The mode could definitely use improvements, but it’s a fun mode to switch up the objective grind.
Pros:
- I love that the game mode incentivizes teamwork more than objective. I like that the group is forced to hold down an area as a unit, sink or swim together. In objective, sometimes it feels like there’s very little opportunity for team play, and is much more “every man for himself”
- I like that the game mode actually makes us fight the zeds. In objective mode you’re pretty much trying to minimize how much fighting you’re doing a lot of times. So I like that it’s a switch up to a more combat-oriented mode.
- I really like how each match is a consistent length, usually about 25 mins. Sometimes I’ll play a game of objective mode where everyone dies halfway thru and a 30 min game turns into a 45+ min game.
- One of my favorite parts of survival mode is how it is more difficult than objective mode a lot of times. At least on nightmare. Nightmare survival is genuinely a harrowing experience each time, where there’s no guarantee of making it out alive. I actually use the early extract in this mode sometimes. Nightmare objective can feel like a running simulator until you get to hard choke points, like community center on Pottsville, or the train extract on Broadway.
- On that same note, I love how Hard difficulty survival mode is like the chillest experience ever. Sometimes I just wanna turn my brain off, smoke some herbal remedy, and have a good time mindlessly killing zeds.
Cons:
- I dislike that the XP and credits you get from survival mode is hardly worth the time you spend playing it. There needs to be critical supplies or something to balance this out. NGL maybe it’s just a me-thing but it feels like I’m “wasting” time by playing this mode because it will inevitably make my responder retirement grind take longer, despite my overall love for the mode.
- I dislike that after you play the game mode more than 3 times that the song selection gets old. Can we pretty please have more songs? I’m gonna go insane if I have to hear a select couple songs for the millionth time. Purposefully infecting myself just so I have a different experience listening to the speakers lol. Throw in some intense classical music, instrumental jazz music or something to add to the atmosphere of absurdity/chaos.
- I dislike that every single match is about protecting the speakers. Would be nice if there were maps that the emphasis was on zone control points A, B, and C like in the first game. Just to switch it up a bit and add some variation.
- I dislike how your success on survival mode on Nightmare comes down to the RNG of where the speaker is on Wave 3 sometimes. Like you just know when you get a ground/first floor speaker in a house, rather than a basement or 2nd story it’s gonna be a bad time.
- I wish there were a scoreboard on this mode that keeps tally of how many zeds each person kills. Not that it really matters, and it shouldn’t affect XP gain, but it would be satisfying for me. In hard difficulty lobbies where there’s a lot of newer players, it’d be nice to actually see on the scoreboard that I’m making a big impact in our success. It’s also just an ego thing, like games such as Killing Floor I’m always trying to “dif” the other roles in kills, headshots, large zed takedowns etc, and that’s part of the challenge for me is to outperform others in our cooperative efforts.
I also wanted to add that I agree with others who have said they should focus on making objective maps, and just “chopping up” parts of those maps to make multiple survival maps. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the addition of Ruby Lake. Great map. But we definitely need more priority on objective maps for that responder retirement grind, and for fun. A map like Power Plant that gives you the options to hit up allllll those juicy extra POIs are what make the replayability of it so fun each time.
If they don’t have plans on releasing objective maps fast enough (which they aren’t), they desperately need to allow community-made maps to keep the game alive. The only reason I put so many hours into the 1st game was because the community servers with custom maps that made it a refreshing, new & challenging experience every time I opened the game.