r/odnd • • 1d ago

Alarums & Excursions Issue 22 -- An interesting take on cursed items

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/odnd • • 1d ago

systems Which from these?

18 Upvotes

So Ive become curious about ODnD and its retroclones and decided to dive into them just need a bit of help deciding between some options ive found

- White Box: Cyclopedia – seems to be a clone of S&W rules but adds a lot to the game, which does seem different from others in the sphere but sounds cool. First game I saw other than the lbbs in this area

- Dungeon Delver: can't remember what about it sounded interesting but it did stick out to me at the time as slightly different and interesting

- Champions of Zed: It sounds interesting that its built upon an even earlier version of the game but it might be best appreciated when looking alongside with the lbb or a more faithful retroclone to them.

Of course I'm open to hearing about which other one would be good to start. Ik Sword and Wizardry is the most popular so finding a game would be easiest with that or the LBB.


r/odnd • • 2d ago

history Ken St. Andre (1947–2026): Remembering the Tunnels & Trolls Creator and Roleplaying Game Pioneer

Thumbnail
tabletopsentinel.com
124 Upvotes

The Flying Bufallo has sadly departed. We are starting to run short of RPG pioneers. Wish the best to Ken’s family. He was a great guy and I'm sure they are too. He will be missed.


r/odnd • • 3d ago

history On the origin of girdles?

18 Upvotes

So I was playing Baldur's Gate 1 and picked up a Girdle of Femininity/Masculinity. Whilst I (like so many other D&D players) have been familiar with the item, I began to be interested on how such an item ended up in Dungeons & Dragons.

My original thought was that it was first introduced in AD&D Dungeon Master's Guide and was used in Gygax adventures like the Tomb of Horrors. However, a quick check with a lad far more knowledgeable pointed me to the OD&D Greyhawk as the first piece of literature where the item is mentioned.

After that, the trail seemed to be quite cold, until then I remembered how Tim Kask (I think the Dorks of York video) described the issues that they were having in Lake Geneva with all the directions that the fans were exploring OD&D. He mentioned how in the East Coast people were so into girdles and then Alarums and Excursions (thought I can't 100% say if the California fanzine was directly linked or served as an example of Kask's on how just people went on with their ideas like a rocket ship).

So I was just wondering if anyone else was more familiar with this particular factoid before I start thinking of bulk buying PDFs from Lee Gold just for the heck of it. Were the girdles (especially the Femininity/Masculinity) something that started as a goof curse item in the Lake Geneva (or Minnesota crew), or something that the wider community came up with and it ended in a TSR publication. As far as I understand, a lot of fan material made it into the D&D publications.

Just something I have been pondering a for a while and thought to reach out if anyone much better equipped with particulars of TTRPG history knows so I can end my windmill chase.


r/odnd • • 4d ago

Swords and Wizardry GM screen inserts laid out weird

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/odnd • • 4d ago

The original plans for 1e AD&D

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/odnd • • 6d ago

It appears our D20's come from Japan

Post image
52 Upvotes

This article lays out the origin for the D20.

Early on D20's were numbered 0 to 9. All my Zocchi sets are numbered like that.

Dave Arneson said in an interview he found his dice in England. There are war gamer groups from Bristol who adopted the Japanese dice in the 60's. The path for their migration to D&D seems clear.

This seems spot on to me.

https://analoggamestudies.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Evan_An-Elegant-Little-Instrument_The-Japanese-Standards-Association-and-the-Birth-of-the-Modern-d20_Analog-Game-Studies-11.2.pdf?fbclid=IwY2xjawVoK5lleHRuA2FlbQIxMABwZG9mAWJyaWQRMTVBMmhxczlGM1NEakJmVU1zcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEf5x6rCmfd1BIwV4OHvYQdKCYfbWgYwCLFooxeogdnJXGnP-Nz_LiWb_1x1Fg_aem_M--UOCHmPZrnw2Xc5V5-YQ


r/odnd • • 6d ago

Weapon +1 is quite different in 2d6 or d20 combat!

25 Upvotes

Just something I wonder: how do you guys handle +1 weapons? In the man-to-man combat system, hits were determined by rolling 2d6 and checking the weapon vs. armor matrix. Here, the +1 of the weapon is quite impactful, if your target is 8, then a +1 to your roll will boost your probability of success from 42% to 58%, which is crazy. In a d20 system (like the alternative combat system, or the combat system of most retroclones) a +1 weapon would just give a flat 5% boost.

