r/onednd • • Oct 07 '26

Moderator Announcement MODERATOR ANNOUNCEMENT: Wizards of the Coast Unionization Efforts.

361 Upvotes

Some of you may already be aware that employees at Wizards of the Coast are pursuing unionization efforts. There is also a petition circulating for those who wish to express their support.

For anyone interested in learning more or supporting the effort, you can find the petition here:

https://actionnetwork.org/forms/uwotcpetition/

Sharing this information should not be interpreted as an endorsement or opposition by the r/onednd moderation team. We're simply making the information available to members who may be interested.

Unfortunately, previous discussions surrounding this topic have repeatedly devolved into personal attacks, hostility, and violations of our community rules. We've had to remove multiple posts and comments, shut down discussions, and issue bans as a result.

We recognize that people have strong opinions about this subject, and they're entitled to those opinions. However, disagreement does not excuse treating other members disrespectfully.

For the time being, we will not be hosting further discussions about this topic in r/onednd. This announcement is being provided for informational purposes, and comments will be locked. Additional posts attempting to restart the discussion will be removed.

This is not a judgment on the merits of unionization or anyone's position on the issue. It's a moderation decision based on the conduct we've encountered and our responsibility to maintain a civil community.

Thank you for understanding.

The r/onednd Moderation Team


r/onednd • • 17h ago

Discussion The World of Warcraft "combo strikes" feature is really sad

58 Upvotes

For those who haven't played the game, combo strikes is a monk ability that discourages spamming the same attacks - gives you bonus damage for using a different move than the one you used last.

But in D&D is does the direct opposite. Instead, it rewards you for spamming the same thing over and over, since monks don't have martials arts moves to choose from. It's not a huge thing in the long run, nowhere as egregious as "melee tank barbarian is the same thing as full casting ranged healer shaman, right?", but it is a bit pitiful.

Edit: I don't mean that it's sad they didn't pick another method. I mean that it's sad monk is so lacking in martial arts moves that there's no way they could have made it work.


r/onednd • • 4h ago

5e (2024) Which would fit my character better: Eldritch Knight vs. Zealot Barbarian?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 1h ago

Resource A new way to save and share 5e builds

0 Upvotes

Hello! For some time now, I've had more character build ideas than chances to play them. My friends and I play in person with physical books, and I've never had the need for digital tools like D&D Beyond. However, I kind of struggled to jot down my ideas in a coherent form every time in my notes, so I started thinking about a "writing standard" for character builds, in particular for 5e24, which is the edition we are playing.

As a Pokémon VGC amateur, I always liked the idea of PokePastes, an immutable link that renders your Pokémon team and makes it easy to share and import into various related tools. Starting from that idea, I tried coming up with the same resource but for D&D instead, leading me to dndpaste.

The tool is designed to help you write down your builds into replicable recipes, not to make a full character sheet, specifically for sharing or simply saving the build for yourself in a tidier manner. I've added a few QoL features to help out, but at its core it's just a guided text editor, nothing fancy.

I'm not a dev, so as a disclaimer, I used AI to build the current online tool, but the format and structure come from me. On the technical side, I would love to hear your feedback, both as users and as experts, if anyone around here can help out!

To test it out, here's a crazy vampiric touch sorcerer troll build using the UA Defiled Sorcerer and Raised by Cultists origin feat in combo with the new WoW Troll (Amani): https://dndpaste.fcomfy.workers.dev/MkjvlYRjJo


r/onednd • • 21h ago

5e (2024) Player wants a Goolock Mind Sliver build

36 Upvotes

So im running a campaign, players start at level 3 and one of them is considering making a great old one warlock specialized into CC but mostly into the mindsliver cantrip, they took agonizing blast, eldritch spear, and devils sight applying agonizing and eldritch spear to mind sliver. So essentially they can look at a person and with no components cast mind sliver from 150 feet away as long as they can see them for no cost.

