Stop the Clocks is simultaneously a banger compilation and kinda a let down. It's not a singles collection, but more in the vein of The Beach Boys' Classics Selected by Brian Wilson. A true, curated by the band, best-of. Except Brian Wilson included a new song, California Feelin', to incentivize old fans to buy the album too. StC nearly got this as well with, well, 'Stop The Clocks', but for one reason or another it was left off the album. A big disappointment indeed.
So with all that shit out of the way, is it a good compilation? I mean it's one of the first things I recommend when I tell people about Oasis, it is that good. It's all you need to get started with them, except it lacks any Be Here Now and Dig Out Your Soul material, and it is mysteriously light on 2000s material. Well, not really. Liam wasn't involved in this compilation at all. This was Noel's show, and it shows because he decides to basically put two EPs of DM and WTSMG and then a "and these other selections I guess" on the two discs. Don't get me wrong, he picked amazing tracks, but it is absolutely dire that he left out Stop Crying Your Heart Out, Gas Panic, Hindu Times, Stand by Me, Let There Be Love... It's rough for sure, and it did not have to be this way either because each CD is only 45 minutes long. There was absolutely room for more material.
What is here is excellent though. This is a really well-picked lot of songs. Opening on Rock n' Roll Star is 100% the right move, there's a really good selection of B-sides in Acquiesce, Talk Tonight, Half the World Away, and The Masterplan. The run at the end of Morning Glory tracks is a nice touch too. I'm glad they were not broken up, but i do think Champagne Supernova should have been the ender just like on the LP. The statement of intent in the album itself really shows the mindset that was behind the selection of tracks.
...this is not a full stop, but merely a time out; a dream set list, and a chance for the world to review the immense contribution that Oasis have made and continue to make to rock 'n' roll.
This was made during a time where Oasis had records to promote. Where they had to put in DBTT cuts and when they had to meet sales targets. In 2006, this album is more like what Noel and Liam would have agreed on the set list being if they could basically do whatever they wanted. That run from track 16-18 is their encore. It was probably the right choice, but I think looking through the official Discord and seeing everyone's "what if" tracklists for their own Stop the Clocks, with the exact same 9+9 listing, shows the amount of quality in their catalog that you could have one hundred permutations and no one can really agree on one. This is Noel's take.
So I would personally love to see a StC that was all Liam's choices. That's all.
Edit: Wow a lot of people really do not like this compilation.