I know this probably doesn't matter as much, but I am curious, do you guys buff +1 weapons when using a d20 based combat system?

I also remember reading somewhere (old lords maybe?) that a +1 weapon acutally gives you an extra attack roll, but maybe that is the 1:20 scale system, I'm not sure.

PS. Same goes for stat modifiers I guess. In OD&D, a DEX of 12+ means "Fire any missile at +1." Again, that has quite a different impact depending on whether you use 2d6. Or even using 1d6, if your PC is fighting in a battle using the 1:20 scale! Crazy...


r/odnd • • 9d ago

LFG PBP - The Tourney - Joust & Melee - Chainmail + OD&D

12 Upvotes

I've been watching too many "Knight of the Seven Kingdoms" edits on YouTube, and it's got me really in the mood to run some kind of tourney game, featuring gallant knights jousting on horseback, as well as an on-foot melee. This idea has got my imagination in an iron grip, and isn't showing any sign of letting up, so I'm dealing with it the best way I know how.

I'd like to announce the opening of a new game! If you want to prove your valour in the tourney, send me a message, or comment below. For this game, I'll primarily be using a modified version of the Chainmail "man to man" rules, supported by the Original Dungeons & Dragons rules as necessary. We will commence proceedings with a joust, followed by a general melee. There may be other additional events and goings-on, but I will keep those a surprise for the time being.

I'll be running this game in my usual play-by-post style, where you just tell me what you want to do, and I'll handle all of the mechanics on my end. This'll be updated at a "one post per day" rate, those who've played in my games before know I like to run a fast-paced game.

This game will run concurrently with my ongoing "Castle Schlagenhoff" campaign, which I'm pleased to say has been running smoothly for over four months now, something I attribute to the amazing players who are part of this campaign. Truly, I count myself lucky to share a table with them, and I hope to get to know even more of you with this new game.

See you at the lists, players.


r/odnd • • 11d ago

homemade material WIP Hex Map I’m making for OD&D + Chainmail domain play!

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/odnd • • 11d ago

Dave Arneson's Family Needs Your Help

73 Upvotes

Hey folks,

I am sure everyone here knows who Dave Arneson is.

I am going around to various sites asking for help.

Dave's daughter, Malia reached out to Chris and I with upsetting news.

Her husband Luke has a brain tumor, which hopefully can be removed through a new type of surgery he will undergo.

We are here asking you to donate to a fund to help them get through this.

Every bit helps - even just a dollar.

Please take a minute to go to the link.

Also, if you can share the link it would help too.

We are fingers crossed everything will turn out well after Luke's surgery, but this kind of medical crisis also has real world costs.

Thanks so much everyone, Chris and Griff

Info is at the link:

https://www.givesendgo.com/lukesbrainfund


r/odnd • • 13d ago

OD&D rules Combat systems of OD&D and Chainmail

47 Upvotes

An expansion of my previous comment regarding the use of different combat systems in the original D&D with Chainmail.

You can see the full article here: https://vladar.bearblog.dev/combat-systems-of-odnd-and-chainmail/


Generally, you have about five combat systems available when running OD&D with Chainmail:

  • Troop Type System
  • Man-to-Man Combat
  • Jousting
  • Fantasy Combat
  • Alternative Combat System (ACS)

Troop Type System: The main combat mechanics of Chainmail's large-scale (1:20 or 1:10) combat are resolved by rolling several six-sided dice according to the "Combat Tables" (Appendix A, Chainmail, p.40), cross-referencing the attacking vs. defending troop type. E.g., three Medium Horse figures attacking a unit of Light Foot would roll six dice (2 per figure), killing an enemy figure for every roll of 5 or 6.

Man-to-Man-Combat: Additional rules for the small-scale (1:1) battles in Chainmail, resolved by rolling 2d6 according to the "Man-to-Man Melee Table" or "Individual Fires With Missiles" (Appendix B, Chainmail, p.41), cross-referencing the attacker's weapon vs. the defender's armor.

Jousting: An addition to the Man-to-Man rules, this concerns "Knights in 'friendly' combat," using the "Jousting Matrix" (Appendix C, Chainmail, p.42). In the OD&D aspect, this will mostly be used for tournaments and jousting matches with the castle occupants, as described in the "Castles" section (The Wilderness, Vol.III, p.15).

Fantasy Combat: Besides giving Troop Type statistics for various fantasy creatures with the "Fantasy Reference Table" (Appendix D, Chainmail, p.43), the "Fantasy Supplement" of Chainmail brings forth a new set of rules to resolve the combat between more powerful creatures, such as Heroes, Wizards, Trolls, Dragons, etc. (13 categories total), rolling 2d6 on the "Fantasy Combat Table" (Appendix E, Chainmail, p.44).