Personally I find the idea of a psychic sniper silently killing someone with a brain aneurysm in public by just looking at them to be incredibly cool and would love to implement it however I am mildly concerned by the balance, in combat it doesn't seem that strong at all and much more manageable than a typical warlock build however in social situations it seems like it could be rather powerful.

Anyways I just wanted to see your thoughts on if ive understood everything correctly.


r/onednd • • 14h ago

5e (2024) Question about Fast Hands

9 Upvotes

If I am playing a thief rogue at level 3 and take either booming blade or true strike via the magic initiate feat, can I scribe those spells on to scrolls if I have arcana proficiency/calligraphers tools and can I then cast them as a bonus action?


r/onednd • • 1d ago

WotC Announcement Wizards is giving its share of the Anthropic settlement to D&D authors

370 Upvotes

As the title says. Wizards of the Coast and D&D authors got a split portion from the Bartz vs Anthropic settlement (the case about training AI from copyrighted books), and WotC is giving its portion to the authors.

I've shared more detail about what's happened - and comment from Wizards - here: https://www.wargamer.com/dnd/anthropic-settlement


r/onednd • • 15h ago

Question Can you cast Mage Hand targeting a spot you can't see?

1 Upvotes

The description doesn't say anything about having to see the location the hand appears at, only "a point you choose within range"

I assume it wouldn't be very useful to do so under most circumstances since you wouldn't be able to see what you're doing with it, but still.


r/onednd • • 3h ago

5e (2024) [Hot take?] One-handed dual wielding is RAW, mechanically fine, and I won't ban it at my tables

0 Upvotes

The 2014 two-weapon fighting rules say, "When you take the Attack action and attack with a light melee weapon that you're holding in one hand, you can use a bonus action to attack with a different light melee weapon that you're holding in the other hand". The 2024e version does not stipulate needing the different weapon to be held in the other hand. Is this a hint that dual wielding with 1 hand is RAI? IDK. But we also don't have confirmation that 1-handed dual wielding isn't intended.

What's easier to accept is probably using 1 hand to throw weapons (e.g. handaxe+Nick light hammer). I think it's easy to accept that after throwing a weapon, you can use the same hand to throw another weapon. However, this doesn't seem like a neat cutoff - if this is allowed, in melee, you could attack with a handaxe, throw it with Extra Attack (at disadvantage, due to being in melee), pull out your light hammer, and then attack twice with it using Nick + Dual Wielder BA. This is practically the same as blanket-allowing Nick/DW with one hand, except it imposes disadvantage on 1/4 of the attacks, and makes the default flavor even more ridiculous.

Flavor-wise Nick/DW with shield could make sense as e.g. targe-and-dirk, or having a forearm-mounted shield or armguard that gives you more usage of your shield-arm. I'm fine with accepting a shield as just a default part of a dual wielder's kit and archetype, the same way I'll accept the existence of wizards with armor and shield from a 1 level dip. Like, oh, dual wielders strap a piece of metal to their forearm for defense, I guess that's just how they fight in this setting. One must imagine 5.5e Drizzt happy with his +2AC armguard.

Balance-wise it's a bit of a mixed bag: It buffs martials (yay) and allow melee warriors to frontline better (yay), but somewhat outcompetes GWM until later in the game (or until you get a nice GWM magic weapon). It's also a buff to weapon+shield loadouts (yay). Overall I think it's fine, if a player wants to dual wield with a shield I'll let them and it won't break the game. I don't think it's perfect situation, but IMO it's not worth banning either because banning it creates new balance problems, e.g. 1-hand DW+shield throwing builds being somehow tankier than their melee counterparts. And oh if you really want to you can stack both Dueling and Two Weapon Fighting, which is decently strong but the opportunity cost makes it balanced enough to not set off my alarms. Maybe just me, but I prefer not to ban anything unless it significantly degenerates the game, and RAW 1-handed dual wielding martials aren't overpowered enough for me to shut down when armor wizards are on the menu.

