and bring good vibes into the session.

If you’re based within the M25 area and are able to get together with us weekly, please send me a dm 🙏


r/musicians • • 9h ago

PLS SUGGEST YAMAHA GUITAR GIFT FOR BF

2 Upvotes

On a budget pls. Ranging from 10-15k Philippine peso


r/musicians • • 13h ago

How do I get started?

4 Upvotes

Admittedly, I've been thinking about making music for awhile now (specifically lo-fi music if ur wondering) and I don't really know how to get started making that or music in general. At most, all I know is that I'm taking a music appreciation class at my college so...anyone know how to get started with actually making music of my own?


r/musicians • • 10h ago

Hey guys general advice wanted from some experienced musicians

2 Upvotes

So my metalcore band is finally gigging off the back of our first 2 gigs we are/ have booked quite a few different shows from super local to 3 hours away, but what i have found is promoters and venue’s lock in dates post poster ect but never give us actually details until last minute ie there tech rider ect, in our epk we include tech spec, stage plot logos videos ect is it the norm to just trust they will have everything, and will contact me if anything xtra we need ? As i feel like im walking into every gig blind.
Maybe im just young and naive to the industry.

All advice and criticism welcome, thank you guys


r/musicians • • 9h ago

Best Underground Hits, Vol. 1

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 1d ago

what do you do when you've lost passion?

25 Upvotes

i'm sorry if this offends anyone somehow. but i have been doign music all my life since i was 4 years old and i'm 20 now.

i'm a classical pianist with a scholarship at a music uni conservatoire and it's my third year, and i have absolutely lost all passion for music.

i can not stand hearing any classical music in public or anywhere without wanting to rip my ears off.

i could drop out but the guilt is driving me insane since they gave me a scholarship. i have the talent but not the passion,, what is the point? i'd rather have the passion but not be as skilled. thats the whole point of music, no?
i've tried so hard for the past 15 years just to throw it away because i cant be bothered. idk how to feel. it was my dream to be a teacher or part of a pit band.

playing music for most of my life and practicing for hours every day, i'm not really good at anything else. i'm burnt out and have felt like this for 2 years. i'm telling myself, just sit down and practice and put my head down and finish uni. but wow it's hard.

practicing feels like a chore and its so hard seeing all my friends and classmates genuinely so curious and interested and excited to go practice. and i always pretend i'm the same lol


r/musicians • • 14h ago

Music room ideas

1 Upvotes

Looking to free up some space in the music room. I’d like to get stuff off the floor like the floor monitors. Anyway to stack up floor monitors on to shelves or the guita amps? Show me your ideas please


r/musicians • • 18h ago

Community for musicians

2 Upvotes

People have been talking about wanting community within the art community. Im 20 (F) and I sing and write songs, which is really more of a solo thing. So I ask, why do musicians need community when I can learn to do everything alone? What’s the point?

Any thoughts?


r/musicians • • 21h ago

Is it unacceptable to invite ARs to come check you out at a gig that you’re only opening for?

3 Upvotes

Context: My friend’s band released a new single and they’re hosting a release party. My friend asked me and some others to open for them.

I was thinking about inviting ARs from some local labels to check me out during the show but I was worried if it’d be making it “about me” too much?

Cause at the end of the night, the main focus should be to celebrate the main band’s new single right? That’s why I’m not entirely sure if I should because I wanna respect that.

Just wondering what would your guys’ takes on this?


r/musicians • • 14h ago

Remember the name SAGE.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 19h ago

Need members for r/sirgeorgemartin! So feel free to join and share

Post image
1 Upvotes

Much Appreciated:)


r/musicians • • 20h ago

Maria Calfa-DePaul

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 20h ago

Looking for feedback on my debut single about Indian representation around the world

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I’m working on my debut single, which is about Indian representation and culture around the world. I’m still learning and improving, so I’d really appreciate honest, constructive feedback on the song—whether it’s the lyrics, flow, delivery, or overall idea.

If you’re interested, please leave your feedback in the comments. I’d also be happy to arrange a call with anyone who’s comfortable sharing more detailed thoughts. Thanks for taking the time to listen and help me grow as an artist!

heres the song: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zCzSt6DeMk0mdg3dviqZsst3c0LujH9t/view?usp=sharing


r/musicians • • 20h ago

Adrianne Lenker - Anything, by me

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/musicians • • 20h ago

Question for keyboardists

1 Upvotes

Hi folks. For context. I’m a keyboardist for a Pink Floyd tribute band, and I’ve been doing that for about 3 years. I have been playing for close to 30 years but I took about 13 years off up til I joined this band. As a result, I’m pretty out of touch with the tech side of things.

My main board since 2010 is an RD-700NX which I love but it is bloody heavy, and I had a car accident last October and it’s not easy to carry that big thing around.

I’m wondering if anyone is able make any recommendations for an appropriate replacement for the board that might less heavy?

Thanks so much!


r/musicians • • 1d ago

How Many EP’s Did You Make Before Committing To A Debut LP?

2 Upvotes

My band's finishing up recording our debut EP.

We’ve sat with these songs long enough that we started writing our second record. We’re kind of stuck in limbo on whether it should be another 4-5 track self titled ep, or a 7 track self titled short album.

What should I be considering to make a decision, obviously cost and stuff but in terms of reach, and marketability? Where should we, as a band, 7 or 8 months after our debut ep release to help dial in which decision is better?

If anyone has any market insight or like industry “best practices” for this kind of thing. At the end of the day we wanna do what feels right and what we wanna do but at the same time if there's a science to this with like some backed data on what's better I'd like to know yk.

Edit - Band is Melodic Hardcore / Shoegaze


r/musicians • • 1d ago

How to get my spark back playing bass

5 Upvotes

Due to mental health problems, i stopped playing bass for almost a year

Last year i used to play all the time. My bass used to feel like it was the half of my soul

I'm mentally recovering now, and i want my spark back

But playing bass doesn't feel the same anymore

I get unmotivated easily

Any suggestions? What should i do?


r/musicians • • 1d ago

Songs Not To Play

24 Upvotes

I can't remember who told me this or if it was a fever dream, but I was told to never play these songs (or types of songs) in gigs or open jams.

* Cats in the Craddle

* Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald

I believe the person suggested not playing these as if you're doing a gig or jam, you want positive vibes in the crowd, you don't want people bummed out or crying. Maybe because I used to do an adult comedy gig years ago, that someone suggested not doing them.

How true it this? Have ever heard to not play SAD songs at gigs or open jams?

Or was it a fever dream on mine?


r/musicians • • 1d ago

Any working/gigging musicians who started from scratch after 30?

46 Upvotes

I know there is been plenty of famous artist who made it big after 30, that’s not what I’m talking about. My question is are there any working musicians who play local paid gigs, play in local churches for money or service and maybe tour sometimes with small artists who started playing their instrument after 30?

I grew up in family of musicians(both of my brothers are professional musicians) and I started played drums when I was 5 but it was always on and off since I was 5 until my 15 maybe 16. I also now a little bit of guitar and a little of music theory.

I am now 31 and I started taking drumming lessons again surprisingly I still remember a lot of things and I’m learning the bass guitar which is easy since I know the basics of guitar and I know the notes on the fretboard.

Is it realistic to aspire to be play at a non famous professional level(local gigs, local churches,etc) in the next 2-3 years?