Alternative Combat System: OD&D provides a new d20-based system based on the character's level (or monster's Hit Dice) vs. the Armor Class of the target (same as in the Man-to-Man tables, from 9 (unarmored) to 2 (plate & shield)), which was later adopted as the main combat mechanic in the later editions of the game (starting as early as Supplement I: Greyhawk).


During the course of play, you will use all of the above-mentioned systems, selecting the most suitable one for the situation at hand. This is explained more clearly in the "Draft version" of OD&D, in sections that sadly didn't make it to the release (p.22):

Men vs. Men: If there are small numbers fighting it will be most interesting to use the Man-to-Man Melee Table. If large numbers are fighting the Combat Tables based on a troop ratio of 1:20 should be used.

Men vs. Fantasy Figures: It is suggested that the 1:20 Combat Tables be used, with men scoring 1 hit point when they hit and fantasy figures scoring hits equal to a die roll (1-6). Of course, some fantasy figures cannot be hit by normal men, and no hit points will be scored against them. (See the Fantasy vs. Fantasy section below.)

Fantasy vs. Fantasy: Because of the vast number of fantastic creatures and levels of men, a matrix to show hits is totally impractical (we know because we tried, but with 70 or more categories it became too unwieldy to handle) We therefor recommend that a system utilizing a 20-sided die (incriments of 5%) be adopted.

To summarize it all, here's the basic practical guideline:

  • Large-scale combat: (1:20 or 1:10):

    • Men or Fantasy figures vs. Men: Troop Type System with each successful hit removing 1 figure;
    • Men vs. Fantasy figures: Troop Type System with simultaneous hits equal in number to the target's HD required to remove 1 figure.
  • Small-scale combat: (1:1):

    • Men vs. Men: Troop Type System or Man-to-Man Combat with each successful hit dealing d6 damage;
    • Jousting: Jousting system;
    • Men vs. Fantasy figures: Troop Type System or Alternative Combat System with each successful hit dealing 1 hp of damage;
    • Fantasy figures vs. Men: Troop Type System or Alternative Combat System, doing one attack as a man-type per HD (or according to the "Fighting Capability" stated in class tables), with any bonuses applying to only one of the attacks, i.e. a Troll attacks six times, once with a +3 bonus (OD&D, Vol.II, p.5);
    • Fantasy vs. Fantasy: Fantasy Combat System or Alternative Combat System, doing a single attack per round.

Here, "Men" are those without a "Fighting Capability" rating and generally having less than 4 HD, such as "kobolds, goblins, dwarves, orcs, elves, men, hobgoblins, etc." ("Questions Most Frequently Asked About Dungeons & Dragons Rules", The Strategic Review Vol.1, No.2, p.3), and "Fantasy figures" are those having the Fantasy Combat rating, and generally having 4 or more HD (including Heroes, Wizards, etc., as per the Fantasy Combat System).

Troop Type to Armor Class conversion

The classification in the Chainmail's "Melees" section (pp.14-15) provides the following examples for the footmen troop types:

Light Foot: Missile troops, Swiss/Landsknechte, Peasants, Crews

Heavy Foot: Normans, Saxons, Turks, Vikings, Men-at-Arms

Armored Foot: Dismounted Knights. Sergeants, Italian City Levies and Condottiere

This gives us a rough correlation between the Troop Type and Man-to-Man/ACS Armor Class:

  • Light (AC 9 to 7): Unarmored, Shield, Leather or Padded;
  • Heavy (AC 6 to 4): Leather & Shield, Chain, Chain & Shield;
  • Armored (AC 3 or better): Plate, Plate & Shield.

πŸ“ NOTE: There are some contradictory examples regarding the exact split between the three types. E.g., "Bandits: Composition of Force" (OD&D, Vol.II, p.6) stats Leather & Shield as Light Foot, but the soldiers in "The Temple of the Frog" (Blackmoor, p.40) wearing Leather & Shield are considered Heavy Foot and are also "considered to be armed/armored as that of a bandit". My decision to place AC 6 into the "Heavy" category was also supported by the Man-to-Man Melee and Missile tables having the Leather & Shield "to-hit" target generally higher than the "Leather or Padded" (AC 7) category.