You could ban it at your table, and I'll understand. But if a player at my table is excited to use it, and they're on top of keeping track of the mechanics, I'll let them.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Discussion The Problem With The Martial Caster Divide Isn't Martials.

136 Upvotes

A lot of people seem to want to 'fix' martials. Martials are not the problem. The problem is that over the successive editions life has become easier and easier for casters.

"Oh but they were just trying to make it more fun for caster players" some people say. "It would suck if I lost MY spell" they say. But you are part of a team and in the older editions you had to work as one.

There should be real penalties for trying to cast spells when there is a meataxe in your face swinging a sword at you. Or a racing-snake firing arrows at you while you are trying to concentrate on breaking the rules of reality.

In earlier editions you had to state your intended action before initiative was rolled. This included declaring casting a spell. If the other side won initiative and shot the caster with an arrow or ran up and whacked him with a sword, the spell failed and the caster lost the spell slot as it fizzled. This worked. You had to work as a team.

Now because of the initiative system this cannot happen. And if it could there would be cries of "I need to at least get a CON" save, and then there would be a feat that fixed the issue anyway. The problem here isn't martials being under-powered or lacking abilities, the problem is casters having it too easy.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) What are the pain points of the classes?

41 Upvotes

Is there anything about the classes you don't like or feel that are underwhelming?


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Discussion PHB 2024's been out for 2 years. What's your favorite character you made in it?

41 Upvotes

The new 5.5e has been out for quite some time now, and we now have a pretty respectable amount of additional official releases for it. For anyone who've made a new character to play, continued with an old one but updated the system/features for your current character, or just theory-crafted a character you want to play.

No restrictions or specifics. You can bring up a character with old feats, subclasses, or homebrews with 5.5e classes as the chasis. Even UA if you, say, played a Psion they really enjoyed.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) The 'Observant' and 'Keen Mind' Bonus Actions are useful outside combat

26 Upvotes

Say you're in a dungeon and you're about to search a large room for traps. The GM tells you this search requires 10 minutes and a Perception check. Your Perception bonus is good, but you're under a time crunch. What you really want is a way for that search to be faster.

Here's where the Observant feat's 'Quick Search' comes in. If a search for traps has a base time-cost of 10 minutes, this is equivalent to 100 turns of taking the Search action, or 100 Search actions. But if you can use your Bonus Action AND your Action to search, you can take two Search actions per turn, which means you can complete the 100 Search actions in 5 minutes. That might be enough to let you search a second room of the same size before 'Detect Magic' runs out. Or you could take 10 minutes and use your action to Dodge on every turn, just in case a trap goes off in your face.

Same goes for 'Keen Mind' and being able to Bonus Action your way through time-consuming Investigation checks, either at double-speed or with some sensible multitasking. Both feats seem to have solid out-of-combat applications, unless your GM never runs dungeons with time constraints.

Feat texts for reference:

OBSERVANT (+1 INT or +1 WIS, requires INT 13+ or WIS 13+)
Keen Observer. Choose one of the following skills: Insight, Investigation, or Perception. If you lack proficiency with the chosen skill, you gain proficiency in it, and if you already have proficiency in it, you gain Expertise in it.
Quick Search. You can take the Search action as a Bonus Action.

KEEN MIND (+1 INT, requires INT 13+)
Lore Knowledge. Choose one of the following skills: Arcana, History, Investigation, Nature, or Religion. If you lack proficiency in the chosen skill, you gain proficiency in it, and if you already have proficiency in it, you gain Expertise in it.
Quick Study. You can take the Study action as a Bonus Action.


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Question Sylune's Viper and Rakshasa's Greater Magic Resistance

17 Upvotes

EDIT: Thanks everyone for your insights! I was originally on board with the idea of Venomous Bite automatically missing against GMR, but I wanted to be absolutely sure I'm not missing anything.

