TLDR at the bottom
I'm in love with Verdis La Traviata for about 15 years (since I was in my teens), it really means a lot to me. Aside from that one, I only listened to two other operas over those years, I like both: Heinrich Marschner's "Der Vampyr" and Bizet's Carmen.
I wanted try out other operas and subscribed to MetOnDemand for a month. I started with Puccini: Tosca and La Boheme. The singers were awesome, I liked the story, but not a single song or melody got stuck in my head. I couldn't even remember one if I tried (except for Vissi d'arte maybe)..and I tried while listening to some songs multiple times afterwards. It's like nothing really stood out which is kind of weird because I heard people say Puccini was 'opera for the masses' (as a negative thing).
I thought maybe opera's not for me then (except La Traviata) but decided to at least listen to some other works of Verdi to check if it's a composer issue. So far I've listened to multiple recordings of Il Trovatore and Rigoletto and I like these SO much more already and definitely will watch them too. (You can tell for sure but I have zero clue about music theory and composing.)
Any idea what could be the cause? What's the main difference between Verdi and Puccini? I heard Puccinis songs were more approachable and memorable, but to me it's exactly the other way round?
Bonus question: Is there another composer or specific opera that I should try that's similar to the operas I like?
TLDR: After adoring La Traviata for 15 years I tried to get into other operas. Puccinis works sounded strangely boring and unmemorable for me - but I do seem to like other operas by (1850s) Verdi. Any idea why or am I just an idiot? What should I try next?
Edit: Thank you all so much! I watched Lucia di Lammermoor on Met on Demand yesterday and really liked it. What an awesome experience. I also spent time listening to some parts of Anna Bolena, Roberto Devereux and Don Giovanni and seems like these are absolutely my taste too. Exactly what I was looking for, going to watch performances of these next. Obviously will check out the other recommendations too. Y'all seem to be absolutely right about my preference in structure, THANK YOU! ♥️ Besides I never got in touch with other opera enthusiasts before, so it made me really happy.
(PS - Suor Angelica didn't really speak to me as recording only, but I'll watch that anyway since it's short and see if my impression changes)