For horses, the Man-to-Man system provides two types: Unarmored and Barded. The same list from the "Melees" section provides some examples again:

Light Horse: Magyars, Mongols, Saracens, Spanish, Turks, Hobilars

Medium Horse: Mongols. Norman Knights, Esquires. Saracens. Spanish. Turks, Turcopoles

Heavy Horse: Knights, Reiter, Gendarms

Thus, Light Horse = unarmored rider and horse, Medium Horse = armored rider, unarmored horse,* and Heavy Horse = armored rider and horse.

* Also supported by "Bandits: Composition of Force" (OD&D, Vol.II, p.6).

For missile combat, most of the time you will be using the Man-to-Man's "Individual Fires With Missiles" table, but for the mass combat table, the categories are:

  • Light, no shield (AC 9 or 7);
  • Heavy OR shield (AC 8, 6, 5, 4);
  • Fully armored (AC 3 or better).

Troop Type to Weapon Class conversion

For melee, the weapon categories are generally based on the Weapon Class stated in the "Man-to-Man Melee Table":

  • 1 to 2: Light
  • 4 to 8: Heavy
  • 9 or more: Armored

πŸ“ NOTE: The "Hand Axe" category is stated as Weapon Class 1 in the original, but since there is no Weapon Class 2 weapon at all, I strongly suspect this to be a typo and treat Hand Axe as the Weapon Class 2 weapon.

There would be some exceptions if you expand the list with other weapon types, e.g., clubs, short swords, and staffs being in the Light category despite their higher Weapon Class. (Additional weapon types will be covered in a later post.)

Bonuses

Magic weapon bonus is added to the roll in Man-to-Man or Alternative Combat System, or adds an equal number of dice in the Troop Type system. Similarly, magic armor subtracts its bonus from the attacks vs. the wearer or from the number of dice rolled against him (OD&D, Vol.II, p.30).

Men-types wielding magical weapons would be able to score full damage plus weapon bonus against Fantasy figures instead of 1 point of damage (or no damage at all), as they do normally (see "Wights", OD&D, Vol.II, p.9).

There is no bonus for High Strength (13-18) for Fighters until Supplement I: Greyhawk (p.7), except the note of Strength aiding "in opening traps and so on" (OD&D, Vol.I, pp.10-11). If you want to give the Fighters an edge, I wouldn't suggest granting them anything more than a +1 to-hit bonus for High Strength applied to a single attack, just like the HD Bonus of the monsters.


r/odnd • • 13d ago

OD&D rules Fun Facts: OD&D - initiative

10 Upvotes

I need to go back and triple-check, but I do not believe that the word "initiative" appears in the 3LBBs.


r/odnd • • 13d ago

OD&D Prime Requisite Ability Exchanges: What's the Logic?

23 Upvotes

In OD&D, does anyone understand the logic behind the ability score exchanges for prime requisites?

Magic-Users and Clerics can trade 3 points of Strength for 1 point in their prime requisite.

Fighting-Men and Clerics can trade 2 points of Intelligence for 1 point in their prime requisite.

Fighting-Men and Magic-Users can trade 2 points of Wisdom for 1 point in their prime requisite.

Why are the exchange rates different? Is there a particular reasoning behind these numbers, or were they simply arbitrary design choices?


r/odnd • • 16d ago

events History of D&D Talk, 12/7, Sun Prairie Public Library Wisconsin

Post image
52 Upvotes

Hey everybody! I'm doing a talk at the Sun Prairie Public Library (near Madison Wisconsin) about the early history of D&D. I will be using material from my own game collection to talk about all of this. It will be on Monday, December 7th, 6:30-8pm at Sun Prairie Public Library - it's free and open to the public - please show up!


r/odnd • • 16d ago

settings Supplement 2 Blackmoor missing pages

8 Upvotes

I have a PDF of Blackmoor that I'm printing out to do some bookbinding. The copy I have goes from page 57 to page 60 and is missing the intervening pages. If anyone has the actual book, what's supposed to be on those pages?


r/odnd • • 16d ago

OD&D rules Dungeon mapping language - part 4

9 Upvotes

Continuing with the Example of Play from Volume III:
"CAL: The elf will check out the hollow sound, one of us will sort through the refuse, each trunk will be opened by one of us, and the remaining two (naming exactly who this is) will each guard a door, listening to get an advance warning if anything approaches.

"REF: Another check on the hollow sound reveals a secret door which opens onto a flight of stairs down to the south. The refuse is nothing but sticks, bones, offal and old clothes. One chest is empty; the other had a poison needle on the lock. (Here a check to see if the character opening it makes his saving throw for poison.) The chest with the poison needle is full of copper pieces β€” appears to be about 2,000 of them."