Sylune's Viper:

"...While the spell is active, you gain the following benefits:

Venomous Bite. As a Magic Action, you can make a ranged spell attack using the snake against one creature within 50 feet..."

Rakshasa:

"...Greater Magic Resistance. The rakshasa automatically succeeds on saving throws against spells and other magical effects, and the attack rolls of spells automatically miss it..."

......

Does the ranged spell attack that is part of the spell Sylune's Viper automatically miss Rakshasa? Or is the ranged spell attack in this case not considered an attack roll of spell?

If it was a Fire Bolt, I feel like the answer would be an obvious "yes, it automatically misses."


r/onednd • • 15h ago

Self-Promotion What's my best opener anyways? I simulated 10,000 fights to find out.

0 Upvotes

My main goal was building a tool to help me calculate best plays. Because I truthfully don't know. I suspect that in any scenario there's too much info and options for my brain to decide.

For me, this project is about testing what moves work best, and to help a DM appropriately size enemy teams.

With my Circle of Stars Druid I would use Guiding Bolt then Starry Form Archer. Turns out that was the wrong move.

OpenerWin rate
AI picks each turn69.8%
Starry Form Archer first64.2%
Guiding Bolt then Starry Form Archer62.5%

Same fight with the SRD druid that ships with the app (you can rerun this):

OpenerWin rate
AI picks each turn68.5%
Moonbeam first62.1%
Spike Growth first47.5%

I'm focusing on making it more user friendly. The engine is just that, an engine. There's a lot of room for a cleaner UI. But it functions as designed.

I want to know what would hold you back from using it. If the answer is AI, MonteCarlo is more math than AI.

I directed the project and Claude Code wrote most of the code. I approved or defined all decisions.

5.5e (SRD 5.2.1). Free, open source.

App: https://cerutti13.github.io/montecrit/

Code: https://github.com/Cerutti13/montecrit


r/onednd • • 1d ago

Question Find Familiar and Magic Action?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Different Ruling on Sneak attack in 5.5

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 1d ago

5e (2024) Gaze of two minds and advantage

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 2d ago

Homebrew Balancing: A bow that ignores Full Cover on marked targets

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm the DM. My party has just cleared a magical forge and the owner has offered to make each of them a roughly Uncommon magical item tailored to them that will scale with the party's level. The party's Hunter Ranger (level 5, Sharpshooter) has asked for a Heavy Crossbow that

  1. Ignores the Loading property
  2. Ignores Full Cover against "marked" targets that he has seen

I use "marked" because instead of Hunter's Mark, each player has the following item:

Hunter's Tag
As a Bonus Action, you may place this tag on a hostile creature within 5 feet. While this creature is marked, they suffer the effects of Hunter's Mark as if it was cast by the Ranger. This effect does not require Concentration by the Ranger and ends when the creature drops to 0 HP. The Ranger can also end this effect at any time (no action required). This effect can only apply to one creature at a time.

In practice, this Ranger wants guided bolts against a hostile creature that is marked by Hunter's Mark, kind of like Yondu's arrow from the MCU.

In terms of balancing, the Repeating Shot bow the Artificer can make is an Uncommon rarity ignores the Loading property, so some of the power budget is already taken up by that. I don't really have an idea of how powerful the second effect would be, but I was thinking of limiting the effect to PB times/Long Rest initially, and letting that amount increase as part of the scaling, along with the Hunter's Mark damage itself.

I'd appreciate some insight into whether this effect is balanced with that in mind, or how to balance it if it isn't. The Ranger is pretty set on the seeking missiles fantasy, so I'd love to fulfill that.

Anything helps! Cheers :)


r/onednd • • 2d ago

Self-Promotion The Dragon Compendium Reached Gold Best Seller and discounted by 50% for Black Friday!

0 Upvotes

The Dragon Compendium Reached Gold Best Seller and discounted by 50% for Black Friday!

You can find it here: https://www.dmsguild.com/it/product/485797/the-dragon-compendium

Delve further into the world of dragons within the pages of the Dragon Compendium.