While not exactly about mapping, this exchange reveals how some issues are dealt with, namely secret doors and traps on chests.

  • In the case of the secret door, the "hollow sound" is a clue that there is a secret door - but the exact nature of the "check" is left undefined. As the referee, you might want to specify how to find and open a secret door, but this suggests that it isn't absolutely necessary, especially if you have someone like an elf who is better able to figure it out (due to more sensitive senses).
  • Merely saying "each trunk will be opened by one of us" without checking for traps sets the stage for making a saving throw versus poison.
  • Counting coins is also abstracted. A roll of US pennies (should you still be able to get them) holds 50 pennies, or copper coins. 2000 copper pieces is therefore 40 rolls of pennies, more or less. I could easily see asking if the party would take the time to get an exact count, especially for thousands of coins, but in the play example, it is left as "appears to be about 2,000 of them" without any further elaboration.

r/odnd • • 18d ago

OD&D rules Dungeon mapping language - part 3

11 Upvotes

Continuing with the example of play from Volume III:

"CAL: Okay, what does the room look like β€” we’re examining the walls, ceiling, floor, and contents of the room itself.

REF: (After checking to see if dwarves and/or elves are in the party:) The room is a truncated pyramid. The east wall is the truncated part, directly opposite the door you entered. It is 10’ long with another door in it. The walls connecting it to the west wall, the place you entered, are each about 35’ long. The west wall, which is where you entered, is 30’ long with a door in the middle of the wall. The elf has noted that there seems to be a hollow spot near the east end of the southeast wall. The floor and ceiling seem to have nothing unusual. The room contains the bodies of the gnolls, a pile of refuse in the north corner of the west wall, and two trunks along the wall opposite the one which sounds hollow."

This is the first room encountered. The door the party entered through was to the east and therefore is in the west wall of the room itself. This is a pretty straightforward explanation of the shape of the room, which is not a simple shape. When the REF describes it as a "truncated pyramid" that is relative to the direction of travel - going east.

How I might have described it: "The room is 30' from west to east; there is a door in the east wall directly across from you. The west wall is 30' north to south; the door you came through is in the center of the west wall. The east wall is only 10' north to south, with that door I previously mentioned. The 'north' and 'south' walls are angled, really northeast and southeast, connecting the longer west wall to the shorter east wall. There seems to be a hollow spot near the east end of the southeast wall..." (additional description comes after this).

Again, there is no particular difference between the two descriptions, save that the one in Volume III uses a shape to describe the space - "a truncated pyramid" and the description I provided gives the distance from east to west - missing in that original description. Both descriptions expect that the mapper will keep the "top-down" view in mind, to understand the space in question.


r/odnd • • 18d ago

Could you play Gygax Original (Hand written) Role-Play Dungeons and Dragons?

Thumbnail reddit.com
23 Upvotes

r/odnd • • 19d ago

OD&D rules Fun Facts: OD&D

55 Upvotes

There are far more rules in OD&D for exploration than there are for combat. Seriously: go check out Volume III, and while some of the exploration rules involve elements of combat, the vast majority of them do not.


r/odnd • • 20d ago

Castle Greyhawk is up for sale!

39 Upvotes

The Collector's Trove has Gary's original manuscripts for Castle Greyhawk up for auction on eBay. Important to note that it's the physical documents only, no IP rights at all.
www.ebay.com/itm/860104946494


r/odnd • • 21d ago

Gary Gygax's House Rules – A Recreation of How He Actually Played (Beta)

Thumbnail drive.google.com
61 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've recreated a document containing what I believe to be Gary Gygax's latest house rules, based on the information I've been able to find.

We all know Gary wrote extensively about the rules of D&D, but there's an interesting distinction between the rules he published and the rules he actually used at his own gaming table.

The goal of this document is to bring those personal house rules together into a clear, easy-to-read format that is ready to play.

This is still a beta version! If anyone has additional information, references, personal accounts, or corrections regarding how Gary actually played D&D, I'd really appreciate your input.

I'd love to make this as accurate as possible.

Thank you!

--------------------------------------------------
NEW VERSION OF THE DOCUMENT:
A References section has now been added, documenting the sources from which these rules were taken.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PuQGi-NauTkfEnfluTvOTgAtTSjM01lU/view?usp=sharing


r/odnd • • 21d ago

What if playing RPGs could be fun and easy to do?

Thumbnail gallery
23 Upvotes