This volume allows you to create a dragon-related class, play a dragon-related race, add magical items and dragon-themed monsters to any of your campaigns!

Inside you will discover:

- Chapter 1: New Race, the Half-Dragon. Uncover the secrets of the half-dragon race, including their variants linked to different draconic ancestors.

- Chapter 2: New Class, the Soulbonded. Embark on a journey as a soulbonded, a humanoid bound to the souls of dragons. Choose your path as a knight, a valiant dragon rider; a sage, a master of ancient draconic magic; or a devourer, a feral warrior whose very essence is intertwined with the might of dragons.

- Chapter 3: New Items. Discover a range of 13 new magical items themed around dragons, including weapons, armor, and rare artifacts. Each is paired with fabulous art depicting each item.

- Chapter 4: New Monsters. Discover 17 new and formidable monsters, ranging from minor challenges to major adversaries, from CR1 to CR22. This chapter provides a variety of foes suitable for any setting and adventure. Every creature is illustrated to bring this monstrous menagerie to life.

- No AI art used!


r/onednd • • 3d ago

Self-Promotion Dungeons and Dragons World of Warcraft Review

Thumbnail
therpggazette.com
86 Upvotes

You know, I talked about how I was somewhat harsh on D&D in the past, especially near the beginning of the blog. My stance softened slightly with 5.5e, altough I continued to criticize the fast pace of powercreep within this edition.

Then the anouncement of the Universes Beyond came and the reaction from the community was quite split, some interested, but, at least in the online discourse, a lot of people quite negative. Well, I for once found myself in an interesting spot, as, although I do sometimes enjoy hating on WotC, this time, I wanted to wait and see. Because this new line is not new. We've had it before in the days of 3e and 3.5, with a plethora of amazing games that came out of that era, chief among them for me being Star Wars Saga Editon.

I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt and see how they go about these products. Now we finally got them onnour hands and I want to offer a fair judgement and I gotta say, for the most part, I am impressed.

The book looks gorgeous, there is some support for higher level play, some nice variant features for a couple of classes, the Ranger and Barbarian standing out, some pretty cool spells that offer a degree of tactical depth, cool subclasses, especially the Discipline Domain Cleric and the Path of the Elements Barbarian. The DM also gets I think one of the first proper implementations of the Renown feature, lots of new monsters and some pretty good dungeons, everything wrapped in that gorgeous Azeroth foil.

Unfortunately there are also some less then stellar aspects. Some of the dungeons presented are little more then a series of combat encounters linked by straight lines, while some of the classes are pretty damn cool and fun, others are absolute shit, looking at you Shadow Priest. The spells are also a bit too power creep-ish and speaking of, once again, WotC lives up to their name and plays favorites with the Spellcasters, while leaving the martials behind.

All in all, that would be my TL;DR, for my thoughts at large, please do check out the article, it helps immensely. If you managed to look over the book, to play with some of the new materials, I am eager to hear your thoughts!

Till next time, cheers!


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) Is a Charm Immunity Magic Item too Strong for a Barbarian?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) Why do many feats only work for spell damage? And would it be balanced to change that?

11 Upvotes

Some feats are more martial leaning or spellcaster leaning, and that's fine. Some are even clearly designed in mind for a specific class. But I noticed there are feats could work for everyone, but they include specific wording to stop this. "When you cast a spell that causes xxx (type) damage..." So, my first question is, for what design purpose might WoTC have to limit these feats to only spellcasters?

My second question is, how could this be redesigned in a way that wouldn't unintentionally break the game?

  • If the wording is just "when you cause xxx damage" then that would include magic items and maybe WoTC wanted activations that came from the PCs themselves. The wording could then be "when you cause xxx damage not caused by a magical item".
  • Maybe the previous would allow the feat to be used too many times which could be addressed by ruling "pick when you get this feat either: 1. when you cast a spell that causes xxx damage OR 2. when you cause xxx damage that is neither from spell nor magical item"

Bonus question: DMs would you be okay if an elemental fighter or celestial rogue wanted to take a feat that activates on spell-type damage but uses it for non-spell activations? I think it'd be okay but am interested in what others' thoughts are.


r/onednd • • 2d ago

5e (2024) [Promotional] - Common, a chrome extension for D&D 5E and 5.5E players and GMs

0 Upvotes

Hi there. First off, this is my only self-promotional post here and I believe I am folllowing all the rules, but if for some reason this post violates please let me know and I’ll be happy to do whatever is needed to respect the rules of the community.

I built a little Chrome extension that I want to share with everyone today. It’s called Common and it’s currently in beta while I work out the final kinks with a few groups that are using it currently. I’m sharing it here as it’s getting mature enough that I’d love some feedback from the wider community on the tools and usefulness. It is basically a UI for TTRPGs that gives you a HUD and a Command Palette to use that is always the same so that you can focus on what’s going on at the table and interacting with your players/GM and NOT on where the button is for that one obscure class feature or how to roll dice for the extra 2d6 you get from the magic object you picked up or how to quickly pop 3 more goblins into inititive order.

I started playing TTRPGs with an online group just under a year ago and quickly found out it’s one of my favorite passtimes. I went from my first 5.5E campaign (which is still rolling 11 months later) into one shots across 5E, several campaigns that were false starts in both systems, an attempt at Pathfinder (I’ll figure it out someday), Daggerheart, and DC20 to the point where I now am settled into that original campaign, an online homebrew DC20 campaign, and an in person 5E homebrew group as well that meets monthly. As a new player in all of these different games, and now as a player with a BIT more experience, the only problem I ever ran into was the same: all of the tools online OR in person were different for every game even though I was basically trying to do the same exact things. I had started on D&D Beyond with Roll20 as a VTT and got used to that, so my first Foundry game you can imagine how bad I felt holding up the game for everyone else. Or the first time using Maps in dndbeyond, or a character sheet with real dice for in person sessions, etc etc. There are just a lot of combinations of tools to use out there and each one works fairly significantly differently.

So I built Common as a way to start unifying the experience to make things work the same way across games/platforms/tables. All I wanted was to be able to look at whatever MAP/VTT I’m playing on and have access to all my character sheet stuff, all the same controls, and not worry about the roll values being different or calculated by a system that isn’t the same as what everyone else at the table was using. 

That was all pretty easy and fun. Then I started building GM tools…. holy shit did that get more interesting. It is now just as much a tool for GMs as it is for players! You can see the majority of the feature list on the docs page here: totalpartyfill.com/common/docs

Anyways, I don’t want to make this any longer than it already is, if you are interested please feel free to check out the tool in the Chrome store. Like I mentioned, it’s in beta for another week or two so platform support is limited to the original D&D Beyond/Roll20 combination I started with, but the platforms I have queued up to release in the coming weeks open it up to many more game platforms, VTTS, and in-person options. As this is a D&D-focused sub I won’t talk about the other game systems I’ve got lined up other than to say that they are there and in testing.

Thanks for taking a minute to check it out

[AI DISCLOSURE] - I hate using AI as much as anyone, but I did use it for designing the actual UI artwork pieces of the extension (the borders and the icons you click on, etc) as I just don’t have that skillset. To that end, they look just as shitty as you’d expect. If there are any talented artists out here in the community that want to be involved and could help me REPLACE those pieces I would LOVE LOVE LOVE to hear from you!!!! Feel free to DM me or post something here.

PS - I do also ask you to create an account for this extension so that I can save your settings/state for the games you play. PLEASE feel free to check out the terms/privacy policy on these accounts to see how serious I am about this and that your data will NEVER be tracked, shared, or collected and specifically what we will contact you about and when (HINT: it’s one time and it’ll just be about the launch when the beta ends).